Version 01.05.02 (New) Russian A.I. HQ SUs Locked

Please post your after action reports on your battles and campaigns here.

Moderator: Joel Billings

User avatar
tm1
Posts: 2623
Joined: Tue May 14, 2013 10:21 pm
Location: Central Coast NSW Australia

Re: Version 01.05.02 (New) Russian A.I. HQ SUs Locked

Post by tm1 »

HI
I am following I'm waiting to see how you handle Odessa and Leningrad against the AI, my advice that I learnt so it not mine but I'm passing it on.

18th Armee drives through Latvia and targets Tallinin put Model in command first chance you get, everybody says that he is the man for the Armee and there right he has worked well for me.

$th Pz Armee objectives Riga , Pskov, Novgorod then onto the Moscow / Leningrad rail link cut it as soon as you can then the 3 ports isolate lenningrad.

9th Armee to attack Leningrad maybe 1 Panzer Div to support or more up to you.

16th Armee objectives back in the WITE 1 days the Valdai Hills was vital the consensus here when I ask the question not anymore but I still make a prime objective, reasons well a couple if you can some 3rd Pz Armee mobile Div's to help you can reach the Msta river you can take Vyshny Volochek then turn south with your Panzer's take Torzhok and be setup to take both the Moscow Volga canal and Volga Res.
Also for 16th Armee if you keep advancing north out of the hills you will see a town called Borovichi its resource centre very handy.
ReginaldBednar2
Posts: 315
Joined: Thu Aug 01, 2019 10:46 pm

Re: Version 01.05.02 (New) Russian A.I. HQ SUs Locked

Post by ReginaldBednar2 »

WAR IN THE EAST III SUGGESTIONS:

RUSSIA POINT OF VIEW
  • #1Soldiers/Factor Workers/Farmers human being modeling in wartime production [Leningrad/Moscow/Stalingrad]
  • #2Command decision freezing (Siberia, Siberia, Siberia!) and random leadership attribute assignment at the start of the game (earn as you go)
  • #3Beloved T-34/76.2mm(s) running of diesel fuel and being abandoned (1/2 or 1/3 ratio to Wehrmacht MBTs at the start of the invasion!!!!!)

GERMAN POINT OF VIEW
  • #1Soldiers/Factor Workers/Farmers human being modeling in wartime production [waves/re-tooling is very point/foreign,foreign,foreign]
  • #2Command decision freezing (permanent retirement, out of retirement, and treason) and random leadership attribute assignment at the start of the game (earn as you go)
  • #3Prussian wargames do include logistics, minatures++
SUMMARY
  • Better control of what is, can be, and should be produced for both sides based on changing combat conditions
  • Better command and control modeling based on historical research
  • Locomotive points, freight car points, food points, electricity points, goal points (civilian usage also modeled!), etc.
ReginaldBednar2
Posts: 315
Joined: Thu Aug 01, 2019 10:46 pm

Re: Version 01.05.02 (New) Russian A.I. HQ SUs Locked

Post by ReginaldBednar2 »

TYPE point ===> important
ReginaldBednar2
Posts: 315
Joined: Thu Aug 01, 2019 10:46 pm

Re: Version 01.05.02 (New) Russian A.I. HQ SUs Locked

Post by ReginaldBednar2 »

TYPO goal ===> COAL
ReginaldBednar2
Posts: 315
Joined: Thu Aug 01, 2019 10:46 pm

Re: Version 01.05.02 (New) Russian A.I. HQ SUs Locked

Post by ReginaldBednar2 »

FM Patton studied EVERTHING RELATED TO US/GERMANY/USSR/GB MILITARY!

For example: Black aide (Ike's aide), black drivers (Operation Market Garden),
Battle of Bulge (101AB/82AB limos), ...

Yes, in effect, 16/7 is around 3, rounded up.
50/7 is around 8, rounded up.
We will never see those tanks over the horizon again!

3 divisions over 10 miles with all 9 regiments abreast means 6250 m/9 = 694.44 m/regiment = 0.69444 km/regiment ===> good buy regiment!

That how it was done!
The other 8 regiments wait days for orders from Stalin's headquarters and dream nightmares about Siberia until they are surrounded!
ReginaldBednar2
Posts: 315
Joined: Thu Aug 01, 2019 10:46 pm

Re: Version 01.05.02 (New) Russian A.I. HQ SUs Locked

Post by ReginaldBednar2 »

Are you Microsoft Certifiable II?
ReginaldBednar2
Posts: 315
Joined: Thu Aug 01, 2019 10:46 pm

Re: Version 01.05.02 (New) Russian A.I. HQ SUs Locked

Post by ReginaldBednar2 »

tm1 wrote: Sat Nov 14, 2026 1:44 pm HI
I am following I'm waiting to see how you handle Odessa and Leningrad against the AI, my advice that I learnt so it not mine but I'm passing it on.

