Vichy Collapse bug

[joshuamnave]

Using a rail move to rail a vichy unit from one city to another within vichy causes it to collapse.

[Shannon V. OKeets]

ORIGINAL: Zartacla

Using a rail move to rail a vichy unit from one city to another within vichy causes it to collapse.

I could not reproduce this.

I railed units from every city in Vichy France to every other city in Vichy France, including moving an HQ to a non-city. I even railed an air unit between two cities. There were no problems at all.

[joshuamnave]

rail the unit in lyons down to marseilles. Causes a vichy collapse for me.

Ahhh - in your tests was Vichy neutral? In this file, Vichy is at war with, but not hostile to, CW

[Shannon V. OKeets]

ORIGINAL: Zartacla

rail the unit in lyons down to marseilles. Causes a vichy collapse for me.

Ahhh - in your tests was Vichy neutral? In this file, Vichy is at war with, but not hostile to, CW

Which is why I always ask for saved games with instructions. It avoids having me spend time and effort on things I can't reproduce.

[joshuamnave]

And yet... the file I uploaded hasn't been downloaded. This is why I stopped uploading saves for so long - it avoids having me spend time and effort on things that are not wanted.

You know what would be great? An in game option to post a bug report that automatically includes a save file. No more having to open another window, log in to message board, get past the captcha, go into my save game folder, create a zip because the save game files are something like .5% too large to post directly, then write up a bug report, go back into my folder and upload the zip... all to voluntarily help fix bugs in a game that I paid full retail for something like four years ago. I spent some time doing QA for computer games and used to get paid for doing that kind of thing.

Just sayin'

[Centuur]

Give us some time, will you! You posted this gamesave two days ago. We can't investigate everything immediately, can't we?

Now, here comes the conclusion after investigating the gamesave:

I can't reproduce this using your gamesave, using the latest beta testers version. So I hope that in the next public beta, your problem will disappear.

[Shannon V. OKeets]

ORIGINAL: Centuur

Give us some time, will you! You posted this gamesave two days ago. We can't investigate everything immediately, can't we?

Now, here comes the conclusion after investigating the gamesave:

I can't reproduce this using your gamesave, using the latest beta testers version. So I hope that in the next public beta, your problem will disappear.

I confirmed that with 2.5.2.0 too.