fortification building question

This new stand alone release based on the legendary War in the Pacific from 2 by 3 Games adds significant improvements and changes to enhance game play, improve realism, and increase historical accuracy. With dozens of new features, new art, and engine improvements, War in the Pacific: Admiral's Edition brings you the most realistic and immersive WWII Pacific Theater wargame ever!

Moderators: wdolson, MOD_War-in-the-Pacific-Admirals-Edition

User avatar
Icedawg
Posts: 1613
Joined: Fri Jan 27, 2006 8:55 pm
Location: Upstate New York

RE: fortification building question

Post by Icedawg »

ORIGINAL: Lowpe

If that airfield is operational, what is there to stop you from flying in fighters to cap trap, or flying in bombers, even 4es, for a quick raid. It is a big airfield, with air hqs, and is very dangerous.

Not many allied bombers are dangerous in late 41 and early 42. Furthermore, most allied fighters are just target practice and experience/skill builders for Japanese fighter pilots.

Trying to stand and fight in an area the Japanese player is focused on is nothing short of suicide at this point in the war. Instead, finding a slightly out-of-the-way base that can be used to hit less-defended Japanese bases is probably the way to go until mid 42.

My current opponent had moderate success doing this. His B-17s flying at long range found some ports I didn't adequately CAP. Result - about 20 xAKs sunk in port. It didn't stop my offensive (or even seriously slow it down), but it did bag him some nice easy victory points and cost me a few high-end xAKs.
User avatar
EHansen
Posts: 360
Joined: Fri Dec 06, 2013 1:31 am

RE: fortification building question

Post by EHansen »

ORIGINAL: Icedawg
ORIGINAL: Lowpe

If that airfield is operational, what is there to stop you from flying in fighters to cap trap, or flying in bombers, even 4es, for a quick raid. It is a big airfield, with air hqs, and is very dangerous.

Not many allied bombers are dangerous in late 41 and early 42. Furthermore, most allied fighters are just target practice and experience/skill builders for Japanese fighter pilots.

Trying to stand and fight in an area the Japanese player is focused on is nothing short of suicide at this point in the war. Instead, finding a slightly out-of-the-way base that can be used to hit less-defended Japanese bases is probably the way to go until mid 42.

My current opponent had moderate success doing this. His B-17s flying at long range found some ports I didn't adequately CAP. Result - about 20 xAKs sunk in port. It didn't stop my offensive (or even seriously slow it down), but it did bag him some nice easy victory points and cost me a few high-end xAKs.

And never discount the moral boost he got. [:)]
rroberson
Posts: 2057
Joined: Tue May 25, 2004 7:53 am
Location: Arizona
Contact:

RE: fortification building question

Post by rroberson »

ORIGINAL: Lowpe

If that airfield is operational, what is there to stop you from flying in fighters to cap trap, or flying in bombers, even 4es, for a quick raid. It is a big airfield, with air hqs, and is very dangerous.


Mostly it's January 1942. Buffs die in the sky. I spent most of them in December 1941 flying suicide CAP missions. At this point he controls the air and there isn't much I can do about it.

Usually I can hang with Singapore until march or even April depending on my opponent. I usually do it building up the fortress and running supplies in. Sans the fortress the place may go down at the historical date.

We shall see.
Image
rroberson
Posts: 2057
Joined: Tue May 25, 2004 7:53 am
Location: Arizona
Contact:

RE: fortification building question

Post by rroberson »

ORIGINAL: witpqs
ORIGINAL: rroberson

I suppose I need to start haunting the forums again. I had no idea that the 10K thing and the naval attacks with HBs had been resolved. Its been one of those long held "house" rules things I had always just accepted.
I must point out that opinions vary about this as much as anything else, but I'm sure you already realized that! [:D]


Ain't that the truth!
Image
User avatar
castor troy
Posts: 14331
Joined: Mon Aug 23, 2004 10:17 am
Location: Austria

RE: fortification building question

Post by castor troy »

ORIGINAL: rroberson

I suppose I need to start haunting the forums again. I had no idea that the 10K thing and the naval attacks with HBs had been resolved. Its been one of those long held "house" rules things I had always just accepted.

4E bombers are still extremely effective in naval attacks if they have skilled crews, no matter what. This has become worse with one of the betas that changed attack altitudes and the effect on the load out. Now you can bomb from 2000ft with level bombers dropping their full load, which means a B-17 drops 8x500lb bombs on your ships and a B-24 even 10x500lb bombs while it earlier was halved bomb load from below 6000ft when not being an attack bomber. If you play Babes you will have a harder time due to increased flak effects but that will mostly mean you take more damaged bombers, the enemy still takes a sunken fleet. I'd really suggest keeping a hr on this, I usually restrict low nav bombing with 4E to Navy bombers.

Adding in that at some point it was changed that a bomber can only score one hit no matter how many bombs he carries to more hits per bomber you will end up with the 4E being the most effective anti naval option under above's circumstances. Realising what the beta did with the bomb loads during low nav attacks I've ran roughly 50 turns comparing 4E (B-24) at 2000ft with attack bombers (B25) at 1000ft and dive bombers (SBD) dive bombing 10000ft, all having 70 skilled crews against various targets like DD, merchant convoys up to CV/BB groups. Now the big surprise, the B-24 scored the most hits... even if the SBD scored 1000lb bomb hits, on all targets that could be penetrated by 500lb bombs, the B-24 came up first, followed by the B-25 and the SBD was last. And to me it just showed that having a big number of die rolls to score hits is just the best you can get. So the two changes to the game (more possible hits per bomber and no load reduction if above 1000ft) really has put the game upside down and I wonder why that hasn't really been noticed so far it seems.
User avatar
Lowpe
Posts: 24582
Joined: Mon Feb 25, 2013 2:25 pm

RE: fortification building question

Post by Lowpe »

ORIGINAL: Icedawg
Not many allied bombers are dangerous in late 41 and early 42. Furthermore, most allied fighters are just target practice and experience/skill builders for Japanese fighter pilots.

