AndyMac vs String - The beginning of the end

Post descriptions of your brilliant successes and unfortunate demises.

Moderators: wdolson, Don Bowen, mogami

User avatar
String
Posts: 2661
Joined: Tue Oct 07, 2003 7:56 pm
Location: Estonia

AndyMac vs String - The beginning of the end

Post by String »

AndyMac - The pathetic wimpy spineless allied forces
String - The glorious and mighty Imperial Japan

Scenario #13

[:'(]

Some of you, those who frequent the Paradox Interactive OT forums, may be familiar with my WITP AAR there. That's the "for japanese eyes only" version, but today I got the thought of doing an open AAR on these forums as well. I decided to do the AAR on PI forums from the egoistical urge to get more readers, what would have been yet another AAR here was a unique one over there ;) Well whatever, it's here now too. The tide is beginning to turn and I thought I'd give AndyMac the opportunity he deserves to show the rest of the crowd here how persistant and dedicated he really is.

Okay, this is a game that was started a long time ago, november or october 2004 i think. The original allied opponent was a guy called Sanch and this was the first PBEM for both of us. It quickly became apparent though that he was somewhat less familiar with game mechanics than I was.

The game started at 01/05/1942 (I'll use the european day/month/year system) and has now reached 16/03/1943. I'll give you a "short" report on how things have gone so far.

First the pacific :

As you may, or may not, know , the scenario #13 starts right before the battle of the coral sea. The starting OOB and orders are such that the battle should occur and so it did, with a few modifications. History was changed as I gathered Zeroes and Betties from the vicinty to Rabaul and reinforced the fighter squadrons on Shokaku and Zuikaku before sending them into the fray. My opponent left his carriers on the other side of new guinea, and at first ravaged the Buna invasion convoy. But his carriers were unable to move towards mine due to the landmass inbetween. Result was a devastating japanese carrier strike from range 4 which sank Yorktown and damaged Lexington so bad that she was easy pray for the Betties from Rabaul. American retaliation strike only damaged Shoho lightly (~25 sys)

So with the Coral sea battle won with little damage on the japanese side, Port moresby was invaded. The rest of the japanese carriers were also in the area by that time and in a very bloody week sank several allied heavy cruisers trying to intercept my carriers. [:-]

Port moresby was intitally underinvested, so it didn't fall before I sent in another brigade, but by the end of may it had fallen.

Meanwhile i had made two diversionary attacks, a failed paradrop on Derby, northern OZ and a small landing on Attu, which also failed to take the island. Surface raiding was also tried which ended with a CL sunk when she ran into a convoy screen of a CA and several DD's.

The rest of the american carriers showed them briefly before the fall of PM to bombard Apanama. They vanished after that again.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

By then I was content with the fact that I had eliminated 2 enemy carriers for no loss of my own so I had only one last operation planned, the capture of Baker and Canton islands to interdict supply lines to OZ.

This took some time to plan and gather forces so the KB was sitting idle at Kwajalein. Somewhere around 7th of june an enemy cruiser TF was detected in the triangle between Wallis, Baker and Canton islands, I suspected enemy carriers so I sent the KB on a highspeed raid.. What they found was just a small convoy escorted by just a few DD's. All ships were sunk ofcourse. Somewhat of a dissapointment but over the course of the next few days the carriers found several other small convoys and sank them. Also the raid revealed that Canton was defended by only a single base force while Baker had a larger garrison.. so I decided to go after Canton alone and leave Baker where it was.

It was then, when the KB was already quite low on fuel, when american carriers were found.. I think I almost jumped up from my chair when i saw the message "H8K Emily spots CV Enterprise".. there were however doubts if I could catch them. The KB was very low on fuel afterall. I decided to gamble however and sent the KB south highspeed. I also had the baby KB in the area covering the invasion force.

Image

After two days of cat and mouse I caught Enterprise and Saratoga right inbetween baby KB and the big KB. Both american carriers were promtly sunk for the cost of about 40 planes. [8D] Btw, it later became apparent that the american carriers were also very very low on fuel.

This was when my previous opponent quit and AndyMac took over.

Canton was captured quickly afterwards and for about 3-4 months the pacific was quiet except two carrier raids on american supply lines to OZ, which yielded some nice results.

