
Another Routine Convoy versus Sub Battle
Moderators: wdolson, MOD_War-in-the-Pacific-Admirals-Edition
RE: Another Routine Convoy versus Sub Battle
Ok, more gunfight ...


- Attachments
-
- A21moregunfight.jpg (217.28 KiB) Viewed 368 times
RE: Another Routine Convoy versus Sub Battle
Shells flying everywhere ...


- Attachments
-
- A22moregunfight.jpg (206.35 KiB) Viewed 368 times
RE: Another Routine Convoy versus Sub Battle
That cursed sub lands another hit ...


- Attachments
-
- A23subsh..hitsak.jpg (103.45 KiB) Viewed 369 times
RE: Another Routine Convoy versus Sub Battle
Back to the gunfight ...


- Attachments
-
- A24akattackssub.jpg (104.12 KiB) Viewed 368 times
RE: Another Routine Convoy versus Sub Battle
More torpedoes! Unbelievable.


- Attachments
-
- A25torpsmiss.jpg (103.49 KiB) Viewed 369 times
RE: Another Routine Convoy versus Sub Battle
Ok, back to the gunfight. Hey, we finally score a hit!


- Attachments
-
- A26gunfightakhits.jpg (206.23 KiB) Viewed 368 times
RE: Another Routine Convoy versus Sub Battle
And another hit - I surprised the merchies have any shells left.


- Attachments
-
- A27lastgunfight.jpg (205.79 KiB) Viewed 368 times
RE: Another Routine Convoy versus Sub Battle
That last hit finally did the sub in. The xAK 'West Cape' gets the credit for the kill!


- Attachments
-
- A28subslips.jpg (102.79 KiB) Viewed 368 times
RE: Another Routine Convoy versus Sub Battle
And here's the butcher's bill for this fracas ...
Sub attack near Manihiki at 161,158
Japanese Ships
SS I-21, hits 9, heavy damage
Allied Ships
xAK Diamond head, Torpedo hits 1, on fire, heavy damage
SC-641
AG Aries, Torpedo hits 1, on fire, heavy damage
xAK West Ivis, Shell hits 2, Torpedo hits 1, on fire, heavy damage
xAK West Ira, Shell hits 1
xAK West Cape
Probably 3 goners, plus a nice hole in another hull. That sub put up some fight.
Sub attack near Manihiki at 161,158
Japanese Ships
SS I-21, hits 9, heavy damage
Allied Ships
xAK Diamond head, Torpedo hits 1, on fire, heavy damage
SC-641
AG Aries, Torpedo hits 1, on fire, heavy damage
xAK West Ivis, Shell hits 2, Torpedo hits 1, on fire, heavy damage
xAK West Ira, Shell hits 1
xAK West Cape
Probably 3 goners, plus a nice hole in another hull. That sub put up some fight.
RE: Another Routine Convoy versus Sub Battle
The Emperor would be proud.
Todd
I never thought that doing an AAR would be so time consuming and difficult.
www.matrixgames.com/forums/tm.asp?m=2080768
I never thought that doing an AAR would be so time consuming and difficult.
www.matrixgames.com/forums/tm.asp?m=2080768
- Jorge_Stanbury
- Posts: 4345
- Joined: Wed Feb 29, 2012 12:57 pm
- Location: Montreal
RE: Another Routine Convoy versus Sub Battle
Banzai [&o]
- Bullwinkle58
- Posts: 11297
- Joined: Tue Feb 24, 2009 12:47 pm
RE: Another Routine Convoy versus Sub Battle
Hail the God of subs [X(]
RE: Another Routine Convoy versus Sub Battle
BANZAI!

Member: Treaty, Reluctant Admiral and Between the Storms Mod Team.
RE: Another Routine Convoy versus Sub Battle
I AGREE! That skipper deserves the "Order of the Rising Sun"!!!!!
- USSAmerica
- Posts: 19211
- Joined: Mon Oct 28, 2002 4:32 am
- Location: Graham, NC, USA
- Contact:
RE: Another Routine Convoy versus Sub Battle
That was awesome! [:D]
Mike
"Good times will set you free" - Jimmy Buffett
"They need more rum punch" - Me

Artwork by The Amazing Dixie
"Good times will set you free" - Jimmy Buffett
"They need more rum punch" - Me

