LST vs. IdahoNYer (DBB-C, A AAR) 6 yrs and done! VJ Day!

Post descriptions of your brilliant victories and unfortunate defeats here.

Moderators: wdolson, MOD_War-in-the-Pacific-Admirals-Edition

User avatar
IdahoNYer
Posts: 2744
Joined: Sun Sep 06, 2009 2:07 am
Location: NYer living in Boise, ID

22-23 Apr 44

Post by IdahoNYer »

22-23 Apr 44

Highlights – IJN surfaces forces raid into CV TFs with nasty results; Merak and Morotai landings go in.

Jpn ships sunk:
DD: 1 (Okinami)
MTB: 5
SC: 2
AMc: 1
xAP: 1

Allied ships sunk:
DD: 1 (Bell - collision)

Air loss:
Jpn: 94
Allied: 32

Subwar:
Jpn: 2 Attacks, 0 ships hit
Allies: 4 Attacks, 2 ships hit (PB, TK dam)

Jpn Amph Inv: None

Allied Amph Inv:
Merak (IO)
Morotai (SOPAC)

Bases lost: None

Bases Liberated:
Kluong (Burma - flipped, base just north of Singapore!)
Sorong (SOPAC)

SIGINT/Intel: Well, no air Kamikaze strikes against the CVs, but sort of a naval Kamikaze strike did well in the Celebes Sea - with minimal IJN losses….will this be a new tactic?

West Coast/Admin: NSTR.

In NOPAC, NSTR.

In CENPAC, DD TF (4DD) follow up the SBDs to Guam with good effect - finding and sinking two big xAPs and a dozen or so barges. DDs loiter, but will head back to Woleai next turn. Navy Heavies hit Saipan AF with good effect, but B-29s didn’t fly. Will continue the pressure on the Marianas.

In SOPAC, got a nasty surprise against US CV TFs as they closed on Tarakan. IJN came out with small surface forces to engage the carrier TFs - and of course, I had just detached the primary Allied surface TF to bombard Tarakan - which was effective, but ultimately cost the CVs. I had left two DD TFs of 3 DDs each to provide cover to the CVs, and that wasn’t enough. First surface contact off Tawi-Tawi was with an IJN DD TF (3DDs) which was duly engaged by the US DDs - neither side scored any hits. But the US DD TF was apparently distracted enough to allow the IJN CA TF (CA, 2CL, 2DDs) to get into the CV TF - despite US radar picking up the intruders at 25k yards, zero moonlight likely contributed to the issue, engagement started at 10k yds with wolf well amongst to flock - despite BBs, cruisers and DDs in the US CV TF, the IJN went right after the carriers and scored repeated hits with little return fire. By the end, CV Wasp took 3 8” shells while Intrepid, Bunker Hill and CVK Unicorn also took damage. Return fire was negligible, and the IJN withdrew without any major damage inflicted. Later, as the CV TFs got closer to Tarakan to launch daylight fighter sweeps against Miri/Brunei, IJN MTBs sortied and got in the mix of the CV TFs. Although no hits were scored by the MTBs, they did sow enough confusion to cause a few collisions - DD Bell was sunk and CLs Santa Fe and Montpelier damaged…Babar island mayhem revisited. Daylight brought good fighter sweeps against with 38 Zeros lost to 4 Corsairs - but no shipping was seen or hit by strikes. Navy fighters also swept Tarakan in support of very effective B-24 raids, but no fighters were engaged. The B-24s wrecked both oil and refinery production as well as closed the AF. At the end of the two days, CV Wasp as still burning with (76/60(13)/42/40 fires), CV Intrepid (26/12(3)/32(4), Bunker Hill (17/0/2) and CVL Unicorn (22/17(9)/12). Not good. Wasp will likely sink due to the fires before she can make Tarakan, but at least I got the pilots off. Intrepid will need to head to Pearl, and will see if Manus and the Fleet Train can repair Bunker Hill and Unicorn. Part of the US Fleet needs to take on fuel, and with the loss of the damaged CVs, will need to reorganize a bit as well. While the Celebes Sea mayhem was taking place, troops were landed at Morotai in good order and Sorong was taken in one attack. And despite the damaged CVs, the Talaud-eilanden landings will go in as scheduled as troops complete loading at Madang. The CVs are also needed to support SWPAC in the Makassar Strait, and also need to go back to provide fighters across to Miri/Brunei - that will be the tough mission. On the positive side, CV Wasp will be replace by Brit CV Illustrious, just finishing fitting out her new air group at Ceylon. CV Intrepid will rendezvous with CV Essex at Pearl and hand over her airgroup to Essex coming out of the Panama Canal. CV Franklin is also due in a few weeks, so while damaged, the Fleet is still in excellent shape.

