1943-1945 Campaign Expanded Air HQ

Post descriptions of your brilliant victories and unfortunate defeats here.

Moderator: MOD_WarintheWest

User avatar
LiquidSky
Posts: 2845
Joined: Tue Jun 24, 2008 4:28 am

Re: 1943-1945 Campaign Expanded Air HQ

Post by LiquidSky »

The longest I have seen is late October. Almost always they surrender on the first turn in September.

It's not really possible to keep them in the game. The surrender rules are:

On the Axis logistical phase (after the allies hit end turn), if all of Sicily or Sardinia or Corsica are owned, an invasion of mainland Italy takes place, or the allies own a hex in mainland Italy....a surrender check will be made. I think the invasion check is an extra check.

The check is a random d200 against the CV (divided by 4) of all germans outside of a 10 hex radius of any allied unit. No surrender possible in July and the CV value is only halved in August.

While it is possible to get 400 CV in Italy in August, I don't think you can get 800 for September. If you have 400 CV (away from the allies) it will be a 50/50 roll every turn. They will surrender.

Note, you are not going to prevent the fall of Sicily or Sardinia...and you are certainly not going to stop them from invading somewhere. Plus eventually you will have to put germans on the front lines.


The Italian ground units are out matched by the allies, and will be pushed back. They do, however, have a very nice anti-naval airforce. I flew the above mission with about a third of the Italian naval bombers. They also have a couple hundred fighters that are mostly not crap.
“My logisticians are a humorless lot … they know if my campaign fails, they are the first ones I will slay.” – Alexander the Great
kentkroeckel
Posts: 706
Joined: Mon Jun 26, 2017 6:32 pm
Location: USA Colorado

Response

Post by kentkroeckel »

Hello to all. Wanted to respond to a couple posts. I got behind this weekend due to an outdoor yard project. I will finish up on Monday with it. Meanwhile, I have been working on turn two. Unfortunately I lost a bit of air documents I had done on turn one. Need to save often in game so I do not loose hours of work. My bad and lessen learned. I should finish turn two on Monday night.

Clarification from Mr. Liquid Sky:

EDIT: Yup, I just booted up the scenario and at start manpower for the Brits is only 5k. After the German turn (when the allies get their logistics done) the Brits have over 100k manpower in transit. Open up your production window and change from Active to Transit and you will see them.

Kent Response: Thank you Mr. Liquid Sky for that clarification. I would have never thought of doing this. More the reason Allied Command is buying adult disposable diapers for command personnel; in preparation for many a stressful meetings. Ha.

Now a disclaimer for those who feel I have lessened the authenticity of this post. adult disposable diapers were made available to the public in 1978. A Sweden developer worked with the design in 1943; but the two piece design was not too successful. Odd problem with plastic back then.Ha.
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________

Comment by Mr. Tm1 on turn one:

Some heavy Axis Naval air power there looks like this could be a bloody fight on the Sicilian beaches if the Axis have hit the transports hard.

Kent Response: Nope. The diary post says it all. No Allied invasion on turn one.

TM1 comment:
Just wondering what length of time and who has the longest recorded record for keeping Italy in the game and has there ever been anyone able in a PVP game that Italy actually stayed in game till the very end. It is feasible to keep Italy from surrendering completely but the odds are incredible to keep the allied player from getting a surrender.

Kent Response: With someone who has never played before anything is possible. With two skilled players I do not think it is possible to keep Italy from surrendering. I do hope this challenge does not set a new record. Ha.
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________


Thank you to all for the questions and comments; all are appreciated. And a thank you to Mr. Liquid Sky for his help in this endevour.
Last edited by kentkroeckel on Mon Nov 16, 2026 5:10 pm, edited 2 times in total.
kentkroeckel
Posts: 706
Joined: Mon Jun 26, 2017 6:32 pm
Location: USA Colorado

Turn Two Invasion

Post by kentkroeckel »

I wanted to continue with the last post from Mr. TM1. It involved the surrender of Italy.

Reasoning for my invasion choice was to gain the requirement for Italy's surrender. I thought capture of any of the three islands satisfied this but Mr. Liquid Sky stated Corsica does not trigger this. I am sure when he reads this, Mr. Liquid Sky will clarify the Corsica detail. But for now, Corsica is not the easiest of the three to take nor is Sicily.

