Indivisibiliter ac Inseparabiliter - K.u.K Kriegsmarine (Austria-Hungary) AAR - 1890 - HOSTED ON NWS FORUM

Rule the Waves III is a simulation of naval ship design and construction, fleet management and naval warfare from 1890 to 1970. and will place you in the role of 'Grand Admiral' of a navy from the time when steam and iron dominated warship design up to the missile age.
Post Reply
TheConeezeanEmperor
Posts: 4
Joined: Sat Apr 15, 2023 12:11 pm

Indivisibiliter ac Inseparabiliter - K.u.K Kriegsmarine (Austria-Hungary) AAR - 1890 - HOSTED ON NWS FORUM

Post by TheConeezeanEmperor »

(This is my first attempt at an AAR, but hardly my first playthrough of the Rule the Waves series, being a staunch fan since RTW1 (and an avid Austria-Hungary player all throughout). I do not know how much community overlap there is between Rule the Waves and From The Depths, but if there is some overlap, some of you may know me from that game's community, where I made a name for myself by producing hyper-detailed realistic ships based upon ships I had designed and used in Rule the Waves 1 and later 2, alongside my contributions to the in-game campaign rosters.

In any case, this is to be a playthrough of my beloved Austria-Hungary once again, with an 1890 start through to the 1970s, hopefully. In any case, without further ado:)

Indivisibiliter ac Inseparabiliter - Indivisibly and Inseparably
Image

"To explain the exact intricacies of the recent political and pseudo-political movements within the various layers of the Empire's court and governments would be a hopeless exercise in futility. The machinations of madmen and geniuses alike, gross incompetence, racism, arrogance, brilliance, and great statesmanship all came to a head in a month of upheaval and change. Change surprisingly unfelt by the general population or lower echelons of the constituent regions of the great central European bulwark, but change that spread almost unhindered through the normally sluggish and stubbornly traditional core of the nation. As the dust settled, outwardly it seemed like not much had actually altered.

However, despite the fact that echoing ramifications of this upheaval would be felt for decades to come, the most apparent changes that are relevant to us are related to the prioritisation and organisation of the various military branches within the K.u.K's domain. The factions within the court who favoured naval prestige, lead by the titular Archduke Franz Ferdinand, had managed to at least partially achieved their goals of increased naval funding, and in so doing disrupted the chain of command within the Kriegsmarine. The army was now lumped with a number of new efforts to renew and modernise, all of which were underfunded and no doubt destined for failure. Finally, of course, the Hungarian aristocracy was up in arms once again, aggravated by the changes, and newfound naval funding, demanding the Hungarian military and nation receive that focus instead.

Regardless, as part of the shake up of the traditionally entrenched Naval leadership, a new Marinekommandan, Chef der Marinesektion and Flottenkommandant had been selected, all roles being granted to an unusually young and enthusiastic man named Rudolf Graf Montecuccoli degli Erri, already pushing for modernisation and expansion within the previously strategically insignificant navy." - Excerpt from the introduction to 'The navy of a dozen tongues' by Naval Historian Ferdinand Rudolf Montecuccoli, published 1989

The Current Geopolitical Situation:

After all was said and done, the raise in naval funding had far more of an impact on foreign relations than any internal court shenanigans. Italy, in particular, was not very pleased at this turn of events. The young nation had been pumping alot of their economy into their Regina Marina as part of their efforts to raise legitimacy and prestige among the other great European empires, and always saw Austria-Hungary as a natural rival, given their constant attempts to claim Tirol, Triest, and other contested territories. The fact that Austria-Hungary's naval budget has gone up by almost a third resulted in a number of heated letters of protest, and performative naval exercises. Still, Montecucoli was unconcerned. Not only would Italian posturing simply aide in justifying increased funding, but despite their greater numbers and funding, their reputation for quality of training and vessel were remarkably poor. Overconfidence, perhaps, but even so it was clear Italy would be the pre-eminent rival for his new navy.

The only other directly threatening force was that of the French, with double the budget and more than double the tonnage, as the K.u.K Kriegsmarine stands it could only serve in a defensive capacity against such a force, should it be pitted against the Empire. Which is where Germany comes in. Enjoying relatively friendly relations with their germanic sister state had proved beneficial in the past, and given the newly crowned Kaiser Wilhelm II's fanatical obsession with all things naval, a sound bet would be to try and grow an alliance between the two powers. With the German navy occupying the majority of the French force, the K.u.K Kriegsmarine would have far more of a chance if war were to arise.

Finally, the dying empire of the Spanish. Once navally dominant, and for the last few years comparable with Austria-Hungary, the recent reduction in funding, and scrapping of alot of their older ships had placed their navy on the bottom rung of the Mediterranean naval hierarchy. Hardly a concern, though a possible ally if the old friendships the Spanish and Habsburgs can be restored. Whether such an ally would be nearly as useful as the effort to woo them would imply is up for debate, however any support is better than no support.

