1943-1945 Campaign Expanded Air HQ

Post descriptions of your brilliant victories and unfortunate defeats here.

Moderator: MOD_WarintheWest

kentkroeckel
Posts: 715
Joined: Mon Jun 26, 2017 6:32 pm
Location: USA Colorado

Turn 4 Allied Ground Phase

Post by kentkroeckel »

July 24, 1943.

Following hex was attacked by Allies but Italian infantry division held.
Screenshot 2026-11-19 225102.jpg
Screenshot 2026-11-19 225102.jpg (195.93 KiB) Viewed 103 times

Second attack forced a surrender.
Screenshot 2026-11-19 225328.jpg
Screenshot 2026-11-19 225328.jpg (180.77 KiB) Viewed 103 times

This next attack is really interesting. An Italian parachute division, despite being isolated, had impressive modifies to the combat total. 106 to the Allies' 27. That is just incredible. I highlighted it in blue.
Screenshot 2026-11-19 225515.jpg
Screenshot 2026-11-19 225515.jpg (163.24 KiB) Viewed 103 times

Second attack broke them, so they surrendered but they put up an impressive fight. The previous week they fought really well too.
Screenshot 2026-11-19 225958.jpg
Screenshot 2026-11-19 225958.jpg (182.76 KiB) Viewed 103 times
kentkroeckel
Posts: 715
Joined: Mon Jun 26, 2017 6:32 pm
Location: USA Colorado

Thoughts about what is next

Post by kentkroeckel »

Greetings to all. I wanted to explain what is facing the Allies in this unique challenge.

In the air, I expected an aggressive response from Mr. Liquid Sky. Luftwaffe air naval would be ruthless on the Sardinia invasion. However, not the case. But Allies are still loosing a tremendous amount of aircraft, which I think is normal with the (Expanded Allied air headquarters.) Yet look at how the losses for Germany have been noticeably small. Mr. Liquid Sky is inflicting effective carnage while protecting the Luftwaffe.

I am trying to counter this with suspended tactical ground attacks because they seem ineffective for the cost. Main effort is air naval protection along logistic paths and unit sea movement. this seems to be working.


Allied strategic plan: With Mr. Liquid Sky's exceptional skill set, it seems impractical to invade Mainland Italy yet. In August I believe Germany will have sufficient combat points to prevent Italian surrender. So Allies need to look at what opportunities are left. The obvious one is the British Channel Islands. Since Allies are committing so much to sea protection, it only makes sense to secure these as soon as possible. But to be clear, removing the Axis division for garrison duty on Europe is the right call by Mr. Liquid Sky. Okay, that takes care of two task forces. Four still left for a mission.

Dealing with four instead of six task forces does change the equation a bit. Unlikely for a Mainland invasion but there are still two targets left. Those being Corsica and Sicily. Corsica being the safer one because of it's isolation from German logistics. Additionally, securing of Sardinia makes air over Corsica easier to control. Yet if Mr. Liquid Sky decides to challenge this he could do so. Corsica is close to northern Italy and France. No ports can be invaded either so task forces would be on the beaches longer. Possibly up to four weeks. That creates a huge target for Germany.

Sicily is a bit harder for the Allies to secure the air space and naval hexes surrounding. It is bigger too, allowing for an Axis staunch defense. Most importantly though, it is connected to the Mainland vie ferry. No automatic isolation possible. Yet to counter this, Sicily is the more valuable prize. I do believe four task forces can also still succeed in an amphibious invasion. Importantly also, ports can be invaded directly.
User avatar
LiquidSky
Posts: 2846
Joined: Tue Jun 24, 2008 4:28 am

Re: 1943-1945 Campaign Expanded Air HQ

Post by LiquidSky »

Thought I might make a comment or two about the air battle against the allies.

In one word: Futile.

They get around 800-900 trained pilots a turn. I get 35 German.
They start with thousands of planes in their Active Pool. Get, well I don't remember, but it's a lot of planes built every turn.

Even with the atrocious rate Kent is burning up his airforce, he is still winning the air war.

However.....my goal is not to 'defeat' the allied airforce. It is not to win a war of attrition. I don't actually care about shooting down bombers and I definitely do not want to shoot down a fighter. Every fighter of his I shoot down is a bomber that got through.