I (Allies) chose Sardinia, and only Sardinia. Meaning, I did not divide the invasion up. I want a quick and strong victory. Especially, against Mr. Liquid Sky, who was right all along in his assumptions. I just hope he felt Germany needed to protect Corsica as well.

I dedicated air attacks on bases located on Sicily and near Rome. I followed the path of sea air and assumed those near the area are where the Axis air naval planes are located. I am still processing the turn so do not know what the results will be or if a guessed wrongly.
kentkroeckel
Posts: 706
Joined: Mon Jun 26, 2017 6:32 pm
Location: USA Colorado

Turn Two Clarification

Post by kentkroeckel »

I see Mr. Liquid Sky has already posted on Italian surrender. So there you go, He got it perfectly for you Mr. TM1. I did not see the thread had switched to a second page. My bad and a bit embarrassing. Yet I will keep my responses up because then you will be able to see how detailed Mr. Liquid Sky's response is and how vastly superior it is.

The only thing I was going to add was that Corsica is a French Island and not an Italian Island. Just during the war did its sovereignty gets switched for the duration of World War II. I was going to add that maybe that is why Corsica does not help trigger a surrender.
kentkroeckel
Posts: 706
Joined: Mon Jun 26, 2017 6:32 pm
Location: USA Colorado

Turn Two Allied Air Phase

Post by kentkroeckel »

July 10, 1943.

Hello to all; and now starts the carnage. I made several mistakes in setting up the Allied air so it will take until turn five to get all in place and aircraft frames switched out. I often change minor Allied two engine planes for heavy bombers. RAF two engine pilots cannot do this. Also, Allied tactical bomber pilots are not able to change to fighter trained. A regular RAF fighter pilot can switch between the two trainings.

Now for the air results. On Allied phase, Germany lost 91 aircraft while Allies lost 430. That is a Luftwaffe advantage of 339. An impressive start for Mr. Liquid Sky's Luftwaffe. Results seem to indicate minimal air naval engagement from Germany. I think Mr. Liquid Sky is waiting for task forces to maul. More of a reason to land and get task forces off the beach or city. In fact, when invading a city or town there is no advantage in staying. There is already a port so leave once you secure it.

Axis air missions were around 3,000 while Allies were near 26,000. No main issue with it but a fun fact to show! Always remember that it is the effectiveness and not quantity of air attacks. Low morale removes any change of victory.

Now I wanted to show German air losses from their phase. Germany lost around 15 aircraft while Allies near ten. Below is metric chart showing the total for both air phases.
Screenshot 2026-11-16 193604.jpg
Screenshot 2026-11-16 193604.jpg (127.97 KiB) Viewed 252 times

The air phase is costly for Allies until all is in place by turn five. Still though, Allies air is marginal until it gets boosts throughout the game, all the while the Luftwaffe morale is lowered periodically.

Next picture I would like to show is the naval protection around UK. 1943 is not kind to the Allied player with regard to naval protection but I like what I see right now. Additional air naval missions made this happen.
Screenshot 2026-11-16 194208.jpg
Screenshot 2026-11-16 194208.jpg (161.2 KiB) Viewed 248 times

Rain reduced air naval protection for western Mediterranean. This exposes any units embarking from UK.
Screenshot 2026-11-16 194537.jpg
Screenshot 2026-11-16 194537.jpg (486.32 KiB) Viewed 246 times

Main Mediterranean, Corsica, and Sardinia are well protect in the waters. This means launch ports along with landing zones should not be under much attrition.
Screenshot 2026-11-16 194924.jpg
Screenshot 2026-11-16 194924.jpg (221.7 KiB) Viewed 246 times
Last edited by kentkroeckel on Tue Nov 17, 2026 11:08 pm, edited 1 time in total.
kentkroeckel
Posts: 706
Joined: Mon Jun 26, 2017 6:32 pm
Location: USA Colorado

Turn 2 Allied Ground Phase

Post by kentkroeckel »

July 10, 1943.

first picture is of the four ports on Sardinia. Three can be invaded with am amphibious attack, and so are. Two look to be unopposed. One has two units on it so an engagement will occur. by the way, the paths have 6-9 hex attrition rate. I do not think that is bad. All ports do or soon will have airbases and all are connected by rail.
Screenshot 2026-11-16 195828.jpg
Screenshot 2026-11-16 195828.jpg (195.78 KiB) Viewed 241 times