Trying to stand and fight in an area the Japanese player is focused on is nothing short of suicide at this point in the war. Instead, finding a slightly out-of-the-way base that can be used to hit less-defended Japanese bases is probably the way to go until mid 42.

My current opponent had moderate success doing this. His B-17s flying at long range found some ports I didn't adequately CAP. Result - about 20 xAKs sunk in port. It didn't stop my offensive (or even seriously slow it down), but it did bag him some nice easy victory points and cost me a few high-end xAKs.

I am not advocating standing and fighting, but flying in and out with a trap or surprise raid.

Obviously, I don't know all the particulars in this game, but as Allies you could get the AVG there, or P40's from Manila, B17s from PI, etc. Only a dozen B17s flying low can do a lot of damage because the drop so many bombs, especially a surprise raid. Plus air HQs make them even more dangerous.

Additionally, you could be flying troops in (unlikely) or out (likely) and running supply missions.

All of these are reasons to bomb the airfield even if no planes are currently present. Plus, you get the added benefit of forestalling fort building.[:)]

Plus, in 1943 and later the Allies will be bombing empty airbases or ports to keep them suppressed, and that too will prevent fort building.




rroberson
Posts: 2057
Joined: Tue May 25, 2004 7:53 am
Location: Arizona
Contact:

RE: fortification building question

Post by rroberson »

ORIGINAL: castor troy
ORIGINAL: rroberson

I suppose I need to start haunting the forums again. I had no idea that the 10K thing and the naval attacks with HBs had been resolved. Its been one of those long held "house" rules things I had always just accepted.

4E bombers are still extremely effective in naval attacks if they have skilled crews, no matter what. This has become worse with one of the betas that changed attack altitudes and the effect on the load out. Now you can bomb from 2000ft with level bombers dropping their full load, which means a B-17 drops 8x500lb bombs on your ships and a B-24 even 10x500lb bombs while it earlier was halved bomb load from below 6000ft when not being an attack bomber. If you play Babes you will have a harder time due to increased flak effects but that will mostly mean you take more damaged bombers, the enemy still takes a sunken fleet. I'd really suggest keeping a hr on this, I usually restrict low nav bombing with 4E to Navy bombers.

Adding in that at some point it was changed that a bomber can only score one hit no matter how many bombs he carries to more hits per bomber you will end up with the 4E being the most effective anti naval option under above's circumstances. Realising what the beta did with the bomb loads during low nav attacks I've ran roughly 50 turns comparing 4E (B-24) at 2000ft with attack bombers (B25) at 1000ft and dive bombers (SBD) dive bombing 10000ft, all having 70 skilled crews against various targets like DD, merchant convoys up to CV/BB groups. Now the big surprise, the B-24 scored the most hits... even if the SBD scored 1000lb bomb hits, on all targets that could be penetrated by 500lb bombs, the B-24 came up first, followed by the B-25 and the SBD was last. And to me it just showed that having a big number of die rolls to score hits is just the best you can get. So the two changes to the game (more possible hits per bomber and no load reduction if above 1000ft) really has put the game upside down and I wonder why that hasn't really been noticed so far it seems.


Egads that's horrible. Yeah that HR should remain in place. I have been going with the standard no 4Es against naval targets...that practice will continue.
Image
User avatar
Bullwinkle58
Posts: 11297
Joined: Tue Feb 24, 2009 12:47 pm

RE: fortification building question

Post by Bullwinkle58 »

ORIGINAL: rroberson

Egads that's horrible. Yeah that HR should remain in place. I have been going with the standard no 4Es against naval targets...that practice will continue.

It's not horrible. It is, as usual when 4Es are discussed, half the story.

You don't need to play Babes to get the flak upgrades. They are addable in a stock scenario. Lokasenna and I are playing with them (also the ASW changes.) At 2000 feet anything and everything on the ground can generate damage on the 4E.

Second, the test requires trained naval attack crews in the 4Es. Those are hard to mix with trained Ground attack pilots. It takes a long time to train both, or it takes swapping for Naval and waiting the delay for the pilots to show up. By then the port might be clean.

Third, VPs for 4E are doubled. Shoot down three and that's a basic IJN DD. It's a medium xAK. It's some I-boats. Given the replacement rates on 4Es that's a bad trade IMO, since in many cases one 500lb hit on those targets can be repaired if Fires are not too high.

Fourth, 4Es have a terrible ops loss rate from landing damaged. They don't get shot down that much early game, but they break out of sight of the Japanese player. If they land damaged they often take 7-10 days to be repaired at a medium-sized field. A DB is ready in a third to a quarter of the time.

Fifth, it is very expensive in terms of supply to get those bombs on target. Flying 25 4Es from an island will stress the supply burn severely and bring lots of xAKs into risk from subs.

I've probably done as many Port attacks with 4Es as most players and they are not a wonder weapon. Used against moving naval targets they're a terrible choice too. Worse. In some cases, where the Japan player masses 70 or more ships in a port in range of a bunch of 4Es, sure, use them. But not at 2000 feet. Crazy. Balloons alone will get them at 6000 or below. At 9000 and up they have a decent shot against flak, and most bombs will miss. They might get 3-4 hits, 1-2 of which might be fatal. Call it 6-12 VPs. Lose three and it's -6 against that sum, plus the damage, plus the supply, plus the use of av. support that doesn't go to any other friendly planes at that base.

