fortification building question

This new stand alone release based on the legendary War in the Pacific from 2 by 3 Games adds significant improvements and changes to enhance game play, improve realism, and increase historical accuracy. With dozens of new features, new art, and engine improvements, War in the Pacific: Admiral's Edition brings you the most realistic and immersive WWII Pacific Theater wargame ever!

Moderators: wdolson, MOD_War-in-the-Pacific-Admirals-Edition

Freedom205
Posts: 307
Joined: Mon Dec 04, 2000 10:00 am
Location: Michigan USA

fortification building question

Post by Freedom205 »

It is my understanding that forts wont build if airfields are damaged. Could someone please verify this for me, and has this been the case all along or and added feature?

Thanks in advance

Mike
mind_messing
Posts: 3394
Joined: Mon Oct 28, 2013 11:59 am

RE: fortification building question

Post by mind_messing »

ORIGINAL: Mike Hall

It is my understanding that forts wont build if airfields are damaged. Could someone please verify this for me, and has this been the case all along or and added feature?

Thanks in advance

Mike

Engineers repair damage first before building. Always has been so, as far as I can remember.
User avatar
btd64
Posts: 15237
Joined: Sat Jan 23, 2010 12:48 am
Location: Lancaster, OHIO

RE: fortification building question

Post by btd64 »

Yes, Repair first, Build second....GP
IntelUltra7 16cores, 32gb ram, NvidiaGeForceRTX 2050
DW2-Alpha/Beta Tester
WIS Manual Team Lead & Beta Support Team

"Do everything you ask of those you command" Gen. George S. Patton
WiS Discord channel coming soon....
User avatar
Bullwinkle58
Posts: 11297
Joined: Tue Feb 24, 2009 12:47 pm

RE: fortification building question

Post by Bullwinkle58 »

ORIGINAL: Mike Hall

It is my understanding that forts wont build if airfields are damaged. Could someone please verify this for me, and has this been the case all along or and added feature?

Thanks in advance

Mike

AFs, and ports as well.
The Moose
User avatar
castor troy
Posts: 14331
Joined: Mon Aug 23, 2004 10:17 am
Location: Austria

RE: fortification building question

Post by castor troy »

ORIGINAL: Mike Hall

It is my understanding that forts wont build if airfields are damaged. Could someone please verify this for me, and has this been the case all along or and added feature?

Thanks in advance

Mike


first thing eng work on is damage to the airfield, followed by damage to the airbase and damage to the port last. Only if all of this is 100% repaired you will see works on forts. Has been that way all back to WITP.
rroberson
Posts: 2057
Joined: Tue May 25, 2004 7:53 am
Location: Arizona
Contact:

RE: fortification building question

Post by rroberson »

As the opponent in the game mike is referencing let me relate what is happening.

Mike has decided to flatten Singapore with air power. We are about 3 weeks into our game. Now Mike isn't flattening the airfields to keep me from flying out of there, but rather to prevent me from building up the fortresses in Singapore. To me, this is taking advantage of a game mechanic. Just like flying 4Es against naval targets or using them to bomb targets under 10K is a game mechanic. Both of those things are really effective but hardly realistic and we have house rules to govern them. To me, this is the exact same thing.

Now cratering an airfield should have nothing to do with an armies ability to dig fox holes or set up barricades yet, due to the mechanics of the game that's precisely what is happening. Mike admits he is taking advantage of that poor game design and bombing the airfield to prevent me from building up the fortress in Singapore before his forces can get there. Which will allows him to walk in and take it with little fuss. Now Singapore always falls, that is not at the heart of the issue here. However, taking advantage of a game mechanic that at best can be seen as poor game design is pretty gamey from my viewpoint and hardly sporting.

After what happened to me in a previous game where my opponent was exploiting every game weakness...I fully admit I am pretty sensitive to gamey play and may be going overboard here.

