The Last Stand: Final Months of the Battle (October-December 1943) NOW WITH GAME FILE

Post descriptions of your brilliant successes and unfortunate demises
SoulBlazer
Posts: 766
Joined: Sun Oct 27, 2002 5:28 am
Location: Providence RI

Post by SoulBlazer »

Well, it's the last day of October 1942. Drex has exactly 60 days left in order to try to claim victory.

Today I was surprised to see a Allied Inf unit landed at Lea Lea! How it got there undected I don't know -- maybe a sub drop off? He's got subs all over the place now -- I'm lucky only one AO has been hit as of late by them.

I'm still seeing that massive fleet of CV's, CVE's, BB's, and change north of Australia -- but no transports. There are some near Irau, but I'm not sure which way they are heading.

I have no less then six plans in the back of my mind to deal with a Allied attack, but I'm not moving the Combined Fleet out until I am sure what is going on. Even then, I'm not sure how things might go -- or if it might just be another turkey shoot as recently doomed Lusakn in his AAR.

On the bright side, my airplane losses are not that bad this last game week, the bases are still functional despite bombing, and my transports continue to unload at Lunga without interference. :D
The US Navy could probaly win a war without coffee, but would prefer not to try -- Samuel Morison
SoulBlazer
Posts: 766
Joined: Sun Oct 27, 2002 5:28 am
Location: Providence RI

Post by SoulBlazer »

Still waiting to see what Drex does with that fleet.

Is anyone reading this? Replies are nice now and then. :D
The US Navy could probaly win a war without coffee, but would prefer not to try -- Samuel Morison
Bradman
Posts: 46
Joined: Fri Oct 25, 2002 1:34 am
Location: Sydney, Australia

Post by Bradman »

Um, I am, and enjoying it too. I'm just a bit of a lurker that's all. :o :rolleyes:
User avatar
dpazuk
Posts: 119
Joined: Mon Feb 25, 2002 10:00 am
Location: Ottawa, Canada

Post by dpazuk »

I'm reading it as well. Long time lurker...short time poster :D
Blah Blah Blah
SoulBlazer
Posts: 766
Joined: Sun Oct 27, 2002 5:28 am
Location: Providence RI

Post by SoulBlazer »

BATTLE UPDATES!

I've not put anything up today because the turns have been flying. Both Drex and I were home for most of today so the the action has been hot and furious.

Here is a attempt to describe the major events of the last seven days of battle:

NOVEMBER 1st

It is confirmed by Japanese Intel that air attacks on PM are stepping up, and that a massive Allied fleet seen off of the north coast of Australia the last few days is indeed heading north. With worth of this announcement, the fitting Japanese plan is taken out and called into action. All day every fit warship in Rabul is organized into a fleet, fueled up, given a commander, and made ready to leave port.

The carriers all form in one task group, believing that saftey is in numbers. Over 400 planes are on deck, but it is known there will be massive air losses to inflict any damage on the Allies. A conservative aporach is needed, so Nagato flies his flag from mightly Zuikaku.

All of Japan's battleships and her best cruisers and destroyers gather in a second fleet -- eight BB's in all, led by the awsome Musashi. Flying her flag in this ship is the amazing Tanaka.

Finally, a second surface combat fleet of damaged and supporting elments makes up the rear, led by Admiral Kondo, flying his flag from Mogami.

By evening, the fleets are ready and leave harbor, along with a transport and a small escort fleet and the last Japanese sub.

NOVEMBER 2nd

I had delayed sending out the Combined Fleet for two reasons -- to make sure I knew where Drex was attacking, and in the hope that my airbase planes would soften him up or at least tire him out. But waiting also means that the base has a chance to get pounded. Today my planes from PM did try to attack the Americans but were wasted without any hits. I moved my three fleets south from Rabul on a corse away from any Allied bases and made sure they remained in training. They would regroup at 'Point Z' just east of GG.

The American subs saw me first, though. One managed to put a fish into one of heavy cruisers. The damage was'nt bad but the ship had to turn away to Shortland to make sure it did'nt get worse. Despite being damaged by a depth charging, it attacked again the same day, this time hitting a destroyer and also sending it home. But the sub was not lucky enough to aboid a second depth charging and she was confirmed sunk.