Which is why, as I've long maintained and history showed, their primary use over the whole war ought to be on strategic targets.
The Moose
User avatar
Yaab
Posts: 5626
Joined: Tue Nov 08, 2011 2:09 pm
Location: Poland

RE: fortification building question

Post by Yaab »

By the way, most fighters use lower/upper front attack against unescorted bombers. At start, Claudes and Nates bring more firepower to the fight then the first B-17 version which packs just one 0.50 Browning if F position. Even Sonias pack more punch in F position.
User avatar
Bullwinkle58
Posts: 11297
Joined: Tue Feb 24, 2009 12:47 pm

RE: fortification building question

Post by Bullwinkle58 »

ORIGINAL: Yaab

By the way, most fighters use lower/upper front attack against unescorted bombers. At start, Claudes and Nates bring more firepower to the fight then the first B-17 version which packs just one 0.50 Browning if F position. Even Sonias pack more punch in F position.

I would not hesitate to send B-17s against any of those if the target was worth it.
The Moose
User avatar
witpqs
Posts: 26376
Joined: Mon Oct 04, 2004 7:48 pm
Location: Argleton

RE: fortification building question

Post by witpqs »

ORIGINAL: Bullwinkle58
ORIGINAL: rroberson

Egads that's horrible. Yeah that HR should remain in place. I have been going with the standard no 4Es against naval targets...that practice will continue.

It's not horrible. It is, as usual when 4Es are discussed, half the story.

You don't need to play Babes to get the flak upgrades. They are addable in a stock scenario. Lokasenna and I are playing with them (also the ASW changes.) At 2000 feet anything and everything on the ground can generate damage on the 4E.

Second, the test requires trained naval attack crews in the 4Es. Those are hard to mix with trained Ground attack pilots. It takes a long time to train both, or it takes swapping for Naval and waiting the delay for the pilots to show up. By then the port might be clean.

Third, VPs for 4E are doubled. Shoot down three and that's a basic IJN DD. It's a medium xAK. It's some I-boats. Given the replacement rates on 4Es that's a bad trade IMO, since in many cases one 500lb hit on those targets can be repaired if Fires are not too high.

Fourth, 4Es have a terrible ops loss rate from landing damaged. They don't get shot down that much early game, but they break out of sight of the Japanese player. If they land damaged they often take 7-10 days to be repaired at a medium-sized field. A DB is ready in a third to a quarter of the time.

Fifth, it is very expensive in terms of supply to get those bombs on target. Flying 25 4Es from an island will stress the supply burn severely and bring lots of xAKs into risk from subs.

I've probably done as many Port attacks with 4Es as most players and they are not a wonder weapon. Used against moving naval targets they're a terrible choice too. Worse. In some cases, where the Japan player masses 70 or more ships in a port in range of a bunch of 4Es, sure, use them. But not at 2000 feet. Crazy. Balloons alone will get them at 6000 or below. At 9000 and up they have a decent shot against flak, and most bombs will miss. They might get 3-4 hits, 1-2 of which might be fatal. Call it 6-12 VPs. Lose three and it's -6 against that sum, plus the damage, plus the supply, plus the use of av. support that doesn't go to any other friendly planes at that base.

Which is why, as I've long maintained and history showed, their primary use over the whole war ought to be on strategic targets.
+1

Good job shooting down 4E FUD. [:)]
User avatar
Lokasenna
Posts: 9304
Joined: Sat Mar 03, 2012 3:57 am
Location: Iowan in MD/DC

RE: fortification building question

Post by Lokasenna »

ORIGINAL: witpqs
ORIGINAL: Bullwinkle58
ORIGINAL: rroberson

Egads that's horrible. Yeah that HR should remain in place. I have been going with the standard no 4Es against naval targets...that practice will continue.

It's not horrible. It is, as usual when 4Es are discussed, half the story.

You don't need to play Babes to get the flak upgrades. They are addable in a stock scenario. Lokasenna and I are playing with them (also the ASW changes.) At 2000 feet anything and everything on the ground can generate damage on the 4E.

Second, the test requires trained naval attack crews in the 4Es. Those are hard to mix with trained Ground attack pilots. It takes a long time to train both, or it takes swapping for Naval and waiting the delay for the pilots to show up. By then the port might be clean.

Third, VPs for 4E are doubled. Shoot down three and that's a basic IJN DD. It's a medium xAK. It's some I-boats. Given the replacement rates on 4Es that's a bad trade IMO, since in many cases one 500lb hit on those targets can be repaired if Fires are not too high.

Fourth, 4Es have a terrible ops loss rate from landing damaged. They don't get shot down that much early game, but they break out of sight of the Japanese player. If they land damaged they often take 7-10 days to be repaired at a medium-sized field. A DB is ready in a third to a quarter of the time.

Fifth, it is very expensive in terms of supply to get those bombs on target. Flying 25 4Es from an island will stress the supply burn severely and bring lots of xAKs into risk from subs.

I've probably done as many Port attacks with 4Es as most players and they are not a wonder weapon. Used against moving naval targets they're a terrible choice too. Worse. In some cases, where the Japan player masses 70 or more ships in a port in range of a bunch of 4Es, sure, use them. But not at 2000 feet. Crazy. Balloons alone will get them at 6000 or below. At 9000 and up they have a decent shot against flak, and most bombs will miss. They might get 3-4 hits, 1-2 of which might be fatal. Call it 6-12 VPs. Lose three and it's -6 against that sum, plus the damage, plus the supply, plus the use of av. support that doesn't go to any other friendly planes at that base.

Which is why, as I've long maintained and history showed, their primary use over the whole war ought to be on strategic targets.
+1

Good job shooting down 4E FUD. [:)]

Agree.

