
Pat vs Ronnie GW AAR
Moderator: Shannon V. OKeets
RE: Pat vs Ronnie GW AAR
No need to worry about rebasing.


- Attachments
-
- MJ42i3gr..ikesAA.jpg (560.52 KiB) Viewed 177 times
Pat
RE: Pat vs Ronnie GW AAR
MJ42 i3
Axis Ground Strike Results
Now, if I can just get enough troops to the beaches of Western France.

Axis Ground Strike Results
Now, if I can just get enough troops to the beaches of Western France.

- Attachments
-
- MJ42i3gr..results.jpg (2.23 MiB) Viewed 177 times
Pat
RE: Pat vs Ronnie GW AAR
Never mind.ORIGINAL: ashkpa
I will run the battle shortly, but the fighter will not make it back over the Dnieper. It's range is 3 and that is too far from the site of the battle.Yes. Instructions, target the bomber. Stay until the bombers is either shot-down, aborted or cleared or the fighter is aborted or shot down. Rebased in the woods behind the Dnieper.
Ronnie
RE: Pat vs Ronnie GW AAR
Ronnie,
I believe there is a bug, check the Tech Support Area.
I believe you should have the option of flying 1 pt of ground support into an attack on St-Malo, but the CW is never given the option.
Attack is 12:12 for +2, +5 for flipped units and +0.5 for blitz with the ARM-division. I have nothing that can reach the hex and the only support you can provide is the Albacore, all of your shore bombardment has been used getting ashore and the two CA remaining face-up are carrying divisions. If you wish to fly, then we will need to off-line determine and roll the fractional and then modify the actual roll as needed.
I believe the fractional would be 5/6ths of a chance for me to get to +2, otherwise it is +1(2:3 odds). I could roll the fractional on ACTS and it would send you a notice of the roll as well. I could roll it has a 1000 side dice or a 6 sided dice.
Pat
P.S. There are two other attacks on the East Front, but no reaction is possible.
I believe there is a bug, check the Tech Support Area.
I believe you should have the option of flying 1 pt of ground support into an attack on St-Malo, but the CW is never given the option.
Attack is 12:12 for +2, +5 for flipped units and +0.5 for blitz with the ARM-division. I have nothing that can reach the hex and the only support you can provide is the Albacore, all of your shore bombardment has been used getting ashore and the two CA remaining face-up are carrying divisions. If you wish to fly, then we will need to off-line determine and roll the fractional and then modify the actual roll as needed.
I believe the fractional would be 5/6ths of a chance for me to get to +2, otherwise it is +1(2:3 odds). I could roll the fractional on ACTS and it would send you a notice of the roll as well. I could roll it has a 1000 side dice or a 6 sided dice.
Pat
P.S. There are two other attacks on the East Front, but no reaction is possible.
Pat
RE: Pat vs Ronnie GW AAR
OK. If you have the dice I trust you to manually roll them. But go ahead with the defensive ground support and resolve as you feel is correct.ORIGINAL: ashkpa
Ronnie,
I believe there is a bug, check the Tech Support Area.
I believe you should have the option of flying 1 pt of ground support into an attack on St-Malo, but the CW is never given the option.
Attack is 12:12 for +2, +5 for flipped units and +0.5 for blitz with the ARM-division. I have nothing that can reach the hex and the only support you can provide is the Albacore, all of your shore bombardment has been used getting ashore and the two CA remaining face-up are carrying divisions. If you wish to fly, then we will need to off-line determine and roll the fractional and then modify the actual roll as needed.
I believe the fractional would be 5/6ths of a chance for me to get to +2, otherwise it is +1(2:3 odds). I could roll the fractional on ACTS and it would send you a notice of the roll as well. I could roll it has a 1000 side dice or a 6 sided dice.
Pat
P.S. There are two other attacks on the East Front, but no reaction is possible.
Ronnie
RE: Pat vs Ronnie GW AAR
MJ42 i3 Land attacks. Three attacks, we will start with the St-Malo, where I believe there is a bug that is not letting the CW fly the Albacore for ground support. Ronnie is flying it. Here is my calculations
odds of 12:13 are 5/6 of the way from 12:18 (2:3 = +1) and 12:12 (1:1 = +2), so the modifier is 1 + 5/6 = +1.8333
Then +5 for disorganized defenders
and +0.5 for ARM div in a blitz
Total is +7.333
With an external die roller I rolled a 5 on 6-sided die resulting in a missed fractional
So the total modifier should be +7 on the Blitz. (I set the fractional die roll in the image below to ensure the fractional was missed). Net result was an 18, which retreated the defenders off the beach (destroyed with no retreat path).

