this footrace just barely. I may not be so lucky further north of here where the Germans are running nearly free.

Moderators: ralphtricky, JAMiAM






That's an excellent idea. I seem to remember, however, that there's a house rule about no disbanding anything for the Soviet player toORIGINAL: Lobster
Some would not have the Soviet artillery anywhere near the Germans. They would all be sipping vodka back by the Volga. Since headquarters have artillery they might disband them if it looked like they were going to be surrounded and killed just to save the artillery some of them have. That stuff is a game changer later on. But not all of us play the same, eh?![]()
ORIGINAL: larryfulkerson
That's an excellent idea. I seem to remember, however, that there's a house rule about no disbanding anything for the Soviet player toORIGINAL: Lobster
Some would not have the Soviet artillery anywhere near the Germans. They would all be sipping vodka back by the Volga. Since headquarters have artillery they might disband them if it looked like they were going to be surrounded and killed just to save the artillery some of them have. That stuff is a game changer later on. But not all of us play the same, eh?![]()
follow. But there's no playback since this isn't a pure PBEM game and John wouldn't know if I DID disband them but it's the honor
system here and I still have a smigeon of self respect left so I'd rather not do that to John. I'm using the arty to try to stiffen the front
line a bit but I can see your point too. Excellent gameplay by you, again. Thanks for the tip.
Okay, well then, if there's no house rule against disbanding then I say let's do it. Save some arty tubes for later. Great idea.ORIGINAL: Lobster
Dude! Do you seriously think I'm telling you to cheat??? Really? I'm cut to the quick. [&:]
I've been through the briefing and docs and there are no house rules that I can find. You must be thinking of one of the FitE mods. If you have found some house rules could you please point me in the proper direction.
ORIGINAL: larryfulkerson
Okay, well then, if there's no house rule against disbanding then I say let's do it. Save some arty tubes for later. Great idea.ORIGINAL: Lobster
Dude! Do you seriously think I'm telling you to cheat??? Really? I'm cut to the quick. [&:]
I've been through the briefing and docs and there are no house rules that I can find. You must be thinking of one of the FitE mods. If you have found some house rules could you please point me in the proper direction.
That works for me. I think so too. New house rule: Only units in a supplied town can disband. Done and done.ORIGINAL: fogger
I think there should be a house rule that only units in a supplied town can disband


I think you're correct in that the commander on the ground in real life wouldn't have that option and so our doing it is artificial.ORIGINAL: Cfant2
I have to say, I don't like it. It's no cheating for sure, as it is not forbidden, but I regard it as an exploit, if it happens near the front. No problem at the Ural, but near the front you avoid the possibility to loose the material, this way weakening your opponent. And you save the material without using rail capacity.
If your opponent is ok with the rule, then there is no need for any more thinking about it [:)]
