A specific question on Kull's spreadsheet...

[Gilmer]

Hey, guys, if I'm supposed to put a question underneath where Kull's spreadsheet is posted about, I'll start doing that. I don't want to mess up any protocol.

Allied setup.
Lines 1172-1177
Create a TF in Hong Kong.

There's a part that says "absolute". Can anyone tell me what that means? I have been searching the unit play cards for something that I can set to absolute, but am coming up empty.

[Gilmer]

I didn't click twice this time.

[pbiggar]

I do not have the spreadsheet open right now, but it probably means to set the threat tolerance to "Absolute" so they will do their best to get away and not abort the mission because of Japanese air and naval superiority.

[dr.hal]

Are you chatting about turn 2 strategy? I was of the understanding that on turn 1 tha Allies can't create any new TFs... they can unite or split existing TFs but.....do I have this wrong?

[Gilmer]

Are you chatting about turn 2 strategy? I was of the understanding that on turn 1 tha Allies can't create any new TFs... they can unite or split existing TFs but.....do I have this wrong?

The Kull spreadsheet is from Turn 2. It presupposes you already ran Turn 1 and got historical results.

[Gilmer]

I do not have the spreadsheet open right now, but it probably means to set the threat tolerance to "Absolute" so they will do their best to get away and not abort the mission because of Japanese air and naval superiority.

Ahh, that makes sense! Thank you.

[dr.hal]

Are you chatting about turn 2 strategy? I was of the understanding that on turn 1 tha Allies can't create any new TFs... they can unite or split existing TFs but.....do I have this wrong?

The Kull spreadsheet is from Turn 2. It presupposes you already ran Turn 1 and got historical results.

Ahhh ok, got it......

[BBfanboy]

I do not have the spreadsheet open right now, but it probably means to set the threat tolerance to "Absolute" so they will do their best to get away and not abort the mission because of Japanese air and naval superiority.

I agree with this. You won't find the threat tolerance setting on the ship screen - it's for the TF so go to that screen and select the Routing Orders. I always set Direct and Absolute routing if I am near the enemy and the mission must not abort. For warships and troop convoys I choose a good commander with high naval and medium-high aggression (and guts).
In extreme threat environments the TF can still change its routing during turn execution to save itself.

[Gilmer]

I've noticed, and I'm not criticizing/complaining and also I may be wrong, of slight differences between the spreadsheet and the actual locations of some units/ships.

[Bo Rearguard]

I've noticed, and I'm not criticizing/complaining and also I may be wrong, of slight differences between the spreadsheet and the actual locations of some units/ships.

Likely because in the many years since Kull first released the set-up spreadsheets, there have been many updates and revisions to the game. Kull admitted that although he occasionally updated his spreadsheet he didn't necessarily catch every location change. Your best bet if you can't find a unit where the spreadsheet states it is, is to do a ID number search to pinpoint it and try and send it to the destination suggested. Some land units may have to march to a nearby railhead first to get going.

[Gilmer]

Yeah, that's what I'm doing. I search them out. There was one instance where I don't think an LCU was on the map yet, but as someone else said, this can be done in the first few days, so no worries. Also, if I miss one or two things and don't do them exactly on those 2 or 3 items out of 4600, then I doubt my game is ruined, lol.

I guess I just like to talk.

[Sardaukar]

"The whole world is in chess. Any move can be the death of you. Do anything except remain where you started, and you can't be sure of your end. " -King Baldwin IV, Kingdom of Heaven