odds of 12:13 are 5/6 of the way from 12:18 (2:3 = +1) and 12:12 (1:1 = +2), so the modifier is 1 + 5/6 = +1.8333
Then +5 for disorganized defenders
and +0.5 for ARM div in a blitz
Total is +7.333
With an external die roller I rolled a 5 on 6-sided die resulting in a missed fractional
So the total modifier should be +7 on the Blitz. (I set the fractional die roll in the image below to ensure the fractional was missed). Net result was an 18, which retreated the defenders off the beach (destroyed with no retreat path).

- Attachments
-
- MJ42 i3 st..o attack.jpg (620.84 KiB) Viewed 177 times
Pat
RE: Pat vs Ronnie GW AAR
MJ42 i3: Land attacks on East Front
Axis achieved their goals here as well.

Axis achieved their goals here as well.

- Attachments
-
- MJ42 i3 Ea.. Attacks.jpg (1.47 MiB) Viewed 177 times
Pat
RE: Pat vs Ronnie GW AAR
MJ42 i3 end:
Here are images of two key areas.
Notice the Blitz in the Ukraine has isolated, at least temporarily, several Russian armies and threatens the resources.
The heroic ARM division is under the 5-1 Garrison. They are marching to take out Brest next.

Here are images of two key areas.
Notice the Blitz in the Ukraine has isolated, at least temporarily, several Russian armies and threatens the resources.
The heroic ARM division is under the 5-1 Garrison. They are marching to take out Brest next.

- Attachments
-
- MJ42 i3 Ke.. Updates.jpg (938.36 KiB) Viewed 177 times
Pat
RE: Pat vs Ronnie GW AAR
Turn 17. May/June 1942. Allied #4. Actions.
The allies have their work cut out for themn to try to right the ship after a very well played impulse by Pat. The US and CW have a "Dieppe" on their hands at the beaches of Brest and St-Malo. The latter of which have just seen all allied forces their overrun and pushed back into the sea. In the Pacific, the Japanese continue to expand their sphere of control and now have put the US bases at Rabaul and Port Vila out of supply. And, let's not forgot the Eastern Front, the axis in southern Russia have put an entire Soviet Front out of supply and at risk of encirclement.
I must admit that I am up against a superior opponent and who's kicking my proverbial rear end. Pat is meticulous, relentless and an outstanding strategist. And you know what, I'm having a blast! Though this is a game I feel that I'm "interacting" with history. The situation that I encounter now in this game, I feel must be similar to how the allied leaders "felt" in the dark days of late 1941 and early 1942 in WW2. Well, with the very real and critical exception that my casualties are virtual counters removed from the map versus flesh and blood. A most comforting exception I must say.

The allies have their work cut out for themn to try to right the ship after a very well played impulse by Pat. The US and CW have a "Dieppe" on their hands at the beaches of Brest and St-Malo. The latter of which have just seen all allied forces their overrun and pushed back into the sea. In the Pacific, the Japanese continue to expand their sphere of control and now have put the US bases at Rabaul and Port Vila out of supply. And, let's not forgot the Eastern Front, the axis in southern Russia have put an entire Soviet Front out of supply and at risk of encirclement.
I must admit that I am up against a superior opponent and who's kicking my proverbial rear end. Pat is meticulous, relentless and an outstanding strategist. And you know what, I'm having a blast! Though this is a game I feel that I'm "interacting" with history. The situation that I encounter now in this game, I feel must be similar to how the allied leaders "felt" in the dark days of late 1941 and early 1942 in WW2. Well, with the very real and critical exception that my casualties are virtual counters removed from the map versus flesh and blood. A most comforting exception I must say.

- Attachments
-
- 04ALACTIONS.jpg (496.93 KiB) Viewed 177 times
Ronnie
RE: Pat vs Ronnie GW AAR
Turn 17. May/June 1942. Allied #4. IJN Intercept?
The USN moves the (out of supply) BB Wyoming and transport based at Rabul into the Coral Sea.
Do the Japanese wish to attempt to intercept?

