My favorite Puresim experience was when I found myself (actually) cheering and hollering (for real) after I was managing the game where my pitcher threw a no-hitter. Even my wife was excited!

Moderator: puresimmer
ORIGINAL: Bustoff
It's the least I could have done for the guy, at whom I screamed "What is WRONG with you?" many times during his previous appearances.
The winning run is on base, and one of your guys delivers in the clutch, getting that single or double that brings in the game-winning RBI.
ORIGINAL: Frozen Stiffer
On that same note, I must add the TWO, yes 2, occasions I have experienced when in my eagerness to get the game going, I hit ENTER to advance to the next play instead of pinch-hitting for a reliever that had just blown his save. In both cases, the reliever drove in the game-winning run. In one it was a solo-home run, in the other it was an RBI single.
Not only was the WIN unexpected, but WHO got the win!