On the 2nd of september a massive Invasion hit New Hebrides and New Caledonia. Over 400 japanese ships snuk up to the Catalina Squadrons at Luganville undetected and within a week both Luganville and Efate were in japanese hands and were operating aircraft vs Noumea.

In the middle of September I landed on the northern tip of New Caledonia and marched down to Noumea and laid siege to it on the 4th of October. The start was slow as I had brought no HQ units but that problem was solved within two weeks. BB's were also making regular bombardment runs on the base. 3 and 4 alternating between days

Image

Ten days later the KB raided Suva which had become a major allied base, sinking a CA 3 CL's and 2 CLAA's.. a nice catch :) The siege of Noumea lasted well into November, and in the middle of the month it was clear that Andy was up to something. Allied subs were swarming the area (and falling victim to my ASW planes) and several large TF's were detected north of NZ. Noumea fell on the 24th of November though and the enemy pulled his TF's out.

The capture of Noumea pushed the score over 4:1 limit, where it has remained ever since.

After that Norfolk island was taken and then it was quiet until the 6th of january 1943 when the KB launched a surprise raid on Sidney harbor, hoping to catch the remaining american CV's there.. Instead they found a large number of BB's there which recieved little damage due to the very heavy AA fire. In the end, for the loss of numerous good pilots only BB Tennessee was heavily damaged.

This raid showed Andy where the KB was and prompted him to launch his first major offensive, the invasion of Canton island. While he was landing through huge minefields (over 6k mines there) and withering CD fire I was loading reinforcements at Truk. Most of the Combined Fleet was being assembled at Kwajalein.

To make a long story short.. some of his troops were left beind due to a mistake, the others suffered heavily from mines and CD's and the island had level 9 forts and over 250 AP's of troops there.

Image

All of his assaults failed and didn't even reduce the fort level.

In february the reinforcement convoys arrived under the cover of the might of the Combined fleet, all BB's and CV's were in the area and the allied ships withdrew. I landed over 100k troops on the island, from almost 300 troop ships. Our surface ships raided nearby atolls sinking barges, AV's and AVD's while the KB raided Wallis Island (which was now a major allied base) twice, sinking a large number of merchant ships there.

It was when the second raid took place (and the KB was 8 hexes southwest of Canton) that we decteted enemy carriers about 8 hexes northeast of Canton. So the carriers were ordered back and..

Image

At range five we only carried bombs but Essex, Hornet and Wasp were all devastaded but CV Illustrious survived. At that time I didn't know that the scuttled ships didn't show up immediatly on the intel screen, so when only the Wasp and Illustrious was detected on the next morning I thought that the Essex and Hornet had got away and pursued them towards Palmyra. Wasp was sunk by betties from Canton but Illustrious escaped. My carriers then ran into 6 CVE's which were sunk over the course of two days... While pursueing the carriers I had several clashes with the airforce at Palmyra (corsairs) and by the end of the battle my carrier air arm was quite depleted.

Also, while chasing down the enemy I had sent a large cruiser taskforce out towards Palmyra which met two american BB's and escorts. I lost two CA's there, the first of the war. The two american BB's were sunk too.

With the forces from Canton island I finally took Baker island, removing the thron in the side of supply lines to Canton island.
After that it has been rather quiet in the pacific, other than the occasional heavy bomber raid on Canton

Ship losses by the end of February:

TK 21 / 0
SS 34 / 19
SC 7 / 0
PT 85 / 1 [X(]
PG 6 / 2
PC 1 / 1
MSW 20 / 3
DMS 7 / 0
DM 2 / 0
DD 30 / 5
BB 2 / 0
CV 7 / 0
CVE 6 / 0
CLAA 2 / 0
CL 4 / 3
CA 7 / 2

AVD 5 / 0
AV 2 / 0
AP 9 / 6
AO 4 / 0
AK 68 / 2
AD 2 / 1
+ some allied landing craft


China

China is all japanese by now. Sanch tried to start an offensive with the chinese and paid dearly for it. One after another the chinese cities were surrounded on the railway line and overrun. The last city, Chengtu, fell in late december IIRC and while there are some chinese troops trapped in the coutryside the theatre is quiet, except for the japanese aircraft training.