In SWPAC, IJA troops at Makassar are eliminated in one attack with 2500 casualties. That wraps up major fighting on southern Celebes, and focus now shifts to the upcoming Bailkpapan/Samarinda landings as invasion convoys will depart embarkation ports next turn - all staging at Makassar before heading to target in a few days. After the successful Tarakan raids, most Heavies will rest, one group going to hit Manado to keep it surpressed. CVE TFs will also transit to Makassar from covering Morotai to provide cover for the Balikpapan landings - lots of moving pieces - not to mention keeping the flow of support troops and supplied into the newly won bases. Lastly, recon is showing very little IJA on Java - on the eastern end, only Soerbaja looks to be garrisoned, so will try and get some troops to establish a landing point as soon as practical - whether prepped or not.

In China, NSTR.

In Burma, that limited attack against a port unit easily pushed it aside with an Indian Bde in pursuit able to attack it again next turn. I’m not looking to push hard here, but will take an easy advance when possible. In the air, the fighter sweeps over Bangkok did well, downing 24 Tojos for 3 Spits and 2 P-47s. Heavies will follow more sweeps next turn, including B-29s based at Rangoon and B-24s out of Port Blair. Expecting a tough fight against additional fighters and heavy flak.

In the IO, 3rd Mar Div and support lands at Merak, with the bombardment apparently destroying a single token unit in the hex. But the base doesn’t “flip”, so Marines will have to take it next turn. Follow on troops - three Bdes worth - will be brought across the Sunda Strait as soon as possible to take advantage of the unexpected light resistance - recon shows Batavia is the only reported garrisoned base so far in the western end of the island. At sea, a CL TF (CL 2DD) and a DD TF (5DD) have transited the Sunda Strait and are still enroute to disrupt shipping in Miri/Brunei.

Image
Attachments
440423.jpg
440423.jpg (190.6 KiB) Viewed 277 times
User avatar
BBfanboy
Posts: 20554
Joined: Wed Aug 04, 2010 5:36 pm
Location: Winnipeg, MB
Contact:

RE: 22-23 Apr 44

Post by BBfanboy »

Ouch on the CV TFs. Good move on his part, combined with good die rolls for him.

CV Wasp might survive the fires if it has a good enough escort. I am not sure but some think that having a ship of similar size with her will help fight the fires, but that might also require remaining in hex to simulate the assisting ship alongside. Luck!
No matter how bad a situation is, you can always make it worse. - Chris Hadfield : An Astronaut's Guide To Life On Earth
User avatar
IdahoNYer
Posts: 2744
Joined: Sun Sep 06, 2009 2:07 am
Location: NYer living in Boise, ID

RE: 22-23 Apr 44

Post by IdahoNYer »

ORIGINAL: BBfanboy

Ouch on the CV TFs. Good move on his part, combined with good die rolls for him.

CV Wasp might survive the fires if it has a good enough escort. I am not sure but some think that having a ship of similar size with her will help fight the fires, but that might also require remaining in hex to simulate the assisting ship alongside. Luck!

Excellent move by L_S_T....and it gets worse!

No chance to help out the cripples on the next turn.....
User avatar
IdahoNYer
Posts: 2744
Joined: Sun Sep 06, 2009 2:07 am
Location: NYer living in Boise, ID

24-25 Apr 44

Post by IdahoNYer »

24-25 Apr 44

Highlights – First two US CVs are lost at sea. Enough said……

Jpn ships sunk:
SS: 3 (I-31, I-179, RO-40)
E: 3
SSX: 1
MTB: 8
TK: 2
xAK: 1

Jpn ships un-sunk:
SS: 1 (RO-104)

Allied ships sunk:
CV: 2 (Wasp, Intrepid) [:@]
SS: 1 (Thresher)

Air loss:
Jpn: 27
Allied: 206

Subwar:
Jpn: 2 Attacks, 0 ships hit
Allies: 6 Attacks, 5 ships hit (2E, 2TK sunk; TK dam)

Jpn Amph Inv: None

Allied Amph Inv: None

Bases lost: None

Bases Liberated:
Merak (IO)
Buitenzorg (IO-flipped)

SIGINT/Intel: Major Jpn air concentration discovered by air recon on Formosa; no idea where the IJN is concentrated however.

