Market Garden Scenarios

[MikeJ19]

Good day all,

I would like to do a Market Garden scenario and there are two options that come with the game. Has anyone played one of the following scenarios?

1. Market Garden 44 - this one is in the WWII - Western Front folder.

2. Holland - A bridge too Far 1944 - Custom Graphics folder

The maps and details are very different. So, I'm looking for some advice as to the best one to play...

Thanks,

[sapper32]

Also in the west front folder is West Wall Holland 1944 by Trey Marshall

Regards Sapper32

[Custer7]

I've played them all. The most historical OOB is Holland - A Bridge too Far 1944 -. It is 6hr turns, the other half day. So 40 turns vs 20 turns. I playtested it years ago for Erik. Trey's West Wall takes in a larger scope than the other two. It covers a longer period and the campaign in Holland, where Market Garden was just one episode. With Elmer the PO now a formidable foe, it would be interesting to see how any of them play out. I played them back in the early day, before III even. I think you would enjoy all of them.

[Custer7]

If you wanted an opponent, I'd be interested. It has been a while since I did PbeM. Either one is good.

[Silvanski]

West Wall Holland is a solid scenario

[MikeJ19]

Good evening all,

Thanks for the input. While at work today, I had decided that the bridge too far scenario was not really what I was looking for. However, having looked at the larger scenario - West Wall Holland - I think that it will be a challenge. It will be the longest scenario that I have tried and it looks like I have a variety of options. I'm going to give it a try, this should be fun.

Custer 7, thanks for the offer. However, I'm not ready yet to try a real opponent. I worry that I do not have enough time to make it fair for the other player. My gaming time gets reduced during the summer months...

Have a good day!