SRA

Was mostly quiet until the beginning of january 1943 when a large concentration of aircraft was seen in northern OZ. I gathered most of the army bombers and after some several heavy air battles shut down darwin and Wyndham airfields, destroying a large number of allied planes on the ground. In march he finally managed to reopen the airfields and has now taken Aru, Tenimbar and Kai islands (which were ungarrisoned) by surprise raids. Lautem, the airfield from where i based my bombers, was also shut down by heavy bombers.

Burma

I used Mandalay as my bomber base to shut down every single airfield within sally range. Sanch, and later on AndyMac tried to contest this several times with bad results on their side. It was only in late december 1942 when Andy managed to establish his airbase at Dacca. After a failed attempt in early february he finally shut down Mandalay airfield in the beginning of March, using corsairs to escort hundreds of bombers.


So this is that.. Andy is finally hitting back with his LBA. I'll post the current intel screen when I do the last turn.




Surface combat TF fanboy
Andy Mac
Posts: 12578
Joined: Wed May 12, 2004 8:08 pm
Location: Alexandria, Scotland

RE: AndyMac vs String - The beginning of the end

Post by Andy Mac »

Strings analysis is fairly accurate from my side as well.

I inherited a game that was in a bad state. No supply was forward units were dispersed, no base forces had been brought forward, China was a real mess and I had 4 CV's sunk many glorious ships were on the bottom of the ocean.

Overall very very bad situation. (But I enjoy a challenge !!)

Big issue was the difference between Scen 13 and 15 interms of ground and air units (especially base forces available to allies) I hadnt realised just how much of a boost scen 15 can be for the allies.

China was the worst mess half of the Chinese army was on the trails to attack Burma in an effort to re open the burma road.

By the time I got them back String had rolled up most of China cutting me off from and resupply. He has taken all of China now but we are both only using Chnese forces if we pay PP's for them (e.g. I have about 6 SEAC Chinese Divisions and a couple of Base Forces in India gewtting ready for the glorious reconquest of China)

As a stroke of extreme luck it appears that the US Aviation regiments assigned to China command ar going to appear in India although the base forces dont !!!! So I have 4 large aviation regiments arriving in Karachi that will help a lot.

What little force I had was dispersed heavily so I tried to concentrate on the Line Islands, at Fiji and at New Cal. ( A mistake as it appens removing my forces from Santo and Luganville to reinforce New Cal meant I had no advance warning of the Neew Cal op)

To be honest I didnt want to try and defend new cal but the point score is just large to ignore. (It is unfortunate that a base that is almost undefendable without naval superiority has so many points attached to it. It is in fact very very exposed as String proved !!!! and as I will prove right back to him in 44)

He conquered the place just in advance of a major relief effort I was throwing everythign in an attempt to relieve New Cal and avoid auto defeat. But the island fell before I was committed.

Basically the entire US and RN Fleet was about 5 days from attacking when it fell so I cut my losses when String said he wanted to continue despite auto victory.

OK so what next for the allies ground forces were mauled air units were mauled and my fleet was heavy on the battle line light on Carriers.

I had developed a plan for a three pronged attack in Centpac late in 43 but wanted to clear my lines and take Canton as a prelimenary as it was a pain for convoy routing and to be honest it should be easy as it is in P38 range of Wallis...

I wanted to wait for Corsairs before attempting it as I wanted to protect my bases better than Wildcats could.

I had units prepped and ready to go I was going to send 2nd USMC Div backed by 4 RCT's and a lot of engineers and BF's to allow me to get AF back up and running quickly in case of a counter attack.

Strings raid on Sydney pin pointed KB this gave me a window to launch the attack it was little earlier than I would have liked as I didnt have Crsairs except on west coast but I was confident. The depth on the Minefield was a nasty surprise but my troops got ashore. Only somehow somewhere 2nd USMC had unloaded itself all I had were 40 support squads. I didnt have enough inf after the disruption of landing to take the island.

I rushed by FT Inf of two more RCT's forward but they werent enough the counter attack came and I lost a lot of troops.

Unfortunately at this point I got buck fever no other words for it while KB was off raiding Wallis to noeffect I saw Yamato NW of Canton and decided to send in my arriers (Essex, Wasp, Hornet and Illustrious) the the 6 CVE's following on 180 miles back to provide LRCAP and replacements.