West Coast/Admin: CV Essex arrives in LA from Panama Canal. Will take aboard and transit two USMC night fighter squadrons and head to PH. Essex lacks a true carrier group, and with Intrepid lost with planes aboard, I’ll have to make one from ground based elements.

In NOPAC, NSTR.

In CENPAC, airstrikes against Saipan achieve little as recon didn’t fly. Will rest most bombers next turn and then resume strikes.

In SOPAC, L_S_T had a worse surprise was instore this turn….MTBs ranged out of Manado and intercepted CV Intrepid and its lone DD escort (AI had broke it off into an Escort TF) before the fleet could rejoin to it north of Manado - although DD Halligan sunk three of the six MTBs, the MTBs hit CV Intrepid with 5 torpedoes…needless to say, more than enough to sink her. CV Wasp, as expected foundered and sunk enroute to Ternate. Intrepid’s loss was totally unexpected, so her airgroup was of course aboard….and the majority - but not all - the pilots were lost. Tracker accounts for all the pilots - many were KIA, some WIA, some MIA and some will go straight to the reserve pool. Interesting. I thought when a CV’s airgroup is lost with the CV, all the pilots were lost. Not so apparently. In any case, losing not one, but TWO CVs to bloody nuisance TFs, is a bitter blow. Cudos to L_S_T for a heck of a daring and successful raid! For now, the CVs will withdraw to refuel and reorganize in order to support the landings at Talaud-eilanden. Brit CV Illustrious will depart Ceylon next turn to join the fleet, and as mentioned, CV Essex is heading off the West Coast (Franklin is about a week behind). In the meantime, the Fleet is short over 100 fighters till then, and CV Bunker Hill and Brit CVL Unicorn still need to head to repairs. Tau Amphib will depart Madang and head to rendezvous with CVE TF out of Manus and a CA TF, now departing Morotai, at Sansapor in a few turns. Morotai holds two attacks, but the cost to the defenders is high (about 500 to 35 casualties respectively) and forts are reduced to 1, so I expect the base to be taken next turn. Transports begin taking assault troops off Sorong to reduce over stacking and remission. Other than the carrier debacle, things are on track in SOPAC. Just a flesh wound….

In SWPAC, Balikpapan and Samarinda Amphib TFs depart embarkation ports and head to staging areas at Makassar and Salajar respectively. CVE TFs, recently departed from Morotai will also link up there. Heavies hit Manado and will hit it again next turn with a max effort before switching attention to targets in Borneo. While the focus will be Balikpapan, recon is showing very little IJA presence in Java, so will attempt a quick landing on the eastern end with minimal troops shortly. SWPAC will need to release some assault shipping after Balikpapan to SOPAC/CENPAC as the Theater Main Effort shifts north in May.

In China, NSTR.

In Burma, the raid on Bangkok does fairly well, meeting no CAP while AA claims two B-24s and a B-29 for moderate damage. Will continue to hit Bangkok for a few turns or until the AF is unusable.

In the IO, Merak flips to Allied control with the Marines present and they will head to Batavia as additional troops are brought in by sea and airlift. The challenge is preparation - if Batavia is heavily fortified, losses may be heavy due to the minimal prep. But defenses appear to be minimal, not only in Batavia, but across Java. At sea, a DD TF (5DD) and a CL TF (CL, 2DD) will raid/bombard Miri next turn, and B-29s, weather permitting, will hit the base at night as well. The lone B-24 group remaining in Sumatra, along with B-25s, will hit Singapore for the first time next turn. Singapore remains heavily manned, but air recon shows no fighters - will sweep just the same.


Image
Attachments
440425.jpg
440425.jpg (135.24 KiB) Viewed 277 times
User avatar
Capt. Harlock
Posts: 5379
Joined: Sat Sep 15, 2001 8:00 am
Location: Los Angeles
Contact:

RE: 24-25 Apr 44

Post by Capt. Harlock »

Ouch. Really bad luck for Intrepid. (I wonder about the algorithm the AI uses to form TF's for crippled ships: IRL when the Franklin was nearly sunk, both Alaska and Guam were detached to escort her.)
Civil war? What does that mean? Is there any foreign war? Isn't every war fought between men, between brothers?