18th Armee drives through Latvia and targets Tallinin put Model in command first chance you get, everybody says that he is the man for the Armee and there right he has worked well for me.

$th Pz Armee objectives Riga , Pskov, Novgorod then onto the Moscow / Leningrad rail link cut it as soon as you can then the 3 ports isolate lenningrad.

9th Armee to attack Leningrad maybe 1 Panzer Div to support or more up to you.

16th Armee objectives back in the WITE 1 days the Valdai Hills was vital the consensus here when I ask the question not anymore but I still make a prime objective, reasons well a couple if you can some 3rd Pz Armee mobile Div's to help you can reach the Msta river you can take Vyshny Volochek then turn south with your Panzer's take Torzhok and be setup to take both the Moscow Volga canal and Volga Res.
Also for 16th Armee if you keep advancing north out of the hills you will see a town called Borovichi its resource centre very handy.
1. Odessa: Cut off with combination of Wehrmacht infantry divisions and Rumanian infantry divisions, and actually sacrifice some Wehrmacht replacements. (Bessarabia == nothing to the Fuhrer).

2. Leningrad: Yes, take it, but maybe in 1942! Yes, maybe take Moscow in 1942 also and win! This is not Avalon Hill's version of reality. Cutoff Leningrad RR's in 1941 and much as possible but destroy the Russian Army via supermen encirclements, brute force miniature encirclements, and preservation of supermen assets

3. 18th Army can be easily bogged down in Soviet swamp heaven with a RR there to move half of the entire Soviet Army if necessary (100% infantry preferable, forts, and fortified units waiting for them in Operation Swamp Kursk). The ports will not sustain the entire 18th Army, and you need to tie up an entire RR superman repair brigade to have any chance of success. That leaves only one other available RR superman repair brigade (think, supermen run ghettos and concentration camp idiots) to support the NE run to Leningrad (goodbye the Fuhrer's grand entry into a fully cleared Moscow in 1941)!

4. Panzer's don't do well in a combination of swamps, heavy forests, large bodies of water that are not frozen, with obvious RR lines of advancement! Think, road construction engineer supermen (ghettos and concentrations camps actually a much higher priority, as do well fed German frauleins).
The rule of success in War in the East II for both sides: infantry and tanks and where our halftracks!). PS Moscow had a much priority for Stalin than the combination of defending Leningrad and Stalingrad combined!

5. Please explain which 9th Army you are talking about? 16th Army? Where are you getting the extra Panzer Division from? You must fully reinforce the 18th Army for either strategy: are you doing this? Are you getting this from North Africa?
ReginaldBednar2
Posts: 315
Joined: Thu Aug 01, 2019 10:46 pm

Re: Version 01.05.02 (New) Russian A.I. HQ SUs Locked

Post by ReginaldBednar2 »

SUGGESTIONS ABOUT MAKEING A/C EASIER FOR THOSE WHO NEVER WARGAMED
  • Define English standard aircraft (a/c) functional designations (TB: Anti-shipping), (DB: Dive Bomber, also good anti-shipping), (F: Best fighters who generate real aces), (FB: Fighter Bombers, fighters which can carry bombs also, never having any aces), (HB: Heavy Bombers [house destroyers]), MB: Medium Bombers [artillery destroyers], LB: Light Bombers [rifle destroyers], S [drops supplies to scouts], and R [reconnaissance for scouts]
  • When you hover the mouse over a base with the Aircraft Display Mode icon selected, please display all of the following in an easy to read, list format:
    Base name
    Associated a/c higher HQ [non-blue rectangular label]
    Associated a/c AOG [blue label] (a/c holding container which different types of a/c)
    A/c unit which will be a wings or squadron or whatever is left of the unit
    A/c that the unit actually has (one type-only)
    Above English standard a/c functional designation
    A/c unit % used (bombing airbases, bombing cities, bombing factories requires 0% utilization)
    Ammo supplies available on base or that can right-clicked, airbase re-supplied
    Supply supplies available on base or that can be right-clicked, airbase re-supplied
    Total airbase capacity
    Total airbase remaining capacity
    Depot in hex
    Depot non-value number (one in triangle, so 2=S type unit)
  • Koluft means supports a Wehrmacht Army or Army Group (not usually desirable for the freedom-loving Luftwaffe, like Goehring himself)
  • Higher a/c headquarters have dashed, box, outlines which are too light in intensity (but so beautiful colors!) could really be more functional and not waste as much time
  • MAKE SURE YOUR MAUS++ (ELEFANT--) WORKS 99+% OF THE TIME BEFORE SIMULATING
User avatar
tm1
Posts: 2623
Joined: Tue May 14, 2013 10:21 pm
Location: Central Coast NSW Australia

Re: Version 01.05.02 (New) Russian A.I. HQ SUs Locked

Post by tm1 »

ReginaldBednar2 wrote: Sun Nov 15, 2026 12:03 am
tm1 wrote: Sat Nov 14, 2026 1:44 pm HI
I am following I'm waiting to see how you handle Odessa and Leningrad against the AI, my advice that I learnt so it not mine but I'm passing it on.

