- the depots in Greater Germany should be 3 for ports and 4 for most depots (pass on all supplies). I had to manually change them (numerous occurrences)
ISSUES CONCERNING V 1.05.02
Moderator: Joel Billings
-
ReginaldBednar2
- Posts: 322
- Joined: Thu Aug 01, 2019 10:46 pm
ISSUES CONCERNING V 1.05.02
ISSUE NUMBER 1
- Joel Billings
- Posts: 33798
- Joined: Wed Sep 20, 2000 8:00 am
- Location: Santa Rosa, CA
- Contact:
Re: ISSUES CONCERNING V 1.05.02
This is not a bug, but WAD. The rear area depots are lower priority to pass along their freight. Players are free to change them as they like.
All understanding comes after the fact.
-- Soren Kierkegaard
-- Soren Kierkegaard
-
ReginaldBednar2
- Posts: 322
- Joined: Thu Aug 01, 2019 10:46 pm
Re: ISSUES CONCERNING V 1.05.02
Mr. Billings:
I have looked at the actual freight (pseudo-supplies) in the rear areas of Greater Germany. The lower the number in the depot triangle in N mode, the more freight actually in the depot in my game. Depots with a 4 in the triangle have highest priority for passing freight on. My airbases which are to supply ground units in the combat phase I set to 2 (inside the triangle).
I have looked at the actual freight (pseudo-supplies) in the rear areas of Greater Germany. The lower the number in the depot triangle in N mode, the more freight actually in the depot in my game. Depots with a 4 in the triangle have highest priority for passing freight on. My airbases which are to supply ground units in the combat phase I set to 2 (inside the triangle).
-
ReginaldBednar2
- Posts: 322
- Joined: Thu Aug 01, 2019 10:46 pm
Re: ISSUES CONCERNING V 1.05.02
ISSUE NUMBER 2
- The Luftwaffe lost a very large number of 406 aircraft due to air combat the first turn, almost all in fighter bombers and bombers A total of 636 aircraft where lost due to all causes. I just used the default directives, but no AI AIRCRAFT ASSIST
Re: ISSUES CONCERNING V 1.05.02
What "Morale" Setting are you playing at? Soviet with higher Morale setting has a better performing VVS.ReginaldBednar2 wrote: Fri Nov 13, 2026 5:12 pm ISSUE NUMBER 2
- The Luftwaffe lost a very large number of 406 aircraft due to air combat the first turn, almost all in fighter bombers and bombers A total of 636 aircraft where lost due to all causes. I just used the default directives, but no AI AIRCRAFT ASSIST
“Amateurs study tactics; professionals study logistics.”
My Mods:
GE Gui & Sym Mod Depot (continued)
Rasputitsa for your eyes. Soviet colours redone.
My Tools:
Turn-Dates-Converter
Command Efficiency with Command Range Modifier
Planning map 1.02.45_Beta
My Mods:
GE Gui & Sym Mod Depot (continued)
Rasputitsa for your eyes. Soviet colours redone.
My Tools:
Turn-Dates-Converter
Command Efficiency with Command Range Modifier
Planning map 1.02.45_Beta
Re: ISSUES CONCERNING V 1.05.02
How did you do that? Is that the air phase or all of T1?ReginaldBednar2 wrote: Fri Nov 13, 2026 5:12 pm ISSUE NUMBER 2
- The Luftwaffe lost a very large number of 406 aircraft due to air combat the first turn, almost all in fighter bombers and bombers A total of 636 aircraft where lost due to all causes. I just used the default directives, but no AI AIRCRAFT ASSIST
Vanilla air phase has Axis losses at about 150. Just checked my opponents T1 and Axis total losses were 397. No recon.
Molotov : This we did not deserve.
Foch : This is not peace. This is a 20 year armistice.
C'est la guerre aérienne
Foch : This is not peace. This is a 20 year armistice.
C'est la guerre aérienne
Re: ISSUES CONCERNING V 1.05.02
Wiedrock wrote: Fri Nov 13, 2026 11:33 pmWhat "Morale" Setting are you playing at? Soviet with higher Morale setting has a better performing VVS.ReginaldBednar2 wrote: Fri Nov 13, 2026 5:12 pm ISSUE NUMBER 2
- The Luftwaffe lost a very large number of 406 aircraft due to air combat the first turn, almost all in fighter bombers and bombers A total of 636 aircraft where lost due to all causes. I just used the default directives, but no AI AIRCRAFT ASSIST
ReginaldBednar2 wrote: Thu Nov 12, 2026 8:56 pm DETAILED GAME SETUP OPTIONS [...]