--Victor Hugo
ChuckBerger
Posts: 279
Joined: Wed Aug 09, 2006 11:11 pm

RE: 24-25 Apr 44

Post by ChuckBerger »

Yikes. Bad luck, no doubt... but I do wonder what went on under the hood here. I can usually come up with a plausible story for WitP outcomes, but this one is just too implausible. (The original sea battle, not the MTB strike afterwards.) A couple of IJN cruisers wandering in to the middle of a US carrier group, inflicting fatal damage, and sauntering out again unscathed, with the escorts doing nothing - nope, not buying it. Not at this stage of the war, with radar etc.
jwolf
Posts: 2493
Joined: Tue Dec 03, 2013 4:02 pm

RE: 24-25 Apr 44

Post by jwolf »

My sympathies as to the Wasp and Intrepid. The Japanese definitely got the breaks in that sequence of events, but in fairness they were probably overdue for a good run.

Why do a naval invasion at Batavia when you can just unload everything for free at Merak? [&:]
User avatar
Bif1961
Posts: 2014
Joined: Wed Jun 25, 2008 11:52 pm
Location: Phenix City, Alabama

RE: 24-25 Apr 44

Post by Bif1961 »

They might be using the Yorktown example when it was damaged and being towed from the area after Midway she had only one destroyer as an escort.
adarbrauner
Posts: 1523
Joined: Thu Nov 03, 2016 3:40 am
Location: Zichron Yaaqov, Israel; Before, Treviso, Italy

RE: 24-25 Apr 44

Post by adarbrauner »

You kept such a strong escort by your carriers I don't think you could be held in fault and responsible in any way;

As others wrote already is difficult to interpret such a behavior by the AI in determining the results of the sea clash...one would expect the escort was more than enough to fend off the attack. How can we justify what happened here from an historical-realistic point of view?
adarbrauner
Posts: 1523
Joined: Thu Nov 03, 2016 3:40 am
Location: Zichron Yaaqov, Israel; Before, Treviso, Italy

RE: 24-25 Apr 44

Post by adarbrauner »

Only thing I could think of is that your fleet's Op points were expended up at the time the AI determined the engagement, hence the lack of response by the escort. It is fairly possible LST took it into account!
adarbrauner
Posts: 1523
Joined: Thu Nov 03, 2016 3:40 am
Location: Zichron Yaaqov, Israel; Before, Treviso, Italy

RE: 24-25 Apr 44

Post by adarbrauner »

Where did the IJA ships sortie out from? And the MTBs? Did the come from different directions?

Could you provide a map?

That happened in the second day of the turn, right?
User avatar
IdahoNYer
Posts: 2744
Joined: Sun Sep 06, 2009 2:07 am
Location: NYer living in Boise, ID

RE: 24-25 Apr 44

Post by IdahoNYer »

ORIGINAL: Capt. Harlock

Ouch. Really bad luck for Intrepid. (I wonder about the algorithm the AI uses to form TF's for crippled ships: IRL when the Franklin was nearly sunk, both Alaska and Guam were detached to escort her.)

I've seldom (if ever) seen more than one, perhaps two DDs cut as escorts for cripples. What exactly triggers a ship being a "cripple" that is cut loose from a task force is also a mystery. For Intrepid, it was likely its fairly hefty engine damage - 32. But if I had the choice, I certainly wouldn't have detached her.

Such is life in WiTP!
User avatar
IdahoNYer
Posts: 2744
Joined: Sun Sep 06, 2009 2:07 am
Location: NYer living in Boise, ID

RE: 24-25 Apr 44

Post by IdahoNYer »

ORIGINAL: ChuckBerger

Yikes. Bad luck, no doubt... but I do wonder what went on under the hood here. I can usually come up with a plausible story for WitP outcomes, but this one is just too implausible. (The original sea battle, not the MTB strike afterwards.) A couple of IJN cruisers wandering in to the middle of a US carrier group, inflicting fatal damage, and sauntering out again unscathed, with the escorts doing nothing - nope, not buying it. Not at this stage of the war, with radar etc.


Not implausible at all with WiTP - real world, perhaps. But in the WiTP universe, large CV TFs are found to be very vulnerable to a surface action. Certainly not realisitic perhaps, but known and its my fault for not having a more robust surface task force to protect the CV TFs. Just chalk it up to lessons learned and will try not to let it happen again!
User avatar
IdahoNYer
Posts: 2744
Joined: Sun Sep 06, 2009 2:07 am
Location: NYer living in Boise, ID

RE: 24-25 Apr 44

Post by IdahoNYer »

ORIGINAL: jwolf

My sympathies as to the Wasp and Intrepid. The Japanese definitely got the breaks in that sequence of events, but in fairness they were probably overdue for a good run.

Why do a naval invasion at Batavia when you can just unload everything for free at Merak? [&:]


Long overdue jwolf….I've been extremely fortunate in this game so far. Especially against a guy as crafty as L_S_T!