The fourth port of Sardinia has a beach next to it so that is where the British have landed. the beach is unopposed. The beach will get a good airbase but no rail to it. When the fourth port is taken, it will be upgraded with an airbase and it does have rail. Logistics completion on Sardinia, along with air cover; that is the goal.
Screenshot 2026-11-16 200612.jpg
Screenshot 2026-11-16 200612.jpg (123.71 KiB) Viewed 241 times

Order of invasion importance. All ports needed to be invaded. Those that could not, needed to be invaded nearby. That took four task forces. Final two task forces invaded near Corsica. The reason is to help secure Sardinia quickly but also to add two more size two airbases. Here is where location matters. I want, if possible, to have airbases on rail. No trucks needed then. The two final amphibious locations have rail. Perfect to attack Corsica and central Italy.
Screenshot 2026-11-16 201705.jpg
Screenshot 2026-11-16 201705.jpg (107.98 KiB) Viewed 238 times

Final part to the invasion of Sardinia is an airborne mission. Do not want to take a chance on an axis unit moving onto the final port if they try to escape. That is why I am risking a British air assault division to secure Tortoli. It works out well since the beach is next to the final port. If successful, Axis units will be isolated. They can still leave by air transport. Infantry at least.
Screenshot 2026-11-16 202218.jpg
Screenshot 2026-11-16 202218.jpg (51.25 KiB) Viewed 233 times

The Americans are invading near Corsica, (north Sardinia) while the Commonwealth is invading south and central Sardinia.
User avatar
LiquidSky
Posts: 2845
Joined: Tue Jun 24, 2008 4:28 am

Re: 1943-1945 Campaign Expanded Air HQ

Post by LiquidSky »

I am having trouble loading the game from the server. It keeps giving me an error. Until that gets fixed I will have to tease you with this:
Screenshot 2026-11-16 221942.png
Screenshot 2026-11-16 221942.png (825.35 KiB) Viewed 202 times
Every turn I like to look at the reports. It gives a day by day accounting of air activity, which will highlight if my fighters are in range of air superiority, and which planes are shooting down which planes.

In this case it shows that most of my losses were on the Italian and not the German airforce. Further down it also shows how much damage flak inflicts. The report will also mention TOE changes and an ad nauseum amount of info on supply movement.

The report is generated when the allies finish their turn, and will be generated again after the axis air phase.
“My logisticians are a humorless lot … they know if my campaign fails, they are the first ones I will slay.” – Alexander the Great
User avatar
LiquidSky
Posts: 2845
Joined: Tue Jun 24, 2008 4:28 am

Re: 1943-1945 Campaign Expanded Air HQ

Post by LiquidSky »

Looks like I am back in business....Looks like Sardinia is a lost cause....I already evacuated the PzG division that was stationed there. This turn I bombed his troops on the NorthEastern coast, a British division and an american one, inflicting good casualties on the British. Whenever I get a chance, I will always bomb troops that are too far from fighter protection.

Other then that, not much to report...moving troops to Italy to garrison the coast for the inevitable invasion to come.
“My logisticians are a humorless lot … they know if my campaign fails, they are the first ones I will slay.” – Alexander the Great
kentkroeckel
Posts: 706
Joined: Mon Jun 26, 2017 6:32 pm
Location: USA Colorado

Turn 3 Allied Air Phase

Post by kentkroeckel »

July 17, 1943.

Victory points for turn were -6. Game total is -36. So far Mr. Liquid Sky has had Germany receive victory points each turn.

Rain is over Europe and most of the Mediterranean.