Axis: Human
Soviet: Computer
Difficulty: CHALLENGING
[...]
Pick Scenario: 1941 Campaign
[...]
“Amateurs study tactics; professionals study logistics.”
My Mods:
GE Gui & Sym Mod Depot (continued)
Rasputitsa for your eyes. Soviet colours redone.
My Tools:
Turn-Dates-Converter
Command Efficiency with Command Range Modifier
Planning map 1.02.45_Beta
My Mods:
GE Gui & Sym Mod Depot (continued)
Rasputitsa for your eyes. Soviet colours redone.
My Tools:
Turn-Dates-Converter
Command Efficiency with Command Range Modifier
Planning map 1.02.45_Beta
Re: ISSUES CONCERNING V 1.05.02
ReginaldBednar2 wrote: Fri Nov 13, 2026 4:24 pm ISSUE NUMBER 1
- the depots in Greater Germany should be 3 for ports and 4 for most depots (pass on all supplies). I had to manually change them (numerous occurrences)
The Depot priorities go form 0 to 4 and not from 4 to 0. So freight flows fromReginaldBednar2 wrote: Fri Nov 13, 2026 5:07 pm Mr. Billings:
I have looked at the actual freight (pseudo-supplies) in the rear areas of Greater Germany. The lower the number in the depot triangle in N mode, the more freight actually in the depot in my game. Depots with a 4 in the triangle have highest priority for passing freight on. My airbases which are to supply ground units in the combat phase I set to 2 (inside the triangle).
- NSS→anywhere except priority "0" depots
- 1→2,3,4
- 2→3,4
- 3→4
- 4→nowhere but to consumers.
"4 for most depots (pass on all supplies)"
→So you set all of Western Germany to Priority 4 depots or what? And not sure if your "pass on" is the same as mine.
“Amateurs study tactics; professionals study logistics.”
My Mods:
GE Gui & Sym Mod Depot (continued)
Rasputitsa for your eyes. Soviet colours redone.
My Tools:
Turn-Dates-Converter
Command Efficiency with Command Range Modifier
Planning map 1.02.45_Beta
My Mods:
GE Gui & Sym Mod Depot (continued)
Rasputitsa for your eyes. Soviet colours redone.
My Tools:
Turn-Dates-Converter
Command Efficiency with Command Range Modifier
Planning map 1.02.45_Beta
-
ReginaldBednar2
- Posts: 322
- Joined: Thu Aug 01, 2019 10:46 pm
Re: ISSUES CONCERNING V 1.05.02
It is true that depot triangle numbers can be 0 (except for national supply centers of course), but why use them? It means no supplies are passed to any nearby unit? I haven't encountered any situation so far where that would be necessary. Practically, 1=store 2=medium store 3=light store 4=pass everything needed on if what players need to know. Note that depot levels are simply notational, 4=national supply 3=port 2=theater depot 1=unit depot, which has nothing at all to do with how much supply is generated or storable.
-
ReginaldBednar2
- Posts: 322
- Joined: Thu Aug 01, 2019 10:46 pm
Re: ISSUES CONCERNING V 1.05.02
In regard to CHALLENGING morale settings, please set a game up to CHALLENGING mode and they will display (like 110 instead of 100).
They are fixed for every player and every game.
They are fixed for every player and every game.
-
ReginaldBednar2
- Posts: 322
- Joined: Thu Aug 01, 2019 10:46 pm
Re: ISSUES CONCERNING V 1.05.02
The Luftwaffe (air-to-air combat) could confidently expect a 10:1 kill ratio, and the Wehrmacht (land combat) could confidently expect an average of 6:1 kill ratio.
