Tophat vs ADavidB - Back at It

Post descriptions of your brilliant successes and unfortunate demises.

Moderators: wdolson, Don Bowen, mogami

User avatar
Ron Saueracker
Posts: 10967
Joined: Mon Jan 28, 2002 10:00 am
Location: Ottawa, Canada OR Zakynthos Island, Greece

RE: Again three bases lost...

Post by Ron Saueracker »

Soapbox space -

Once again the pure idiocy of the ground movement rules made the entire operation a joke. My troops gained fatigue from 30 to 70 while they were trying to move from the road hex across the river to the crossroads hex. One hex, a week's time, and a totally unjustifiable increase in fatigue that allowed Tophat's division to kick my troops out before my troops could even get an artillery bombardment off. At times like this I really wonder why I bother to play this game, then I calm down and decide to let things be and try to figure out a way to win despite all the bad design decisions in the game.

Soapbox space ended -

Dave Baranyi

Hey! Ya never know, maybe since they have decided to fix the ASW finally perhaps they might venture to fix a few other big flaws like air to air and land combat issues. Be a great thing, what?[:)]

Good to see ya back! Told ya so...[;)]
Image

Image

Yammas from The Apo-Tiki Lounge. Future site of WITP AE benders! And then the s--t hit the fan
User avatar
ADavidB
Posts: 2464
Joined: Mon Sep 17, 2001 8:00 am
Location: Toronto, Canada

RE: Again three bases lost...

Post by ADavidB »

Hey! Ya never know, maybe since they have decided to fix the ASW finally perhaps they might venture to fix a few other big flaws like air to air and land combat issues. Be a great thing, what?

Good to see ya back! Told ya so...

Glad to be back. This "concept" of only playing one PBEM game has improved things greatly - I get frustrated with little buggy things in the game fewer times in a day. [:D]

Take care -

Dave
User avatar
Ron Saueracker
Posts: 10967
Joined: Mon Jan 28, 2002 10:00 am
Location: Ottawa, Canada OR Zakynthos Island, Greece

RE: Again three bases lost...

Post by Ron Saueracker »

ORIGINAL: ADavidB
Hey! Ya never know, maybe since they have decided to fix the ASW finally perhaps they might venture to fix a few other big flaws like air to air and land combat issues. Be a great thing, what?

Good to see ya back! Told ya so...

Glad to be back. This "concept" of only playing one PBEM game has improved things greatly - I get frustrated with little buggy things in the game fewer times in a day. [:D]

Take care -

Dave

Yep, one PBEM at a time also keeps the booboos to a minimum![:)] Great AAR...too bad it's not a CHS though. I'm a big fan of Don and the team's work. I am really aching to get a PBEM going once I get sorted.
Image

Image

Yammas from The Apo-Tiki Lounge. Future site of WITP AE benders! And then the s--t hit the fan
User avatar
ADavidB
Posts: 2464
Joined: Mon Sep 17, 2001 8:00 am
Location: Toronto, Canada

Chasing the Mongols Away...

Post by ADavidB »

June 24 -

This was a fairly quiet turn with rain dampening some operations and the need by both sides to recuperate and re-think the situation slowing down the pace a bit. There were only a couple of air raids in China. My Chinese short-range bombers found those Mongols who were retreating in the North and hit them hard again. Then Tophat sent bombers to Wuchow but they again hit nothing despite the lack of CAP. After the bombers came in Tophat's sweeping fighters came in - so Tophat lucked out there. But since Tophat's bombers are being pretty ineffective I'm not bothering to challenge Tophat's fighters at this time - I'll wait until I'm ready to surprise him in a big and painful manner.

The lack of operations in China is allowing my air units, both British and Chinese, to recover strength as my bases recover supply. Most of my Chinese bases now have level 9 fortifications and have adequate air fields so my demand for supplies for base-building is dropping off readily. And with Tophat's ground forces split all over the place he hasn't been able to attrite my land forces much recently. Now if he will only become tempted to bring "one too many" units out of Manchuria so that the Soviets get activate. I've got lots of nice units there that are "dying" to get a work out. [;)]

Tophat's ships around Baker Island went back to base. I've set my bombers at Canton Island to hit the airfield at Baker Island again this turn. We'll see how well they do the second time. I've also had a chance to refuel all of my combat TFs in either Palmyra or Christmas Islands so they are on the way back to Hawaii too. I'm not prepared for an all out assault on Baker at this time, so I'll just satisfy myself with a bombing campaign. While the Japanese capture of Baker Island is a nuisance, it doesn't really affect my overall plans, other than cause me to add one more Fall invasion to the List. BTW - another Japanese AP sank in the aftermath of the Battle of Baker Island. I'm still amazed that I accomplished so much with so little and at no cost to my forces!

