What If...Rommel had Commanded?

[eddieballgame]

A simple experiment switching out Luttwitz for Rommel.
A 'what if' scenario using 'On to Dinant' as the test run.
Place the 'On_to_Dinant_what_if_Rommel' file in the 'ardennesscenarios' folder.
Load the game & then load the scenario.

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1JO5A4v ... sp=sharing

[Anonymous]

Rommel would be calling AH often to ask to halt the folly of an offensive because of lack of resources and unreasonable goals.

[eddieballgame]

ORIGINAL: csiemers

Rommel would be calling AH often to ask to halt the folly of an offensive because of lack of resources and unreasonable goals.

Considering a few of 'ah' generals agreed with you...I concur.

[Forever2]

ORIGINAL: csiemers

Rommel would be calling AH often to ask to halt the folly of an offensive because of lack of resources and unreasonable goals.

Rommel would be calling AH often to ask to halt the folly of an offensive because of lack of resources and unreasonable goals.

Are you sure about this ??
Romell committed suicide on October 14, 1944, after being seriously wounded on July 17, 1944
Any sources?

[eddieballgame]

ORIGINAL: Forever2

Are you sure about this ??
Romell committed suicide on October 14, 1944, after being seriously wounded on July 17, 1944
Any sources?

Yes, his forced suicide 'option' is a matter of record.
That is why it is a 'what if' he was not requested to do so & was still active.

[Turtler]

ORIGINAL: csiemers

Rommel would be calling AH often to ask to halt the folly of an offensive because of lack of resources and unreasonable goals.

Considering how often Rommel was Mr. "Lack of Resources and Unreasonable Goals" - especially in North Africa- I'm not so sure.

[Tempest5]

ORIGINAL: eddieballgame

A simple experiment switching out Luttwitz for Rommel.
A 'what if' scenario using 'On to Dinant' as the test run.
Place the 'On_to_Dinant_what_if_Rommel' file in the 'ardennesscenarios' folder.
Load the game & then load the scenario.

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1JO5A4v ... sp=sharing

Thanks.