What say you? Gamey game mechanics or just another day of war.
Image
User avatar
Bullwinkle58
Posts: 11297
Joined: Tue Feb 24, 2009 12:47 pm

RE: fortification building question

Post by Bullwinkle58 »

You're going overboard here. It's been part of the game forever. It is perfectly reasonable for him to choose to bomb the AF for "AF reasons." It's not his fault that causes forts not to build. Same with bombing the port. If you had the whole RN parked there he shouldn't be allowed to bomb the port because it keeps you from building forts?

It might not be realistic, but it's part of the design. You can do it to him as well. There's no way to stop the effect without castrating the land-bombing model.
The Moose
rroberson
Posts: 2057
Joined: Tue May 25, 2004 7:53 am
Location: Arizona
Contact:

RE: fortification building question

Post by rroberson »

I guess that's the point bullwinkle. If he was bombing it for airfield reasons I probably would have just shrugged. I never win at this game ;-). So it would be nothing new. He is doing specifically because he knows that it will preventing me from building my fortress level. That by it's definition is gamey.

Why have house rules if you are simply going to find other ways to get around game mechanics.

Like I said, I know I'm sensitive to this sort of thing after what happened in my last big game, I guess I get frustrated about having to constantly be on guard. If you guys say it's no big deal, then I guess it isn't.
Image
User avatar
LoBaron
Posts: 4775
Joined: Sun Jan 26, 2003 8:23 pm
Location: Vienna, Austria

RE: fortification building question

Post by LoBaron »

rroberson just my 2c´s:

The base repair/fort building sequence has not been changed since the old days of Uncommon Valor. Damaging port and airfield to prevent fort build always has been a valid tactic, even more so as forts cannot be damaged or destroyed by air attack.
Image
User avatar
Bullwinkle58
Posts: 11297
Joined: Tue Feb 24, 2009 12:47 pm

RE: fortification building question

Post by Bullwinkle58 »

ORIGINAL: rroberson

I guess that's the point bullwinkle. If he was bombing it for airfield reasons I probably would have just shrugged. I never win at this game ;-). So it would be nothing new. He is doing specifically because he knows that it will preventing me from building my fortress level. That by it's definition is gamey.

Why have house rules if you are simply going to find other ways to get around game mechanics.

Like I said, I know I'm sensitive to this sort of thing after what happened in my last big game, I guess I get frustrated about having to constantly be on guard. If you guys say it's no big deal, then I guess it isn't.

I followed your last big game, and that tactic was a lot more questionable than this.

I guess I'd counter by asking how you know what his motive is for bombing the AF, and why? If you want to be "realistic" did the Japanese and Allied commanders exchange mail telling each other their motives? Bombing the AF also destroys supply, and is probably the best way to do that outside of a ground attack. Should he not be allowed to try to kill your supply dumps?

I'd personally like the game to allow you to point your engineers at whatever task you think they should do first, but it doesn't allow that and never has. Bombing Singers to stop fort building is one of the oldest Japan moves in the game. It's so common it's not even worth mentioning anymore IMO. One thing you can do is so overload Singers with engineers that you can repair the AF and still get a little fort building in. I was able to do that in my AARed game. You can read about it if you want.

OTOH, he can so overload the bombing effort you can't repair each day. But that costs him a lot of supply, ops losses, and flak losses, and it means those planes aren't bombing somewhere else, like the PI or Burma. He's making a choice on priorities if he focuses on Singers. You can choose to put engineers there, or not, and that's your right too.
The Moose
Freedom205
Posts: 307
Joined: Mon Dec 04, 2000 10:00 am
Location: Michigan USA

RE: fortification building question

Post by Freedom205 »

thanks, was just making sure I was correct in my assumption ( on how fort repair worked and how long it had been in the game )

Regarding Robs comments, I invade Palambang very early in the game and need Singers shut down as much as possible to enable amphibious TFs to make it to Palambang. The fact that it stops/slow the building of forts is a secondary benifit. It takes a big investment in Khoto to do so. I dont bomb the port because it is of no military advantage to me and I feel port bombing is way too effective in the game. ( most ports would be alerted to coming planes and get ships moving, imo ) Plus the Japanese pay dearly anytime the bomb anything so you better have a reason to send the bombers.
rroberson
Posts: 2057
Joined: Tue May 25, 2004 7:53 am
Location: Arizona
Contact:

RE: fortification building question

Post by rroberson »

ORIGINAL: Bullwinkle58
ORIGINAL: rroberson

I guess that's the point bullwinkle. If he was bombing it for airfield reasons I probably would have just shrugged. I never win at this game ;-). So it would be nothing new. He is doing specifically because he knows that it will preventing me from building my fortress level. That by it's definition is gamey.

