ORIGINAL: viberpol
ORIGINAL: castor troy
hmm, how do you think Noumea OR Canton would be properly defended two or three weeks after the war started? From Noumea to Johnston Island there are perhaps 250 av all together!
While it wasn´t really smart to attack KB I can also understand your opponent when finding it strange also. [8|] In the game you can bypass thousands of miles to invade some places deep in the southern Pacific. Take every island there and after two months you begin to attack the SRA. That´s not possible in real life but it´s the best way in the game... [8|]
Castor, the funny thing is I did not conquer Noumea.
I don't think I would, eventually.
I had 4 JAP Divisions engaged at Manila, rest of my assault was on Malaya -- heading Singapore... as "proper" as it should be
All INF reinforcements I got landed at Mersing to cut out the withdrawing Allies.
How on earth could I get AND HOLD Noumea attacked with a single (52nd.. I think.. with changed HQ from HIsland HQ) division and several Japanese marine NLFs?
AND this was mod! My opponent had several French units and IND divisions trasfered to Malaya, Lightnings adn Davointine D520 from the early game.. etc.
ORIGINAL: herwin
Definitely ahistorical and not logistically supportable. The closest fleet base was Truk, and that was 2000 miles away. No land-based air cover. The invasion fleet would have taken several weeks to load and get there. Exactly zero chance of surprise. It wasn't until Rabaul was taken and some airbases established in the Solomons that Suva and Noumea were vulnerable to anything more than a random raid.
Of course, I'm speaking as a naval analyst, not a gamer.
And herwin, I invaded Luganville and Etafe the week before -- having even the air CAP over my transports.
And it was a surprise -- how can I explain Lightnigs strafing my CV's?
He didn' expect KB to be there? Underestimate the power of my surface TFs and morale of my night trained crew? [:D] And last, but not least, gave the wrong orders.. [;)]
Ok, but this thread is not on assesing the strategy, but to point out how important is a solid opponent![]()
okay, you didn´t take Noumea. You took Luganville and Efate... [8|] Completely different... [8|] As said before, if he goes toe by toe with his three carriers against KB then that isn´t surprising that all what he brought is sunk. If he quits because of this then it´s a shame. If he quits because he loses bases in the south Pacific within a month after PH then it´s different. As Herwin pointed out it´s just not possible in real life to bypass thousands of miles of enemy territory. In the game you can because you know that those dozens of enemy bases you bypassed aren´t doing you any harm.
That´s something you should discuss earlier. Even if you might lose the surprise factor, he can´t do anything about it anyway... even if he knows you would go after New Caledonia within the first couple of weeks.
I´m experiencing the same at the moment against John 3rd as he took New Caledonia without trouble (only one BF present) but he got a bloody nose further east when I sunk 2CVs and one CVL against no damage on my side. You can´t be everywhere at once as IJN but you can bring the complete KB to rule the place where it is present. For me it isn´t a problem if my opponent goes to India, the South Pacific, Austrailia,.... but there are many people who consider that "a problem".
Just explain me how on earth New Caledonia, Fiji, Canton,.... would have been conquered in real life two or three weeks after PH...