As for Batavia, I'm not going to land at Batavia - I'll march there from Merak and other lightly defended locales. I'm just surprised there is so little defending Java.
User avatar
IdahoNYer
Posts: 2744
Joined: Sun Sep 06, 2009 2:07 am
Location: NYer living in Boise, ID

RE: 24-25 Apr 44

Post by IdahoNYer »

ORIGINAL: adarbrauner

Where did the IJA ships sortie out from? And the MTBs? Did the come from different directions?

Could you provide a map?

That happened in the second day of the turn, right?

I'm not really sure where the MTBs came from - I "think" Menado on the NE tip of Celebes. Sorry, can't do a map right now....but my CVs were in the Celebes Sea just north of Menado. You can get an idea from post 1206.


User avatar
IdahoNYer
Posts: 2744
Joined: Sun Sep 06, 2009 2:07 am
Location: NYer living in Boise, ID

26-27 Apr 44

Post by IdahoNYer »

26-27 Apr 44

Highlights – No disasters at sea this turn; back to business…

Jpn ships sunk:
SSX: 1
PB: 1
TK: 3
xAK: 2
xAKL: 2

Jpn ships un-sunk:
SS: 1 (I-185)

Allied ships sunk: None

Air loss:
Jpn: 28
Allied: 12

Subwar:
Jpn: 2 Attacks, 0 ships hit
Allies: 6 Attacks, 1 ship hit (TK sunk)

Jpn Amph Inv: None

Allied Amph Inv: None

Bases lost: None

Bases Liberated:
Morotai (SOPAC)

SIGINT/Intel: NSTR.

West Coast/Admin: Numerous APAs are due upgrades in April, and I’m now starting to head them to ports about 4-6 at a time. I’ve only done two so far. It’s a two-week upgrade that can be done at forward locations (no repair yard needed), which is good, but I don’t want to strip too much amphib assault capability all at once.

In NOPAC, NSTR.

In CENPAC, NSTR.

In SOPAC, back to normal operations. CV TFs take on fuel north of Sansapor, and they will need to reorganize a bit next turn before heading back out in combat configuration. BB Mass and a few CLs that are due a refit are cut loose to head to repair yards. Talaud-eilanden Amph and support are all still enroute to stage at Sansapor. In the air, Heavies from SOPAC and SWPAC focus on Manado with moderate results; they’ll need another go to shut the AF down. On the ground, troops take Morotai on the first attack, with the last 750 soldiers of the 6th South Seas Det being eliminated at a cost of 35 troops. Focus now shifts to Talaud, and then SOPAC will focus on bringing assets forward and consolidation as the main effort shifts to CENPAC in May.

In SWPAC, Balikpapan and Samarinda Amphib TFs with support depart staging areas and head to Balikpapan. Samirinda Amph will keep troops aboard initially as troops are landed at Balik. With recon showing few Jpn troops in Java - an Aussie IN Bn will be landed at the eastern tip at Banjoewangi and an Aussie CDO Bn will be droped on Tjepoe, just west of Soerbaja. Some limited additional support troops will be ferried in once these bases are secured, but Java will be a mostly IO Theater show. SWPAC’s focus will remain on Borneo.

In China, NSTR.

In Burma, the raid on Bangkok does fairly well, meeting no CAP while AA claims two B-24s and a B-29 for moderate damage. Raids continue to hit Bangkok and damage increases, but AF is still operational. Raids will continue.

In the IO, the DD and CL TFs find a pair of TKs off Miri/Brunei and sink them prior to bombarding Miri with poor results, although 9 Zeros, 3 Jakes and three other planes were destroyed on the ground. B-29s, coming in at night do neglible damage to oil, but take no losses to night fighters or AA. Will hit Miri AFs at night with the B-29s next turn, and DDs will set out from Palambang to raid shipping. Until Balikpapan AFs can be secured, bombing Miri will be limited to night. B-24s and B-25s focused on Singapore’s industry with limited results, but met no CAP and light AA. Will continue to target Singapore industry. Java right now is the primary focus, and Marines move inland from Merak and are airlanded at Buitenzorg. Canadian Bde is embarked at Oosthaven and will be landed east of Batavia at Kalidjati - with limited LRCAP support, so if I’m wrong about Java’s defenses, this could be messy. Two other Bdes are also being shipped over from Sumatra which should be enough to take Java (for a total of 4 Bdes from Sumatra), and can look to pull the US Marines out once Batavia falls. Once these Bdes are landed in Java, one Amphib TF will be pulled to Rangoon to land limited troops in northern Malaya, and all US APAs will detach back to SWPAC.
Image
Attachments
440427.jpg
440427.jpg (227.8 KiB) Viewed 277 times
User avatar
IdahoNYer
Posts: 2744
Joined: Sun Sep 06, 2009 2:07 am
Location: NYer living in Boise, ID

28-29 Apr 44

Post by IdahoNYer »

28-29 Apr 44

Highlights – Miri DD raid hit hard by Kamikazes enroute; landings on Java progressing rapidly.

