NSS Berlin CupCake Freight drops
NSS Prague CupCake Freight drops
Moderator: Joel Billings
I have not done that and think you may already have the answer. Since I know you are the Book Guy and have great knowledge. Is this worth it? Or no?Jango32 wrote: Fri Nov 04, 2022 2:16 pm Do a comparison of the logistics report (received & need) with and without the freight drops.
Correct, BUT if pulling more Freight out than normally released in the turn is the question, right?Wiedrock wrote: Fri Nov 04, 2022 2:40 pm I'd rather build another lvl1 Depot which will request 4k supplies from any NSS and therefore result in the same/more freight being shipped out of your NSSs. The Ju's I'd use for frontline depots not connected to the rail network yet, to reduce truck attrition.
I am not sure if I understand this sentence (stupid Germanist me).HardLuckYetAgain wrote: Fri Nov 04, 2022 2:42 pm Correct, BUT if pulling more Freight out than normally released in the turn is the question, right?
Have I mentioned that I prefer PBEM over server based?HardLuckYetAgain wrote: Fri Nov 04, 2022 2:21 pm Plus I no longer have the turn to check that information![]()
M60A3TTS wrote: Fri Nov 04, 2022 4:49 pmHave I mentioned that I prefer PBEM over server based?HardLuckYetAgain wrote: Fri Nov 04, 2022 2:21 pm Plus I no longer have the turn to check that information![]()
![]()
But I understand the desire to keep your opponents honest, too.
After the first ten turns, great. Go for it. I do a little of this myself.HardLuckYetAgain wrote: Fri Nov 04, 2022 2:01 pm All the JU52 Transport missions pulling out a really nice Freight load for further movement of that freight the next turn. Let me know you comments.
Ok, Axis supply has already ran for the turn and my depots got whatever the system decided to send out for the Axis at the start of the Axis Turn to my depots. Thus, that is all that is coming out of the NSS's this turn for the Axis since that has already happened. Here is the Basic Sequence of play and a picture of Berlin at the start of the turn with 2,497,056.HardLuckYetAgain wrote: Fri Nov 04, 2022 2:21 pmI have not done that and think you may already have the answer. Since I know you are the Book Guy and have great knowledge. Is this worth it? Or no?Jango32 wrote: Fri Nov 04, 2022 2:16 pm Do a comparison of the logistics report (received & need) with and without the freight drops.
Plus I no longer have the turn to check that information
Let me check some of my other snapshot I took in earlier turns and may have captured by accident. Will do this when I get some free time later this afternoon to search all my snapshots I take of supply
If I don't have the snapshots I will set up a test bed real quick to check it.
Ok, for comparison I took your numbers in this post and added up the first 11 turns. (hopefully I am correct on adding)M60A3TTS wrote: Fri Nov 04, 2022 5:21 pm Here for a comparison is my latest PBEM game with the per turn vehicle loss to repair.
-9589
-4999
-2404
-4856
-3223
-4867
-4471
-5241
-4513
-4767
-3562
-2864
-4912
-4988
-3714
-2722
-3609
I only broke the 6k mark once, on turn 1 when the panzers are stretched out everywhere. Now there are a number of things I did to reduce vehicle losses, and flying supplies to forward depots/airfields contributed to that. So did not rushing the panzer spearheads and thereby playing a bit more conservatively (thanks to the OP for that idea).
Your numbers are impressive and it's good to see that two Axis players going at it in similar, yet different styles are seeing an ability to significantly improve on previous vehicle loss rates.HardLuckYetAgain wrote: Sat Nov 05, 2022 1:28 am
Ok, for comparison I took your numbers in this post and added up the first 11 turns. (hopefully I am correct on adding)
-9589
-4999
-2404
-4856
-3223
-4867
-4471
-5241
-4513
-4767
-3562
For a total of 52,492 trucks in for repair according to your numbers.
Compare that to my 48,568 trucks in for repair turn 11 which I am almost 4,000 lower than your total. (compared to the team game loss of 67,059 in your first post with my number I am almost 20,000 less trucks loss)
Trucks.png
And here is the "Area" turn 11 I am covering and you will notice I am within 22ish hexes of Stalingrad and 6ish hexes from Rostov turn 11. I am playing heavily in the South which normally has HORRID supply and with less truck losses compared to the two examples. So to me the extra supply out of the NSS is WELL worth it. But maybe I am wrong. Here is a picture of the Front.
T11 Frontage.png

Yes, very nice frontage, very comparable. Thank you M60 for sharing!!!M60A3TTS wrote: Sat Nov 05, 2022 2:04 amYour numbers are impressive and it's good to see that two Axis players going at it in similar, yet different styles are seeing an ability to significantly improve on previous vehicle loss rates.HardLuckYetAgain wrote: Sat Nov 05, 2022 1:28 am
Ok, for comparison I took your numbers in this post and added up the first 11 turns. (hopefully I am correct on adding)
-9589
-4999
-2404
-4856
-3223
-4867
-4471
-5241
-4513
-4767
-3562
For a total of 52,492 trucks in for repair according to your numbers.
Compare that to my 48,568 trucks in for repair turn 11 which I am almost 4,000 lower than your total. (compared to the team game loss of 67,059 in your first post with my number I am almost 20,000 less trucks loss)
Trucks.png
And here is the "Area" turn 11 I am covering and you will notice I am within 22ish hexes of Stalingrad and 6ish hexes from Rostov turn 11. I am playing heavily in the South which normally has HORRID supply and with less truck losses compared to the two examples. So to me the extra supply out of the NSS is WELL worth it. But maybe I am wrong. Here is a picture of the Front.
T11 Frontage.png
Here is my T11 front line trace FWIW.
![]()