A Poll: Targetting artillery

lnp4668 · Post by **lnp4668** » Sat Feb 23, 2002 12:40 am

Just wants to conduct an unofficial poll here:

Is it "gamey" to use onboard artillery unit to target its bombardment?

Pro: With C&C on, one often ran out of order from FOs to conduct bombardment.

Con: Artillery calling its own shot without LOS to target could be unrealistic.

So what do you think? More pros and cons are welcome.

Drex · Post by **Drex** » Sat Feb 23, 2002 1:19 am

yes I think it is unrealistic to think that onboard arty could provide its own co-ordinates. but even if the FO is out of orders, any "O" u can call arty, the only difference is the TOA.

ZinZan · Post by **ZinZan** » Sat Feb 23, 2002 1:33 am

Yes I agree that it is "gamey" to use an onboard arty to plot arty. You missed a MAJOR pro (I believe) in that the Art rating affects accuracy so arty is more accurate.

My own rule of thumb (in games vs comp) is to only use a O unit who has LOS, or whose subordinates have LOS to target hex.

I don't worry about this when playing PBEM (though rarely use onboard arty to spot unless it has LOS) as it is impossible to police.

lnp4668 · Post by **lnp4668** » Sat Feb 23, 2002 2:11 am

Originally posted by Drex:
yes I think it is unrealistic to think that onboard arty could provide its own co-ordinates. but even if the FO is out of orders, any "O" u can call arty, the only difference is the TOA.

So do the 0 unit of the artillery section/platoon counts?

Charles2222 · Post by **Charles2222** » Sat Feb 23, 2002 2:37 am

I'm somewhat divided here. I have no reason to believe it is gamey, but then I suspect something is waiting in the wings. Especially consodering limited C&C orders, onboard can always fire into a general area without a spotter at anytime desired, so what's to be gamey about that? I'm pretty experienced with bombarding without spotters, in fact that's 95% of my bombarding and it's reliable enough (though almost everything goes through the FO). Perhaps the real problem, if there is one, is that the non-spotted scatter may need to be higher. Seem other games I've played had a considerably worse scatter, but then maybe those games were wrong. In my case I want a one or two hex scatter or better, as I'm usually trying to hit something besides just one spot that can be seen. I'd consider it wasteful to hit a single hex with more than 10 rounds.

ubertechie · Post by **ubertechie** » Sat Feb 23, 2002 2:48 am

I Would tend to agree with charles - i think that the 0 unit should be abel to call in arty but it should be less accurate would make FO units better value

Cheers

Ubertechie

DROregon · Post by **DROregon** » Sat Feb 23, 2002 2:53 am

I always use FO first, then next best available 0 unit. (I never thought to use onboard arty!)

troopie · Post by **troopie** » Sat Feb 23, 2002 4:09 am

I've never thought to use onboard artillery to target off board artillery. I've always used FOs and the HQ.

troopie

bchapman · Post by **bchapman** » Sat Feb 23, 2002 6:44 am

Is it "gamey" to use onboard artillery unit to target its bombardment?

I think it is but so what? If you are playing for fun against the AI I don't see any thing wrong with it. If playing PBEM, I think you should have an agreement before the game starts about artillery (Spotting, Points, etc.) and this way neither player feels like they have been "gamed". It's like using the save game in the M/C's where you drive all your units as far as they will go, save the game and then have a full movement count again in the same turn. If that is how you like to play then there is no problem. After all this is a GAME. We can change OOB's, Preferences, Settings or whatever to try and make it as historic and accurate as possible, but it's still a game. Since it's here for our enjoyment, use it the way you get the most enjoyment out of it.

Rebelbug

<img src="biggrin.gif" border="0"> <img src="biggrin.gif" border="0">

Alby · Post by **Alby** » Sat Feb 23, 2002 8:00 am

Oh great, the old sp3 self spotting arty 00 delay junk has returned?? GRRRRRRRR <img src="mad.gif" border="0"> <img src="mad.gif" border="0"> <img src="mad.gif" border="0">

Drex · Post by **Drex** » Sat Feb 23, 2002 8:59 am

i guess if an enemy unit has been spotted, then it is reasonable to assume that the information (without co-ordinates)has been radio'd to the arty commander and he can decide to bombard that area. I don't know what the accuracy is but it should be low. the TOA would be fairly quick. I don't think it is a big issue.

tracer · Post by **tracer** » Sat Feb 23, 2002 11:11 am

Originally posted by Alby:
Oh great, the old sp3 self spotting arty 00 delay junk has returned?? GRRRRRRRR <img src="mad.gif" border="0"> <img src="mad.gif" border="0"> <img src="mad.gif" border="0">

Oh man, don't even say that. Couple that with the PBEM opponent who would spend half his points on arty....them's were the bad old days.

lnp4668 · Post by **lnp4668** » Sat Feb 23, 2002 12:16 pm

Originally posted by Alby:
Oh great, the old sp3 self spotting arty 00 delay junk has returned?? GRRRRRRRR <img src="mad.gif" border="0"> <img src="mad.gif" border="0"> <img src="mad.gif" border="0">

Actually this may be more related to Svennemir's post:
http://www.matrixgames.com/cgi-bin/ultimatebb.cgi?ubb=get_topic&f=2&t=008576