Jpn ships sunk:
E: 1
SS: 1 (I-185)
MTB: 1
xAK: 1
xAKL: 1

Allied ships sunk:
DD: 3 (Philip, Arunta, Rapid)
SS: 1 (KXVI)

Air loss:
Jpn: 43
Allied: 29

Subwar:
Jpn: 2 Attacks, 0 ships hit
Allies: 4 Attacks, 4 ship hit (E sunk, CL (Kuma), TK, xAK dam)
SS KXVI sunk on surface in D/C attack and SS Sea Rover dam by mines off Cam Ranh Bay

Jpn Amph Inv: None

Allied Amph Inv:
Balikpapan (SWPAC)
Banjoewangi (SWPAC)
Kalidjati (IO)

Allied Airborne Attacks:
Tjepoe (SWPAC)
Melak (SWPAC)

Bases lost: None

Bases Liberated:
Melak (SWPAC)
Babo (SWPAC - flipped)
Tjepoe (SWPAC)
Kalidjati (IO)

SIGINT/Intel: Well….I’m again surprised by L_S_T! This time its launching Kamikazes on a DD sortie and using Babs and Jakes as Kamis. If he’s willing to do that, it adds much to his ability to interdict lightly defended convoys from undeveloped bases. I was figuring on the massing of Kamis on a high value target such as Amphib or CV TFs, not small groups on small targets.

West Coast/Admin: NSTR.

In NOPAC, NSTR.

In CENPAC, NSTR.

In SOPAC, CV TFs reorganize after refueling into three balanced TFs with 3CV/3CVLs each, giving them about 425 a/c each. The Fleet will now move into position just north of Talaud-eilanden to provide cover for the Amphib. The Amphib TF, plus a CVE TF and CA TF in support will depart Sansapor and head to target next turn. Heavies have reportedly shut down Manado AF, but Mindanao AFs are in range, so anything is possible. Heavies will now shift to hit ground targets, which are expected to be in Bde strength against an amphib of a Mar Div plus support. Repl TF will cut half its AOs back to Manus to refuel stocks, while the remainder and the replenishment CVEs remain at Sansapor.

In SWPAC, very busy in SWPAC! Troops fully ashore with no issues at Balikpapan, and empty assault transports will be cut loose to head to SOPAC for future operations. Samarinda Amph TF, with supporting CVE and CA TFs will now depart the Balikpapan area and head to debark troops next turn. Balik troops will hold in place, limiting themselves to bombarding to see what the defenses look like. The battalion level airborne attack at the inland Borneo base of Melak took the abandoned base without issue - the goal of which is to have the IJA at Balikpapan eventually withdraw south and not inland. So far so good in Borneo. Same with Java’s eastern landings. Troops ashore at the eastern tip at Banjoewangi, finding it abandoned, but do suffer some disabled squads due to the lack of preparation. On the north shore, just west of Soerabaja, another airborne assault secures Tjepoe, and follow on forces will be brought ashore in the coming turns to both bases. The upcoming challenge in SWPAC will be to do more with less - specifically less APAs as half of which are heading to SOPAC and a few more are heading to refit. Some will be gaining from assault transports being freed up in the IO Theater, but total lift will likely be only a division or so total.

In China, NSTR.

In Burma, recon reports Bangkok AF as shut down so bombers will shift target - to a “troops in the open” concentration north of Bangkok along the river line where an Indian Bde has managed to secure a lodging - well out in front of any follow on support however. Will likely loose this foothold, but might be able to rough up a few IJA units with airpower. Until I can secure a Bde’s worth of assault transports from IO to do “an end run” to Tavoy and Moulmein, I don’t intend much ground offensive action in Burma. Goal right now is to keep the IJA focused north and west of Bangkok.

