[1.20q #174] Supply calculation is different between OOB and unit's card

[alocritani]

It seems that supply is calculated differently in OOB window and unit's card.
Unit's card seems to only consider items that are missing some supply for calculation. In this example, fuel is 2/3 so 67%

but in OOB all items are used for calculation: 2 (fuel) + 19 (food) = 21/23 = 95%

OOB.png (762.56 KiB) Viewed 300 times

[alocritani]

Partially related

supply.png (77.36 KiB) Viewed 294 times

I asked for 2 food, I received 2 food -> I have 10 food; I used 2 food for upkeep, so remaining food is 8 (over 10). Calculation is ok but the bar is show completely full.

Now I moved out of supply: remaining food is 6, bar is 80% full

supply2.png (81.7 KiB) Viewed 294 times

And, even if I've supply stock available, I'm starting getting hunger: is it really intended?

According to manual (5.10.7.3) it seems hunger should begin when upkeep is not provided, but in this case upkeep is provided.

hunger.png (31.76 KiB) Viewed 294 times

[Vic]

Unit received 22 items of 23 requested. About 95%. Hence...

best wishes,
Vic

[alocritani]

Unit received 22 items of 23 requested. About 95%. Hence...

Thanks for answer but on unit's card is indicated 67, only in OOB is correctly shown 95%.

What about the second comment, instead? is it intended that upkeep stocks' bar seems off? It's reporting 8/10 but the bar is show full.
Finally, is it really intended that troops start suffering from hunger even if they have food in stocks?

[Soar_Slitherine]

Unit received 22 items of 23 requested. About 95%. Hence...

Thanks for answer but on unit's card is indicated 67, only in OOB is correctly shown 95%.

They're measuring different things. The OOB window shows how full the unit's supply stocks are, the bottom panel shows how much of the supply requested during the last logistics phase was delivered.

What about the second comment, instead? is it intended that upkeep stocks' bar seems off? It's reporting 8/10 but the bar is show full.

The logistics system fills the unit's stocks to up to 10, but because they always eat 2 food after their stocks are refilled, 8 is as full as stocks are ever going to be when you look at that tab. As such, it doesn't particularly make sense for the bar to be displayed as less than full either.

[alocritani]

Unit received 22 items of 23 requested. About 95%. Hence...

Thanks for answer but on unit's card is indicated 67, only in OOB is correctly shown 95%.

They're measuring different things. The OOB window shows how full the unit's supply stocks are, the bottom panel shows how much of the supply requested during the last logistics phase was delivered.

Double-checking bottom panel seems to show the worst supply-related situation: it shows 0 even if I received 1 fuel and 1 food but I received no ammunitions; OOB shows total supply status instead.

worstCase.png (140.22 KiB) Viewed 267 times

What about the second comment, instead? is it intended that upkeep stocks' bar seems off? It's reporting 8/10 but the bar is show full.

The logistics system fills the unit's stocks to up to 10, but because they always eat 2 food after their stocks are refilled, 8 is as full as stocks are ever going to be when you look at that tab. As such, it doesn't particularly make sense for the bar to be displayed as less than full either.

Yes I understand but still is strange having 8/10 and the bar completely full...

What about hunger when out-of-supply but with food in stocks? Is it really intended to work that way? while I can accept it as a mechanic, it seems a bit strange: you may even start losing troops to attrition while there's enough food in stocks to feed them!