The daily air raid on Soerabaja came and went with the usual results - damage for Tophat's bombers but trivial damage to the Dutch. Tophat's bombardments at Soerabaja and the Chinese bases are also accomplishing little. The Stalemate in the Far East is looking good to me.

The other area of action this turn was Timor where Tophat got all worked up about not being able to hit my B-17Es at 35K feet with his Zeros on CAP. Well, that's how it goes. [:D] Tophat will just have to start to bring Tonys or Tojos forward. But then, he shouldn't get too worked up about this - despite having "decent" experience my B-17s still didn’t get any hits on Koepang. But the raid still serves its purpose of keeping Tophat scrambling.

Dave Baranyi
User avatar
ADavidB
Posts: 2464
Joined: Mon Sep 17, 2001 8:00 am
Location: Toronto, Canada

RE: Again three bases lost...

Post by ADavidB »

Yep, one PBEM at a time also keeps the booboos to a minimum! Great AAR...too bad it's not a CHS though. I'm a big fan of Don and the team's work. I am really aching to get a PBEM going once I get sorted.

One game at a time helps to keep my life in some semblence of order...[:D]

BTW - Tophat and I already put in a house rule limiting ASW TFs. And even that doesn't have a lot of an affect on my strategy because I like to send out many small ASW TFs rather than one big on. I like to increase my odds of finding the sub.

The CHS is tempting and I have a lot of admiration for the folks who are working on it, but I'm still very, very cautious about spending time on anything other than the "official" version. And given all the heartaches and headaches that have come with the V1.7x Betas, I'm glad that Tophat and I have strickly avoided the temptation to upgrade. V1.602 is working well enough for us for now.

Thanks again for the comments -

Dave Baranyi
User avatar
ADavidB
Posts: 2464
Joined: Mon Sep 17, 2001 8:00 am
Location: Toronto, Canada

Homan Holds Again...

Post by ADavidB »

June 25 -

Things were reasonably quiet in the air this turn again. Tophat decided to send a couple of Sentai of Oscars to sweep my Chinese fighters at Hengchow. The Chinese held their own well despite being outnumbered 4:1. Of course, all this means is next turn, if Tophat sends those Oscars back; they will have to deal with Brit Mohawks. [:D]

Tophat hasn't sent his fighters and bombers against Sian for several days now. This has allowed me to pull back the weaker squadrons and the bombers and let the fighters build back up. Now if he goes in he will face four full squadrons of Brit Mohawks. At the same time my Brit bombers continue to build back up to full strength. So, while I'm resting them this turn, next turn they will go out again to hit another Japanese air base. Tophat is now around 300 air losses "in front" of me; air-to-air combat losses are starting to build for the Japanese, as are on-the-ground losses.

Speaking of air losses; my B-17s did a nice job on Tophat's Zeros at Baker and even found the time to bomb the airfield a bit too. Tophat is a bit concerned that his basic A6M2 Zeros are the only fighters in his forces that can't go up to attack the Allied 4-engine bombers over 35K feet. But then, maybe he has more things than just altitude to worry about - the bombers that hit Baker were at 6K feet. [;)]

And, as usual, the Japanese Army bombers had another lousy day attacking Soerabaja, suffering damage to half of the attackers while causing a couple of handfuls of casualties among the Dutch. It things stay like this for a few more months I may well put some bombers back into Soerabaja once I have P-38s available for escort duty.

But it wasn't just the bombers who had a bad day; Tophat tried a deliberate attack on Homan with results that didn't please him:

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ground combat at Homan

Japanese Deliberate attack

Attacking force 201231 troops, 2187 guns, 198 vehicles

Defending force 111757 troops, 420 guns, 0 vehicles

Japanese engineers reduce fortifications to 8

Japanese assault odds: 0 to 1 (fort level 8)

Japanese ground losses:
6485 casualties reported
Guns lost 192
Vehicles lost 6

Allied ground losses:
2232 casualties reported
Guns lost 66

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I bet that Tophat will try to bomb Homan again; he hasn't tried for a couple of game-weeks.

Dave Baranyi
User avatar
Ron Saueracker
Posts: 10967
Joined: Mon Jan 28, 2002 10:00 am
Location: Ottawa, Canada OR Zakynthos Island, Greece

RE: Homan Holds Again...