I also noticed that the American fleet was aproaching Lea Lea, which they had allready taken by landing a small unit a few days eariler.

Despite possibly losing surprise, I pushed on.

NOVEMBER 3rd

Today the fleets reached 'Point Z' without further incident. They refuled and got ready to go into combat, and pilots were taken off of training.

Thunderstorms came in today, thus allowing the American crews to rest as well, although bombers from Aussie land continued to strike PM. Somehow the base was still functional although I was losing a lot of planes. The Allied fleet parked either right off PM or at Lea Lea.

To my surprise, I saw THAT was where the Allied troops were landing, and not at PM.

Another American sub attacked today, but it's spread missed and the sub was damaged heavily.

NOVEMBER 4th

Today was the big day for air combat. The weather was still thunderstorms but both carrier fleets got close to one another and traded off air strikes. PM was too damged to do much more then send a few Zero's over my carriers for extra CAP.

The net result of the day was that I lost over 100 planes with the Allies losing only around 50. I lucked out with damage. Only the Shokaku was hit and it was a minor hit. On the Allied side, Victorius was hit hard with two bombs and a torpedo, and two CVL's were also reproted damaged.

As the sun set, the carriers headed a little to the east to regroup with the support fleet and the main battleship fleet charged in to Lea Lea. A large fleet was still present there as well, and many units were unloaded, especily the Eng units.

NOVEMBER 5th

The turn started off with the expected surface combat. Tanaka's fleet of 8 BB's, 4 CA's, 2 CL's, and 4 DD's ran into a covering Allied fleet consiting of 5 BB's, 5 CL's, and 8 DD's. The fighting was hard and fast, fought at long range first and then closing. Neither side had much luck with torpedos, but there was no surprise.

The battle left two battleships on each side hurt, one a little worse then the other -- Nagato the worst and then Mutsu for the Japanese, and Massachusets the worst and then Nevada for the Allies. Musashi had taken a fair ammount of damage as well, as she was ganged up on, and had to be seperated from the main fighting fleet. A heavy cruiser and a few destroyers were also hit hard enough to be compeled to retire. On the American side, it looked like every ship had been hit hard, with the light cruisers espeicly battered. Two Japanese DD's and one American CL and DD sank after the battle.

Tanaka had orders to go for the transports, even though much of their unloading was down, and he succeeded in doing so, falling upon a CVE with transport ships and MSW's. One Japanese DD sank due to previous wounded, but the American CVE was sunk as well as a number of support ships. After this, Tanaka withdrew his fleet.

The day's weather remained Thunderstorms and the American carriers had not gotten any closer to my ships. This allowed me to rain down strikes -- but not on the main carriers, as they were hidden, but on support CVE's. Their air attacks sank one CVE and crippled a second, as well as hitting a few other minor ships. Very minor air losses were suffered.

Also, a American unit showed up in GG and started to attack, but the Japanese had ample time to dig in and beat off the attacks.

NOVEMBER 6th.

Today opened with a bang -- both sides most wounded battleships found themselves at grief. One of the Japanese subs in the area was lucky enough to pick the right route that some crippled Allied ships might take heading back to Australia and found the big modern BB Massachustes in his sights, with only a light escort. A spread of six Long Lances were fired, and the deadly fish showed they had not lost their touch. Three connected solidly into the allready hurt BB, and she blew up and sank in a matter of minutes. The DD's did succeed in damaging the Japanese sub with a lucky depth charge. Drex has now lost his last modern BB.

As the sun rose, the weather softened a little to rain but air strikes would still be impacted. Nagato was badly hurt and limping away slowly. Unlike Mustu, who was east of GG allready and attacked by American subs twice. They managed to sink her DD escort but the big target itself was untouched.

I hoped that Nagato would draw the attention of the American carrier planes, and she did. All morning she was hit hard, but she remained afloat, although a burning wreck by mid day. In the afternoon she was hit again, and finally in the evening she rolled over and sank.

She had done her work, though, as it allowed my carriers to get further away and launch more strikes on the American carriers, also working with planes from PM. One small strike was down to two Kates by the time they got into range of a Essex class carrier. One was shot down, the other damaged, but the damaged pilot stayed true on course, and hit the carrier with a good solid hit, leaving the enemy flattop in flames. An allready damaged CVL was also reported hit. The crippled CVE from a couple days back sank.