-
ReginaldBednar2
- Posts: 322
- Joined: Thu Aug 01, 2019 10:46 pm
Re: ISSUES CONCERNING V 1.05.02
Good questioning! I simply ran the canned (pre-defined by default for Turn 1) air directives, most of which are for airfield attack over a large defined area. Almost all of the air-to-air combat losses were attacking airfields! It is basically in the air phase, since the combat phase does not allow airfield attack.56ajax wrote: Sat Nov 14, 2026 5:18 amHow did you do that? Is that the air phase or all of T1?ReginaldBednar2 wrote: Fri Nov 13, 2026 5:12 pm ISSUE NUMBER 2
- The Luftwaffe lost a very large number of 406 aircraft due to air combat the first turn, almost all in fighter bombers and bombers A total of 636 aircraft where lost due to all causes. I just used the default directives, but no AI AIRCRAFT ASSIST
Vanilla air phase has Axis losses at about 150. Just checked my opponents T1 and Axis total losses were 397. No recon.
Our think your 150/397 total losses are much closer to expected vis-a-vis 636.
(1) What version are you getting numbers from?
(2) If A.I., which was it and what was the difficulty level?
(3) Do you think A.I. assist for this version is the problem?
(4) Why not load my version (latest available) and just run the air phase as is, and give me the plane loss data (type and causes of loss)?
Re: ISSUES CONCERNING V 1.05.02
Are you writing with help of or getting your information from an AI LLM?ReginaldBednar2 wrote: Sun Nov 15, 2026 5:58 am It is true that depot triangle numbers can be 0 (except for national supply centers of course), but why use them? It means no supplies are passed to any nearby unit? I haven't encountered any situation so far where that would be necessary. Practically, 1=store 2=medium store 3=light store 4=pass everything needed on if what players need to know. Note that depot levels are simply notational, 4=national supply 3=port 2=theater depot 1=unit depot, which has nothing at all to do with how much supply is generated or storable.
“Amateurs study tactics; professionals study logistics.”
My Mods:
GE Gui & Sym Mod Depot (continued)
Rasputitsa for your eyes. Soviet colours redone.
My Tools:
Turn-Dates-Converter
Command Efficiency with Command Range Modifier
Planning map 1.02.45_Beta
My Mods:
GE Gui & Sym Mod Depot (continued)
Rasputitsa for your eyes. Soviet colours redone.
My Tools:
Turn-Dates-Converter
Command Efficiency with Command Range Modifier
Planning map 1.02.45_Beta
Re: ISSUES CONCERNING V 1.05.02
All the inactive ADs (major effect) being activated [I can't speak for why they are in the game.], plus some extra losses from the 110Morale (minor effect compared to the other) gives you ~400-430 losses during T1 Air Phase (ran 3 times), not anywhere near 600+. So the 600+ likely is the whole T1 losses combined with the ADs/Difficulty.56ajax wrote: Sat Nov 14, 2026 5:18 amHow did you do that? Is that the air phase or all of T1?ReginaldBednar2 wrote: Fri Nov 13, 2026 5:12 pm ISSUE NUMBER 2
- The Luftwaffe lost a very large number of 406 aircraft due to air combat the first turn, almost all in fighter bombers and bombers A total of 636 aircraft where lost due to all causes. I just used the default directives, but no AI AIRCRAFT ASSIST
Vanilla air phase has Axis losses at about 150. Just checked my opponents T1 and Axis total losses were 397. No recon.
Or ADs/Doctrines being messed with in any other way manually before executing T1 Air Phase.
- Attachments
-
- T1 Air losses 110 plus all ADs_example.jpg (308.98 KiB) Viewed 375 times
-
- T1 Air losses 110 plus all ADs.jpg (57.08 KiB) Viewed 375 times
“Amateurs study tactics; professionals study logistics.”
My Mods:
GE Gui & Sym Mod Depot (continued)
Rasputitsa for your eyes. Soviet colours redone.
My Tools:
Turn-Dates-Converter
Command Efficiency with Command Range Modifier
Planning map 1.02.45_Beta
My Mods:
GE Gui & Sym Mod Depot (continued)
Rasputitsa for your eyes. Soviet colours redone.