Luftwaffe only concentrated on tactical bombing of Allied units on Sardinia. And it was successful. What surprises me most though, is that Mr. Liquid Sky did not attack Allied task forces with Axis naval air. I will not tease fate so will remove them this turn. Sea superiority is still good despite rain.
Screenshot 2026-11-17 152953.jpg
Screenshot 2026-11-17 152953.jpg (189.81 KiB) Viewed 165 times

Sea control near UK is going well despite a couple of air naval units failing to get supply so are not available this turn.
Screenshot 2026-11-17 153006.jpg
Screenshot 2026-11-17 153006.jpg (164.34 KiB) Viewed 165 times

What really excites me so far is the amphibious pool. Allies only lost three amphibious transports during the invasion of Sicily. That is a good ratio for a full landing. Basically, that is negligible becasue Allies receive four every turn. However, Allies did loose fifty cargo ships this turn but there is no way to stop that; high lightened in yellow.
Screenshot 2026-11-17 154211.jpg
Screenshot 2026-11-17 154211.jpg (165.52 KiB) Viewed 165 times

Mr. Liquid Sky and myself are creating this thread as informative, while hopefully entertaining. Point being, the amount of detail on each side will be generously provided compared to a strictly competitive game. Yes, we are both doing our best but you will notice a significant amount of data and pictures will be displayed in this challenge. We think you will find this enjoyable.

Yet there will be some information held back to keep the game realistic. For example, I will not reveal to Mr. Liquid Sky when or where the Allies will be invading. Nothing personal Mr. Liquid Sky but you are with Enemy Command. Ha.

One final thought on this. Mr. Liquid Sky seems to know anyway, where the Allies will land. I do believe this is because German High Command is conducting experiments with ESP. (Mind Projection) I do feel this gets close to an inappropriate use of a weapon, like gas during World War I. HA. To combat this I have instructed Allied High Command to wear tin foil hats during secret meetings. (I did actually look up the date tin foil was made so that it would factually correct.) Your welcome Mr. Jeffro K.
User avatar
LiquidSky
Posts: 2845
Joined: Tue Jun 24, 2008 4:28 am

Re: 1943-1945 Campaign Expanded Air HQ

Post by LiquidSky »

It is true I did not interdict his naval movements.

There are a couple of missions that can be selected to fly on either the friendly phase (now) or on the enemy phase (his air turn) or both. Naval interdiction is one of them.

If I fly on my air phase only, it will interdict his supply since all his logistics are done at the end of my turn. He will see it, but be unable to react to it since I won't fly on his turn.
If I fly on his air phase....... it will interdict his naval movement. This will also potentially spoil an invasion.
If I do both...he knows where my air is flying for his air phase, and will react accordingly.

Naval interdiction is also kind of hard on the aircraft. You lose a few operationally every time they fly. As well, air superiority is like a minus to the values they drop...so not only would I lose even more bombers to air superiority, they drop less.

I general, I am very much a 'mission oriented' kind of player. I dislike moving units for the sake of moving them. I am not going to fly air unless I must, or if an opportunity pops up where I can do damage outside of his air cover.

And where 'I must' collides with 'air cover', I will lose half my bombers.
“My logisticians are a humorless lot … they know if my campaign fails, they are the first ones I will slay.” – Alexander the Great
User avatar
Seminole
Posts: 2254
Joined: Thu Jul 28, 2011 12:56 am

Re: Heel of Italy

Post by Seminole »

kentkroeckel wrote: Thu Nov 12, 2026 11:58 pm Continuation of landing sites. Mr. Seminole suggested an invasion of the Heel of the Boot of Italy. He felt the Allies could keep control of the air through the six level two airbases that would be created. I feel differently. I believe the distance is too great for successful Allied logistics if the Axis concentrate the Luftwaffe. And I do mean any available aircraft. I would drain Europe too, for a victory. The Italian air force has range limitations but it would not be a factor for this mission. Aircraft would be launching from the Boot and Sicily, completely harassing the Allied invasion site and along the supply line.