With both sides having lost a battleship, Tanaka reorganized his combat fleet and was sent charging into attack Lae Lae again, still filled with American ships.

NOVEMBER 7th

Weather finally improved to overcast, allowing both sides to launch strikes at one another. The Japanese fell back slowly while the Americans also cautiously followed.

Tanaka went into Lae Lae again and attacked three different American fleets. A damaged CVE was shot at but not hit. Two CL's and a DD were blasted to the bottom of the ocean, as was the primary target of the raid -- enemy transports. However, Hyuga took two torpedo hits and left the battle badly hurting.

American strikes thus focused on the damaged Hyuga, furhter damaging her, and also managing good hits on the Haruna. This further reduces the power of the once mightly Japanese navy. At least the Americans have been hurt as well. Only one American strike went in for the carriers -- 26 unescorted Avengers, with 20 shot down and the other six damaged.

Long range bombers from Lunga and Japanese carrier strikes tried to pentrate the thick American CAP, but no hits were reported. Both sides must be exausted by this point.

GG continues to stay in Japanese hands for the time being.

How long will Japanese luck last? And is the damage being inflicted on the Americans enough to hold the line? A lot of transports have been sunk but a lot of Japanese ships damaged. Only time will answer that question.
The US Navy could probaly win a war without coffee, but would prefer not to try -- Samuel Morison
SoulBlazer
Posts: 766
Joined: Sun Oct 27, 2002 5:28 am
Location: Providence RI

Post by SoulBlazer »

ANOTHER UPDATE

Not sure who is reading here, but I'll continue with the postings. :D

NOVEMBER 8th

Hyuga was not doing well. The ship, as previously reported, had taken two torpedo hits during Tanaka's second raid and while the ship was'nt in danger of sinking her speed was very slow. Since luck had been riding with me, I pushed it -- for the past few days my carriers had been falling back to around GG but I let them stick around and sent my remaining carrier planes into battle, trying to buy time for the Hyuga to escape.

For very minor damage on the Allied fleet I had a CVL blasted almost to the point of sinking and a second CVL and a CV damaged. I was willing to have some damage to my carriers because of my 300 plane losses -- what planes I had left I could easily put on a few carriers. Especily with time running out. Not wanting to lose all of them, though, I finally decided to split the fleet and bug out, putting all my remaining planes on ASW to try to get through the sub net Drex had put in.

Despite some sightings, no American sub attacks were made during the trip home, much to Drex's chargin. ;)

NOVEMBER 9th

Having left Hyuga to her fate, it came as no shock to me the American carriers closed east of GG and attacked the ship, sinking her and her escort DD. That was now two BB's I had lost, although this was a older one. Lunga was not quite shut down, but none of the level bombers attacked. PM was shut down for the most part, and all I could do was try to offer resistance to some of the daily bombing raids coming in.

Transports carried troops to Buna and northern NG to ensure that even if Drex did take PM he would'nt be able to push past it.

American troops landed at GG. This base, weakly held since I took it at the start of the game, would easily fall. I was'nt terribly concerened about that.

NOVEMBER 10th

GG fell to the Americans. I also noticed some American troops at Russel Island base. However, the Americans were in for a rude shock -- I had just recently transported some troops there (those two things still having a lot off) and I knew I could hold the base easily enough.

The last of the cripples made it home from the week long naval battle off of PM. I shuffled my remaining 150 planes around my healthy carriers, fueled up the ships, and started sending FT's out with the best ships, sending the cripples on to Truk. Since I thought maybe the US would be bold enough to come raid Rabul, I wanted them gone. Luckily, after sticking around one more day, the American war fleets seem to have returned to Australia.

A crippled US CL sank today, indicating that there was some lasting effects from our battles. The best was yet to come, though......

NOVEMBER 11th

Because I received a report today of the Nevada sinking off the coast of Australia! The second BB that had been crippled in my surface battle with them. Now we both lost two BB's and it made me feel a whole lot better. :)

The first American troops marched down to PM from the Allied landing base at Lae Lae (they are still working on turning that into a base).