Well unknown to me I had been spotted and KB rushed back and hit me from beyond my range with overwhelming strikes.

3 CV's lost only Illustrious survived because Kates were using bombs. KB pursued and caught the CVE's because they cannot run fast enough. Scratch another 6 flattops...

Over all disaster.

Only news to cheer me up was a CA led squn caught up with the Nevada TF and didnt enjoy it much a pair of CA's were crippled and later sunk

String then had a stroke of mediocre luck despite orders the the contrary KB reacted into range of Wallis and attacked fortunately for me the first Corsairs Sqns had arrived flown over from the Long Island.

KB's air gps took a bit of a kicking which has bought me some time.

Since then I have focussed efforts on LBA from Northern Australia Burma and Wallis plans are being developed but I am going to struggle to get down to 3 :1 before the end of the year. However I do have plans to cause string some problems but given the setbacks it will take some time

Andy
User avatar
Fornadan
Posts: 86
Joined: Sat Jan 22, 2005 12:10 am

RE: AndyMac vs String - The beginning of the end

Post by Fornadan »

So you're gonna gloat on this forum too[;)]
Andy Mac
Posts: 12578
Joined: Wed May 12, 2004 8:08 pm
Location: Alexandria, Scotland

RE: AndyMac vs String - The beginning of the end

Post by Andy Mac »

Hmmmmm if he is gloating on the other forum he wont be for long I may be down but I am very very far from out.

Plans have been cast and the evil Japanese empire is going to get its teeth kicked in....

It may take a little longer but I will get it done somehow !!!!

p.s. below is a little report I wrote of my side of Canton shortly after the event for Strings other board.


> OK I thought I would put my thoughts over the last few turns down on paper
> ;)
>
> Allied strategy in the early part of 43 was wait for Corsairs and P40N's
> and then about April/May time launch a massive CENTPAC offensive on
> multiple prongs. I am able to release this information as following the
> Battle of Canton the plan has been scrapped...... This plan know as
> Operation Trident required a lot of transport and a lot of ground forces
> but I planned on having a full Marine Division spearheading each attack.
>
> That was the plan ..then we hit Canton.
>
> Canton from my perspective was a pain in neck in order to free up some
> assault transport I wanted to neutralise the base as it sits squarely on
> my LOC between Fiji and Pearl. Lets be clear this operation was for the
> allies in the nature of a clearing the lines offensive getting ready for
> the main event. i.e. it wasnt supposed to be a major battle !!!!!
>
> The Line Islands were heavily fortifed to the NE to the SW I had Wallis
> Island and numerour developed bases. And as a trip wire I had baker Island
> PBY's so I was confident this would be a relatively safe operation. I
> assembled a force of 3 Divisions worth of Infantry spearheaded by the 2nd
> USMC and plenty of support troops. My plan was to take the island quickly
> get it up and running as a base (hence the support troops) and place some
> fighters, bombers on it to fight off a counter attack although I didnt
> really expect one. I had 6 CVE's (2 Replenishment) 4 CV's (Wasp,
> Illustrious, Hornet and Essex), 6 BB's were also committed (Nevada,
> Pennsylvania, Indiana, California, Colorado and Maryland) and numerous
> CA's etc I figured if I could take the base quickly by applying
> overwhelming force at a point when the IJN was out of the picture then I
> could get back on with prep for the real attack.
>
> Well that was the plan now what went wrong !!!! I assume String has
> gloated (justifiably) at length on the destruction of the allied force.
>
> Stage one ensure the IJN is somewhere else. His strike on Sydney meant
> that I was certain I could attack
>
> Stage two close the AF on Canton complete success Liberators and BB's are
> good at closing AF's
>
> Stage three land troops ok this is where it started to go wrong after
> losing 20+ MSW's at New Cal I was slightly short in this class of unit but
> this turned into a disaster you could have almost walked ashore from two
> miles out he must have laid thousands of mines. Shup after ship hit mines
> the problem was not the losses but the additional disruption on my already
> heavily disrupted landing force. Unexpected but not a disaster. Then the
> real disaster occured....the convoy carrying the Spearhead 2nd USMC Div
> had unloaded itself at its origin port instead of 15,000 Battlehardened
> marines I had 600 cooks of the 4th USMC Field Kitchen ..... experts in
> Barbecueing under fire. No excuses my fault I have no idea how or why most
> of the Division disembarked itself. The implications were profound I did
> not have enough assault troops to storm the island. Instead of a lightning
> assault I was going to have to wait for the 24th US Division in the 2nd
> wave to arrive.
>
> Unfortunately the second wave had not even embarked when my initial
> assault failed. It quickly became apparent that the IJN was not about to
> let me take the island I kept trying to sow the seeds of doubt in String's
> mind that it was a trap and that I had deliberatly not taken the island.
> He didnt fall for it (or perhaps he did but decided to trigger the trap in
> overwhelming force !!!!) In any event I didnt want to write of 50,000
> troops so I kept my CV's reasonably close.
>
> Stage four IJN Counterinvasion
>
> After he counter invaded I knew I should cut my losses my mistake had cost
> me 50,000 men. I wasnt stong enough to force a CV battle so I decided to
> keep my CVE's back and probe with CV's from the east.(I should have sent
> them all to the East Coast)
>
> Well my ground troops were going down and I sighted Yamato out on its own.
> I dont knwo if it was bait or just my bad luck I sent in my fast CV's with
> the CVE's 180 miles behind them to sink the Yamato and recover a little.
>
> Unfortunately his CV's had spotted me (unknown to me) and closed. the
> rest as they say is history. I lost 3 CV's, 6 CVE's and two BB's for no
> damage to the enemy only HMS Indestructable survived despite numerous bomb
> hits she ended up at 5 sys damage (gotta love armoured flight decks !!!!!)
>
> He got a little to eager to finish off Illustrious (I think his highly
> aggressive CV commander may have reacted wo orders) and got his carrier
> air gps shredded against my LBA, the only other thing that went ok for me
> was a pair of IJN CA's mixing it up with Nevada and coming off worst.
>
> I am considering what I can do in this situation but I can say it will
> take a long time for the allies to recover from this one !!!
>
> Allied C in C Pacific (soon to be relieved or shot if things dont get
> better !!!!)