The USN moves the (out of supply) BB Wyoming and transport based at Rabul into the Coral Sea.
Do the Japanese wish to attempt to intercept?

- Attachments
-
- 04ALIJN..QUESTION.jpg (218.37 KiB) Viewed 177 times
Ronnie
RE: Pat vs Ronnie GW AAR
Turn 17. May/June 1942. Allied #4. Eastern Med, Axis Intercept?
Do the axis wish to attempt to intercept the two RN heavy cruisers moving into the Eastern Med from Malta? If so, which unit do you wish to use for the attempt?

Do the axis wish to attempt to intercept the two RN heavy cruisers moving into the Eastern Med from Malta? If so, which unit do you wish to use for the attempt?

- Attachments
-
- 04ALAXI..Question.jpg (231 KiB) Viewed 177 times
Ronnie
RE: Pat vs Ronnie GW AAR
Turn 17. May/June 1942. Allied #4. IJN Intercept?
The RN moves a transport loaded with a fighter into the Arabian Sea.
Do the Japanese wish to attempt intercept? If so, which unit do they use for the attempt?

The RN moves a transport loaded with a fighter into the Arabian Sea.
Do the Japanese wish to attempt intercept? If so, which unit do they use for the attempt?

- Attachments
-
- 04ALIJN..estion2.jpg (240.95 KiB) Viewed 177 times
Ronnie
RE: Pat vs Ronnie GW AAR
Yes. Target is the transport primarily. Sub will dive deep and not be committed to the battle.The USN moves the (out of supply) BB Wyoming and transport based at Rabul into the Coral Sea.
Do the Japanese wish to attempt to intercept?
Pat
RE: Pat vs Ronnie GW AAR
Yes, use the Condor.Do the axis wish to attempt to intercept the two RN heavy cruisers moving into the Eastern Med from Malta? If so, which unit do you wish to use for the attempt?
Pat
RE: Pat vs Ronnie GW AAR
Yes, the only one available is the CA.Do the Japanese wish to attempt intercept? If so, which unit do they use for the attempt?
Pat
RE: Pat vs Ronnie GW AAR
Turn 17. Allied #4. IJN Intercept Attempt. Arabian Sea.
This attempt fails and the loaded transport continues on to the 0-box of the Red Sea.

This attempt fails and the loaded transport continues on to the 0-box of the Red Sea.

- Attachments
-
- 04ALIJN..Attempt.jpg (240.55 KiB) Viewed 177 times
Ronnie
RE: Pat vs Ronnie GW AAR
Turn 17. Allied #4. German NAV Intercept Attempt. East Med.
The attempt fails. The two RN heavy cruisers continue on to the 0-box of the Arabian Sea.

The attempt fails. The two RN heavy cruisers continue on to the 0-box of the Arabian Sea.

- Attachments
-
- 04ALGER..Attempt.jpg (226.34 KiB) Viewed 177 times
Ronnie
RE: Pat vs Ronnie GW AAR
Turn 17. Allied #4. IJN Intercept Attempt. Coral Sea.
The attempt succeeds. The USN transport and battleship stop and go into the 2-box of the Coral Sea.

The attempt succeeds. The USN transport and battleship stop and go into the 2-box of the Coral Sea.

- Attachments
-
- 04ALIJN..Attempt.jpg (226.36 KiB) Viewed 177 times
Ronnie
RE: Pat vs Ronnie GW AAR
Turn 17. Allied #4. USN and RN Contested Sea Areas. The Pacific.
No attempt by the USN or RN to try to initiate a naval combat in any of these four sea areas.

No attempt by the USN or RN to try to initiate a naval combat in any of these four sea areas.

- Attachments
-
- 04ALNAV..oCombat.jpg (1.15 MiB) Viewed 177 times
Ronnie
RE: Pat vs Ronnie GW AAR
Turn 17. Allied #4. RN Contested Sea Areas. East Med.
No attempt by the RN to try to initiate a naval combat in the East Med.

No attempt by the RN to try to initiate a naval combat in the East Med.

- Attachments
-
- 04ALNAV..oCombat.jpg (334.7 KiB) Viewed 177 times
Ronnie