Post by Ron Saueracker »

Looking good for the Allies in 1942 for a change. Good wortk![:)]
Image

Image

Yammas from The Apo-Tiki Lounge. Future site of WITP AE benders! And then the s--t hit the fan
User avatar
ADavidB
Posts: 2464
Joined: Mon Sep 17, 2001 8:00 am
Location: Toronto, Canada

Oscars on a Hunt

Post by ADavidB »

June 26 -

This was a very quiet turn with only two air attacks. The first was my nightly "experiment in futility" as I try to get the Brit night fighters to find the airfield at Mandalay. The leader's qualifications are in the 70s, as is the average experience of the pilots. But they still only find the field about once in every 2 dozen flights. Never-the-less, I keep on trying, remembering the old motto, "Even a blind squirrel occasionally finds a nut."

The other air attack was another sweep by the Oscars in South China over Hengchow. This time I found out that Tophat does have some decent Oscar pilots as my Brits didn't wipe the floor with the Japanese. Now, this doesn't happen to be one of my more experienced Mohawk units, so the results weren't too surprising, but it does tell me that I can't yet get too cavalier over what units I put into the line of fire.

And other than Tophat's usual artillery bombardments in China and Soerabaja there was no other action. Speaking of Soerabaja, I checked out the Dutch units there and I got a very pleasant surprise. Other than the HQ unit which, thanks to the game mechanics, is taking the brunt of the daily artillery attacks, the Dutch troops have low fatigue, high morale, low disruption and increasing experience. And the total assault strength has gone up again to a new high! If this goes on for a few more months these guys will be able to go on a counter-offensive. [;)]

For next turn I am leaving things pretty much as they were with the exception of a few bombing runs that I will attempt in China - weather permitting. This turn was yet another in a long, long series of bad weather turns, except that this time there were no "clear" areas on the map.

Dave Baranyi
User avatar
ADavidB
Posts: 2464
Joined: Mon Sep 17, 2001 8:00 am
Location: Toronto, Canada

RE: Homan Holds Again...

Post by ADavidB »

Looking good for the Allies in 1942 for a change. Good work!

Thanks, but all I've done is stall the Japanese - I am still far from being able to take the fight to the Japanese in any serious manner. Also, there are still two areas which are effectively up-for-grabs if Tophat decides that he wants to expand more - the South Pacific and the Aleutians.

Now, realistically, I don't know what it would gain Tophat to spend a lot of effort going after either region; other than for pure nuisance sake. But I haven't tried to build up either region, with the exception of Anchorage and New Zealand. I have a big, experienced US Division in Auckland along with the Kiwi troops, and fortifications that are getting stronger every day. So if Tophat thought that he was having trouble in Soerabaja, he will really find trouble in Auckland. But I seriously doubt that he will commit way down there. The rest of the South Pacific, on the other hand, will continue to be at risk for some time yet as I continue my focus on the East Central Pacific.

Thanks again for the comments -

Dave Baranyi
User avatar
ADavidB
Posts: 2464
Joined: Mon Sep 17, 2001 8:00 am
Location: Toronto, Canada

Landing at Dili...

Post by ADavidB »

June 27 -

Tophat is on the move again in the DEI with troops landing at Dili on Timor. So far only a single NLF has landed - my troops may, just may, hold out a bit there, but there are no guarantees. Therefore I moved out the Dutch Catalinas out of Dili and put them in Lautem. I've also set my Hudsons back to Naval Attack and I'm sending out my B-17s on a Ground Attack at Dili. I suspect that Tophat has LR CAP over his ships, so I'm hoping that the B-17s take care of that.

Meanwhile, in the Central Pacific, Tophat is trying to send a transport TF to Baker Island. I'm sending my B-17s after the airfield at Baker again, and as well I'm going to try to sneak a small surface combat TF in and out of Baker before Tophat can react with his carriers and heavy surface combat ships. Tophat also sent out an ASW TF that hit one of my subs in the Marshalls.

In China my Chinese IL-4cs caught Tophat with his "CAP down" in Hong Kong:

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Day Air attack on Hong Kong, at 43, 42

Japanese aircraft
no flights

Allied aircraft
IL-4c x 8

Japanese aircraft losses
Ki-43-Ib Oscar: 2 destroyed
Ki-49 Helen: 1 destroyed

Japanese ground losses:
5 casualties reported
Guns lost 1

Airbase hits 2
Runway hits 3

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I'm sending the same planes to Canton next turn to see if they get equally lucky. I'm also sending the Brit Wellingtons after Tophat's main air base again.

But Tophat had his way in the skies over Hengchow again - that group of Oscars is a force to be reckoned with. I've put in a more experience fighter squadron this time - we'll see how well they do.

Dave Baranyi
User avatar
ADavidB
Posts: 2464
Joined: Mon Sep 17, 2001 8:00 am
Location: Toronto, Canada

Attack at Dili...

