SHIP REARM QUESTION

Dereck · Post by **Dereck** » Tue Dec 25, 2012 3:10 am

Is there a formula/calculation to use to determine the amount of naval support required to rearm a certain weapon in a port?

Thanks

cohimbra · Post by **cohimbra** » Tue Dec 25, 2012 3:27 am

I don't know the formula, but if you look to pag.284-287 of the game
manual you can easy found what you want (20.1.2.2 "Ship rearmament at
ports table").

Dereck · Post by **Dereck** » Tue Dec 25, 2012 4:17 am

There are a LOT of weapons however that are NOT on that list and I an trying to create my own repair/rearm spreadsheet for every weapon used so having a formula/calculation is important.

Alfred · Post by **Alfred** » Tue Dec 25, 2012 5:54 am

1. The formula data is provided in s.20.1.2.2 of the manual.

2. The rearming process is outlined in s.9.3.3.2 of the manual.

Alfred

n01487477 · Post by **n01487477** » Tue Dec 25, 2012 6:25 am

ORIGINAL: dereck

There are a LOT of weapons however that are NOT on that list and I an trying to create my own repair/rearm spreadsheet for every weapon used so having a formula/calculation is important.

Well hopefully I'll get this done sometime ...

In the meantime if you need help with the calculations - PM me. Otherwise I got everything from the manual.

Dereck · Post by **Dereck** » Tue Dec 25, 2012 12:23 pm

ORIGINAL: Alfred

1. The formula data is provided in s.20.1.2.2 of the manual.

That is the formula for the amount of SUPPLY. I'm looking to determine how much NAVAL SUPPORT is required.

2. The rearming process is outlined in s.9.3.3.2 of the manual.

Alfred

PaxMondo · Post by **PaxMondo** » Tue Dec 25, 2012 12:34 pm

Its in the manual.  You just need to search ... there's a table with port size and naval support ...

Alfred · Post by **Alfred** » Tue Dec 25, 2012 1:02 pm

ORIGINAL: dereck

ORIGINAL: Alfred

1. The formula data is provided in s.20.1.2.2 of the manual.

That is the formula for the amount of SUPPLY. I'm looking to determine how much NAVAL SUPPORT is required.

2. The rearming process is outlined in s.9.3.3.2 of the manual.

Alfred

Do you seriously believe I would direct a poster to a specific section of the manual which does not provide the specific answer to the question posed?[:-]

Read again the sections I directed you to, the answer is there. If you need further assistance look at the table on page 211 of the manual although that only deals with the native capability of the port, a factor you did not specifically request info on in your OP.

Alfred

Dereck · Post by **Dereck** » Tue Dec 25, 2012 1:20 pm

ORIGINAL: Alfred

ORIGINAL: dereck

ORIGINAL: Alfred

1. The formula data is provided in s.20.1.2.2 of the manual.

That is the formula for the amount of SUPPLY. I'm looking to determine how much NAVAL SUPPORT is required.

2. The rearming process is outlined in s.9.3.3.2 of the manual.

Alfred

Do you seriously believe I would direct a poster to a specific section of the manual which does not provide the specific answer to the question posed?[:-]

Read again the sections I directed you to, the answer is there. If you need further assistance look at the table on page 211 of the manual although that only deals with the native capability of the port, a factor you did not specifically request info on in your OP.

Alfred

The formula on page 285 specifically says SUPPLY and I keep saying I want to determine the amount of NAVAL SUPPORT required. The chart on page 211 just shows the Rearm Level but not how the Naval Support is determined when it is something like Port-4 + Naval Support.

Dereck · Post by **Dereck** » Tue Dec 25, 2012 1:22 pm

ORIGINAL: PaxMondo

Its in the manual. You just need to search ... there's a table with port size and naval support ...

Where? I've looked and I can't find one that shows the Naval Support. I'm not talking about the charts on pages 285 thru 288 because that is what I'm trying to find a formula for (somehow) to calculate the NAVAL SUPPORT for on weapons that are not listed in that chart.

n01487477 · Post by **n01487477** » Tue Dec 25, 2012 1:25 pm

PseudoCode enabled.

1. Work out the rearm cost for the device.
if deviceID = 195 then rearm = 500
if deviceID = 196 then rearm = 1500
if deviceType = DPGUN or NAVYGUN or FLAK then rearm device = Effectiveness() * 2;
if deviceType = ASW or TORPEDO ) then rearm = d.GetLoadCost();

2. Work out the PortNavalSupport for each level of PortSize
// basic Port rearm levels with no Naval Support
port_ReArmLevel[] = {0,15,25,40,110,300,700,5500,6000,6500,9999};
if(port_ReArmLevel[portsize] >= rearm cost) // so for each port rearm level checks rearm cost
then no naval support required.
else
if (portSize ==1)
NavalSupport = roundup((0.2*reArmCost)-3);
else if (portSize <= 10)
NavalSupport = roundup((0.2*reArmCost)-(port_ReArmLevel[portSize-1]/5));

Not great pseudo code - but I guess you can get the point. Also, this is not fully tested so if there are errors - not my fault...use at your own risk and if you find errors please give me feedback

Cheers

n01487477 · Post by **n01487477** » Tue Dec 25, 2012 1:28 pm

ORIGINAL: dereck

ORIGINAL: PaxMondo

Its in the manual. You just need to search ... there's a table with port size and naval support ...

Where? I've looked and I can't find one that shows the Naval Support. I'm not talking about the charts on pages 285 thru 288 because that is what I'm trying to find a formula for (somehow) to calculate the NAVAL SUPPORT for on weapons that are not listed in that chart.