Why have house rules if you are simply going to find other ways to get around game mechanics.

Like I said, I know I'm sensitive to this sort of thing after what happened in my last big game, I guess I get frustrated about having to constantly be on guard. If you guys say it's no big deal, then I guess it isn't.

I followed your last big game, and that tactic was a lot more questionable than this.

I guess I'd counter by asking how you know what his motive is for bombing the AF, and why? If you want to be "realistic" did the Japanese and Allied commanders exchange mail telling each other their motives? Bombing the AF also destroys supply, and is probably the best way to do that outside of a ground attack. Should he not be allowed to try to kill your supply dumps?

I'd personally like the game to allow you to point your engineers at whatever task you think they should do first, but it doesn't allow that and never has. Bombing Singers to stop fort building is one of the oldest Japan moves in the game. It's so common it's not even worth mentioning anymore IMO. One thing you can do is so overload Singers with engineers that you can repair the AF and still get a little fort building in. I was able to do that in my AARed game. You can read about it if you want.

OTOH, he can so overload the bombing effort you can't repair each day. But that costs him a lot of supply, ops losses, and flak losses, and it means those planes aren't bombing somewhere else, like the PI or Burma. He's making a choice on priorities if he focuses on Singers. You can choose to put engineers there, or not, and that's your right too.


I had been watching the fortress of singapore as I always pay attention to it during the early phase of the game. I noticed right away that the forts were not building. I kept waiting to see if it would resolve itself because sometimes things pop up. Eventually, I let him know that I thought we might have a problem (bug) with the game as the fortress continued to not build. It was then he revealed the fact that it was the game mechanic preventing my fort from building and "the" reason he was flattening my airbase with airpower. One of those things I had never run into in the decade I have been at this.

I guess I didn't realize this was a "thing" that all JFBs used. I never have, but I don't go looking for every game mechanic to exploit. I just play the game. Which is why I brought it here. I guess now that I know I will soldier on. And next time be sure to pour engineers into Singapore. [8D]
Image
User avatar
Icedawg
Posts: 1613
Joined: Fri Jan 27, 2006 8:55 pm
Location: Upstate New York

RE: fortification building question

Post by Icedawg »

ORIGINAL: rroberson

As the opponent in the game mike is referencing let me relate what is happening.

Mike has decided to flatten Singapore with air power. We are about 3 weeks into our game. Now Mike isn't flattening the airfields to keep me from flying out of there, but rather to prevent me from building up the fortresses in Singapore. To me, this is taking advantage of a game mechanic. Just like flying 4Es against naval targets or using them to bomb targets under 10K is a game mechanic. Both of those things are really effective but hardly realistic and we have house rules to govern them. To me, this is the exact same thing.

Now cratering an airfield should have nothing to do with an armies ability to dig fox holes or set up barricades yet, due to the mechanics of the game that's precisely what is happening. Mike admits he is taking advantage of that poor game design and bombing the airfield to prevent me from building up the fortress in Singapore before his forces can get there. Which will allows him to walk in and take it with little fuss. Now Singapore always falls, that is not at the heart of the issue here. However, taking advantage of a game mechanic that at best can be seen as poor game design is pretty gamey from my viewpoint and hardly sporting.

After what happened to me in a previous game where my opponent was exploiting every game weakness...I fully admit I am pretty sensitive to gamey play and may be going overboard here.

What say you? Gamey game mechanics or just another day of war.

rroberson - I used to think the way that you do on this issue, but then someone (I forget who) had me look at it like this.

The game has no option for reducing fortifications by air attack. The only way the game allows fort reduction it is to actually carry out a land combat attack. So, instead of looking at these AF attacks as attacks on the AF, consider them instead to be attacks on the fortified ground defenses in the hex. Your opponent is intending to reduce the forts, but the game doesn't allow it, so this is his way of accomplishing his goal.