Post by ADavidB »

June 28 -

This turn featured the resumption of widespread action despite continued generally bad weather everywhere. First off, one of my S-boats put two torpedoes into a Japanese AP in the Invasion Fleet at Dili. But that won't stop Tophat; he obviously wants Dili badly and sent his big 5-BB bombardment TF back into action for the first time in quite a while. They hammered Dili badly and destroyed all of the supplies there. There are several other TFs standing off a ways off from Dili; I suspect that at least one of them is a carrier TF because none of my Australian bombers flew to try to hit any of the TFs or the troops that are already on the ground in Dili. There is also a CS in one of those TFs. That suggests strongly the presence of heavy LR CAP over the invasion fleet.

In China the weather washed out my planned big Brit air attack but allowed a couple of other smaller attacks. The Chinese IL-4cs got over Canton but were met by a strong CAP consisting of a few Tojos and lots of Nates. I didn't lose any bombers but they got shot up badly and they didn't hit the target. Tophat also sent that large, strong group of Oscars over Hengchow again. This time my more experienced Brit Mohawk squadron gave as well as they got, but there were still too many Japanese fighters on the sweep for a single squadron to handle. I may need to bring in a couple of squadrons of Hurricanes just to defend Hengchow.

Tophat finally changed his strategy at Soerabaja. He sent his Japanese Army bombers in at 16,000 feet and targeted the air fields. Using this approach his planes avoided a lot of flak damage and caused a fair amount of damage to the field which required supply to fix. The damage was all fixed by "daylight", but if Tophat keeps this up he may well be able to attrite my supply significantly. Unfortunately, I can't tell my engineers not to rebuild the air fields. Maybe this is why Tophat predicted that Soerabaja would last for only another 10 days. I think that my supply will hold out longer than that, but we will see.

My B-17s flew over Baker today and performed as I had hoped:

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Day Air attack on Baker Island, at 94, 92

Japanese aircraft
A6M2 Zero x 12

Allied aircraft
PB2Y Coronado x 3
B-17E Fortress x 27

Japanese aircraft losses
A6M2 Zero: 1 destroyed, 2 damaged

Allied aircraft losses
PB2Y Coronado: 1 damaged
B-17E Fortress: 1 destroyed, 3 damaged

Japanese ground losses:
28 casualties reported

Airbase hits 3
Airbase supply hits 3
Runway hits 17

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

This group of bombers needs to build up experience so Baker is as good a target as any. I'll rest up these bombers again this turn. Also in news about Baker Island, that transport TF that I spotted last turn to the Northwest of Baker now appears to be heading back to home port, if my Intel is any good. Was it a Fast Transport TF that dumped its load and fled, or a regular transport TF that was "scared off" by the bombers? Or is it a bait to see if I send my carriers back? In any event, my small combat TF will cruise into Baker this evening to see if there are any targets-of-opportunity, so I'll have a better idea of what is going on tomorrow.

BTW - another of the damaged ships from the Baker Invasion TF sank in the Marshalls today.

Dave Baranyi
User avatar
ADavidB
Posts: 2464
Joined: Mon Sep 17, 2001 8:00 am
Location: Toronto, Canada

Air Wars All Over...

Post by ADavidB »

June 29 -

This was certainly a chippy turn, with lots of air action all over and some naval action too. First off, Tophat automatically occupied some "dot" somewhere called "Roti Island". Hmmm, its supper time and that is making me hungry. <g>

The big bombardment TF came back to Dili and hammered my troops again. Next, the scout planes from the TF found the S-boat that torpedoed the AP in the invasion force last turn and hit it. So I've got to send that sub home for repairs. But my B-17s flew out of Darwin and surprisingly enough did a lot of damage to Tophat's invasion troops. Then my Hudsons flew a naval attack against a CS that is in the invasion TF, but they didn't get any hits.

At the same time Tophat's Japanese Army bombers went after Soerabaja at 16K feet again, doing about the same amount of damage as the last time. But this time the AA seems to have found the correct range and damaged or destroyed a number of Japanese bombers too.

The bulk of the air action was in China. Tophat did a sweep of Hengchow with his "super-Oscars" but I didn't have any fighters on CAP, so that was a waste for him. Then Tophat did a much more productive sweep as Oscars and Zeros hit Homan. I had Chinese Biplanes on patrol which held their own against the Oscars, but they were wiped out by the Zeros. So I am now retiring those Biplanes to the "far boonies" until I get P-40Ns in 1943. (It's just too bad that I can't give them some of my P-39s that are collecting dust.)