Well I had to work it out ... which can be done from the chart.

Which you can see I've done ...

Alfred · Post by **Alfred** » Tue Dec 25, 2012 2:04 pm

ORIGINAL: dereck

ORIGINAL: Alfred

ORIGINAL: dereck

Do you seriously believe I would direct a poster to a specific section of the manual which does not provide the specific answer to the question posed?[:-]

Read again the sections I directed you to, the answer is there. If you need further assistance look at the table on page 211 of the manual although that only deals with the native capability of the port, a factor you did not specifically request info on in your OP.

Alfred

The formula on page 285 specifically says SUPPLY and I keep saying I want to determine the amount of NAVAL SUPPORT required. The chart on page 211 just shows the Rearm Level but not how the Naval Support is determined when it is something like Port-4 + Naval Support.

1. What part of the last sentence of the first paragraph on page 284 immediately under the section heading 20.1.2.2 is hard to understand and not directly on point?

2. Where does the word "supply" appear in the entire paragraph referred to in the precding point.

3. Where in my first point did I say only "forumula". Go back and read that post and you will see it says "formula data". That means the data for you to create your own formula.

4. What exactly do you think "Rearm Cost" means in the table listed on page 211?

You need all the info provided in the sections I directed you to, to understand the concept of rearming. Only after you understand the concept can you create the correct formula. Now go back and read the sections I have pointed you to where the answer is extremely easy to find.

Alfred

Edit: Don't forget to reread s.9.3.3.2 which I specifically mentioned in my first post. You will need that section to also understand fully the rearm concept which is not just about supply consumption.

Bullwinkle58 · Post by **Bullwinkle58** » Tue Dec 25, 2012 4:20 pm

Or just do what I do: drive up to a pretty big port in a pretty big ship and see if you get a pretty large amount of ammo. If not, drive on. [:D]

msieving1 · Post by **msieving1** » Wed Dec 26, 2012 9:40 pm

ORIGINAL: dereck

ORIGINAL: PaxMondo

Its in the manual. You just need to search ... there's a table with port size and naval support ...

Where? I've looked and I can't find one that shows the Naval Support. I'm not talking about the charts on pages 285 thru 288 because that is what I'm trying to find a formula for (somehow) to calculate the NAVAL SUPPORT for on weapons that are not listed in that chart.

All you need to do is look it up in the table on page 285-288. So, for example, to rearm a 16in/50 Mk 7 (Rearm cost = 5400), at a level 6 port, you need 940 Naval Support.

If you really want a formula, try this:

[Naval Support Required] = ([Rearm Cost] - [Rearm Level of Port])/5

n01487477 · Post by **n01487477** » Wed Dec 26, 2012 9:46 pm

ORIGINAL: msieving1

ORIGINAL: dereck

ORIGINAL: PaxMondo

Its in the manual. You just need to search ... there's a table with port size and naval support ...

Where? I've looked and I can't find one that shows the Naval Support. I'm not talking about the charts on pages 285 thru 288 because that is what I'm trying to find a formula for (somehow) to calculate the NAVAL SUPPORT for on weapons that are not listed in that chart.

All you need to do is look it up in the table on page 285-288. So, for example, to rearm a 16in/50 Mk 7 (Rearm cost = 5400), at a level 6 port, you need 940 Naval Support.

If you really want a formula, try this:

[Naval Support Required] = ([Rearm Cost] - [Rearm Level of Port])/5

Wow - you just told me back my formula from an earlier post ... but with a margin of error. Don't you read other people's posts ? ... edit.. sorry im just in a foul mood today.

Chris21wen · Post by **Chris21wen** » Thu Dec 27, 2012 6:26 am

And/or stick a large AKE/AE in a port.

Oliver Heindorf · Post by **Oliver Heindorf** » Thu Dec 27, 2012 7:45 am

I go with what Moose said. Rest is far too complicated for me [:D]

Bullwinkle58 · Post by **Bullwinkle58** » Thu Dec 27, 2012 5:58 pm

ORIGINAL: Oliver Heindorf

I go with what Moose said. Rest is far too complicated for me [:D]

Hear, hear!![:)]

Been playing strat games since the 1960s. Some players always want to know in advance how every corner of the machine works. Fine, if one doesn't lose sight, in Heinlein's immortal words, of that fellow sneaking up to knife you while you fiddle with a rheostat.

Bullwinkle58 · Post by **Bullwinkle58** » Thu Dec 27, 2012 5:58 pm

ORIGINAL: Chris H

And/or stick a large AKE/AE in a port.

Sticking AKEs is a big part of the game to be sure. [:'(]

SHIP REARM QUESTION

SHIP REARM QUESTION

RE: SHIP REARM QUESTION

RE: SHIP REARM QUESTION

RE: SHIP REARM QUESTION

RE: SHIP REARM QUESTION

RE: SHIP REARM QUESTION

RE: SHIP REARM QUESTION

RE: SHIP REARM QUESTION

RE: SHIP REARM QUESTION

RE: SHIP REARM QUESTION

RE: SHIP REARM QUESTION

RE: SHIP REARM QUESTION

RE: SHIP REARM QUESTION

RE: SHIP REARM QUESTION

RE: SHIP REARM QUESTION

RE: SHIP REARM QUESTION

RE: SHIP REARM QUESTION

RE: SHIP REARM QUESTION

RE: SHIP REARM QUESTION

RE: SHIP REARM QUESTION