Pirates Hate me

Moderator: MOD_DW2

Post Reply
Xmudder
Posts: 345
Joined: Sun Feb 14, 2010 10:13 pm

Pirates Hate me

Post by Xmudder »

I'm playing a game with Shadows Rising... and the pirates I used to have protection rackets with all hate me.

The reason? "We are envious of you huge strength and power" -27.6

My closest neighbor, the Quameno guild, is only at -6.

This is not an issue with lone pirates, shadowports, or independent colonies.

Save is 13 megs.
User avatar
MaximKI
Posts: 2773
Joined: Thu Oct 20, 2022 12:29 pm

Re: Pirates Hate me

Post by MaximKI »

How far into your game are you? How many colonies? How long have you had your protection agreements for with the pirate factions?

Do you see any diplomatic bonus in your relations with them from maintaining protection agreements?

Pirates generally don't particularly like empires, so the fact that they don't like you when you're developed isn't unexpected. However, there may be circumstances where that's overtuned and counters any diplomatic progress you have with them.

Have any of them broken protection agreements with you and decided to become hostile with you at all?
Xmudder
Posts: 345
Joined: Sun Feb 14, 2010 10:13 pm

Re: Pirates Hate me

Post by Xmudder »

MaximKI wrote: Thu Oct 08, 2026 1:54 pm How far into your game are you? How many colonies? How long have you had your protection agreements for with the pirate factions?

Do you see any diplomatic bonus in your relations with them from maintaining protection agreements?

Pirates generally don't particularly like empires, so the fact that they don't like you when you're developed isn't unexpected. However, there may be circumstances where that's overtuned and counters any diplomatic progress you have with them.

Have any of them broken protection agreements with you and decided to become hostile with you at all?
I've never seen this before Shadow Rising. All pirate factions will be smaller than settled empires, and thus hate them. Which means the kill the hive to annex the pirates will never happen. 9 colonies, 14b people. 2 pirate factions (I am in contact with 3, and 6 solo), both my race, have just sent fleets after my planets. No declarations of hostility. I just researched destroyers and am auto-building them for my fleets. No bonus from protection agreements.

I have gotten pop ups of purging pirates from independent colonies I annexed.
User avatar
MaximKI
Posts: 2773
Joined: Thu Oct 20, 2022 12:29 pm

Re: Pirates Hate me

Post by MaximKI »

Please do send a save to this address at maxim.k@slitherine.co.uk showing your game state.
Xmudder
Posts: 345
Joined: Sun Feb 14, 2010 10:13 pm

Re: Pirates Hate me

Post by Xmudder »

There is something very wrong here. The pirates, despite having a huge "you are bigger than us! die die die" malus to relations, are kicking my ass. Probably due to all the buffs they got with the new DLC. I like that they are actually using fleets - I don't like that their fleets are bigger and higher tech than mine. Nor do I understand how they can have more powerful fleets than my 11 planet 16 billion pop empire. Albiet, I am still deploying destroyers. Because the AI would rather upgrade civilian ships, and build more civilian ships and troop transports, than expand my existing fleets. So I had to manually add to them (using the top up button on the fleet window) once I realized what was going wrong.
Xmudder
Posts: 345
Joined: Sun Feb 14, 2010 10:13 pm

Re: Pirates Hate me

Post by Xmudder »

Still a problem in 1.3.8.6 beta. All of a sudden every pirate faction gets a "we are envious of your huge strength and power" and relations start dropping. I caught it happening when a pirate faction is killed by someone other than me. Have before and after saves in new game.
PiratesHateMe.png
PiratesHateMe.png (639.95 KiB) Viewed 553 times
Xmudder
Posts: 345
Joined: Sun Feb 14, 2010 10:13 pm

Re: Pirates Hate me

Post by Xmudder »

I Agreed to come to the defense of the only pirate fleet that did not hate me from the hive. They immediately turned hostile. Did not catch it in time to save though.
Xmudder
Posts: 345
Joined: Sun Feb 14, 2010 10:13 pm

Re: Pirates Hate me

Post by Xmudder »

I made some saves, before and after. There is a "despicable attacks against civilian ships" malus I don't understand but have seen before. I would really like messages about my ships attacking, destroying, and dying to follow what is going on. My best guess is that someone else attacked their ships (the hive maybe) and for some reason they blame me. They are also hostile to all nations and independent colonies they are in contact with.
Xmudder
Posts: 345
Joined: Sun Feb 14, 2010 10:13 pm

Re: Pirates Hate me

Post by Xmudder »

Same problem, different game. I killed a hive carrier, added about 8 pirate factions to my empire... and now every pirate faction left in the game hates me for "eliminating a pirate faction"

Did you intend to put and end to the make friends with the pirates, kill the hive, incorporate the pirates? Because it sure seems like it.

Also, this was in a game where I disabled Shadows rising. I had no problem with pirates until now.

I have before and after saves, too big to upload here.
EwaKaczmarek
Posts: 3
Joined: Wed Oct 07, 2026 6:55 am

Re: Pirates Hate me

Post by EwaKaczmarek »

I have run into something very similar in my own campaign, and it has been frustrating for the same reason. I had protection agreements with a couple of pirate factions for a long time, and they were actually useful for keeping trade lanes quiet, but once my empire got much bigger than them the relationship just fell apart. The envy penalty seems to grow so fast that it wipes out everything else, and then one incident, like taking out a hive carrier or clearing pirates from a colony I annexed, turns the rest of them hostile all at once. That makes the whole idea of working with pirates feel pointless, because you can spend a whole game building those contacts and then lose them in a single step for something you did not even mean as an attack on them. I have also had trouble telling what actually triggered it, because the messages do not always make it clear which ships were involved or who started the fight. It would help a lot if the game explained the penalty better, or if eliminating a pirate faction did not count against you with every other pirate faction in the galaxy. For now I am just keeping my distance from the hive and trying not to annex colonies with pirates still in them, but that feels like working around the problem rather than playing the game as intended.
Post Reply

Return to “Distant Worlds 2: Tech Support”