But my Wellingtons had a good run at Wuhan that sort of made up for the debacle at Homan:

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Day Air attack on Wuhan, at 48, 35

Japanese aircraft
Ki-27 Nate x 3
Ki-43-Ib Oscar x 9

Allied aircraft
Wellington III x 56

Japanese aircraft losses
Ki-27 Nate: 1 destroyed, 1 damaged
Ki-43-Ib Oscar: 5 destroyed
Ki-21 Sally: 1 destroyed
A6M3 Zero: 3 destroyed
Ki-15 Babs: 1 destroyed

Allied aircraft losses
Wellington III: 1 destroyed, 9 damaged

Japanese ground losses:
127 casualties reported
Guns lost 2

Airbase hits 9
Airbase supply hits 1
Runway hits 27

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I've decided to up-the-ante in China so I'm starting to move a couple of my better Hurricane squadrons into range. Its funny how I didn't intend to get "sucked into" an escalating war in China a little while ago, but here I go…

The final bit of action was at little, middle-of-nowhere Nanomea Atoll where I have an AVD and a Catalina squadron. Two turns ago a Japanese sub showed up and parked itself at the atoll. So last turn I set that AVD to ASW combat, sent it out one hex, and let it return on its own. This turn the AVD attacked the sub twice, hitting it with a depth charge on the second try.

With all that is going on, it is nice to realize that July is upon us, and with it the ability to start to change the Dutch planes to something more useful and plentiful, there are upgrades for the Yorktown-class carriers, and this is the beginning of something very "dear to my heart" - the arrival of Avengers.

Dave Baranyi
User avatar
ADavidB
Posts: 2464
Joined: Mon Sep 17, 2001 8:00 am
Location: Toronto, Canada

Combat at Dili...

Post by ADavidB »

June 30 -

This was yet another chippy turn with action scattered all over the map. Nothing "massive" is happening but everything does add up as Tophat attempts to push the boundaries of his conquests while I attempt to push back. The only thing that I'm sort of giving up on at this time is my British night fighters - I'm just going to stand them down for a couple of weeks. Maybe if their morale goes up they will find the target once in a while.

Otherwise, as far as action goes, there was all sorts. One of my subs that was cruising along the north shore of PNG found and put a torpedo into a Japanese AP that had some troops in it. But a few hundred miles away to the west of PNG a group of Japanese APDs ran over and sank a Dutch sub. More Japanese subs appeared in the waters between Canton Island and Palmyra too - I'll have to do something about them.

There were more air battles in China. That big Oscar group did a sweep of Hengchow again, but I didn't have any planes in the air so it was for naught as far as the Japanese go. But a big Oscar/Zero sweep over Homan turned quite bloody. My Mohawks hammered the Oscars hard, but the Zeros blasted my Mohawks out of the air. Then a Daitai of Zeros came in escorting a group of Sallys. Again the Zeros blasted my Mohawks but fortunately the Sallys didn't hit anything. But then another smaller sweep of Oscars and Zeros came in and my remaining Mohawks handled them easily. Obviously Tophat has a couple of really good Zero Daitais in China amongst a number of ordinary ones. BTW - my bombers at Sian flew and hammered Tophat's troops at Homan hard, despite all the other fighting in the air over Homan.

One thing that Tophat has changed in China is the location of his air units - he has moved them back in an attempt to get them out of reach of my bombers in China. But my bombers have pretty "long legs" and I will be sending all of them after that base with the good Daitai next turn. BTW - Tophat's land attacks in China are not doing so well, particularly at Kungchang where for the last two turns his bombardment attacks have caused no Chinese casualties at all.

Elsewhere, the daily air raid on Soerabaja caused the Dutch forces no measurable damage while causing about half of the Japanese bombers to be hit by flak. And at Dili Tophat now has LR CAP in place that intercepted and shot down some of the transport planes that I was using to try to drop off supplies. So I am stopping the flights to Dili and focusing on flying supplies to Lautem instead. Also, next turn I am sending that B-17 group to Dili again to attack the Japanese ground forces. The B-17s ought to help to "take care of" the LR CAP too. But all that air activity aside, the oddest thing was that when Tophat's ground troops tried a deliberate attack at the end of the turn they failed to cause much in the way of casualties at all and only got a 0:1 result.

Dave Baranyi
User avatar
ADavidB
Posts: 2464
Joined: Mon Sep 17, 2001 8:00 am
Location: Toronto, Canada

July 1 (Avengers...)