p.s. another piece of good news is that as the 2nd USMC wasnt at Canton it
is in fact fully operational and sitting back in its origin base. (The cooks
were fairly crap so morale actually improved after they surrendered !!!!!)

User avatar
String
Posts: 2661
Joined: Tue Oct 07, 2003 7:56 pm
Location: Estonia

RE: AndyMac vs String - The beginning of the end

Post by String »

ORIGINAL: Fornadan

So you're gonna gloat on this forum too[;)]


Hey! .. I wasn't gloating![:-]

Anyway, 19th of march arrived, and little happened. A few mitchells bombed Akyab airfield and the IJAAF struck at Kai island, cratering the small airstrip there.
Surface combat TF fanboy
User avatar
String
Posts: 2661
Joined: Tue Oct 07, 2003 7:56 pm
Location: Estonia

20th of March 1943

Post by String »

Little to report. SS Scamp managed to torpedo AK Asakaze Maru near Tokyo and evaded the escorts.

Other than that, again a large air raid on Lautem from Darwin

Day Air attack on Lautem , at 33,78

Japanese aircraft
Ki-27 Nate x 3

Allied aircraft
Boomerang II x 11
B-25J Mitchell x 23
B-17E Fortress x 37
PB4Y Liberator x 28
B-24D Liberator x 32

Japanese aircraft losses
H6K2-L Mavis: 2 destroyed
Ki-45 KAIa Nick: 2 destroyed
Ki-46-III Dinah: 1 destroyed

Allied aircraft losses
B-25J Mitchell: 3 damaged
PB4Y Liberator: 1 damaged

Japanese ground losses:
69 casualties reported

Airbase hits 2
Airbase supply hits 2
Runway hits 98


The japs returned the favor by bombing american troops on Kai Island.
Surface combat TF fanboy
Andy Mac
Posts: 12578
Joined: Wed May 12, 2004 8:08 pm
Location: Alexandria, Scotland

RE: 20th of March 1943

Post by Andy Mac »

Fortunately Kai is only a PBY base so little damage is done.

It is so hard to keep aircraft operational.

