Attack Attack Attack - a Hotseat AAR

Please post your after action reports on your battles and campaigns here.

Moderator: AlvaroSousa

Remington700
Posts: 1089
Joined: Sun May 16, 2021 12:42 pm

RE: Allied: February 25th 1945

Post by Remington700 »

Palau Islands
True to history the appropriately named Operation Stalemate (invasion of the Palau Islands) causes heavy loss which arguably could have been avoided. Moral on the Homefront drops as word of the loss of the CV Enterprise and BB Missouri has the general population showing signs of war weariness. President Roosevelt is conspicuously absent from the media and rumors are running wild. Perhaps a peace agreement is in the making. The loss of a carrier is bad, but the loss of the “Mighty Mo” hurts even more. With the sinking of this symbol of “Victory in the Pacific” I continue to regret not researching Large Warships and wonder what the heck I am doing in this area.

Task Force 58 containing the fast attack US carriers steams to Rabaul for repairs effectiveness recovery. They may be in port for a couple of turns. Task Force 57 containing British carriers arrive from Formosa to protect the islands from enemy carrier attack. Despite naval losses the Marines continue to do the job. The 5th Division lands on Peleliu meeting token resistance. The unsupplied Japanese 17th Division cannot stand up to the heavy naval and air bombardment and soon surrenders, losing 8 strength points. The Australian 11th Division lands to clean up around the port facilities. Airfields are repaired and should be able to receive planes in a couple of weeks.

Image
Attachments
788.png
788.png (244.99 KiB) Viewed 1540 times
Remington700
Posts: 1089
Joined: Sun May 16, 2021 12:42 pm

RE: Allied: February 25th 1945

Post by Remington700 »

Philippines
Gen MacArthur arrives in Davao to take direct command in Mindanao. Transports fall under enemy air attack while Mac calmly walks ashore. True to nature the general turns his arrival into a photo op which is greatly needed to buck up morale on the Homefront. Despite some recent setbacks there is still great resolve to see this thing through to the end.

Image
Attachments
789.png
789.png (327.07 KiB) Viewed 1540 times
Remington700
Posts: 1089
Joined: Sun May 16, 2021 12:42 pm

RE: Allied: February 25th 1945

Post by Remington700 »

Builds
UK: 2 Oilers
India: No builds.
Canada: 1 Landing ship.
Red China: 1 Supply unit.
USA: 10 Landing ships. 5 Supply units.

Convoys
No Convoys.

Image
Attachments
790.png
790.png (315.71 KiB) Viewed 1540 times
Remington700
Posts: 1089
Joined: Sun May 16, 2021 12:42 pm

Japan: March 11th 1945

Post by Remington700 »

Japan: March 11th 1945

South China
With the fall of Haiphong, the unsupplied 22nd begins their withdrawal to the east. The ragtag 21st Division plays the role of “Tail-end Charlie” taking a rear-guard position east of the Hong River. There is great danger the unit will be cutoff and destroyed. The chewed-up 3rd Division is scheduled to depart Hong Kong as soon as transport can be arranged. If the withdrawal can be handled correctly the beat-up 2nd Army and a couple of divisions may be saved to help with the defense of the home islands.

Image
Attachments
791.png
791.png (810.24 KiB) Viewed 1540 times
Remington700
Posts: 1089
Joined: Sun May 16, 2021 12:42 pm

RE: Japan: March 11th 1945

Post by Remington700 »

Manchukuo
The Soviet Union has long had their eyes on Manchukuo. It is the buffer between China and Japan. If the Anglo-Indian allies were to land and push toward Harbin the Red Menace might join them in war with Japan. This would put Japanese interests in Korea in danger and with the lack of war materials the enemy could not be stopped. The Yellow Sea and Korea Bay must remain under Japanese control. Key ports need to be strongly garrisoned to avoid giving the enemy a foothold. However there is time to strengthen the area as cold weather will stop all invasions until May.

With the fall of Formosa, the Allies can look for soft areas to capture key VP locations. And triggering the early entry of the USSR is a good way to help in this endeavor. Currently Manchukuo is garrisoned at the minimum required SPs of 160. A hard push to Harbin may drive total SPs below the threshold and trigger Soviet involvement.