Post by ADavidB »

July 1 -

This was another hard fought turn with both sides taking casualties but neither side getting an overall edge in the fighting. We both continue to manoeuvre to try to get local superiority in forces but the fighting is spread out over such a wide area that it is very difficult to do. This confirms to me that my early strategy of husbanding my forces is now paying off since I can meet Tophat's advances everywhere, but I am still concerned about the potential for a Japanese breakthrough if I slip up at any of the Fronts.

In the DEI Tophat sent a cruiser TF to bombard Dili this turn while he rests and re-supplies his battleship TF. The attack did cause some damage, but nothing particularly critical. A group of Bettys then flew in to bomb the Dutch troops. Then my B-17s flew out of Darwin and blew past the Zeros on LR CAP at Dili, inflicting reasonable casualties on the invading Japanese SNLF unit. The sum result of these preliminary actions was quite satisfying; the deliberate attack by the SNLF unit on Dili was a complete failure, with no casualties to the Dutch and substantial casualties to the attackers. Tophat will have to bring greater forces to bear at Dili.

There was action in Java too as one of my remaining Dutch subs torpedoed an AP carrying fresh troop to Kragen, causing serious damage and casualties. But the escorts in the Japanese TF hit the sub with a couple of depth charges, causing severe damage in return. It is a good thing that Soerabaja is so close; I will try to get the sub there and see if I can repair the flooding damage before Tophat decides to bomb the port.

In Soerabaja itself Tophat sent in one air attack against the airfields again and another air attack against the Dutch ground troops. Neither caused a lot of damage or casualties and in both cases the AA hit the attackers hard, but this new strategy is paying off for Tophat as he is starting to regularly reduce the supply level at Soerabaja by a small amount every day. Tophat also used his full attacking force to do an artillery bombardment of Soerabaja this turn instead of just using the dedicated artillery units. However, with around 42K of supplies still available and a slow but steady replacement every day the Dutch ought to be able to continue to fight at near full strength for some time yet.

In the South Pacific my B-17s out of Canton Island blew past the Zeros on CAP, shooting down one and causing a little damage to the air field without suffering too much damage themselves. So this attack was effective in giving my bomber pilots experience even if the overall result wasn't great. With any luck I will give Tophat and the defenders at Baker Island a much bigger surprise soon enough.

In China both sides continue to spar and give each other the occasional solid blow without landing any knockouts. My Wellingtons hit Kaifeng hard but suffered a fair number of casualties in exchange:

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Day Air attack on Kaifeng, at 51, 32

Japanese aircraft
A6M3 Zero x 12
Ki-43-Ib Oscar x 14

Allied aircraft
Wellington III x 78

Japanese aircraft losses
A6M3 Zero: 3 destroyed, 5 damaged
Ki-43-Ib Oscar: 2 destroyed

Allied aircraft losses
Wellington III: 6 destroyed, 13 damaged

Airbase hits 4
Airbase supply hits 1
Runway hits 16

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I’m sending the Wellingtons out again this turn to hit Wuhan; I'm hoping that this will catch Tophat with his CAP down because I don't usually fly big bombing missions two days in a row. My Chinese bombers also did their regular good job of bombing the Japanese troops that are besieging Kungchang and Homan. At this point the attackers at Kungchang no longer have the capability to cause any casualties during their daily bombardment attacks.

But at the same time Tophat sent a well-escorted big bombing raid over Hengchow and caused a fair amount of damage to the airfield there. This was followed up by another big fighter sweep, so it looks as if Tophat has decided to challenge me now at Hengchow. I will need to build up a serious response force there to be able to take on the consolidated Japanese air forces. Right now I am trying to avoid feeding my better units piecemeal into a meat grinder. I've got plenty of units in India but for the most part they aren't trained well enough to send into battle with the good Japanese units that Tophat is using in Coastal China. So I am trying to bring my units in slowly and let them build experience against the Japanese ground troops in Northeastern China first before committing them to the air battles in the South.

And no, I haven't committed the AVG to China yet. I still have them sitting back, enjoying curry and beer in India. They are my trump cards that keep Tophat from attempting any "adventuring" in the Bay of Bengal. If Tophat sees the AVG pop-up in China he will know that the balance of air power has shifted in India. He will also be tempted to throw everything he can at the AVG in an attempt to wear it down. So I need to find the right combination of alternate forces to maintain an acceptable balance in China.

And this being the First of the Month, I received plenty of news; and this time quite good news. First off, there was no British withdrawal; therefore I continue to have substantial naval forces in India that can challenge anything but a total assault by the complete Combined Fleet. Next, my Yorktown-class carriers received their July upgrades which not only brought additional AA capability but also brought the larger, 36 plane fighter squadrons to all of my CVs. Add to this the appearance of Avengers in the air replacement pool and it won't be long before the US carriers are no longer "98 pound weaklings" in the Pacific.