In the IO, got a nasty Kamikaze surprise! The DD TF (7DD) heading to raid Miri was poorly protected by LRCAP - which were also at high altitude, and not prepared for Kamikazes. I figured the DDs would do well enough against either DB or TBs - their speed being the best defense. Not against Kamikazes apparently. And certainly didn’t expect L_S_T to launch “valuable” kamikazes at such a small target. So, 17 Jakes, 13 Jills and even 7 Babs were expended as Kamikazes to sink 3 DDs. Once engaged, the four remaining DDs aborted the mission and returned Palembang. So much for DD raids without good air cover - at least long range DD raids. So Miri is spared for a bit longer. Although mined (along with Brunei), TKs have been managing to secure fuel/oil. Once Samarinda and Balikpapan are secured, this too will end as fighters will be able to provide cover over Miri. A few more days, or a week perhaps at most. On the positive side, raids on Singapore continue to make progress, reducing effective HI to 10(31) and repair shipyard capability to 65(12). More raids will continue, although I don’t see Singers being used as a major base - in fact, my bet is Malaya is ripe for the taking if I want to commit a few Bdes to the effort. Same with Java - landings at Kalidjati are unopposed and the Canadians do suffer some fair amount of disabled troops due to the lack of preparation, but carry the base and will head east to clear the northern coast and link up with troops at Tjepoe. Follow on troops will land and head towards Batavia which looks to be very lightly defended by an SNLF. 3rd Mar Div will recon by bombardment next turn as USMC armor heads along the southern coast toward Tijatjap. So far, the only “tough nut” on Java looks to be Soerabaja, held by a reported 5000+ men, although recon has been poor.

Image
Attachments
440429.jpg
440429.jpg (299.56 KiB) Viewed 277 times
User avatar
IdahoNYer
Posts: 2744
Joined: Sun Sep 06, 2009 2:07 am
Location: NYer living in Boise, ID

Apr 44 Summary

Post by IdahoNYer »

April 44 Summary

A productive, but costly month. The prize of Palembang was finally realized which secured Sumatra while advances in both SOPAC - securing New Guinea, and SWPAC - securing the southern Celebes and a foothold in Java, were all accomplished. Losing two carriers sunk were of course the heavy cost. Still, territorial gains are far in advance of what I anticipated. There is a downside however….gains are outstripping objective planning for the ground forces and forward base development is not keeping up either. China appears to be stabilizing while Burma/Thailand remains in stalemate. The IJN sorties have been scarce, but the one time the IJN ventured a cruiser force to sea was costly to the Allies: Naval losses for the month were fairly minimal to both sides; the IJN reportedly lost 4DD, 1TB, 7E, 15MTB, 2SS and 2SSX compared to the Allies losing 2CV, 4DD, 2SS. In the air, for the first time (as far as I can remember anyway….the Allied air losses exceeded Japan’s - although about 180 came from the loss of the two carriers; 508 for Jpn to 559 Allied.

INTEL: Apparently L_S_T has pulled in his main defensive line well back; much more than I anticipated. The DEI and the Marianas are apparently outside the main defensive belt, only garrisoned to delay. The question now is whether the Philippines are part of the main defensive belt - or whether its Formosa and the Bonins. Perhaps Luzon? I’m still very surprised that the DEI is outside this defensive belt, and that Java and Borneo weren’t more heavily defended - much Allied ground combat power is now freed up. Allied planning needs to now look deeper into the Japanese defenses, with recon expanding to see where the defenses are focused. As of right now, the PI defenses are largely unknown, and that needs to change. As for the IJN, absolutely no idea where the fleet is based, nor what will trigger a major sortie. My best guess is that the IJN is based in the Home Islands. I’m thinking now that an invasion of Luzon will trigger a sortie…but that’s mere guesswork.

SUBWAR: Allied subs finally manage to take a toll of Japanese tankers this past month, sinking 10, as single tankers attempt to pull fuel/oil out of the DEI. It’s still expensive work, as Japanese ASW efforts remain dangerous. Japanese fleet boat combat operations are a rare sight, although it looks like SSTs are being used to evacuate isolated garrisons.

West Coast/USA/Rear Areas: Fighter production jumps to 901 in May with the addition of the British Thunderbolt and the New Zealand Corsair while the obsolete Hurricane finally ends production. Just when I think I’m catching up on US Navy fighter pilot pools, I lose carrier’s worth of pilots which put a big dent into the pools - not all are permanently lost, but most are, and many of those who survived are in delayed status coming back into play. Other pilot pools remain fair to good. April also was a big month for APA upgrades which largely went unheeded, which means I need to get the APAs staggered into ports to refit/upgrade.