My Tools:
Turn-Dates-Converter
Command Efficiency with Command Range Modifier
Planning map 1.02.45_Beta
Re: ISSUES CONCERNING V 1.05.02
1. 01.05.02ReginaldBednar2 wrote: Sun Nov 15, 2026 6:14 amGood questioning! I simply ran the canned (pre-defined by default for Turn 1) air directives, most of which are for airfield attack over a large defined area. Almost all of the air-to-air combat losses were attacking airfields! It is basically in the air phase, since the combat phase does not allow airfield attack.56ajax wrote: Sat Nov 14, 2026 5:18 amHow did you do that? Is that the air phase or all of T1?ReginaldBednar2 wrote: Fri Nov 13, 2026 5:12 pm ISSUE NUMBER 2
- The Luftwaffe lost a very large number of 406 aircraft due to air combat the first turn, almost all in fighter bombers and bombers A total of 636 aircraft where lost due to all causes. I just used the default directives, but no AI AIRCRAFT ASSIST
Vanilla air phase has Axis losses at about 150. Just checked my opponents T1 and Axis total losses were 397. No recon.
Our think your 150/397 total losses are much closer to expected vis-a-vis 636.
(1) What version are you getting numbers from?
(2) If A.I., which was it and what was the difficulty level?
(3) Do you think A.I. assist for this version is the problem?
(4) Why not load my version (latest available) and just run the air phase as is, and give me the plane loss data (type and causes of loss)?
2. Normal
3. No
The ADs are the ones activated by default. There are many others but activating these can cause large losses. If you move air units around before Air Phase it can break pre defined ADs.
If you want to play around increase fighter escorts to 15, loadouts to small bombs and ensure that fighter bases are bombed first.
Molotov : This we did not deserve.
Foch : This is not peace. This is a 20 year armistice.
C'est la guerre aérienne
Foch : This is not peace. This is a 20 year armistice.
C'est la guerre aérienne
-
ReginaldBednar2
- Posts: 322
- Joined: Thu Aug 01, 2019 10:46 pm
Re: ISSUES CONCERNING V 1.05.02
ANSWERS TO TWO ABOUT RESPONDEES
Out of 405 a/c lost due to all causes, 342 (84.4%) were lost to air-to-air combat (probably most were bombers). This implies the bombers were not properly escorted for Ground Attack, or there is a Turn 1 unique issue
Out of 405 a/c lost due to all causes, 342 (84.4%) were lost to air-to-air combat (probably most were bombers). This implies the bombers were not properly escorted for Ground Attack, or there is a Turn 1 unique issue
-
ReginaldBednar2
- Posts: 322
- Joined: Thu Aug 01, 2019 10:46 pm
Re: ISSUES CONCERNING V 1.05.02
Pearl Harbor:
"We need CONFIRMATION!" (BBs Arizona [fire] and Oklahoma [water])
"Don't worry about it!" (B-17s at Schweinfurt)
"You mean the Philippines?" (Plan Orange)
"Today, is a day the will live in infamy!" (B-25 raid on Japan followed by the
Battle of the Coral Sea)
"Due South direction! [SIC]" (How the Enterprise found salvation to last the
entire war and then was scraped without much
fanfare)
"Our Aircraft Carriers Are Mobile Scouting platforms!" (Saratoga in San Diego
undergoing re-innovations, one extra Dauntless dive bombing squadron
designated SCOUTING per carrier, no Dauntless squadrons available for
land operation FOR MONTHS!)
"Tora, Tora, Tora!" (Just skip any attack on death-trap slow battleships and
concentrate on (1) heavy cruisers, (2) destroyers, and (3) submarines,
[SIC]; shoot down all "anti-carrier" planes miles from Pearl Harbor with
their crews in uncoordinated attacks and P-40s that are out of range)
"Search Plan Calculus - The Navy Way!" (1942, the search plans are delivered
to Pearl Harbor without PBY, Devastator, or TBF replacements and
without significant Dauntless dive bomber squadrons either)
"We need CONFIRMATION!" (BBs Arizona [fire] and Oklahoma [water])
"Don't worry about it!" (B-17s at Schweinfurt)
"You mean the Philippines?" (Plan Orange)
"Today, is a day the will live in infamy!" (B-25 raid on Japan followed by the
Battle of the Coral Sea)
"Due South direction! [SIC]" (How the Enterprise found salvation to last the
entire war and then was scraped without much
fanfare)
"Our Aircraft Carriers Are Mobile Scouting platforms!" (Saratoga in San Diego
undergoing re-innovations, one extra Dauntless dive bombing squadron
designated SCOUTING per carrier, no Dauntless squadrons available for
land operation FOR MONTHS!)