Artwork by The Amazing Dixie
RE: Another Routine Convoy versus Sub Battle
Had somehing similar in one of my earlier games. Two AM escorts forced a an IJN sub to the surface. They couldn't hit anything ... so the escorted tankers decided to join the fun ... [8|]
End result; Three tankers taking one penetrating hit each causing "Fuel cargo burning". They sank.
Oh, and the sub sank too ... [;)]
ETA; Great fun with your little "battle AAR" [:)]
End result; Three tankers taking one penetrating hit each causing "Fuel cargo burning". They sank.
Oh, and the sub sank too ... [;)]
ETA; Great fun with your little "battle AAR" [:)]
“Not mastering metaphores is like cooking pasta when the train is delayed"
- castor troy
- Posts: 14331
- Joined: Mon Aug 23, 2004 10:17 am
- Location: Austria
RE: Another Routine Convoy versus Sub Battle
ORIGINAL: Grollub
Had somehing similar in one of my earlier games. Two AM escorts forced a an IJN sub to the surface. They couldn't hit anything ... so the escorted tankers decided to join the fun ... [8|]
End result; Three tankers taking one penetrating hit each causing "Fuel cargo burning". They sank.
Oh, and the sub sank too ... [;)]
ETA; Great fun with your little "battle AAR" [:)]
to me this is pretty much a flawed routine (sorry to say). Why? Because you probably will never ever see a sub scoring so many hits when attacking a convoy submerged, but when the sub is so badly damaged that it is forced to surface it suddenly gets the chance to fire at each and every ship that is firing at the sub. Thank god this doesn't happen often but when it does, it is time to shake your head.
Sub being in sinking condition suddenly taking out halve a dozen ships, something not possible when being undamaged because then you don't get a "gun duel" with the whole convoy during the attack. Hell yeah!
RE: Another Routine Convoy versus Sub Battle
To play devil's advocate here (or maybe just stir up trouble [;)]....While the result seems a bit out of whack at first blush, here's my take on it:
The submarine attacks the routine (automatic?) convoy. He is able to make the contact because the sub has a highly skilled, aggressive commander (more likely if this was a PBEM/human Japanese player). He hits his target, and the escort counterattacks. Two hits with a depth charge is not enough to sink a sub in this game. I've had subs take 4-5 hits and not be forced to the surface. I do think subs are a little too sturdy, but it is what it is. However, in this case, the sub comes up, but not critically damaged or nearly sinking. Once on the surface, the sub starts its diesel engines and finds itself with superior maneuverability vs. AKs, superior firepower (torps and 5.5 inch guns vs. 3 inch), and superior gunnery. The convoy ship commanders are probably all bottom-of the barrel if set up by the automatic system, or not specifically assigned by the Allied player. What is a highly skilled, aggressive sub commander to do?
The answer is probably not "run away." As always, there are a lot of specifics we don't know about the battle, but I think there's a lot of room for this to be a reasonable result.
Any other thoughts on this?
The submarine attacks the routine (automatic?) convoy. He is able to make the contact because the sub has a highly skilled, aggressive commander (more likely if this was a PBEM/human Japanese player). He hits his target, and the escort counterattacks. Two hits with a depth charge is not enough to sink a sub in this game. I've had subs take 4-5 hits and not be forced to the surface. I do think subs are a little too sturdy, but it is what it is. However, in this case, the sub comes up, but not critically damaged or nearly sinking. Once on the surface, the sub starts its diesel engines and finds itself with superior maneuverability vs. AKs, superior firepower (torps and 5.5 inch guns vs. 3 inch), and superior gunnery. The convoy ship commanders are probably all bottom-of the barrel if set up by the automatic system, or not specifically assigned by the Allied player. What is a highly skilled, aggressive sub commander to do?
The answer is probably not "run away." As always, there are a lot of specifics we don't know about the battle, but I think there's a lot of room for this to be a reasonable result.
Any other thoughts on this?
"It's all according to how your boogaloo situation stands, you understand."
Formerly known as Colonel Mustard, before I got Slitherine Syndrome.
Formerly known as Colonel Mustard, before I got Slitherine Syndrome.
- Chickenboy
- Posts: 24648
- Joined: Fri Jun 28, 2002 11:30 pm
- Location: San Antonio, TX










