Op doesn't seem realistic

[dandechino]

Last Stand Arnhem Operation playing as Germans. I move my BG to Arnhem bridge. The enemy puts up no resistence then launches a counterattack the next strategic turn. It seems like they would want to hold the bridge at all costs?

[dandechino]

The result.

[TheReal_Pak40]

Yea, I played that Op the other day and the same thing happened. Seems like the Allied Strategic AI wants to have as many bridges as possible rather than the one bridge that counts. Another victim of lack of beta testing for this game.

[xe5]

Victory in Ops/Camps (except for the GC) is based on VL points. The VL point breakdown in this Op:

Arnhem Road Bridge map = 29
North Arnhem = 12
Elden = 14
Westervoort = 15

Holding only the Arnhem Road Bridge map as the Allied player guarantees a minor Axis victory in the Op.
The strategic AI is merely moving to control the next highest source of VL points.

[TheReal_Pak40]

Hmmm. Well, I suppose that explains why he went to Westervoort. However, considering the circumstances it makes no sense to abandon the primary point map for the secondary when you know that an enemy unit will immediately steal the map that you just abandoned. Once again the AI in the game is rather simplistic in it's goals. And, I could be wrong, but I think the 2nd Bat is the only allied unit in this Op. Therefore, the best the allied side could hope for is to hold the main point map.

[Andrew Williams]

It states the case well for a more enhanced scenario editor.... or more thoughtful scenario design.

[Fred98]

ORIGINAL: Andrew Williams

...... or more thoughtful scenario design.

.....or the values of the objectives to be written on the strategic map.


-

[Tejszd]

ORIGINAL: Andrew Williams
It states the case well for a more enhanced scenario editor.... or more thoughtful scenario design.

Wonder if the Allied AI would still attack if the ops had one less map, thus holding the Arnhem Road Bridge map would guarantee the win? I'll have to test it....

Arnhem Road Bridge map = 29
North Arnhem = 12
Elden = 14
Westervoort = 15

Edit:
- All three German maps at some point have a German BG appear on them.
- Delayed the a BG arrival on Westervoort and made it arrive on the Arnhem Road Bridge a turn later. Removed Westervoot.
- The Allied AI still attacked out of the Arnhem Road bridge map, Elden now being the next highest value enemy held map.

The strat AI doesn't seem to recognize the GE BG threat to the highest value map that it is already holding or that it is already winning....