"Tora, Tora, Tora!" (Just skip any attack on death-trap slow battleships and
concentrate on (1) heavy cruisers, (2) destroyers, and (3) submarines,
[SIC]; shoot down all "anti-carrier" planes miles from Pearl Harbor with
their crews in uncoordinated attacks and P-40s that are out of range)
"Search Plan Calculus - The Navy Way!" (1942, the search plans are delivered
to Pearl Harbor without PBY, Devastator, or TBF replacements and
without significant Dauntless dive bomber squadrons either)
-
ReginaldBednar2
- Posts: 322
- Joined: Thu Aug 01, 2019 10:46 pm
Re: ISSUES CONCERNING V 1.05.02
In the press, Prime Minister Winston Churchill and President Franklin Rooselvelt have assured their people that the war against Germany will always receive the highest, highest, highest priority [SIC].
Re: ISSUES CONCERNING V 1.05.02
If there is an issue then it is applicable to the system as a whole and not on T1. There is no separate "T1 issue", this is how Devs decided to do it in this game and it applies to all turns.ReginaldBednar2 wrote: Mon Nov 16, 2026 7:25 pm ANSWERS TO TWO ABOUT RESPONDEES
Out of 405 a/c lost due to all causes, 342 (84.4%) were lost to air-to-air combat (probably most were bombers). This implies the bombers were not properly escorted for Ground Attack, or there is a Turn 1 unique issue
As long as German Fighters are around you get "historical losses" since the German Fighters will usually wipe the floor with Soviet pilots (besides the occasional RNG that changes this) when the numbers are at least 1:1, but once the German Fighters are too few/are missing completely from an engagement or are screwed in some other way (airfield situation, fatigue, distance between combat-airfield ...and whatnot) we enter the sphere of 'wtf'.
Now you are giving other figures than before, now "405 a/c lost due to all causes" while before it was "406 aircraft due to air combat the first turn, almost all in fighter bombers and bombers A total of 636 aircraft where lost due to all causes.".
And "probably most were bombers" you can answer precisely/yourself, by using the "L"-Key losses Screen choosing its "Air Losses tab". But reading your AAR I am not sure what "bombers" means for you.
Since you are confusing what Fighter-Bombers are/not are.
A Fighter-Bomber is a Fighter plane capable of carrying bombs, it does not mean it is doing so, nor does it imply that it is in any way less capable in dogfighting when not set to a bombing mission than a "regular fighter". So lost Fighter-Bombers are usually not bombers unless you made them be it. But even if, in game they are capable of dropping their bombs and become "fighters" again when engaged.
"Special" Fighter-Bomber variants (only few/limited amounts) which were historically mostly used as/by "tactical bomber" units (German side: early Sturzkampfgeschwader later became Schlachtgeschwader, which used lots of Fw 190s) are ingame represented by some production of a separate "Tactical Bomber" (e.g. Fw 190F), they then can not (properly) fight A2A or do fighter things.
“Amateurs study tactics; professionals study logistics.”
My Mods:
GE Gui & Sym Mod Depot (continued)
Rasputitsa for your eyes. Soviet colours redone.
My Tools:
Turn-Dates-Converter
Command Efficiency with Command Range Modifier
Planning map 1.02.45_Beta
My Mods:
GE Gui & Sym Mod Depot (continued)
Rasputitsa for your eyes. Soviet colours redone.
My Tools:
Turn-Dates-Converter
Command Efficiency with Command Range Modifier
Planning map 1.02.45_Beta
-
ReginaldBednar2
- Posts: 322
- Joined: Thu Aug 01, 2019 10:46 pm
Re: ISSUES CONCERNING V 1.05.02
COMMENT WITH FURTHER GAME PLAY NOT YET PUBLISHED
In W.I.E. the Luftwaffe generally would average a 10:1 loss ratio in a/c compared with the Russian Airforce. It seems more like 5:1 is now the norm, or worse.
In W.I.E. the Luftwaffe generally would average a 10:1 loss ratio in a/c compared with the Russian Airforce. It seems more like 5:1 is now the norm, or worse.