In our game, if the 4Es hurt me on a port strike, it's because I didn't do my job in protecting myself. Even a modicum of CAP is fine. And flak will hurt them. 2 VPs for 4Es is a big swing on it, and then there are all of those intangibles (some of which can be mitigated by circumstance, such as use of aviation support, etc.), but VPs is a tangible and immutable cost.

And I just want to reiterate that I love shooting them down. Nates and Claudes won't do it, however, nor will Oscars. Zeroes can, sometimes. The 4Es are just too durable. Nicks on the other hand... I like that plane for this job. Does well against P-38s, too [;)].
User avatar
Bullwinkle58
Posts: 11297
Joined: Tue Feb 24, 2009 12:47 pm

RE: fortification building question

Post by Bullwinkle58 »

ORIGINAL: Lokasenna

ORIGINAL: witpqs
ORIGINAL: Bullwinkle58



It's not horrible. It is, as usual when 4Es are discussed, half the story.

You don't need to play Babes to get the flak upgrades. They are addable in a stock scenario. Lokasenna and I are playing with them (also the ASW changes.) At 2000 feet anything and everything on the ground can generate damage on the 4E.

Second, the test requires trained naval attack crews in the 4Es. Those are hard to mix with trained Ground attack pilots. It takes a long time to train both, or it takes swapping for Naval and waiting the delay for the pilots to show up. By then the port might be clean.

Third, VPs for 4E are doubled. Shoot down three and that's a basic IJN DD. It's a medium xAK. It's some I-boats. Given the replacement rates on 4Es that's a bad trade IMO, since in many cases one 500lb hit on those targets can be repaired if Fires are not too high.

Fourth, 4Es have a terrible ops loss rate from landing damaged. They don't get shot down that much early game, but they break out of sight of the Japanese player. If they land damaged they often take 7-10 days to be repaired at a medium-sized field. A DB is ready in a third to a quarter of the time.

Fifth, it is very expensive in terms of supply to get those bombs on target. Flying 25 4Es from an island will stress the supply burn severely and bring lots of xAKs into risk from subs.

I've probably done as many Port attacks with 4Es as most players and they are not a wonder weapon. Used against moving naval targets they're a terrible choice too. Worse. In some cases, where the Japan player masses 70 or more ships in a port in range of a bunch of 4Es, sure, use them. But not at 2000 feet. Crazy. Balloons alone will get them at 6000 or below. At 9000 and up they have a decent shot against flak, and most bombs will miss. They might get 3-4 hits, 1-2 of which might be fatal. Call it 6-12 VPs. Lose three and it's -6 against that sum, plus the damage, plus the supply, plus the use of av. support that doesn't go to any other friendly planes at that base.

Which is why, as I've long maintained and history showed, their primary use over the whole war ought to be on strategic targets.
+1

Good job shooting down 4E FUD. [:)]

Agree.

In our game, if the 4Es hurt me on a port strike, it's because I didn't do my job in protecting myself. Even a modicum of CAP is fine. And flak will hurt them. 2 VPs for 4Es is a big swing on it, and then there are all of those intangibles (some of which can be mitigated by circumstance, such as use of aviation support, etc.), but VPs is a tangible and immutable cost.

And I just want to reiterate that I love shooting them down. Nates and Claudes won't do it, however, nor will Oscars. Zeroes can, sometimes. The 4Es are just too durable. Nicks on the other hand... I like that plane for this job. Does well against P-38s, too [;)].

I don't like Nicks. I sweep them whenever I can. Their factory will burn first if I have anything to say about it. [:)]
The Moose
User avatar
castor troy
Posts: 14331
Joined: Mon Aug 23, 2004 10:17 am
Location: Austria

RE: fortification building question

Post by castor troy »

ORIGINAL: Bullwinkle58

ORIGINAL: rroberson

Egads that's horrible. Yeah that HR should remain in place. I have been going with the standard no 4Es against naval targets...that practice will continue.

It's not horrible. It is, as usual when 4Es are discussed, half the story.

You don't need to play Babes to get the flak upgrades. They are addable in a stock scenario. Lokasenna and I are playing with them (also the ASW changes.) At 2000 feet anything and everything on the ground can generate damage on the 4E.

Second, the test requires trained naval attack crews in the 4Es. Those are hard to mix with trained Ground attack pilots. It takes a long time to train both, or it takes swapping for Naval and waiting the delay for the pilots to show up. By then the port might be clean.

Third, VPs for 4E are doubled. Shoot down three and that's a basic IJN DD. It's a medium xAK. It's some I-boats. Given the replacement rates on 4Es that's a bad trade IMO, since in many cases one 500lb hit on those targets can be repaired if Fires are not too high.

Fourth, 4Es have a terrible ops loss rate from landing damaged. They don't get shot down that much early game, but they break out of sight of the Japanese player. If they land damaged they often take 7-10 days to be repaired at a medium-sized field. A DB is ready in a third to a quarter of the time.

Fifth, it is very expensive in terms of supply to get those bombs on target. Flying 25 4Es from an island will stress the supply burn severely and bring lots of xAKs into risk from subs.

I've probably done as many Port attacks with 4Es as most players and they are not a wonder weapon. Used against moving naval targets they're a terrible choice too. Worse. In some cases, where the Japan player masses 70 or more ships in a port in range of a bunch of 4Es, sure, use them. But not at 2000 feet. Crazy. Balloons alone will get them at 6000 or below. At 9000 and up they have a decent shot against flak, and most bombs will miss. They might get 3-4 hits, 1-2 of which might be fatal. Call it 6-12 VPs. Lose three and it's -6 against that sum, plus the damage, plus the supply, plus the use of av. support that doesn't go to any other friendly planes at that base.

