Disproportionate losses for LW
Moderators: Joel Billings, RedLancer
Disproportionate losses for LW
Hi all.
In some air battles above the Reich, the Luftwaffe just suffers very disproportionate losses, like losing 45 while destroying 0! Or 78 against just 8. Is this normal? Is there anything I can do to improve the situation?
Thanks in advance.
In some air battles above the Reich, the Luftwaffe just suffers very disproportionate losses, like losing 45 while destroying 0! Or 78 against just 8. Is this normal? Is there anything I can do to improve the situation?
Thanks in advance.
- Attachments
-
- 644710_20241124213641_1.png (837.3 KiB) Viewed 7031 times
-
- 644710_20241124213755_1.png (780.63 KiB) Viewed 7031 times
-
- 644710_20241124213813_1.png (806.81 KiB) Viewed 7031 times
Check my WWI Gold AAR: https://forums.matrixgames.com/viewtopic.php?t=413235
Re: Disproportionate losses for LW
AFAIK flying day fighters in night against specialized night figters is not good idea
set all day fighters to fly only during day
also British NFs are superior to most of Axis NF models
set all day fighters to fly only during day
also British NFs are superior to most of Axis NF models
Re: Disproportionate losses for LW
I was also thinking about day/night issue but top bar say Day 2 and not Night 2.
Is the time of battle mentioned somewhere?
Is the time of battle mentioned somewhere?
Re: Disproportionate losses for LW
Sorry, but I did not get what you mean by time of the battle. It is the end of may 1944, but that can be seen from the screenshot. What else can I check?
Some more examples are attached. Low experience seems to be always an issue, but even squadrons with above average experience suffer greatly.
Some more examples are attached. Low experience seems to be always an issue, but even squadrons with above average experience suffer greatly.
Denniss wrote: Mon Nov 25, 2024 2:53 pm I was also thinking about day/night issue but top bar say Day 2 and not Night 2.
Is the time of battle mentioned somewhere?
- Attachments
-
- 644710_20241126130353_1.png (792.09 KiB) Viewed 6984 times
-
- 644710_20241126130508_1.png (789.04 KiB) Viewed 6984 times
-
- 644710_20241126145339_1.png (700.72 KiB) Viewed 6984 times
Check my WWI Gold AAR: https://forums.matrixgames.com/viewtopic.php?t=413235
Re: Disproportionate losses for LW
as said above set your day fighters to operated in day-only mode. Operating at night they suffer massive penalties and enemy night fighters will also take a toll on them as seen in your screens.
Re: Disproportionate losses for LW
at the core you are flying low experience pilots against high experience pilots, that alone is a recipe for a disasterMetalist wrote: Sun Nov 24, 2024 8:57 pm Hi all.
In some air battles above the Reich, the Luftwaffe just suffers very disproportionate losses, like losing 45 while destroying 0! Or 78 against just 8. Is this normal? Is there anything I can do to improve the situation?
Thanks in advance.
so as the axis player you have to manage this with care, start to disband night fighter formations as they become less valuable from mid-44, keep the fighter formations as TPI for replacements, when you scrap a NF formation manually allocate the best pilots to the best fighter units
if you look at the AARs there are a lot of discussions of how to manage the LW into 1944, its all about trying to ensure that you win small even when you are losing the wider strategic battle
Re: Disproportionate losses for LW
But these huge losses are happening at days and not at nights, as the screenshot indicates.Denniss wrote: Wed Nov 27, 2024 1:11 am as said above set your day fighters to operated in day-only mode. Operating at night they suffer massive penalties and enemy night fighters will also take a toll on them as seen in your screens.
Thanks for the tips.
Check my WWI Gold AAR: https://forums.matrixgames.com/viewtopic.php?t=413235
Re: Disproportionate losses for LW
It may be some day patrols blended over into the night and tried to confront british night bombers. Composition of enemy bombers is typical for a night attack + you also had some nightfighters on your side (Ju 88G-1)
Re: Disproportionate losses for LW
I make night fighters fly both day & night, that may explain their participation but do not know anything about patrols blending day and night.
Check my WWI Gold AAR: https://forums.matrixgames.com/viewtopic.php?t=413235
Re: Disproportionate losses for LW
JHust make day fighter day-only and night fighters night-only. Operating in opposing day times is bad. You don't wanna loose night specialist in day intercepts and standard pilots are not trained/equipped to navigate at night so suffering high ops losses
Re: Disproportionate losses for LW
There does seem to be something baked in for P47-D and P51-D aircraft to cause disproportionate losses against the LW. I tried setting up a test scenario using similar experience and morale with the TA152 vs both. Sometimes results came out with a slight edge for the TA152, other times the TA152 got slaughtered. For some reason, automatic ground support missions seem to cause huge losses for the LW, even when in better planes (eg TA152) and with exp + morale parity.
