Fall Grau 2.29 Jeremy (Axis) vs. Chris (Allies)

After Action Reports
User avatar
rhinobones
Posts: 2241
Joined: Sun Feb 17, 2002 10:00 am

Re: Fall Grau 2.29 Jeremy (Axis) vs. Chris (Allies)

Post by rhinobones »

Jeremy Mac Donald wrote: Sat Jun 27, 2026 1:42 am Fall Grau 2.29 Jeremy (Axis) vs. Chris (Allies)

I suspect that you are familiar with this scenario, but if not you may want to take a look and see how it compares to Fall Grau. The original scenario was written in the 1999-2000 time frame by Piero Falotti.


1945 - (What if) - Axis invasion of America.zip
(656.61 KiB) Downloaded 20 times

Regards

Space View.JPG
Space View.JPG (331.26 KiB) Viewed 373 times
Close Up.JPG
Close Up.JPG (266.14 KiB) Viewed 373 times
Colin Wright:
Pre Combat Air Strikes # 64 . . . I need have no concern about keeping it civil

Post by broccolini » Sun Nov 06, 2022
. . . no-one needs apologize for douchebags acting like douchebags
User avatar
golden delicious
Posts: 4194
Joined: Tue Sep 05, 2000 8:00 am
Location: London, Surrey, United Kingdom

Re: Fall Grau 2.29 Jeremy (Axis) vs. Chris (Allies)

Post by golden delicious »

rhinobones wrote: Mon Nov 09, 2026 7:39 pm I suspect that you are familiar with this scenario, but if not you may want to take a look and see how it compares to Fall Grau. The original scenario was written in the 1999-2000 time frame by Piero Falotti.
I actually wasn't aware of this one but I opened it up in the editor. I note that the first thing Piero says in the briefing is that it was one of his first scenarios and that it therefore has some problems.

There are certainly some similarities, Jeremy can attest to whether he was inspired by this in his original design for the scenario. However the Allies look to be much stronger than in Fall Grau in their initial deployments, which include a lot of naval units (the Allies have none in Fall Grau), which may make initial Axis gains difficult even with an Axis Mexico. I'm curious if you've played the scenario, and if so what was the result.

I wouldn't want anyone doing a detailed critique of any of the scenarios I was producing around 1999-2000. As Piero says, this was an early effort.
"What did you read at university?"
"War Studies"
"War? Huh. What is it good for?"
"Absolutely nothing."
User avatar
rhinobones
Posts: 2241
Joined: Sun Feb 17, 2002 10:00 am

Re: Fall Grau 2.29 Jeremy (Axis) vs. Chris (Allies)

Post by rhinobones »

golden delicious wrote: Tue Nov 10, 2026 7:13 pm I'm curious if you've played the scenario, and if so what was the result.

No, never played. Scenario length and unit scale are not my preferred choices.

Regards
Colin Wright:
Pre Combat Air Strikes # 64 . . . I need have no concern about keeping it civil

Post by broccolini » Sun Nov 06, 2022
. . . no-one needs apologize for douchebags acting like douchebags
Jeremy Mac Donald
Posts: 368
Joined: Tue Nov 07, 2000 10:00 am
Location: Toronto, Ontario, Canada

Re: Fall Grau 2.29 Jeremy (Axis) vs. Chris (Allies)

Post by Jeremy Mac Donald »

rhinobones wrote: Mon Nov 09, 2026 7:39 pm
Jeremy Mac Donald wrote: Sat Jun 27, 2026 1:42 am Fall Grau 2.29 Jeremy (Axis) vs. Chris (Allies)

I suspect that you are familiar with this scenario, but if not you may want to take a look and see how it compares to Fall Grau. The original scenario was written in the 1999-2000 time frame by Piero Falotti.
I saw the scenario on a scenario list years ago so I was aware of its existence, though I have never tried opening it. This scenario was made after the earliest versions of Fall Grau I am fairly certain.

There was someone that did put out a scenario very close to Fall Grau at basically the exact time Fall Grau was initially released though this individual was doing a 1942 invasion versus my 1943 invasion.

This was my original inspiration...
SS Amerika.jpg
SS Amerika.jpg (4.23 MiB) Viewed 331 times
Necesse est multos timeat quem multi timent

"He whom many fear, fears many"
Jeremy Mac Donald
Posts: 368
Joined: Tue Nov 07, 2000 10:00 am
Location: Toronto, Ontario, Canada

Re: Fall Grau 2.29 Jeremy (Axis) vs. Chris (Allies)

Post by Jeremy Mac Donald »

Turn 27
OK that is actually annoying. I get a 2 rounder and this time I really was kicking off attacks in all directions. I see a lot of Allied units now being railed out to the far west flank. Further Chris really cuts back on the usual counter attack in the East. I think he is partially shutting that down to prepare for the fighting more in the West. That said I am surprised a bit that Omaha gets only very limited support. If I had not been suffering a 2 rounder I would have taken it this turn.

I am definitely concerned about stiffening defences in the West as I really want to get to San Diego.

At the moment the strategy is to start to present enough threats to spread out the Allied defences. The problem with this theory is Chris seems willing to let Omaha fall. If he is willing to give up Denver as well then I am some fair few turns away from presenting another real threat – assuming he reacts to a push on St. Louis.