NOPAC. While nothing happened in NOPAC, I need to start focusing a bit here - getting into the Kuriles before winter weather returns would be highly desirable. Currently, the US 6th IN Div is slated here, but I’m not sure that is enough. While I’d like to advance along the Kurile chain, it will require bringing the CV TF north, and with the advances continuing briskly in other Theaters, I’m hesitant to bring the carriers to the Aleutians for an extended stay - but that does need to happen before winter closes down arctic operations.

CENPAC. I was very surprised at the lack of air opposition in the Marianas. Good. The Allies main effort will be in CENPAC during May - Yap, Rota and Pagan the primary targets to protect the flank of the main Allied thrust to the PI, and also to neutralize the L_S_T’s ability to use the Marianas. Guam is eventually on the list as a B-29 base, but with the B-29s operating at long range, I’m just not convinced the Marianas are the best base for them in a PBEM strategic bombing campaign. Saipan and Tinian are both heavily garrisoned and I plan to avoid landings there.

SOPAC. The landings at Sorong and Morotai culminated the current SOPAC’s offensive objectives. Next step in the Philippine isle of Mindanao, which still needs a bit more time for planning. Still not sure of the PI’s defenses, so will now focus more effort to that in the coming month. May might see landings in Mindanao, but beyond that, much more recon needs to take place.

SWPAC. Celebes, especially Kendari and Makassar, was much more lightly defended than anticipated. So, by month’s end instead of fighting on Celebes, troops are ashore in Borneo and Java. The challenge now is to build up bases and bring the support train forward - to support further landings on Borneo and the Philippines. Objectives for the troops need to be totally re-worked, so there needs to be a delay - hence the benefit of shifting the main effort to CENPAC for May, and then Mindanao. SWPAC is at a crossroads at the moment - future operations will split SWPAC forces with the majority of the Australians (in the form of I and II Corps troops) securing Borneo as well as some outer PI islands to protect the unimpeded advance towards the South China Sea. The US contingent will focus on planning for Luzon. Still need to work out much of the details for the PI campaign beyond Mindanao.

China. It appears the lines are stabilizing in China for the moment. Could be temporary, will see. Supply is getting better across China, but getting it over 100k is still the challenge.

Burma. Didn’t try to do much in Burma in April. A “holding action” is an apt description. A Major IJA force is still in place north and west of Bangkok - I’m a bit surprised this force hasn’t been pulled east to Indochina and repositioned elsewhere in the Empire. I want to keep them where they are for another month or two, until I can get major naval units from the Pacific Theaters into the South China Sea. May should see some naval assisted flanking to seize Tavoy in the Andaman Sea which will lead to IJA troops in Malaya being cut off from the main body in Thailand. And I think Malaya is ripe for the taking with minimal force - less Singers of course. In the air, the B-29’s use so far is limiting. Its high maintenance rate and small squadron size of 7 planes has limited its effectiveness. B-24s remain the mainstay and have been effective in reducing Bangkok’s capabilities.

IO. Well, Palembang was finally taken. Nice! Now what to do with the troops is the major quandary. While a relatively small contingent of what’s available has started to liberate Java - the main force is without a current objective. And with SWPAC’s Australians taking on Borneo, that’s not a needed option. I’m thinking Indo China - an amphibious operation to secure the flank of any future naval operations in the South China Sea - which will be desirable for operations against Luzon, and perhaps bottle up the large IJA contingent still centered on holding Bangkok. Malaya doesn’t really have much strategic value other than gathering some VPs. Need to make a decision here sooner rather than later as the current planning objective for most of the troops is still Palembang. Any future effort - Indo China, Malaya or elsewhere will require the shuttling of troops between the Burma and IO Theaters. With major operations in seizing Sumatra over, I’m going to consolidate the Burma and IO Theaters back into a single South East Asia Theater Command beginning in May.

Image
Attachments
440430.jpg
440430.jpg (267.73 KiB) Viewed 277 times
jwolf
Posts: 2493
Joined: Tue Dec 03, 2013 4:02 pm

RE: Apr 44 Summary

Post by jwolf »

Manado, at the northern end of Sulawesi, is a great base to secure in order to take control over the Celebes Sea in preparation for Mindanao.
User avatar
IdahoNYer
Posts: 2744
Joined: Sun Sep 06, 2009 2:07 am
Location: NYer living in Boise, ID

RE: Apr 44 Summary

Post by IdahoNYer »

ORIGINAL: jwolf

Manado, at the northern end of Sulawesi, is a great base to secure in order to take control over the Celebes Sea in preparation for Mindanao.

Very true.....and L_S_T knows that as well, and has a reported 25k men dug in to defend it. Will bypass....
Post Reply

Return to “After Action Reports”