So the July 1 statistics are in the following chart. I'm quite pleased that the victory point ratio is at a quite respectable 2.30 to 1. That's thanks to the continued survival of the Dutch forces at Soerabaja as well as to the fact that the Japanese air losses remain over 20% higher than the Allied air losses.

Dave Baranyi




Image
Attachments
July1stats.jpg
July1stats.jpg (41.51 KiB) Viewed 238 times
User avatar
PzB74
Posts: 5069
Joined: Tue Oct 03, 2000 8:00 am
Location: No(r)way

RE: July 1 (Avengers...)

Post by PzB74 »

Looks like you're doing well Dave [:)]

From my point of view the most exciting period playing the Allies is when the Japanese are rampant!
Guess you know the feeling - India is close to falling - is there anything you can do to stop them, is it possible that the war can really be lost!? [X(]
It takes either very aggressive play by the Japanese or a string of mistakes from the Allied player to get into such a situation. In your case it seems
like it's up to Tophat to provide the suspense <G>

Anyway, nice to read your AAR! I'm in mid July in my own Allied pbem game...and Mike Hall is really rampant [:'(]
Image

"The problem in defense is how far you can go without destroying from within what you are trying to defend from without"
- Dwight D. Eisenhower
User avatar
ADavidB
Posts: 2464
Joined: Mon Sep 17, 2001 8:00 am
Location: Toronto, Canada

RE: July 1 (Avengers...)

Post by ADavidB »

ORIGINAL: PzB

Looks like you're doing well Dave [:)]

From my point of view the most exciting period playing the Allies is when the Japanese are rampant!
Guess you know the feeling - India is close to falling - is there anything you can do to stop them, is it possible that the war can really be lost!? [X(]
It takes either very aggressive play by the Japanese or a string of mistakes from the Allied player to get into such a situation. In your case it seems
like it's up to Tophat to provide the suspense <G>

Anyway, nice to read your AAR! I'm in mid July in my own Allied pbem game...and Mike Hall is really rampant [:'(]

The "suspense" for me is knowing that I am within a couple of months of being able to turn the game around in a big way in a number of places; KB or no KB. But that depends upon my being able to keep Tophat tied up with my minor forces while I gather and position my major forces for some serious offensives.

Tophat is playing a lot like you did - he brings in very strong forces and makes certain that he can maintain the balance of power in his favor where he wants it. The big difference is that I have been able to gather my forces where I want and build them up so that they present a viable threat if Tophat overextends.

The temptation is there for me to do something about the DEI. But seeing how Wobbly overextended makes me continue with my overall plan rather than straying from it.

So we shall see what happens.

Thanks for the comments -

Dave
User avatar
ADavidB
Posts: 2464
Joined: Mon Sep 17, 2001 8:00 am
Location: Toronto, Canada

RE: July 1 (Avengers...)

Post by ADavidB »

July 2 -

This turn started out well then became quite tough. First off, a couple of Japanese APs that I hit before finally sank; one in Koepang Harbor and one in that TF that is still off of Dili. From there on things went progressively the wrong direction.

Tophat is committing better and better planes and pilots to the battle fronts so my earlier days of getting victories using what are frankly second string aircraft and pilots are pretty much over. So, for example, my Wellingtons hit Kaifeng and did okay against the Oscars on CAP, but the Zeros hit the Wellingtons hard:

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Day Air attack on Kaifeng, at 51, 32

Japanese aircraft
A6M3 Zero x 13
Ki-43-Ib Oscar x 9

Allied aircraft
Wellington III x 50

Japanese aircraft losses
A6M3 Zero: 1 destroyed, 6 damaged
Ki-43-Ib Oscar: 1 destroyed, 3 damaged

Allied aircraft losses
Wellington III: 8 destroyed, 6 damaged

Japanese ground losses:
27 casualties reported

Airbase hits 4
Airbase supply hits 2
Runway hits 27

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

It didn't help that I left one of my better Wellington squadrons set to attack Wuhan and it went in alone:

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Day Air attack on Wuhan, at 48, 35

Japanese aircraft
A6M3 Zero x 12
Ki-27 Nate x 5
Ki-43-Ib Oscar x 11

Allied aircraft
Wellington III x 8

Japanese aircraft losses
A6M3 Zero: 1 damaged
Ki-27 Nate: 1 destroyed
Ki-43-Ib Oscar: 1 damaged

Allied aircraft losses
Wellington III: 3 destroyed, 2 damaged

Airbase hits 1
Runway hits 6

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Fundamentally here, I got away with murder. So I've sat down all of my Wellingtons to let them rest and get replacements. I also sent the Chinese IL-4cs against the airfield at Hong Kong again and they did okay, but nothing really important.