On X day I launched hundred plus heavy bomber raids on Canton/ Mandalay and Timor since then I have never been able to get enough operational heavies together to hit more than one of them every other day.

It is annoying but I wont commit bombers without fighter cover and my LR fighters need rest and recuperation
User avatar
String
Posts: 2661
Joined: Tue Oct 07, 2003 7:56 pm
Location: Estonia

RE: 21st of March 1943

Post by String »

Ahh, today saw some action.

During the night four japanese PT boats tried to sneak into Darwin harbour but were intercepted and sunk by an american taskforce, lead by BB Missisippi. A few hundred miles northeast light cruisers Tenryu and Kuma bombarded Kai island in preparation of a landing by japanese SNLF forces which made ashore with little resistance from the american occupants.

There SHOULD have been a bombardment of Tenimbar by BB Kongo & co but apparently i forgot to set the orders to bombard [:o]. The same tf was then detected 60 miles SE of Lautem and attacked by allied bombers

[center]Image

Luckily, out of torpedo range[/center]

Our ships were covered by longrange CAP and the oscars proved that they can be useful sometimes. The defending fighters penetrated the enemy fighter screen and drove off the bombers. Only 2 Boomerang II fighter bombers managed to attack BB Kongo, both missing with their bombs

Day Air attack on TF at 33,79

Japanese aircraft
Ki-27 Nate x 2
Ki-43-Ib Oscar x 10
Ki-43-IIa Oscar x 48
Ki-61 KAIc Tony x 5

Allied aircraft
F4U-1 Corsair x 2
Boomerang II x 10
Kittyhawk I x 9
Vengeance I x 33
Beaufighter Mk 21 x 8
P-38G Lightning x 21

Japanese aircraft losses
Ki-43-Ib Oscar: 2 destroyed
Ki-43-IIa Oscar: 14 destroyed, 2 damaged
Ki-61 KAIc Tony: 3 destroyed

Allied aircraft losses
F4U-1 Corsair: 1 destroyed
Boomerang II: 5 destroyed
Kittyhawk I: 4 destroyed, 1 damaged
Vengeance I: 4 destroyed, 4 damaged
Beaufighter Mk 21: 5 destroyed
P-38G Lightning: 4 destroyed, 6 damaged

Japanese Ships
BB Kongo


The usual air attacks in Burma, China and southern SRA continued.

As promised, here is the intel screen from today

Image
Surface combat TF fanboy
Andy Mac
Posts: 12578
Joined: Wed May 12, 2004 8:08 pm
Location: Alexandria, Scotland

RE: 21st of March 1943

Post by Andy Mac »

Not a bad result by the IJN going to be interesting I suspect String isnt any more overloaded with troops in this region than I am so it will be small scale raids I would think for a while by both sides

Missisipi v Kongo should be fun both look to have decent supporting units and with all my CV 's sank and given the air units in China I am guessing his in dry dock yes this should be interesting if a sideshow.
Andy Mac
Posts: 12578
Joined: Wed May 12, 2004 8:08 pm
Location: Alexandria, Scotland

RE: 21st of March 1943

Post by Andy Mac »

p.s. I am amazed at who my best fighters are turning out to be blending experience with airframe it isnt Marine Corsairs or RAF Spitfires or even Australian/ USAAF P40's/P38's no none of the above it is in fact those dammed Kiwis :)

Recently upgraded to F4U's I have about 4 Sqns of RNZAF Corsairs with 75+ XP these guys are the business I expect great things from them
User avatar
String
Posts: 2661
Joined: Tue Oct 07, 2003 7:56 pm
Location: Estonia

22nd of March 1943

Post by String »

Well.. the Banda sea area is definetly getting a guadalcanalish feel.

Image

The TF that was bombed yesterday sailed into Darwin harbour tonight and engaged the enemy ships there. BB Mississippi greeted BB Kongo with a 14" shell and then recieved 5-6 in return, one of which knocked out one of the 14" main turrets. BB Musashi also displayed it's firepower by hitting BB Mississippi with an 18" shell. American destroyers proved to be superior to their japanese counterparts, hitting most of them with accurate 5" fire while recieving no hits from japanese destroyers. DD Russell also torpedoed BB Kongo, but the damage was not serious.