18th Armee drives through Latvia and targets Tallinin put Model in command first chance you get, everybody says that he is the man for the Armee and there right he has worked well for me.

$th Pz Armee objectives Riga , Pskov, Novgorod then onto the Moscow / Leningrad rail link cut it as soon as you can then the 3 ports isolate lenningrad.

9th Armee to attack Leningrad maybe 1 Panzer Div to support or more up to you.

16th Armee objectives back in the WITE 1 days the Valdai Hills was vital the consensus here when I ask the question not anymore but I still make a prime objective, reasons well a couple if you can some 3rd Pz Armee mobile Div's to help you can reach the Msta river you can take Vyshny Volochek then turn south with your Panzer's take Torzhok and be setup to take both the Moscow Volga canal and Volga Res.
Also for 16th Armee if you keep advancing north out of the hills you will see a town called Borovichi its resource centre very handy.
1. Odessa: Cut off with combination of Wehrmacht infantry divisions and Rumanian infantry divisions, and actually sacrifice some Wehrmacht replacements. (Bessarabia == nothing to the Fuhrer).

2. Leningrad: Yes, take it, but maybe in 1942! Yes, maybe take Moscow in 1942 also and win! This is not Avalon Hill's version of reality. Cutoff Leningrad RR's in 1941 and much as possible but destroy the Russian Army via supermen encirclements, brute force miniature encirclements, and preservation of supermen assets

3. 18th Army can be easily bogged down in Soviet swamp heaven with a RR there to move half of the entire Soviet Army if necessary (100% infantry preferable, forts, and fortified units waiting for them in Operation Swamp Kursk). The ports will not sustain the entire 18th Army, and you need to tie up an entire RR superman repair brigade to have any chance of success. That leaves only one other available RR superman repair brigade (think, supermen run ghettos and concentration camp idiots) to support the NE run to Leningrad (goodbye the Fuhrer's grand entry into a fully cleared Moscow in 1941)!

4. Panzer's don't do well in a combination of swamps, heavy forests, large bodies of water that are not frozen, with obvious RR lines of advancement! Think, road construction engineer supermen (ghettos and concentrations camps actually a much higher priority, as do well fed German frauleins).
The rule of success in War in the East II for both sides: infantry and tanks and where our halftracks!). PS Moscow had a much priority for Stalin than the combination of defending Leningrad and Stalingrad combined!

5. Please explain which 9th Army you are talking about? 16th Army? Where are you getting the extra Panzer Division from? You must fully reinforce the 18th Army for either strategy: are you doing this? Are you getting this from North Africa?
My mistake I was referring to 18th Armee to besiege and capture Leningrad with some Panzer support and I still say you should use 4th Pz Armee to attack towards the Russian ports that supply Leningrad you need to cut it off completely so they don't use the " Ice Road " in winter.
ReginaldBednar2
Posts: 315
Joined: Thu Aug 01, 2019 10:46 pm

Re: Version 01.05.02 (New) Russian A.I. HQ SUs Locked

Post by ReginaldBednar2 »

End of German Turn 4: July 13, 1941

VICTORY POINTS: Still at 410 (needing 525 to prevent sudden death)

COMBAT:

The plan is to have two corps from 18th Army move north to attack Narva River Line? The other corps plus one corps from the 16th Army, together with the 4th Panzer Group will try to seize the expected, heavily defended Pskov position. Pskov is 4 hexes away. A huge salient now juts towards Pskov. Daugavpils is 3 hexes away on Dvina River.

Also 3 hexes away from Polotsk further down Dvina River. Battle of The Land Bridge begins (major Russian defense line near Ulla). Battle for Dnepr River crossing towards Moscow begins: 4 hexes from Mogilev and 5 hexes from Orsha. Clearing western part of Pripyat Marshes, mainly to prevents division-size sorties out of the huge swamp to cut precious RR supply lines.

Rovno lost in major Russian defense line, which had to be heavily assaulted. Slow advance to Odessa; next river barrier is Dnestr. Flank will be turned at Chertkov!

