ORIGINAL: rroberson
Egads that's horrible. Yeah that HR should remain in place. I have been going with the standard no 4Es against naval targets...that practice will continue.
It's not horrible. It is, as usual when 4Es are discussed, half the story.
You don't need to play Babes to get the flak upgrades. They are addable in a stock scenario. Lokasenna and I are playing with them (also the ASW changes.) At 2000 feet anything and everything on the ground can generate damage on the 4E.
Second, the test requires trained naval attack crews in the 4Es. Those are hard to mix with trained Ground attack pilots. It takes a long time to train both, or it takes swapping for Naval and waiting the delay for the pilots to show up. By then the port might be clean.
Third, VPs for 4E are doubled. Shoot down three and that's a basic IJN DD. It's a medium xAK. It's some I-boats. Given the replacement rates on 4Es that's a bad trade IMO, since in many cases one 500lb hit on those targets can be repaired if Fires are not too high.
Fourth, 4Es have a terrible ops loss rate from landing damaged. They don't get shot down that much early game, but they break out of sight of the Japanese player. If they land damaged they often take 7-10 days to be repaired at a medium-sized field. A DB is ready in a third to a quarter of the time.
Fifth, it is very expensive in terms of supply to get those bombs on target. Flying 25 4Es from an island will stress the supply burn severely and bring lots of xAKs into risk from subs.
I've probably done as many Port attacks with 4Es as most players and they are not a wonder weapon. Used against moving naval targets they're a terrible choice too. Worse. In some cases, where the Japan player masses 70 or more ships in a port in range of a bunch of 4Es, sure, use them. But not at 2000 feet. Crazy. Balloons alone will get them at 6000 or below. At 9000 and up they have a decent shot against flak, and most bombs will miss. They might get 3-4 hits, 1-2 of which might be fatal. Call it 6-12 VPs. Lose three and it's -6 against that sum, plus the damage, plus the supply, plus the use of av. support that doesn't go to any other friendly planes at that base.
Which is why, as I've long maintained and history showed, their primary use over the whole war ought to be on strategic targets.