On the upside I cut the Allied rail lines south of the Billings route this turn. I think it takes about two turns to transit from east to west or vice versa. That limits Allied flexibility.
A heavy back and forth continues in the east.
A heavy back and forth continues in the east.
Jeraxisturn27.jpg (1.85 MiB) Viewed 330 times
Necesse est multos timeat quem multi timent

"He whom many fear, fears many"
User avatar
golden delicious
Posts: 4194
Joined: Tue Sep 05, 2000 8:00 am
Location: London, Surrey, United Kingdom

Re: Fall Grau 2.29 Jeremy (Axis) vs. Chris (Allies)

Post by golden delicious »

Jeremy Mac Donald wrote: Wed Nov 11, 2026 1:55 am There was someone that did put out a scenario very close to Fall Grau at basically the exact time Fall Grau was initially released though this individual was doing a 1942 invasion versus my 1943 invasion.
Now this one I remember. It was 50km/hex like the original Fall Grau but as I recall the units were mostly brigades- the forces on the map were almost ludicrously small for the scale. I don't think it played very well.
"What did you read at university?"
"War Studies"
"War? Huh. What is it good for?"
"Absolutely nothing."
Jeremy Mac Donald
Posts: 368
Joined: Tue Nov 07, 2000 10:00 am
Location: Toronto, Ontario, Canada

Re: Fall Grau 2.29 Jeremy (Axis) vs. Chris (Allies)

Post by Jeremy Mac Donald »

Turn 28
My moral is beginning to plummet as I open this turn. Two turns of early turn ending is concerning me and my unorthodox plan is feeling really shaky right about now. However, my moral will be much improved by turns end. In the East Chris is pulling back on the flank near Memphis meaning that city, which I had previously considered exceptionally difficult to take is now on the menu and might fall not to long from now. The farther flank in the East has pretty much just as much fighting as there has ever been.

Strategically Chris is pulling out a huge amount of armour from the front and sending it to the Far West. I am not exactly pleased by this turn of events but this turn my attacks in the Far West are reasonably successful. I have been sending a lot that way myself after all and the supply line is now very near the front line.

The Allies also just got the event that ends their early high supply levels. For the next little while the Allies supply levels are just the same as the Axis. In fact if this sub offencive comes to an end I could have higher supply levels, at least for a little while.

Otherwise, there is basically no resistance at Omaha and it falls this turn with me putting in a bit of a barrier to avoid Chris taking it back. I expect to resupply here and then head for Denver in a big way. In fact some forces are already converging on Denver as I don’t think its really defended.

Finally, the Allied line near Albuquerque is rapidly pushed back by the Italians and Finns and Albuquerque itself is surrounded on 4 sides as Finish Panzers exploit through the failing Allied resistance. Basically, I started the turn being really concerned that I was being stopped from advancing in far to many places and ended it with Omaha fallen and Denver and Albuquerque looking like the should fall shortly and Memphis becoming a reasonable target soon. I think I know how I can keep on keeping on at least in the medium term and I am hopeful I can break through to San Deigo in time for the Japanese to arrive. It’s messy but maybe I am not that far off what I outlined in my original plan?

Axis = 85 Allies = 167 Spread = 82
The fighting heats up in the West
The fighting heats up in the West
Jeraxisturn28.jpg (1.77 MiB) Viewed 143 times
Necesse est multos timeat quem multi timent

"He whom many fear, fears many"
Jeremy Mac Donald
Posts: 368
Joined: Tue Nov 07, 2000 10:00 am
Location: Toronto, Ontario, Canada

Re: Fall Grau 2.29 Jeremy (Axis) vs. Chris (Allies)

Post by Jeremy Mac Donald »

Turn 29
I don’t get it?

So, I thought significant forces where being transferred from the East to the West but after a turn of very heavy counter attacks, especially in the east, I basically reassemble all my Panzergrenadier Divisions in the far west and realize that, for the most part I am facing junk. American Regiments, Mexican Brigades, stuff that has no chance against the cream of the Panzertruppen. There are a handful of Divisions and Armoured Divisions in the area but not too much and they are vulnerable as is always the case when a few powerful units are depending on very weak ones to hold their flanks.

In the East I slowly fight back through terrain that is constantly being fought over. A lot of my units are resupplying so my advance is minor. On the downside Memphis is receding into the distance as a city on the chopping block.
Omaha I keep and get my rail repair unit. Most of my units are resupplying here but some of the Panzers are already basically full and I start them speeding toward Denver. I saw a handful of Allied reinforcements head for Denver, but nothing really struck me as very dangerous. If the idea is a fight for Denver, I don’t think the Allies have sent enough, and I have the city cut off this turn with a lot of powerful units on the way.

Albuquerque is a bit of a mess with strong Allied counter attacks, but I am still reinforcing the area (though so is Chris) and I have broken through into the centre and am threatening to outflank at least the southern Allied forces.

The best for me though is the Far West where I both cut Mexico and all points south out of supply (except the Yucatan Peninsula). There are at least a handful of units down that way but more significantly I batter all these weak forces into about three stacks and have those stacks well cut off. I don’t see the rest of the Allied army out this way? Maybe it is somewhere beyond the fighting taking place here but right now this is looking very good for me. It will look a lot less good if there is a powerful Allied counterattack. If it is just these stacks desperately trying to escape, I should be able to gobble them up next turn and then really leap forward.

In other good news the Allied subs have been repressed, and Axis supply levels have risen back up. Supplies – at least where the rail lines can reach Axis forces should be excellent.

Omaha = 77%
Denver & Omaha
Denver & Omaha
Jeraxisturn29.jpg (1.85 MiB) Viewed 16 times
Necesse est multos timeat quem multi timent

"He whom many fear, fears many"
Post Reply

Return to “After Action Reports”