Mike (Ger) vs Kamil (Sov) - 41 AltCV

Post descriptions of your brilliant victories and unfortunate defeats here.

Moderators: Joel Billings, Sabre21

KamilS
Posts: 1827
Joined: Fri Feb 04, 2011 10:51 pm

RE: Mike (Ger) vs Kamil (Sov) - 41 AltCV

Post by KamilS »

M60A3TTS


Giving up the Dnepr line near Kiev was a questionable call. That opened the door to what has happened here. Are there many Soviet units being pocketed? Seems not to be the case, just the Soviet side giving up a lot of ground.


I am afraid I disagree.


If you compare advance in the south in all 3 recent Pelton games, you will see, that it was fairly similar until turn 6.

What made the difference was Mike's ability to keep his panzers supplied far beyond my ability to contain them. Repeatedly my positions were flanked, stretched and pierced. There was no stop-gap in German advace, that would have enabled me to consolidate my positions.


If I defended Dnepr with forces at hand I would have lost more units and in the longer run result would be same at best (possibly worse). If I kept more forces in the south, I would greatly limit my chances of success near Leningrad.


I wanted to eventuate industry not only from Kharkov and Stalino but from Zaporozhe and Dnepropetrovsk too while simultaneously successfully fighting in the north. I gambled and lost, thanks to Mike tactical and logistical skill, but I disagree, that abandoning middle Dnepr is in general bad idea.
Kamil
User avatar
M60A3TTS
Posts: 4854
Joined: Fri May 13, 2011 1:20 am

RE: Mike (Ger) vs Kamil (Sov) - 41 AltCV

Post by M60A3TTS »

To clarify, I didn't say it was a bad idea. I said it was questionable. There isn't enough detail in the screenshots or the AAR to make an accurate assessment. It looks like you built a solid defense around the cities you want protected, Stalino/Makeevka/Gorlovka anyways. In doing so, that is going to open up some opportunities for Mike since you can't be strong everywhere.

What are your overall ground losses at this stage? Are you trying to get 100% of the industry out of the Donbas?
KamilS
Posts: 1827
Joined: Fri Feb 04, 2011 10:51 pm

RE: Mike (Ger) vs Kamil (Sov) - 41 AltCV

Post by KamilS »

Well, I was trying to evacuate all industry but ... Mike comprehensively outplayed me.



Loses were low (around 1.5M), I will try to remember to include casualties in next batch of screenshots.
Kamil
Post Reply

Return to “After Action Reports”