CA Maya and CA Australia squared off on their own. Maya torpedoed Australia twice and made numerous 8" hits on the australian cruiser. She recieved only light caliber hits in return. At the same time CL Helena showed that the furutaka class heavy cruiser armor wasn't enough to withstand the 6" american guns, damaging CA Aoba.

In the end the japanese gunnery, especially on Kirishima and Kongo, was superior and many american and australian ships were heavily damaged.

Night Time Surface Combat, near Darwin at 36,84

Japanese Ships
BB Kongo, Shell hits 3, on fire
BB Kirishima, Shell hits 2
BB Musashi
CA Maya, Shell hits 1
CA Chokai, Shell hits 1
CA Kumano, Shell hits 4
CA Aoba, Shell hits 2
DD Kazegumo
DD Kagero, Shell hits 1, on fire
DD Yukikaze
DD Tachikaze, Shell hits 1

Allied Ships
BB Mississippi, Shell hits 7, on fire, heavy damage
CA Indianapolis, Shell hits 3
CA Northampton
CA Australia, Shell hits 1, Torpedo hits 1, heavy damage
CL Achilles
CL Emerald
CL Helena
DD Fletcher, Torpedo hits 1, on fire
DD Gwin
DD Grayson
DD Monssen
DD Bancroft, Shell hits 1, on fire
DD Anderson
DD Russell
DMS Zane

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Night Time Surface Combat, near Darwin at 36,84


Allied aircraft
no flights


Allied aircraft losses
Walrus: 1 destroyed

Japanese Ships
BB Kongo, Shell hits 6, Torpedo hits 1, on fire
BB Kirishima, Shell hits 5
BB Musashi, Shell hits 4
CA Maya, Shell hits 1
CA Chokai, Shell hits 5
CA Kumano, Shell hits 7
CA Aoba, Shell hits 5, on fire
DD Kazegumo, Shell hits 1
DD Kagero, Shell hits 4, on fire
DD Yukikaze, Shell hits 4, on fire
DD Tachikaze, Shell hits 3, on fire

Allied Ships
BB Mississippi, Shell hits 6, on fire, heavy damage
CA Indianapolis, Shell hits 9, on fire, heavy damage
CA Northampton, Shell hits 2
CA Australia, Shell hits 12, Torpedo hits 1, and is sunk
CL Achilles, Shell hits 1, on fire
CL Emerald, Shell hits 2, on fire
CL Helena, Shell hits 1, Torpedo hits 2, on fire
DD Fletcher, Torpedo hits 1, and is sunk
DD Gwin
DD Grayson
DD Monssen
DD Bancroft, Shell hits 1, on fire
DD Anderson
DD Russell
DMS Zane



During the day SS Nautilus torpedoed AK Yamagiku Maru, which was carrying fuel. She was reported to be on fire.

Kai island was retaken by the victorious troops of 15th Naval GDs
Surface combat TF fanboy
Andy Mac
Posts: 12578
Joined: Wed May 12, 2004 8:08 pm
Location: Alexandria, Scotland

RE: 22nd of March 1943

Post by Andy Mac »

Grrrrrr IJN got so very lucky yesterday.

Missisipi held her own against 4 IJN BB's (my spotters should be shot hw could you mistake Musashi for anything else)


The weather closed Darwin Airport the next morning and then in the afternoon cloud cover chileded the retrating IJN TF.

Lucky lucky SOB's

I had 60+ Beuforts and 40+ Vengeance's ready to pounce but the weather shut the airport....
User avatar
String
Posts: 2661
Joined: Tue Oct 07, 2003 7:56 pm
Location: Estonia

23rd of March 1943

Post by String »

Yes indeed, I was lucky. But I knew that Darwin was probably packed with beauforts and dive bombers so I checked the weather report and gambled. I'm also glad to report that no japanese ship is anywhere near sinking condition. It's sad that the Mississippi didn't sink, she did take quite a beating, but she's out of action for some months i think. She'll have to sail all around australia to get to the west coast shipyards as I have PM and I think Andy knows better than to try and get through the straits there.

Anyway, 23rd was rather uneventful. Andy raided Canton island again, destroying 54 planes on the ground and shooting down ~25 in the air. Andy lost 22 P-38's to my fighters.