Which is why, as I've long maintained and history showed, their primary use over the whole war ought to be on strategic targets.


all points you bring up are clearly forgetting one thing! Except the VP for a 4E it's all true for all other bombers too and even worse as all other bombers are shot down easier than the 4E so if you claim 4E would
take horrible losses from ops or whatever, EVERY other bomber type attacking at the same height with the same crews will take MORE losses and score LESS hits. Nobody said they are a wonder weapon, but they are
better than 2E level bombers, 2E attack bombers or 1E divebombers in naval attack so what gives, I don't know what you are trying to say. As if an Allied player would care about the supply difference of 4E flying
from an island instead of 2E when he can take out a couple of IJ cruisers when he would only damage them using his dive bombers. Which bomber type would one choose? Send dive bombers and damage the enemy or send
4E at 2000ft and sink the enemy?

And if you bring it down to the skill levels needed, yes, for naval attack you want to have high skills, usually 70 lownav but for attacks on ground targets, lower skills work just fine. Why? Because using
50 skilled lownav crews might get you only very few hits on ships but 50 skilled grdbmb crews can still work over any airfield or port they attack. And why you talk about low level port attacks running into
balloons is beyond me because it was about nav attacks, not bombing ships in port. If one attacks a defended port at 2000ft then he deserves all the damage he takes anyway. Attack at 10000ft with 100 bombers and
you clear a port of any shipping. That's 1000x500lb bombs if you use B-24 and that's like sniping in the game. If you lose more VP in 4E in a port attack when the port is filled with ships then I should just
stop the discussion here I guess because you are then either playing a completely different game than anyone else or are doing it horribly wrong. The AAR section is full of port attacks by all kind of bombers
from both sides and are showing a whole different picture than you paint.
User avatar
Bullwinkle58
Posts: 11297
Joined: Tue Feb 24, 2009 12:47 pm

RE: fortification building question

Post by Bullwinkle58 »

ORIGINAL: castor troy

ORIGINAL: Bullwinkle58

ORIGINAL: rroberson

Egads that's horrible. Yeah that HR should remain in place. I have been going with the standard no 4Es against naval targets...that practice will continue.

It's not horrible. It is, as usual when 4Es are discussed, half the story.

You don't need to play Babes to get the flak upgrades. They are addable in a stock scenario. Lokasenna and I are playing with them (also the ASW changes.) At 2000 feet anything and everything on the ground can generate damage on the 4E.

Second, the test requires trained naval attack crews in the 4Es. Those are hard to mix with trained Ground attack pilots. It takes a long time to train both, or it takes swapping for Naval and waiting the delay for the pilots to show up. By then the port might be clean.

Third, VPs for 4E are doubled. Shoot down three and that's a basic IJN DD. It's a medium xAK. It's some I-boats. Given the replacement rates on 4Es that's a bad trade IMO, since in many cases one 500lb hit on those targets can be repaired if Fires are not too high.

Fourth, 4Es have a terrible ops loss rate from landing damaged. They don't get shot down that much early game, but they break out of sight of the Japanese player. If they land damaged they often take 7-10 days to be repaired at a medium-sized field. A DB is ready in a third to a quarter of the time.

Fifth, it is very expensive in terms of supply to get those bombs on target. Flying 25 4Es from an island will stress the supply burn severely and bring lots of xAKs into risk from subs.

I've probably done as many Port attacks with 4Es as most players and they are not a wonder weapon. Used against moving naval targets they're a terrible choice too. Worse. In some cases, where the Japan player masses 70 or more ships in a port in range of a bunch of 4Es, sure, use them. But not at 2000 feet. Crazy. Balloons alone will get them at 6000 or below. At 9000 and up they have a decent shot against flak, and most bombs will miss. They might get 3-4 hits, 1-2 of which might be fatal. Call it 6-12 VPs. Lose three and it's -6 against that sum, plus the damage, plus the supply, plus the use of av. support that doesn't go to any other friendly planes at that base.

Which is why, as I've long maintained and history showed, their primary use over the whole war ought to be on strategic targets.


all points you bring up are clearly forgetting one thing! Except the VP for a 4E it's all true for all other bombers too and even worse as all other bombers are shot down easier than the 4E so if you claim 4E would
take horrible losses from ops or whatever, EVERY other bomber type attacking at the same height with the same crews will take MORE losses and score LESS hits. Nobody said they are a wonder weapon, but they are
better than 2E level bombers, 2E attack bombers or 1E divebombers in naval attack so what gives, I don't know what you are trying to say. As if an Allied player would care about the supply difference of 4E flying
from an island instead of 2E when he can take out a couple of IJ cruisers when he would only damage them using his dive bombers. Which bomber type would one choose? Send dive bombers and damage the enemy or send
4E at 2000ft and sink the enemy?

And if you bring it down to the skill levels needed, yes, for naval attack you want to have high skills, usually 70 lownav but for attacks on ground targets, lower skills work just fine. Why? Because using
50 skilled lownav crews might get you only very few hits on ships but 50 skilled grdbmb crews can still work over any airfield or port they attack.

I thought it was clear what I was saying. But again:

--few 4Es are provided to the Allies until very late in the war. Far more 2Es are available. 4Es are more valuable, and have double VPs awarded when lost

-- they drop only 500lb bombs. Never 1000. In that sense they are far less useful against IJN warships than DBs. Their lone advantage is range. Sometimes that makes them the only choice. But at six hexes if I had both available against warships would I send 4Es with a bigger bomb load? Heck no.

--ground bombing from altitude absolutely requires training. Or are you contending that is the one pilot skill when the skill is worthless? And it's virtually impossible to get a pilot to 60-70 in both ground and naval before he is killed.

--4Es taking higher percentage ops losses than 2Es on landing damaged is my impression. I don't have hard data.