Screenshot 2026-11-12 165154.jpg


The Seminole goal is to secure the ports of Taranto, Brindisi, and Bari. Important ports to be sure but the whole Luftwaffe, with Italy too, would spell disaster. At least that is my thought on it. One by one each landing site could get strangled for logistics and then collapse. If bunched together I still think the same outcome is looming.
Screenshot 2026-11-12 165338.jpg
To clarify, I believe that should be the initial Allied mainland landing. I would still take Sicily at the outset. I just immediately reposition TFs to prep for The Heel invasion.
Several LB types are very suitable for naval patrol, and if the Luftwaffe attempts to reposition and contest it, this too is welcome. It will reduce pressure on strategic bombers in the UK, while concentrating fighters in few bases where the remaining LBs in the Med can target them. Take Sicily to base P-47 and P-38 escorts for the B-25 and British LB mine laying ops.
Additionally, I do not encourage the landing spots highlighted. I have other AARs covering what I feel are the preferred spots. Avoid adjacent to ports for their defensive bonus, and put your temp depots on rail hexes so they can feed your invasion longer term from the stockpiles. The TFs also have organic CAP.
The existing 6 level 2 airbases, with 6 more level 2 airbases from invasion hexes, would provide outstanding CAP over the landing sites, and in a few turns allow you to shatter a Luftwaffe over commit. The range and base locations don’t lend themselves to the Luftwaffe sustaining naval interdiction when the Allied player can go after their air bases too.
"War is never a technical problem only, and if in pursuing technical solutions you neglect the psychological and the political, then the best technical solutions will be worthless." - Hermann Balck
kentkroeckel
Posts: 706
Joined: Mon Jun 26, 2017 6:32 pm
Location: USA Colorado

Response to Seminole

Post by kentkroeckel »

Response from Kent:

Greetings to all, and to you Mr. Seminole. Thank you for sharing your response to the WitW community. You truly are a vast source of knowledge. Fist point, I got it wrong on you heel invasion and I do apologize. I did not realize in your presentation a traditional invasion would occur first and then the heel invasion of Mainland Italy. My bad.

Under those conditions it does increase a victory. As you stated clearly, Allied air would be in a much better position of support for the invasion with Sicily secured. My only point was the heel being the initial invasion. And on that choice I feel could lead to failure.

If possible Mr. Seminole, would you repost your invasion on this AAR. It is really a beautiful and thoughtful display of an invasion, showing the intricacies that goes into one. Thank you in advance.

Best wishes to you Mr. Seminole and to all, Kent.
Last edited by kentkroeckel on Wed Nov 18, 2026 3:10 pm, edited 1 time in total.
kentkroeckel
Posts: 706
Joined: Mon Jun 26, 2017 6:32 pm
Location: USA Colorado

Response to Liquid Sky

Post by kentkroeckel »

Kent response to Mr. Liquid Sky.

Fist of all, ouch. I do not know where the Luftwaffe launched from because there is no engagement tail. Tricky Mr. Liquid Sky. I am relieved to find out it is spectacular use of friendly and enemy air phase usage rather than Axis stealth technology. That would really be disturbing for the Allies.

Allied comment on this advanced method of secrecy:

Allies are often required to fly in both phases, as Mr. Liquid Sky has pointed out on how I am using much of the Allied Air Force. With invasions both sides of the turn need to be protected. That means units coming and going along with logistics arriving to the invasion sites. Germany often does not need to do this so the Luftwaffe can be like a magician. Allies, not so much.

One thing the Allies can do is rest categories of aircraft that are not needed. For example, I rest air transports during the air phase. At the end of the turn I rest tactical bombers, level bombers that are not naval, and all escort fighters that are assigned to strategic and tactical bombing. All reconnaissance aircraft are also placed on rest.

Thank you for revealing this tactic Mr. Liquid Sky.
kentkroeckel
Posts: 706
Joined: Mon Jun 26, 2017 6:32 pm
Location: USA Colorado

Turn 3 Allied phase

Post by kentkroeckel »

July 17, 1944.

I already showed for this turn that Germany gained -6 victory points but I did not go into detail on that. I do need to.

On the second turn Mr. Liquid Sky received one point for plentiful garrisons. A smart move for the Axis player since they are easy points to gain. In addition, if a problem arises in a garrison region, you have extra combat points nearby to fix an issue. For the third turn two points were gained.

Mr. Liquid Sky has moved Axis units from the British Channel Islands to France. I do the same thing, along with many a player. Garrison requirements do not extend to the British Islands so why not use this division where it can be utilized. For if the Allied player wants these parcels of land they will get them. All of this is highlighted in blue. Allies also conducted reconnaissance over them on turn two. No units detected.

Allies have concentrated bombing on submarine production faculties and pens. All fifteen locations are being attacked. The second turn generated a point for Germany as did the third. I think in the future this might even go to zero. It is highlighted in yellow.
Screenshot 2026-11-18 110923.jpg
Screenshot 2026-11-18 110923.jpg (101.71 KiB) Viewed 23 times
Post Reply

Return to “After Action Reports”