NOTE: A.I. upfront, with units near 100% TOE and backed up by significant RESERVE divisions, including cavalry and rifle divisions, resulted in very heavy Russian casualties against German panzer units. This turn, the Russians lost 1,207 tanks, including 764 T-34 and 143 KV heavy tanks, for which the Wehrmacht has no similar class of tanks, and 146,687 men. This brings total Russian losses to 854,760 men!
ReginaldBednar2
Posts: 315
Joined: Thu Aug 01, 2019 10:46 pm

Re: Version 01.05.02 (New) Russian A.I. HQ SUs Locked

Post by ReginaldBednar2 »

German_Turn_003_01.png
German_Turn_003_01.png (863.45 KiB) Viewed 149 times
German_Turn_003_02.png
German_Turn_003_02.png (901.06 KiB) Viewed 149 times
German_Turn_003_03.png
German_Turn_003_03.png (948.13 KiB) Viewed 149 times
ReginaldBednar2
Posts: 315
Joined: Thu Aug 01, 2019 10:46 pm

Re: Version 01.05.02 (New) Russian A.I. HQ SUs Locked

Post by ReginaldBednar2 »

German_Turn_003_04.png
German_Turn_003_04.png (971.37 KiB) Viewed 149 times
German_Turn_003_05.png
German_Turn_003_05.png (956.24 KiB) Viewed 149 times
German_Turn_003_06.png
German_Turn_003_06.png (938.23 KiB) Viewed 149 times
ReginaldBednar2
Posts: 315
Joined: Thu Aug 01, 2019 10:46 pm

Re: Version 01.05.02 (New) Russian A.I. HQ SUs Locked

Post by ReginaldBednar2 »

German_Turn_003_07.png
German_Turn_003_07.png (965.04 KiB) Viewed 148 times
German_Turn_003_08.png
German_Turn_003_08.png (887.43 KiB) Viewed 148 times
German_Turn_003_09.png
German_Turn_003_09.png (884.08 KiB) Viewed 148 times
ReginaldBednar2
Posts: 315
Joined: Thu Aug 01, 2019 10:46 pm

Re: Version 01.05.02 (New) Russian A.I. HQ SUs Locked

Post by ReginaldBednar2 »

German_Turn_003_10.png
German_Turn_003_10.png (890.89 KiB) Viewed 148 times
German_Turn_003_11.png
German_Turn_003_11.png (851.56 KiB) Viewed 148 times
User avatar
Wiedrock
Posts: 2258
Joined: Tue Oct 11, 2022 7:44 pm
Location: Germany

Re: Version 01.05.02 (New) Russian A.I. HQ SUs Locked

Post by Wiedrock »

Are these the same T3 pics (again?)?
ReginaldBednar2
Posts: 315
Joined: Thu Aug 01, 2019 10:46 pm

Re: Version 01.05.02 (New) Russian A.I. HQ SUs Locked

Post by ReginaldBednar2 »

Thanks for paying attention; it was very late at night.
ReginaldBednar2
Posts: 315
Joined: Thu Aug 01, 2019 10:46 pm

Re: Version 01.05.02 (New) Russian A.I. HQ SUs Locked

Post by ReginaldBednar2 »

German_Turn_004_01.png
German_Turn_004_01.png (880.16 KiB) Viewed 39 times
German_Turn_004_02.png
German_Turn_004_02.png (967.01 KiB) Viewed 39 times
German_Turn_004_03.png
German_Turn_004_03.png (953.8 KiB) Viewed 39 times
ReginaldBednar2
Posts: 315
Joined: Thu Aug 01, 2019 10:46 pm

Re: Version 01.05.02 (New) Russian A.I. HQ SUs Locked

Post by ReginaldBednar2 »

German_Turn_004_04.png
German_Turn_004_04.png (945.77 KiB) Viewed 39 times
German_Turn_004_05.png
German_Turn_004_05.png (970.22 KiB) Viewed 39 times
German_Turn_004_06.png
German_Turn_004_06.png (965.59 KiB) Viewed 39 times
ReginaldBednar2
Posts: 315
Joined: Thu Aug 01, 2019 10:46 pm

Re: Version 01.05.02 (New) Russian A.I. HQ SUs Locked

Post by ReginaldBednar2 »

German_Turn_004_07.png
German_Turn_004_07.png (931.17 KiB) Viewed 39 times
German_Turn_004_08.png
German_Turn_004_08.png (884.49 KiB) Viewed 39 times
German_Turn_004_09.png
German_Turn_004_09.png (890.92 KiB) Viewed 39 times
ReginaldBednar2
Posts: 315
Joined: Thu Aug 01, 2019 10:46 pm

Re: Version 01.05.02 (New) Russian A.I. HQ SUs Locked

Post by ReginaldBednar2 »

German_Turn_004_10.png
German_Turn_004_10.png (793.94 KiB) Viewed 39 times
Post Reply

Return to “After Action Reports”