Image
Attachments
792.png
792.png (720.78 KiB) Viewed 1540 times
Remington700
Posts: 1089
Joined: Sun May 16, 2021 12:42 pm

RE: Japan: March 11th 1945

Post by Remington700 »

Palau Islands
On Peleliu intelligence agents hiding in caves along Bloody Nose Ridge provided excellent detail on the British CV force. The Combined Fleet detaches the 1st Air Fleet on another hit and run mission to strike the enemy carriers. Achieving surprise, carrier-based planes breakthrough enemy CAP and target the carriers. The CV Leviathan is hit by multiple bombs and torpedoes and immediately begins to sink. The CV Implacable is hit by dive-bombers but remains underpower. The battleship Howe puts up heavy flak which continues after taking hits from two torpedoes. Japanese air losses were negligible with most of the aircraft returning to their carriers.

British aircraft manage to find the Imperial fleet but are unable to penetrate the screening CAP over the carriers. Four enemy SPs are shot down and two more are splashed by AAA fire. Naval losses are minimal with a couple of light cruisers from the 6th Squadron receiving heavy damage but are still under steam. The Air Fleet returns to the safety of Manila for repairs and return of effectiveness.

The hit and run attacks continue to work so I will stick with it until Allied forces can find a way to put a stop to the tactic.

Image
Attachments
793.png
793.png (214.51 KiB) Viewed 1540 times
Remington700
Posts: 1089
Joined: Sun May 16, 2021 12:42 pm

RE: Japan: March 11th 1945

Post by Remington700 »

Builds
Japan: 1 Infantry Army. Replacements remain at 200.

COMINT: 1 Intelligence unit.

Image
Attachments
794.png
794.png (340.22 KiB) Viewed 1540 times
Remington700
Posts: 1089
Joined: Sun May 16, 2021 12:42 pm

Allied: March 11th 1945

Post by Remington700 »

Allied: March 11th 1945

China
Snow continues to lower effectiveness for all units north of the You and Yong rivers. To the south bombers pound the positions of the rear-guard 21st Division. With no time to dig-in the enemy is vulnerable so the Chinese 6th, 7th and 14th armies rush a frontal assault but fail to dislodge the division. A second attack is launched causing additional casualties but the enemy holds. For underestimating the tenacity of the 21st Division, General Chu-tung Ku will be replaced by General Chang from the central China front.

Image
Attachments
795.png
795.png (795.45 KiB) Viewed 1540 times
Remington700
Posts: 1089
Joined: Sun May 16, 2021 12:42 pm

RE: Allied: March 11th 1945

Post by Remington700 »

South China Sea
F4U Corsairs arrive in Quang Ngai to commence operations over Luzon and China. I think I might have solved my fighter-bomber range problem.

I have simulated the use of drop tanks by switching a ground attack plane to the strategic bombing specialty. The range is 12 hexes in 1944 and bumps up to 18 in 1945. The damage is a bit high in my opinion which is offset by weak air to air combat. While not perfect it does seem to fill the void for long range ground support.

Playing the Allies, I have done a poor job with the US advancements. I researched both escort and fighter-bomber (I had to try the FBs) techs which worked well in the early game but ultimately slowed down the overall research rates. And the FBs have little value late game. The extra line of research may be the cause for the US being way behind other countries with technology. Having four Japanese CVLs tear up six fleet carriers each turn is maddening. However, I think this is driven by poor play on my part rather than a game imbalance. Before my next game I will do some testing to determine how to defend against hit and run tactics and to better understand advancement research. I realize this is not a simulation so the Allies should not be automatically superior, however I want to know why they are so inferior in my current game.

Formosa
The 7th and 13th bomber groups fly into Formosa. They consist mainly of A-20 Havocs with the Naval Air specialty. Their range of ten hexes allows them to target Okinawa and Manila. They are also within range of Japanese convoys in the East China Sea which should help to starve out the enemy.