However, Tophat sent a big attack at Hengchow with lots of good Oscars, Zeros and Sallys and did a lot of damage. It was a very good thing that I didn't have any of my weakened fighter units there. Oddly enough, the Chinese had all the airfield damage fixed by "morning". Of course, this all cost plenty of supply points and Tophat is determined to run me out of supply in China.

Even my attack on Baker Island didn't go that well. It appears that Tophat put in some fresh Zeros and while the B-17s held their own, they did take a lot of damage and they didn't get any hits on the air base. I'm going to have to do something different there.

The Allied air attack that worked the best was the B-17 raid on the invasion troops at Dili where the bombers caused a load of casualties for the Japanese. Then the Hudsons flew in against that CS again but they still couldn't find the range. And finally, one of my subs that was between Wake and the Marshalls had a clean shot at a Japanese AP but missed.

Against all that Tophat almost "casually" captured Lombok. I may be delaying Tophat in some places but I haven't really stopped his overall plans in any serious manner.

One strange happenstance occurred this turn. The level of supplies at Soerabaja went from 42K down to 22K! Neither the air nor the artillery attacks did any particularly special damage, so I'm not sure what happened. Also, the assault strength stayed the same. I've seen this sort of thing happen at Soerabaja in other games but in those cases the supplies moved to other bases like Batavia. I sure hope that the supplies didn't move this time because the Japanese control Batavia! [&:]

Oh well, I guess it is just another of the "mysteries" of the game.

Dave Baranyi
User avatar
BLurking
Posts: 201
Joined: Thu Mar 24, 2005 9:28 pm
Location: Frisco, TX

RE: July 1 (Avengers...)

Post by BLurking »

Check the CD batteries, they may have upgraded - and I don't believe that effects the assault value.
Maybe.
Heck, who knows?
User avatar
ADavidB
Posts: 2464
Joined: Mon Sep 17, 2001 8:00 am
Location: Toronto, Canada

RE: July 1 (Avengers...)

Post by ADavidB »

ORIGINAL: BLurking

Check the CD batteries, they may have upgraded - and I don't believe that effects the assault value.
Maybe.
Heck, who knows?

I thought that too, but a number of the CD units had already upgraded to 150mm guns, so it didn't seem to be the case. But maybe all of the base forces upgraded their guns. It sure would be nice if those 150 mm guns would fire on Tophat's troops since he doesn't seem to want to bring any ships into port... [;)]

Thanks for the comments -

Dave Baranyi
User avatar
ADavidB
Posts: 2464
Joined: Mon Sep 17, 2001 8:00 am
Location: Toronto, Canada

The USN Strikes...

Post by ADavidB »

July 3 -

There were surprisingly few air attacks this turn. Between the weather and the need for both sides to rest and repair their air units, few planes got into the air. I forgot to stand down my Chinese IL-4cs so they hit Hong Kong again causing a bit of damage. Likewise, Tophat's bombers hit Hengchow again but caused much less damage than in the previous turn. But most of the action was at sea for a change.

Tophat got very aggressive with his ASW for the first time in a while, chasing after one of my S-boats three times near Dili without hitting it, and sinking another sub to the East of Truk. Tophat's cruisers also came in to bombard Dili again. But the big news from the Allied point of view was that CENPAC surface forces finally got into action with a nice surprise bombardment of Baker Island:

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Naval bombardment of Baker Island, at 94, 92

Japanese aircraft
no flights

Japanese aircraft losses
A6M2 Zero: 1 destroyed

Allied Ships
DD Clark
DD Balch
DD Phelps
DD Selfridge
DD Porter
CA Pensacola
CA Chicago
CA Louisville
CA Chester
BB North Carolina

Japanese ground losses:
481 casualties reported
Guns lost 14

Airbase hits 1
Airbase supply hits 2
Runway hits 8
Port supply hits 5

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I was a bit disappointed that the bombardment only hit one plane and didn't cause more damage to the air base, but still it is a very nice change of pace from being so often on the receiving end of bombardments. This also sends a number of messages to Tophat about my increasing capabilities. I'll refuel this TF at Canton Island then send it down to Pago-Pago where I intend to begin to set up a major center for future operations into the "belly" of the Japanese Central Pacific islands.

And in the ground war, Tophat only did artillery bombardments this turn. But he has more ground troops on the way to Soerabaja, so I can expect another attempt to breach the defenses there to happen in the near future.

Dave Baranyi
Post Reply

Return to “After Action Reports”