--"what gives" is the same thing that gives in ASW and the Super E issue. More launchers is more chances for a hit. 4Es carry more bombs at more risk (VPs). They take damage they take a lot longer to repair and consume far more supplies and av support capability. That ratio is up to the player to decide as to its worth.

But all in, for port attacks against ships, 4Es are the worst aircraft option there is except when they're the only option due to range.
The Moose
User avatar
castor troy
Posts: 14331
Joined: Mon Aug 23, 2004 10:17 am
Location: Austria

RE: fortification building question

Post by castor troy »

ORIGINAL: Lokasenna

ORIGINAL: witpqs
ORIGINAL: Bullwinkle58



It's not horrible. It is, as usual when 4Es are discussed, half the story.

You don't need to play Babes to get the flak upgrades. They are addable in a stock scenario. Lokasenna and I are playing with them (also the ASW changes.) At 2000 feet anything and everything on the ground can generate damage on the 4E.

Second, the test requires trained naval attack crews in the 4Es. Those are hard to mix with trained Ground attack pilots. It takes a long time to train both, or it takes swapping for Naval and waiting the delay for the pilots to show up. By then the port might be clean.

Third, VPs for 4E are doubled. Shoot down three and that's a basic IJN DD. It's a medium xAK. It's some I-boats. Given the replacement rates on 4Es that's a bad trade IMO, since in many cases one 500lb hit on those targets can be repaired if Fires are not too high.

Fourth, 4Es have a terrible ops loss rate from landing damaged. They don't get shot down that much early game, but they break out of sight of the Japanese player. If they land damaged they often take 7-10 days to be repaired at a medium-sized field. A DB is ready in a third to a quarter of the time.

Fifth, it is very expensive in terms of supply to get those bombs on target. Flying 25 4Es from an island will stress the supply burn severely and bring lots of xAKs into risk from subs.

I've probably done as many Port attacks with 4Es as most players and they are not a wonder weapon. Used against moving naval targets they're a terrible choice too. Worse. In some cases, where the Japan player masses 70 or more ships in a port in range of a bunch of 4Es, sure, use them. But not at 2000 feet. Crazy. Balloons alone will get them at 6000 or below. At 9000 and up they have a decent shot against flak, and most bombs will miss. They might get 3-4 hits, 1-2 of which might be fatal. Call it 6-12 VPs. Lose three and it's -6 against that sum, plus the damage, plus the supply, plus the use of av. support that doesn't go to any other friendly planes at that base.

Which is why, as I've long maintained and history showed, their primary use over the whole war ought to be on strategic targets.
+1

Good job shooting down 4E FUD. [:)]

Agree.

In our game, if the 4Es hurt me on a port strike, it's because I didn't do my job in protecting myself. Even a modicum of CAP is fine. And flak will hurt them. 2 VPs for 4Es is a big swing on it, and then there are all of those intangibles (some of which can be mitigated by circumstance, such as use of aviation support, etc.), but VPs is a tangible and immutable cost.

And I just want to reiterate that I love shooting them down. Nates and Claudes won't do it, however, nor will Oscars. Zeroes can, sometimes. The 4Es are just too durable. Nicks on the other hand... I like that plane for this job. Does well against P-38s, too [;)].


and it makes me wonder when rroberson and my reply is talking about nav attacks why this is taken over to PORT attacks. Now a) I haven't heard about a common hr about PORT attack restrictions of 4E but naval attacks
and b) like I've said in my first post, 4E will score more hits and will take less losses than any other type if used in the same way.

Sorry to be rude, arrogant or whatever one wants to call me, but I got no clue why years after release some people are spreading things on the forum that were never true and still aren't true due to some beta
changes. The beta made the 4Es even MORE effective because they can attack with FULL bomb load at low level while they couldn't do so in all the previous years. It's close to ridicoulos to me when the majority
of experienced and long time PBEM players had a hr about 4E on naval attack with the official patch settings and now that the beta changes the bomb loads to FULL load there are people happily claiming 4E on
nav attack are not effective for whatever reason. My mood is going from laughing about it to shaking my head constantly lately. Wake up, TEST it and continue the discussion.

A 4E will do it better in every respect than any other bomber in your arsenal, because it is more durable, got more range and got a shitload of bombs to drop. So if you put a pilot of whatever skill into a 2E bomber
it will score x hits and the unit will suffer x losses. Put the same pilot into a 4E and you will score x+ hits for x- losses. And if you test it, none of the tests will show a different outcome because the game
is working the same for just everyone. Also the fact that 4E don't undergo the escort die roll to attack like any other bomber type does was also missing in the "what makes 4E bombers so bad in attacks on shipping list".
User avatar
castor troy
Posts: 14331
Joined: Mon Aug 23, 2004 10:17 am
Location: Austria

RE: fortification building question

Post by castor troy »

ORIGINAL: Bullwinkle58
ORIGINAL: castor troy

ORIGINAL: Bullwinkle58




It's not horrible. It is, as usual when 4Es are discussed, half the story.

You don't need to play Babes to get the flak upgrades. They are addable in a stock scenario. Lokasenna and I are playing with them (also the ASW changes.) At 2000 feet anything and everything on the ground can generate damage on the 4E.

Second, the test requires trained naval attack crews in the 4Es. Those are hard to mix with trained Ground attack pilots. It takes a long time to train both, or it takes swapping for Naval and waiting the delay for the pilots to show up. By then the port might be clean.

Third, VPs for 4E are doubled. Shoot down three and that's a basic IJN DD. It's a medium xAK. It's some I-boats. Given the replacement rates on 4Es that's a bad trade IMO, since in many cases one 500lb hit on those targets can be repaired if Fires are not too high.

