Idea for figuring out Dogfight capability

Pacific War is a free update of the old classic, available in our Downloads section.
mdiehl
Posts: 3969
Joined: Sat Oct 21, 2000 8:00 am

Post by mdiehl »

The "Turkey Shoot" *should* begin in 1943. Zekes with 90 EXP *should be* dogmeat against P38s with 70 exp. For that matter, they should be dogmeat against P40Es with 70 EXP. The PW model overrates exp, underrates the F4Fs, and has incorrectly modeled the EXP of green US/UK/Aus units.

As for the equation thing. You probably will not satisfy me with the current model because of the flawed assumptions vis a vis experience, maneuverability, and all that. If one persists with the assumption that the IJN/IJA had any kind of plane+pilot advantage over the allies (with a few exceptions -- the F2, the P400) then you have started with the wrong assumptions.

The only way to give the a/c and pilots of all combatants their "due" would be to use an equation that is more complex than the current database allows. Wing-loading, roll rate, power to weight, turning radius at different elevations, maximum speed at different elevations, dive rate, and the very critical "lead time" conferred upon a defending base by radar or observers. The Zeke would easily master the F4F at speeds less than 250 mph. The F4F would hold its own at speeds in excess of 300 mph. The F4F would be more maneuverable at speeds in excess of 350 mph (as in a dive). &c.
Show me a fellow who rejects statistical analysis a priori and I'll show you a fellow who has no knowledge of statistics.

Didn't we have this conversation already?
mdiehl
Posts: 3969
Joined: Sat Oct 21, 2000 8:00 am

Post by mdiehl »

I agree with the doubt about what EXP represents. Also, "whatever" it represents, it seems not to account for the crummy CAC of Japanese combat a/c (Saburo Sakai had his radio removed because it was not worth its dead weight) and their presistent use of an outdated combat formation (3 plane section) long after they should have abandoned it.
Show me a fellow who rejects statistical analysis a priori and I'll show you a fellow who has no knowledge of statistics.

Didn't we have this conversation already?
mdiehl
Posts: 3969
Joined: Sat Oct 21, 2000 8:00 am

Post by mdiehl »

The other problem with EXP is that there is no sense in PW of how much EXP is "adequate." To illustrate: There is an example in Bergerud's "Fire in the Sky" where a US 38 driver discusses and encounter with a very talented George pilot in New Guniea. (I do not recall the page numbers). The 38 driver and his wingmates, "average guys" by USAAF standards (though the 38 driver became an ace) bushwacked the highly maneuverable George, and made several high speed attack runs. In time the 38 driver and his buddies abandoned the chase because the George pilot frustrated their attacks by maneuvering (temporarily, but repeatedly) out of lead. Since they were all in the middle of nowhere and no other objectives were to be accomplished, the 38s broke off and left the George.

Observations:
1. The veyr experienced George pilot was expert enough to fly his a/c to its strength (MVR) and disciplined enough to stick to it.
2. The rather average US pilots were well trained enough to fly their a/c to its strength (speed) and to stick to it. They did not succumb to any temptation to engage the George on its own terms.
3. The only people with the ability to break off the action were the US pilots. The George, however desperate, could not disengage because only the high energy a/c gets that option.
4. The only military objective available to the George pilot was to live through the experience. Given enough time (fuel, ammo) the 38s would eventually have destroyed the George.

Which is yet another reason why speed should count for more than MVR. The speed a/c can break off in a disadvantaged situation. The MVR a/c, if it can't outrun its attackers, can only hope its attackers will get bored and go away.
Show me a fellow who rejects statistical analysis a priori and I'll show you a fellow who has no knowledge of statistics.

Didn't we have this conversation already?
mdiehl
Posts: 3969
Joined: Sat Oct 21, 2000 8:00 am

Post by mdiehl »

Durability is another one of those things that could be bean-counted, but I'm not sure how. After assigning relative numbers one still has to determine whether the range of variation among the numbers is approriate. (That might be the problem with EXP... probably all a/c should have a set max experience of 75). I like the F6F F4U ratings as they are. But I'll offer a few rules of thumb.

1. An air cooled radial is more durable than a water cooled in-line engine.
2. More engines are durable than one engine.
3. More cylinders on a radial are more durable than fewer cylinders on a radial.
4. The heavier the loaded weight of an a/c, the tougher (and more durable) the airframe has to be.
5. When damaged, all other things being equal (location and criticality of damage), the a/c with the better power output is more likely to make it home.
6. Armor, bullet resistent glass, and self sealing fuel tanks make a huge difference.
Show me a fellow who rejects statistical analysis a priori and I'll show you a fellow who has no knowledge of statistics.

Didn't we have this conversation already?
mdiehl
Posts: 3969
Joined: Sat Oct 21, 2000 8:00 am

Post by mdiehl »

The US could have won the war with the P40 and F4F if the Japanese were the only enemy. On 12/7/41 both the US and Japanese a/c were outdated but, ironically, relatively evenly matched in their out-datedness. (Actually, the P40 was a much better plane than the A6M even though the P40 was outdated).

In the ETO/Med, the P40 was at best a medicore opponent to the better varants of the ME109, and inferior to the FW 190. In the tech-escalation for faster a/c, the US/UK eventually won the piston-engined race against the axis powers and soviets, and pulled off a close second-place finish (to the ME262) in the jet-turbine race.
Show me a fellow who rejects statistical analysis a priori and I'll show you a fellow who has no knowledge of statistics.

Didn't we have this conversation already?
mdiehl
Posts: 3969
Joined: Sat Oct 21, 2000 8:00 am

Post by mdiehl »

MT, I have some sources on a/c stats.

If you have particular late war Japanese and US a/c in mind I can probably provide (with reference) stats on a/c airspeeds, variants, armaments, weights, production runs, and comments on service reliability &c. Post here to let me know which, if any, you want.
Show me a fellow who rejects statistical analysis a priori and I'll show you a fellow who has no knowledge of statistics.

Didn't we have this conversation already?
Post Reply

Return to “Pacific War: The Matrix Edition”