This is the damage my air did to him on his air phase:
Screenshot 2026-11-21 040626.png
Screenshot 2026-11-21 040626.png (738.64 KiB) Viewed 28 times
The first column is the number of planes that fighter shot down and by type. The next number is the amount of planes that got damaged. It is the second number that is most important. For example it says my Bf109G-6 shot down 31 Lancaster I's and damaged 177. And a damaged bomber doesn't drop it's bombs. And is probably resting and not bombing the turn after.

Now how do I achieve this? First off, you must pull the fighters back beyond the range of enemy fighters. Let him bomb the Ruhr. That is where I concentrate my priority repair....it's where my construction units go.

Next, you change the load out on your fighters. The BF's come equipped with drop tanks. You don't want them. They fight worse with them, and engage enemy fighters over the Ruhr. Instead, I give them cannons. Since they won't be fighting fighters, it really amps up the damage against the bombers and lessens their range to focus on those internal factories. The FW's I put on NONE for loadout until they get better weaponry.

Finally, and this is most important...you make your fighter squadrons TPI or PRI for pilots. You always give them the trained pilots (only).....and I always sort the fighters by EXP so that the lowest experienced squadrons get the pilots first.

Usually the allies will decide at some point to change the British from night bombing to day bombing. This is a mistake. There is no discernable difference between the damage inflicted during the night bombing vrs day bombing because of a number of different factors, the greatest of which is FLAK is better during the day, and they can face day fighters which are far more lethal then night ones.

Also, the NF BF110's are still fighters....they work better during the day with their cannons at shooting down bombers. I park them in the middle of Germany or even as far as Austria/Poland to catch the riskier long range bombing attempts. And you have a couple hundred of them. I leave the Bomber NF's as night bombers since they really suck at day fighting.

Eventually, because of attrition, your fighter force will lose pilots....then winter comes. It will rebound a bit over the winter, but the allies will also get longer range drop tanks and can the middle factories between Berlin and the Ruhr. Then April. Mustangs with long range. When June hits, and the squadron sizes increase, I usually disband a lot of the NF squadrons so the trained pilots can go into day fighters...but this is the beginning of the end of the Luftwaffe. It no longer matters where you park it, your squadrons are going to be fighting fighters mostly.

It's bye bye Luftwaffe.
“My logisticians are a humorless lot … they know if my campaign fails, they are the first ones I will slay.” – Alexander the Great
kentkroeckel
Posts: 715
Joined: Mon Jun 26, 2017 6:32 pm
Location: USA Colorado

Complement for the Luftwaffe

Post by kentkroeckel »

Kent response to Mr. Liquid Sky.

Once again, your detail of what the capabilities are for the Luftwaffe are stellar Mr. Liquid Sky. I am learning how you make the Luftwaffe so good. As the Allied player I am glad that I made the decision early not to go after tactical bombing on Luftwaffe bases. They are empty near the front due to your strategy. It all makes sense now, as Allied Command connects the dots. Ha.

One fact I was trying to challenge a little was increasing British day bombing results over the Ruhr. However, day bombing results for the Ruhr for this last week did not improve. Just wanted to try one last time to make sure. Wish your analysis had come out earlier. Mr. Liquid Sky. Ha.

I am still wondering when You will use the Italian level bombers Mr. Liquid Sky. Or for that matter, the German naval level bombers too. I understand why you would want to save the German ones for a later time but the Italians go away upon surrender. The only thing that makes sense to me is that all is being held until an Allied invasion of the Italian mainland. Risky strategy though because if Italy surrenders immediately, all of the Italian resources are lost.

there is one last point I want to make about the Allied Air Force and it is important. Victory points are awarded by how the air campaign is going. For turn three and four no points were awarded to Germany for submarines. Meaning, the Allied bombing campaign is going well for this and this represents a valuable success. But in doing so the Allies have to expose many bombers in attacking all fifteen submarine sites.

Next point, is the bombing points the Allies can achieve through bombing. I do not know if submarine and vengeance weapon damage is counted, but for sure all else strategically is. the ratio is greatest in 1943, with each following year decreasing in the ratio reward. This makes victory points through Allied bombing easiest now but minimizes them in 1945.

One more piece to the WitW air war puzzle is morale, and how it changes for all sides during the war. I am sure to many that It comes as no surprise that Allies start the game at their lowest level and progress up from there. The start of each year helps along with June 1944 and June of 1945; if playing with extended game. Axis forces are the opposite. This means the advantage the Luftwaffe has in 1943 diminishes as the game proceeds.
Post Reply

Return to “After Action Reports”