Fourth, 4Es have a terrible ops loss rate from landing damaged. They don't get shot down that much early game, but they break out of sight of the Japanese player. If they land damaged they often take 7-10 days to be repaired at a medium-sized field. A DB is ready in a third to a quarter of the time.

Fifth, it is very expensive in terms of supply to get those bombs on target. Flying 25 4Es from an island will stress the supply burn severely and bring lots of xAKs into risk from subs.

I've probably done as many Port attacks with 4Es as most players and they are not a wonder weapon. Used against moving naval targets they're a terrible choice too. Worse. In some cases, where the Japan player masses 70 or more ships in a port in range of a bunch of 4Es, sure, use them. But not at 2000 feet. Crazy. Balloons alone will get them at 6000 or below. At 9000 and up they have a decent shot against flak, and most bombs will miss. They might get 3-4 hits, 1-2 of which might be fatal. Call it 6-12 VPs. Lose three and it's -6 against that sum, plus the damage, plus the supply, plus the use of av. support that doesn't go to any other friendly planes at that base.

Which is why, as I've long maintained and history showed, their primary use over the whole war ought to be on strategic targets.


all points you bring up are clearly forgetting one thing! Except the VP for a 4E it's all true for all other bombers too and even worse as all other bombers are shot down easier than the 4E so if you claim 4E would
take horrible losses from ops or whatever, EVERY other bomber type attacking at the same height with the same crews will take MORE losses and score LESS hits. Nobody said they are a wonder weapon, but they are
better than 2E level bombers, 2E attack bombers or 1E divebombers in naval attack so what gives, I don't know what you are trying to say. As if an Allied player would care about the supply difference of 4E flying
from an island instead of 2E when he can take out a couple of IJ cruisers when he would only damage them using his dive bombers. Which bomber type would one choose? Send dive bombers and damage the enemy or send
4E at 2000ft and sink the enemy?

And if you bring it down to the skill levels needed, yes, for naval attack you want to have high skills, usually 70 lownav but for attacks on ground targets, lower skills work just fine. Why? Because using
50 skilled lownav crews might get you only very few hits on ships but 50 skilled grdbmb crews can still work over any airfield or port they attack.

I thought it was clear what I was saying. But again:

--few 4Es are provided to the Allies until very late in the war. Far more 2Es are available. 4Es are more valuable, and have double VPs awarded when lost

look at the replacement rates of B-25 and B-24 and come back, let alone that you will lose 2Es easier (if you don't know why go back to start... 60+ dur compared to 40 dur) don't know how many Allied players that made it to late war stated that they had a shortage of 2E until very late in the war. Except those that do crazy things and wonder about their bomber losses in return are those that won't have ample 4E as soon as they get to mid/late war. I've got the strange feeling you are claiming by early war experience and B-17 replacement rates. My last Allied PBEM ended auto victory 1/44 and I had so many 4E bombers in the pool that I nearly fielded no 2E bomber squadrons at all.


-- they drop only 500lb bombs. Never 1000. In that sense they are far less useful against IJN warships than DBs. Their lone advantage is range. Sometimes that makes them the only choice. But at six hexes if I had both available against warships would I send 4Es with a bigger bomb load? Heck no.

and I am going to tell you that 10 times more 500lb bombs dropped from a bomber that just keeps flying will do far more damage than a couple of 1000lb bombs (except on the very few IJN cruisers that are 500lb bomb prove in stock)


--ground bombing from altitude absolutely requires training. Or are you contending that is the one pilot skill when the skill is worthless? And it's virtually impossible to get a pilot to 60-70 in both ground and naval before he is killed.

easy: 50 grd skill will still score bomb hits on airfields, dozens of hits. 50 lownav will yield you nearly no hits on ships in a nav attack notice the difference?


--4Es taking higher percentage ops losses than 2Es on landing damaged is my impression. I don't have hard data.

just not true, not true


--"what gives" is the same thing that gives in ASW and the Super E issue. More launchers is more chances for a hit. 4Es carry more bombs at more risk (VPs). They take damage they take a lot longer to repair and consume far more supplies and av support capability. That ratio is up to the player to decide as to its worth.

They take longer to repair! Yeah, we agree.


But all in, for port attacks against ships, 4Es are the worst aircraft option there is except when they're the only option due to range.

and this is the most absurd thing I have heard in all the years since release of WITP and I have been involved in lots of discussions. THIS tops everything and is plain ridicoulos, Sir.


you are clear and it clearly shows me you didn't test it. Never! I will keep this post as short as possible because like discussing things with other well known friends and their theories, if you test it you will see (hopefully) that 4E will do better than 2E and even 2E (non attack bombers) will do FAR better than dive bombers. The total damage done will be FAR higher than what dive bombers do. Of course it is, 10 bombs per bomber getting 10 die rolls to hit. A dive bomber will only do more damage if a target is attacked that can be penetrated by 1000lb bombs but not by 500lb bombs which is just a hand full of IJN cruisers. BB are prove to 1000lb bombs. Every other target will be penetrated by 500lb bombs and believe it or not, level bombers score so many more 500lb bomb hits than dive bombers score 1000lb bomb hits that the damage done will be far higher. AGAIN, test it. Takes you 3-4hrs to set it up and run the turns.

And I know this now really rude, if you say 2Es take less ops losses from damage than 4Es and 4Es are the worst choice for port attacks then you clearly have no clue about the game at all. This is like discussing
1 day after release. Oh my god. It's really nearly unbelievable to me what you are saying in above's post and that is not even exaggerated, it's just so far off it makes me scream.
Freedom205
Posts: 307
Joined: Mon Dec 04, 2000 10:00 am
Location: Michigan USA

RE: fortification building question

Post by Freedom205 »

ORIGINAL: castor troy
ORIGINAL: rroberson

I suppose I need to start haunting the forums again. I had no idea that the 10K thing and the naval attacks with HBs had been resolved. Its been one of those long held "house" rules things I had always just accepted.