Meanwhile, I continued to work with plans to try to make sure that PM holds -- or at least if it falls, to delay it as long as possible.

SUMMARY OF BATTLE

In retrospect, I don't know if I won or lost this battle. My objective was to try to delay the Americans from landing troops on NG, once it became clear that was his main target. In that, I failed, despite Tanaka shooting up a number of transports and drowning a small number of troops. PM is well garrisoned and defended but it is now cut off and I don't have the strength anymore to force it open. That does'nt mean I can't fight anymore -- luck was with me a lot doing these battles and many healthy units remain.

My secondary objective was just to delay the Allied forces as much as possible. In that goal, I did what I could.

Drex has told me a little about things from his side (we tend to be honest with one another once things like this wrap up), so I'll share what he has confirmed and what is just still educated guesswork on my part.

Japanese losses were two battleships and five destroyers, along with a sub. Three more battleships, three heavy cruisers, two light carriers, two fleet carriers, and four destroyers were damaged to varying degrees -- some will return to Truk and Japan, others will stay and see if they can't get patched up. Carrier airplane losses were about 300. Add in the PM and Lunga air losses and that's about another 150 more during the last two weeks.

Confirmed American losses are two battleships, three escort carriers, four light cruisers, two destroyers, and a sub, plus about a dozen support ships (MSW's, AK's, SC's, etc.) sunk. Estimates on damaged ships are three battleships (confirmed by Drex), two fleet carriers (not sure about Intrepid, but I know Victorius was hit hard), two light carriers, one escort carrier, two light cruisers, several destroyers, and a sub. Estimated American plane losses from both land and carriers during the last two weeks are about 200.

The Japanese navy is defentily in a weaker position, especily the carrier air arm. However, I may have bought enough time to make sure I did'nt lose the game. The American navy is a little weaker as well. I defentily had some luck with the weather and the AI attack routines in this one (helped him as well as me).

Drex said that he had put his CVE's in with the transports to help protect them and act as bait. It worked, but at what cost? If you look at the naval battle from the points aspect alone, then I won that. American ships are worth more points then Japanese ones. Two American BB's and three CVE's are worth a lot more points then two Japanese BB's. If he wants to overtake me in points, he failed to do it in the naval battle. It will have to be done on land.

Looking forward to what the last weeks of game play have. :cool:

'll post a game file after the next turn is run.
The US Navy could probaly win a war without coffee, but would prefer not to try -- Samuel Morison
User avatar
Drex
Posts: 2512
Joined: Wed Sep 13, 2000 8:00 am
Location: Chico,california

Post by Drex »

The decision to break up the CVEs among the important transport TFs was made to insure I would get the troops ashore. The object was to take PM and I knew I needed all the men I could land. The weather was my biggest enemy in that it surrounded my main CV TFs during the main part of the battle and prevented air strikes until you had bugged out. I still have my main CV force and the BBs aren't needed anymore.
Col Saito: "Don't speak to me of rules! This is war! It is not a game of cricket!"
SoulBlazer
Posts: 766
Joined: Sun Oct 27, 2002 5:28 am
Location: Providence RI

Post by SoulBlazer »

Here's the file I promised. One more day has played, with the battle for PM raging and Japanese troops landed again at GG.
Attachments
sb-drex game file.zip
(449.98 KiB) Downloaded 18 times
The US Navy could probaly win a war without coffee, but would prefer not to try -- Samuel Morison
User avatar
Apollo11
Posts: 25221
Joined: Thu Jun 07, 2001 8:00 am
Location: Zagreb, Croatia
Contact:

Any more updates?

Post by Apollo11 »

Hi all,

I find this AAR very interesting and I especially congratulate "SoulBlazer"
for his courage to let us see his inner works (i.e. his UV files)!

So... any more updates?


Leo "Apollo11"


P.S.
"SoulBlazer" you and I preliminary agreed on PBEM but I didn't hear from you
after that. Would we start PBEM after this one is finished?
Image

Prior Preparation & Planning Prevents Pathetically Poor Performance!

A & B: WitW, WitE, WbtS, GGWaW, GGWaW2-AWD, HttR, CotA, BftB, CF
P: UV, WitP, WitP-AE
Post Reply

Return to “After Action Reports”