It works for me. Hopefully it can help set you at ease too.
User avatar
RogerJNeilson
Posts: 1277
Joined: Thu Apr 12, 2012 5:21 am
Location: Bedlington, Northumberland, UK

RE: fortification building question

Post by RogerJNeilson »

Ideally the game should allow you to decide, as in real life, where to deploy your assets given the issue at the base - but it doesn't.

Once you have 'dug foxholes' then you get into significantly more specialised work to build greater fortifications. You have a limited supply of skilled engineers who cannot do two things at once. I guess like Icedawg its an abstraction and there are many of them in the game.

If he is bombing Singers then he's not bombing somewhere else.....

Roger
An unplanned dynasty: Roger Neilson, Roger Neilson 11, Roger Neilson 3 previous posts 898+1515 + 1126 = 3539.....Finally completed my game which started the day WITP:AE was released
rroberson
Posts: 2057
Joined: Tue May 25, 2004 7:53 am
Location: Arizona
Contact:

RE: fortification building question

Post by rroberson »

ORIGINAL: Icedawg
ORIGINAL: rroberson

As the opponent in the game mike is referencing let me relate what is happening.

Mike has decided to flatten Singapore with air power. We are about 3 weeks into our game. Now Mike isn't flattening the airfields to keep me from flying out of there, but rather to prevent me from building up the fortresses in Singapore. To me, this is taking advantage of a game mechanic. Just like flying 4Es against naval targets or using them to bomb targets under 10K is a game mechanic. Both of those things are really effective but hardly realistic and we have house rules to govern them. To me, this is the exact same thing.

Now cratering an airfield should have nothing to do with an armies ability to dig fox holes or set up barricades yet, due to the mechanics of the game that's precisely what is happening. Mike admits he is taking advantage of that poor game design and bombing the airfield to prevent me from building up the fortress in Singapore before his forces can get there. Which will allows him to walk in and take it with little fuss. Now Singapore always falls, that is not at the heart of the issue here. However, taking advantage of a game mechanic that at best can be seen as poor game design is pretty gamey from my viewpoint and hardly sporting.

After what happened to me in a previous game where my opponent was exploiting every game weakness...I fully admit I am pretty sensitive to gamey play and may be going overboard here.

What say you? Gamey game mechanics or just another day of war.

rroberson - I used to think the way that you do on this issue, but then someone (I forget who) had me look at it like this.

The game has no option for reducing fortifications by air attack. The only way the game allows fort reduction it is to actually carry out a land combat attack. So, instead of looking at these AF attacks as attacks on the AF, consider them instead to be attacks on the fortified ground defenses in the hex. Your opponent is intending to reduce the forts, but the game doesn't allow it, so this is his way of accomplishing his goal.

It works for me. Hopefully it can help set you at ease too.


Works for me. I really thought it was just a bug at first...now that I know it is not. I carry on.
Image
User avatar
witpqs
Posts: 26376
Joined: Mon Oct 04, 2004 7:48 pm
Location: Argleton

RE: fortification building question

Post by witpqs »

ORIGINAL: rroberson

As the opponent in the game mike is referencing let me relate what is happening.

Mike has decided to flatten Singapore with air power. We are about 3 weeks into our game. Now Mike isn't flattening the airfields to keep me from flying out of there, but rather to prevent me from building up the fortresses in Singapore. To me, this is taking advantage of a game mechanic. Just like flying 4Es against naval targets or using them to bomb targets under 10K is a game mechanic. Both of those things are really effective but hardly realistic and we have house rules to govern them. To me, this is the exact same thing.

Now cratering an airfield should have nothing to do with an armies ability to dig fox holes or set up barricades yet, due to the mechanics of the game that's precisely what is happening. Mike admits he is taking advantage of that poor game design and bombing the airfield to prevent me from building up the fortress in Singapore before his forces can get there. Which will allows him to walk in and take it with little fuss. Now Singapore always falls, that is not at the heart of the issue here. However, taking advantage of a game mechanic that at best can be seen as poor game design is pretty gamey from my viewpoint and hardly sporting.