Convoy Attacks
In the East China Sea, Baker force consisting of the subs Bonefish, Devilfish and Wahoo patrol a 50-mile area looking for targets. Hunting is good with each sub sinking a freighter without taking damage and the Bonefish sinking a second before taking hits from depth-charges.

A hundred miles to the east, Able force consisting of the Finback, Skipjack and Tang are not as fortunate. Both Skipjack and Tang sink a freighter without being located by escorting destroyers. However, the Finback is caught and after taking minor damage must return to Rabaul for repairs.

Image
Attachments
796.png
796.png (260.79 KiB) Viewed 1540 times
Remington700
Posts: 1089
Joined: Sun May 16, 2021 12:42 pm

RE: Allied: March 11th 1945

Post by Remington700 »

Philippines
On Mindanao A-20s from the 7th Bomber Group are replaced by refitted B-24s with the Naval Air specialty. The have a range of 14 hexes which allows them to target ships in Manila. Four days of airstrikes (4 attacks) target Baybay in Leyte. These will continue to weaken the enemy in advance of an invasion and/or an assault across the strait of Surigao.

Palau Islands
The 5th Marine Division remains on Peleliu and the 2nd Marine Division in Yap. Both units will receive replacements and recover effectiveness while they await orders for their next assignment. B-24 Strategic Bombers are flown to the airbases and begin to fly sorties over Leyte.

Image
Attachments
797.png
797.png (279.01 KiB) Viewed 1540 times
Remington700
Posts: 1089
Joined: Sun May 16, 2021 12:42 pm

RE: Allied: March 11th 1945

Post by Remington700 »

Builds
UK: 2 Supply units.
India: No builds.
China: 1 Infantry Army
USSR: 10 Supply units. 3 Oilers.
USA: 2 Large Infantry Corps.

Convoys
No Convoys.

COMINT
UK: 1 Intelligence unit.
USA: 2 Intelligence units.

Image
Attachments
798.png
798.png (309.06 KiB) Viewed 1539 times
User avatar
John B.
Posts: 3985
Joined: Sun Sep 25, 2011 6:45 pm
Location: Virginia
Contact:

RE: Allied: March 11th 1945

Post by John B. »

Maybe the US can offer to sell Japan some of its oil in exchange a couple of those CVLs. :) Seriously, I'm surprised that Japan is able to move anything at all! I don't know if this would make a difference but I've seen on other threads that you want to keep your carriers in raider mode all of the time to avoid ambushes.
John Barr
Remington700
Posts: 1089
Joined: Sun May 16, 2021 12:42 pm

RE: Allied: March 11th 1945

Post by Remington700 »

Definitely wisdom in that. At times I have been intentionally leaving them out of raider mode to invite the attack. Thinking the odds were in the Allies favor.

Other times I just leave them in Fleet mode after combat rather than sending a destroyer to join the fleet in "raider" mode to change the status. Either way, I have learned a valuable lesson about CV effectiveness - it seems to matter a lot.
Remington700
Posts: 1089
Joined: Sun May 16, 2021 12:42 pm

Japan: March 25th 1945

Post by Remington700 »

Japan: March 25th 1945

China
Oil stockpile is very low with enough for another month. Once the supply is gone, air and sea movement will not be allowed. Units at sea can continue operations however they will lose six percent effectiveness per turn. Oilers do not return effectiveness. This means the fleet can be combat effective for another four months at best. The Combined Fleet relocates to Nagoya on the island of Honshu to avoid being trapped in Manila.

Medium bombers with Naval Air spec leave Legaspi to relocate in Iwo Jima. Dive-bombers in the Bonin and Mariana islands return to the home islands for better defense and are replaced with medium bombers. This is a final adjustment as soon there will not be enough oil to adjust force dispositions.

Image
Attachments
799.png
799.png (745.05 KiB) Viewed 1539 times
Remington700
Posts: 1089
Joined: Sun May 16, 2021 12:42 pm

RE: Japan: March 25th 1945

Post by Remington700 »

Philippines
The 37th Division leaves Cebu and arrives at Incheon to bolster the defense on the Korean peninsula. The beat-up 3rd Division embarks transports and manages to slip undetected in Puson. If all goes well the 2nd Army and the 34th Division will be evacuated from South China in the next two weeks. If my math is correct, there will be at least one more turn to move units. Maybe two depending upon how stockpile affects embarkation.