There are a few ways I found to reduce losses:
1) Have all your squadrons assigned to a mission. Squadrons assigned to missions don't auto reinforce ground support (unless that's what the mission is).
2) Fly air super missions at high alt as this reduces the chance of an interception at a height disadvantage where your squadrons get slaughtered.
My 5c
There are a few ways I found to reduce losses:
1) Have all your squadrons assigned to a mission. Squadrons assigned to missions don't auto reinforce ground support (unless that's what the mission is).
2) Fly air super missions at high alt as this reduces the chance of an interception at a height disadvantage where your squadrons get slaughtered.
My 5c
Re: Disproportionate losses for LW
I realised there is another variable here which is important and you can't see from the combat screens - fatigue.
Squadrons on AS or intercept can very easily get high fatigue (40+) from repeated intercepts. I once found one of my cherished squadrons on 80 fatigue. No wonder it was underperforming. I think fatigue detracts from their effective skill level. Not sure about the maths. But it can explain why some confrontations are so lopsided when you might be expecting better results.
I have had some sucess setting up AS missions configured to fly every other day (schedule under advanced) - that way the intercepts that do happen are much lower fatigue. For example, over northern france set up one AS to fly even days and another to fly odd days. Overlapping two like this seems to produce much better results by hard coding squadron rest times.
Hope this helps.
Matchwood
Squadrons on AS or intercept can very easily get high fatigue (40+) from repeated intercepts. I once found one of my cherished squadrons on 80 fatigue. No wonder it was underperforming. I think fatigue detracts from their effective skill level. Not sure about the maths. But it can explain why some confrontations are so lopsided when you might be expecting better results.
I have had some sucess setting up AS missions configured to fly every other day (schedule under advanced) - that way the intercepts that do happen are much lower fatigue. For example, over northern france set up one AS to fly even days and another to fly odd days. Overlapping two like this seems to produce much better results by hard coding squadron rest times.
Hope this helps.
Matchwood
Re: Disproportionate losses for LW
Comming from WitE2 trying to figure out things there....from that I'd say there are good points Matchwood makes.
Note that the SKILL shown in the combat does not reflect the EXP a pilot 1to1, but includes the FATigue. If Allies fly high and a lot missions at the same day, the same Germans will intercept at high-altitude-short-range-intercepts indefinitely since it does cost little mileage but adds tons of FAT. So you will end up with experienced pilots showing up as low SKILLed due to high FAT.
The forumla for SKILL [in WitE2] is something like EXP*(1-0.25*FAT/100)=SKILL. So e.g. 75EXP*(1-0.25*60FAT/100)=64SKILL. The added fatigue for your current mission is unknown and gets added before determination of SKILL afaik.
If we take the 80FAT example Matchwood gives, which is quickly reached at high altitudes, we see a 75EXP pilot show up with a SKILL of only 60.
Note that, the player M60 in WitE2 has figured that the SKILL of a flight is likely using the highest EXP Pilot and not the average for the calculation.
No idea how Night came up.....I assume people see "British" and go "nighttime mode activated".
Note that the SKILL shown in the combat does not reflect the EXP a pilot 1to1, but includes the FATigue. If Allies fly high and a lot missions at the same day, the same Germans will intercept at high-altitude-short-range-intercepts indefinitely since it does cost little mileage but adds tons of FAT. So you will end up with experienced pilots showing up as low SKILLed due to high FAT.
The forumla for SKILL [in WitE2] is something like EXP*(1-0.25*FAT/100)=SKILL. So e.g. 75EXP*(1-0.25*60FAT/100)=64SKILL. The added fatigue for your current mission is unknown and gets added before determination of SKILL afaik.
If we take the 80FAT example Matchwood gives, which is quickly reached at high altitudes, we see a 75EXP pilot show up with a SKILL of only 60.
Note that, the player M60 in WitE2 has figured that the SKILL of a flight is likely using the highest EXP Pilot and not the average for the calculation.
I assume you are looking at the AG's MOR, have your tried changing National Air Morale to 95 for Germans and 5 to allies and try again. Since what's "baked in" behind the scenes is the national morale values changing over time.matchwood wrote: Thu May 22, 2025 5:53 am There does seem to be something baked in for P47-D and P51-D aircraft to cause disproportionate losses against the LW
[...]
with exp + morale parity.
No idea how Night came up.....I assume people see "British" and go "nighttime mode activated".
“Amateurs study tactics; professionals study logistics.”
My Mods:
GE Gui & Sym Mod Depot (continued)
Rasputitsa for your eyes. Soviet colours redone.
My Tools:
Turn-Dates-Converter
Command Efficiency with Command Range Modifier
Planning map 1.02.45_Beta
My Mods:
GE Gui & Sym Mod Depot (continued)
Rasputitsa for your eyes. Soviet colours redone.
My Tools:
Turn-Dates-Converter
Command Efficiency with Command Range Modifier
Planning map 1.02.45_Beta