After what happened to me in a previous game where my opponent was exploiting every game weakness...I fully admit I am pretty sensitive to gamey play and may be going overboard here.

What say you? Gamey game mechanics or just another day of war.
Chiming in with a quick note. As far as the other two examples you gave - naval bombing with 4EB and bombing <10,000 ft with 4EB - I disagree that they are unrealistic or gamey. Flak has been adjusted a long, long time ago in this game. Examples from WWII were given in previous threads where 4EB at 1 mi were devastating on dug-in ground troops. The lesson is: have flak or be seen and treated as a 'soft target'.

The combination of flak effectiveness and naval bombing skill required have addressed the 4EB versus ship issue quite well, too.
rroberson
Posts: 2057
Joined: Tue May 25, 2004 7:53 am
Location: Arizona
Contact:

RE: fortification building question

Post by rroberson »

I suppose I need to start haunting the forums again. I had no idea that the 10K thing and the naval attacks with HBs had been resolved. Its been one of those long held "house" rules things I had always just accepted.
Image
User avatar
Lokasenna
Posts: 9304
Joined: Sat Mar 03, 2012 3:57 am
Location: Iowan in MD/DC

RE: fortification building question

Post by Lokasenna »

ORIGINAL: Icedawg
ORIGINAL: rroberson

As the opponent in the game mike is referencing let me relate what is happening.

Mike has decided to flatten Singapore with air power. We are about 3 weeks into our game. Now Mike isn't flattening the airfields to keep me from flying out of there, but rather to prevent me from building up the fortresses in Singapore. To me, this is taking advantage of a game mechanic. Just like flying 4Es against naval targets or using them to bomb targets under 10K is a game mechanic. Both of those things are really effective but hardly realistic and we have house rules to govern them. To me, this is the exact same thing.

Now cratering an airfield should have nothing to do with an armies ability to dig fox holes or set up barricades yet, due to the mechanics of the game that's precisely what is happening. Mike admits he is taking advantage of that poor game design and bombing the airfield to prevent me from building up the fortress in Singapore before his forces can get there. Which will allows him to walk in and take it with little fuss. Now Singapore always falls, that is not at the heart of the issue here. However, taking advantage of a game mechanic that at best can be seen as poor game design is pretty gamey from my viewpoint and hardly sporting.

After what happened to me in a previous game where my opponent was exploiting every game weakness...I fully admit I am pretty sensitive to gamey play and may be going overboard here.

What say you? Gamey game mechanics or just another day of war.

rroberson - I used to think the way that you do on this issue, but then someone (I forget who) had me look at it like this.

The game has no option for reducing fortifications by air attack. The only way the game allows fort reduction it is to actually carry out a land combat attack. So, instead of looking at these AF attacks as attacks on the AF, consider them instead to be attacks on the fortified ground defenses in the hex. Your opponent is intending to reduce the forts, but the game doesn't allow it, so this is his way of accomplishing his goal.

It works for me. Hopefully it can help set you at ease too.

This is how I see it. It's a kludgey tool for simulating the bombing of embankments, bunkers, etc.
User avatar
witpqs
Posts: 26376
Joined: Mon Oct 04, 2004 7:48 pm
Location: Argleton

RE: fortification building question

Post by witpqs »

ORIGINAL: rroberson

I suppose I need to start haunting the forums again. I had no idea that the 10K thing and the naval attacks with HBs had been resolved. Its been one of those long held "house" rules things I had always just accepted.
I must point out that opinions vary about this as much as anything else, but I'm sure you already realized that! [:D]
User avatar
Lowpe
Posts: 24582
Joined: Mon Feb 25, 2013 2:25 pm

RE: fortification building question

Post by Lowpe »

If that airfield is operational, what is there to stop you from flying in fighters to cap trap, or flying in bombers, even 4es, for a quick raid. It is a big airfield, with air hqs, and is very dangerous.
Post Reply

Return to “War in the Pacific: Admiral's Edition”