Image
Attachments
800.png
800.png (322.54 KiB) Viewed 1539 times
Remington700
Posts: 1089
Joined: Sun May 16, 2021 12:42 pm

RE: Japan: March 25th 1945

Post by Remington700 »

Builds

Japan: No builds. Replacements reduced to 150.

Image
Attachments
801.png
801.png (333.33 KiB) Viewed 1539 times
Remington700
Posts: 1089
Joined: Sun May 16, 2021 12:42 pm

Allied: March 25th 1945

Post by Remington700 »

Allied: March 25th 1945

China
The 4th Red Army and the Red Guard Army attack the entrenched 16th Division south of Taiuan. After taking a hit, the enemy retreats east to defend the rail line. The Red Guard advances to the outskirts of the town. To the north the 8th Alpine army moves the northwest of Taiuan. The Japanese 26th Division may well be cutoff soon.

To the south, one hundred miles east of Kaifeng the 19th, 20th and 24th armies launch a probing attack against the dug-in Japanese 25th Division doing minor damage. The enemy holds, and with the rain starting to increase all future attacks are cancelled.

Convoy Attacks
Able force is skunked - they fail to locate and sink a freighter. However, the Skipjack takes heavy damage from patrolling destroyers and must return to Rabaul for repairs. A hundred miles to the west, Baker force consisting of the Bonefish and Wahoo spot a convoy and move into firing position. The Wahoo launches a successful spread of torpedoes sinking a Merchant Marine, while the Bonefish comes up empty. Both boats are damaged and must return to port. With three damaged subs and only one freighter sunk, this patrol ends in the favor of Japan.

Image
Attachments
802.png
802.png (770.43 KiB) Viewed 1539 times
Remington700
Posts: 1089
Joined: Sun May 16, 2021 12:42 pm

RE: Allied: March 25th 1945

Post by Remington700 »

Philippines
In preparation for landings on Luzon, five days of continuous airstrikes pound air units in Manila. Damage estimates are not available however effectiveness should have been negatively impacted. Marines and Infantry Corps move around the map in preparation for the coming assault. However, the date of the invasion keeps getting pushed out. Gen MacArthur is livid.

Okinawa
British submarines move to blockade the port at Naha. They arrive unseen and will cut off all supply to the island. Okinawa is strategically located to launch long range bomber attacks against northern Luzon or southern Japan. Medium bombers on Formosa recover effectiveness and prepare to raid the port next turn.

Image
Attachments
803.png
803.png (337.47 KiB) Viewed 1539 times
Remington700
Posts: 1089
Joined: Sun May 16, 2021 12:42 pm

RE: Allied: March 25th 1945

Post by Remington700 »

Builds
UK: 1 Supply unit.
India: 1 Supply unit.
USA: 10 Supply units.

Convoys
No Convoys.

Image
Attachments
804.png
804.png (307.09 KiB) Viewed 1539 times
Remington700
Posts: 1089
Joined: Sun May 16, 2021 12:42 pm

Japan: April 8th 1945

Post by Remington700 »

Japan: April 8th 1945

East China
The evacuation from China continues. General Yamashita returns to Japan to take command of the Imperial Japanese Army. The 2nd Army embarks and steams to Sapporo where the unit will dig in and protect this key northern port. The 37th Division loads up in the last available transports and is returned to the Port of Fukuoka in Kyushu. There will be no more evacuations as Japan is out virtually out of oil.

Snow continues across most of China which will put a stop to enemy advancement. To the south in the Gulf of Tonkin the enemy’s advance has ground to a halt. Gen Sadamu has now taken command of the entire Japanese Army in China and Manchukuo. He will begin to work his way north to Peking. Victory Point cities are highlighted in yellow hexes, and all appear adequately defended.

Image
Attachments
805.png
805.png (1.71 MiB) Viewed 1539 times
Post Reply

Return to “After Action Reports”