4E bombers are still extremely effective in naval attacks if they have skilled crews, no matter what. This has become worse with one of the betas that changed attack altitudes and the effect on the load out. Now you can bomb from 2000ft with level bombers dropping their full load, which means a B-17 drops 8x500lb bombs on your ships and a B-24 even 10x500lb bombs while it earlier was halved bomb load from below 6000ft when not being an attack bomber. If you play Babes you will have a harder time due to increased flak effects but that will mostly mean you take more damaged bombers, the enemy still takes a sunken fleet. I'd really suggest keeping a hr on this, I usually restrict low nav bombing with 4E to Navy bombers.

Adding in that at some point it was changed that a bomber can only score one hit no matter how many bombs he carries to more hits per bomber you will end up with the 4E being the most effective anti naval option under above's circumstances. Realising what the beta did with the bomb loads during low nav attacks I've ran roughly 50 turns comparing 4E (B-24) at 2000ft with attack bombers (B25) at 1000ft and dive bombers (SBD) dive bombing 10000ft, all having 70 skilled crews against various targets like DD, merchant convoys up to CV/BB groups. Now the big surprise, the B-24 scored the most hits... even if the SBD scored 1000lb bomb hits, on all targets that could be penetrated by 500lb bombs, the B-24 came up first, followed by the B-25 and the SBD was last. And to me it just showed that having a big number of die rolls to score hits is just the best you can get. So the two changes to the game (more possible hits per bomber and no load reduction if above 1000ft) really has put the game upside down and I wonder why that hasn't really been noticed so far it seems.
I had noticed the same when I starting playing Beta a few years back. I did some test runs where 10 B-17s would score more hits on ships in port that 40 SBDs would. The big loser was always Tankers or CVs. If the US sends in trained 4e to bomb a port with tankers or CVs in it, the tankers and CVs will be toast. In one test run I did 10, B-17s sank 7 tankers in 1 raid. I am always open to new information but I havnt seen anything that states that this level bombing accuracy has changed. Where this becomes an issue is no port is safe if the allies decide to stage 4e from China. It is very troubling when 10 to 20 4e based in China hit Nagasaki or Takao and take out more Tankers or a CV in 1 raid than Subs take out in a whole year.
User avatar
Bullwinkle58
Posts: 11297
Joined: Tue Feb 24, 2009 12:47 pm

RE: fortification building question

Post by Bullwinkle58 »

I don't need to test it, CT. I've done it in two PBEM games. Never hit a ship with 4Es. But no, I don't fly them at 2000 feet over flak-infested warships. I hit ships a lot with DBs from 15,000, as they were designed to do.

As for rude, yeah, you are, as usual. I'm accused of that sometimes. I think we probably ought not to talk to each other a lot.
The Moose
User avatar
Lokasenna
Posts: 9304
Joined: Sat Mar 03, 2012 3:57 am
Location: Iowan in MD/DC

RE: fortification building question

Post by Lokasenna »

ORIGINAL: Mike Hall
ORIGINAL: castor troy
ORIGINAL: rroberson

I suppose I need to start haunting the forums again. I had no idea that the 10K thing and the naval attacks with HBs had been resolved. Its been one of those long held "house" rules things I had always just accepted.

4E bombers are still extremely effective in naval attacks if they have skilled crews, no matter what. This has become worse with one of the betas that changed attack altitudes and the effect on the load out. Now you can bomb from 2000ft with level bombers dropping their full load, which means a B-17 drops 8x500lb bombs on your ships and a B-24 even 10x500lb bombs while it earlier was halved bomb load from below 6000ft when not being an attack bomber. If you play Babes you will have a harder time due to increased flak effects but that will mostly mean you take more damaged bombers, the enemy still takes a sunken fleet. I'd really suggest keeping a hr on this, I usually restrict low nav bombing with 4E to Navy bombers.

Adding in that at some point it was changed that a bomber can only score one hit no matter how many bombs he carries to more hits per bomber you will end up with the 4E being the most effective anti naval option under above's circumstances. Realising what the beta did with the bomb loads during low nav attacks I've ran roughly 50 turns comparing 4E (B-24) at 2000ft with attack bombers (B25) at 1000ft and dive bombers (SBD) dive bombing 10000ft, all having 70 skilled crews against various targets like DD, merchant convoys up to CV/BB groups. Now the big surprise, the B-24 scored the most hits... even if the SBD scored 1000lb bomb hits, on all targets that could be penetrated by 500lb bombs, the B-24 came up first, followed by the B-25 and the SBD was last. And to me it just showed that having a big number of die rolls to score hits is just the best you can get. So the two changes to the game (more possible hits per bomber and no load reduction if above 1000ft) really has put the game upside down and I wonder why that hasn't really been noticed so far it seems.
I had noticed the same when I starting playing Beta a few years back. I did some test runs where 10 B-17s would score more hits on ships in port that 40 SBDs would. The big loser was always Tankers or CVs. If the US sends in trained 4e to bomb a port with tankers or CVs in it, the tankers and CVs will be toast. In one test run I did 10, B-17s sank 7 tankers in 1 raid. I am always open to new information but I havnt seen anything that states that this level bombing accuracy has changed. Where this becomes an issue is no port is safe if the allies decide to stage 4e from China. It is very troubling when 10 to 20 4e based in China hit Nagasaki or Takao and take out more Tankers or a CV in 1 raid than Subs take out in a whole year.

Well...ships in port are tied up to a pier. Pretty easy to hit with carpet bombing, if you ask me.
Post Reply

Return to “War in the Pacific: Admiral's Edition”