Surface combat TF fanboy
Andy Mac
Posts: 12578
Joined: Wed May 12, 2004 8:08 pm
Location: Alexandria, Scotland

RE: 23rd of March 1943

Post by Andy Mac »

Yup Centpac will be a backwater for a while methinks nothing happening there at all just my routine attritional raids on String.

Sad but true if I lose 2 Fighters to every one of his I come out ahead as I can replace the fighter pilots easily he cannot
Andy Mac
Posts: 12578
Joined: Wed May 12, 2004 8:08 pm
Location: Alexandria, Scotland

RE: 23rd of March 1943

Post by Andy Mac »

OK Operation Triphammer has been approved by allied high command It wont be a surprise but I have learned my lesson OVERWHELMING FORCE is the order of the day.

I wont get tactical surprise it wont be pretty it will cost me a lot of fine ships and lots of heavies but the time has come to turn around allied luck.....

Watch this space
Andy Mac
Posts: 12578
Joined: Wed May 12, 2004 8:08 pm
Location: Alexandria, Scotland

RE: 23rd of March 1943

Post by Andy Mac »

OK I have decided following extensive planning a series of operations will be launched they will be geographically diverse and given the lack of Carrier Air extremely risky but if I am to get the score down to less than 3:1 by the end of the year risks must be taken.

The fourth and last of my transformational fighters becomes operational at the end of this month which at last gives me real options.

Spitfire P38 Corsair P40N

I will explain the 3 generic plans in more detail after String becomes aware of them I have named them operation Triphammer, Jackhammer and then operation Sledgehammer

I estimate Triphammer will be spotted by LR IJN recon within 14 days. Jackhammer will be spottable in about 45 days.

Sledgehammer will hit after the other two are committed.

This is it a recut of my 43 offensive as after the Battle of Canton I am very short of deployable assets. I am going to be risking a lot of shipping if the IJN comes out to play but the risk is worth it.

However if I go full defensive with what Carrier Air I have I can have 3 x 24 marine or FAA Corsairs on CAP backed by 2 - 4 Independence class CVL's with normal strike gps.

With that kind of cover I can attempt some of my more audacious plans especially as I have weeded some of the elite zero pilots.

The only good news is that allied land and air units are getting stronger and stronger String used a storm front to hit the Missisipi Battle Group and get away scot free but the fact remains I have enough airpower in all of my main airforces as well as the soon to activated airforce on Pearl to prevent the Japanese keeping an airforce in operation anywhere in range of my Fighters

Andy
User avatar
String
Posts: 2661
Joined: Tue Oct 07, 2003 7:56 pm
Location: Estonia

RE: 23rd of March 1943

Post by String »

Well the fact is indeed that I cannot really hope to contest the airspace within the reach of his heavy bomber escorts. However we shall see what will happen as I still have all of my carriers intact.
Surface combat TF fanboy
User avatar
pauk
Posts: 4156
Joined: Sun Oct 21, 2001 8:00 am
Location: Zagreb,Croatia

RE: 23rd of March 1943

Post by pauk »

nice summary, but where is my turn?
Image
User avatar
String
Posts: 2661
Joined: Tue Oct 07, 2003 7:56 pm
Location: Estonia

RE: 23rd of March 1943

Post by String »

ORIGINAL: pauk

nice summary, but where is my turn?

In your inbox naturally, been there since yesterday [:D] Anyway, just checked the P40N replacement rates in my allied PBEM ... 200 [X(]. Damn. I think Andy won't try pulling any half hearted efforts like Canton anymore, so it should be interesting.
Surface combat TF fanboy
Andy Mac
Posts: 12578
Joined: Wed May 12, 2004 8:08 pm
Location: Alexandria, Scotland

RE: AndyMac vs String - The beginning of the end

Post by Andy Mac »

3 week delay while I conduct a personal inspection of the harbour defences and capabilities of San Francisco and Vancouver

Visiting the newly rebuilt USS Hornet tomorrow should be good when she is launched she will avenge her predecessors.

Reviewed USS Pampanito and a liberty ship yesterday and the defences at fort Mason and the Golden Gate Bridge defences.

(AKA 3 week touring vacation of US West Coast) !!!!

Andy
Post Reply

Return to “After Action Reports”