All in all, the K.u.K kriegsmarine's priories are clear, the fleet must be modernised in such a way as to ensure they can punch above both their weight and cost, particularly relative to Italian naval doctrine and design. France is a secondary concern, considering the currently stable relations and strength of their navy, though certainly one to be heavily considered, even if the only real viable method of countering their naval advantage is to form an alliance with Germany. Spain, meanwhile, is not really relevant to much of anything.

Image

Game Start Settings:

(This playthrough has been designed in the spirit of alternative history. As such, technological variation has been put to its maximum. Hopefully this will result in some unique designs and doctrinal counterplays. A larger navy size has been selected for the purposes of this playthrough, to allow me enough wiggle room to build some proper battleships down the line, while still enforcing the practical limitations that make an Austria-Hungary playthrough so fun. Though normally I would slow aircraft development and limit the number of aircraft at airbases, I am going to be brave this time, my late-game battleships will just have to have proper fighter escorts and be swamped with AA.)

Image
Last edited by TheConeezeanEmperor on Wed Jun 21, 2023 4:33 am, edited 1 time in total.
TheConeezeanEmperor
Posts: 4
Joined: Sat Apr 15, 2023 12:11 pm

Re: Indivisibiliter ac Inseparabiliter - K.u.K Kriegsmarine (Austria-Hungary) AAR - 1890

Post by TheConeezeanEmperor »

January 1890

Analysis of the current naval roster

Image

As it stands, even a cursory glance at the K.u.K Kriegsmarine indicates a number of issues. Despite being newly built, the Kaiser Class is blatantly outdated from the get go, low tonnage and armed with presumably foreign 12" guns, considering the fact that Austria-Hungary has yet to develop her own method of producing them. One of the primary conditions for Archduke Franz Ferdinand's support of the current Grossadmiral is the promise of larger, more modern, battleships, with an ambitious plan for the K.u.K Kriegsmarine to be able to fight as the other European Navies do, with proper lines of battle.

Image

Compared to her Italian and French counterparts, the Kaiser class is slow, small, and poorly armed. At the very least the armour is superior to the Italian Caio Duilo class, though that advantage is quickly lost when compared to the newer, better protected, Ruggiero de Lauria class. A situation made further daunting by the fact that Italy had two of each class, and were actively constructing two ne Ruggiero de Lauria class vessels, alongside a third of a new class, the Andae Doria class, of which we know frighteningly little.

Image

The Minerva class armoured cruisers seemed to at least be more modern, however they still used single-gun turrets, and were similarly smaller than foreign alternatives, albeit not so severely. The Kaiserin und Konigin Maria Theresa was, however, an entirely different story, being smaller, worse armed, and slower, though better armoured.

Image

Finally, the Zenta, Saida, and Szigetvar class protected cruisers, which are, fitting the pattern, outclassed by foreign vessels. Smaller, slower, and worse armed, they are hardly suited to more than trade escort.

Image

All these issues would have to be solved through new classes of vessel, but at 9,000 tons, the dockyards of Istra are simply not up to the task of competing with the 10,000 to 11,000 ton Italian and French battleships, so it is clear that prioritisation must be given to building new armoured and protected cruisers, as the dockyards are expanded. While foreign docks could be used, it is doubtful the navy's supporters in the court would approve of such an embarrassing admission of inadequacy. This would have to be achieved domestically.
Last edited by TheConeezeanEmperor on Tue Jun 20, 2023 6:23 pm, edited 2 times in total.
TheConeezeanEmperor
Posts: 4
Joined: Sat Apr 15, 2023 12:11 pm

Re: Indivisibiliter ac Inseparabiliter - K.u.K Kriegsmarine (Austria-Hungary) AAR - 1890

Post by TheConeezeanEmperor »

First steps

As such, the very first orders given are simple. Firstly, a new 12 month order for expansion to the Dockyards, then an increase to the research budget to 10%, and prioritisation given to naval artillery. 12" guns would be needed, ideally by the time the dockyards are ready for the next true class of battleships worthy of a European power.

Image

Further, a new design was prepared, for an Armoured Cruiser as large as domestic docks could build. Designed with excessive firepower, both from a heavy 6" secondary battery, and the first domestic implementation of twin gun turrets, the Adria class was to be well armed and armoured, while retaining suitable speeds for such a cruiser at 20 knots. She would be a good interim class, both serving as a large armoured cruiser, and if necessary the class should be capable of being pressed into service in the battleline should war arise before the next class of Battleships are ready.

Image

Of course, no one was under the illusion that the Adria could match the great 11,000 ton beasts of the other Mediterranean navies, but this was the best that could be managed in this short time frame, with the limited dock space available. The current ships that have already been laid down by Montecuccoli's predecessor will be left to reach completion on their own, despite how outdated they already were. At least, until funding gets tight enough to warrant their cancellation. It would be a shame to waste the work already done on them, though, so Montecuccoli only saw that as a last resort.

Image
TheConeezeanEmperor
Posts: 4
Joined: Sat Apr 15, 2023 12:11 pm

Re: Indivisibiliter ac Inseparabiliter - K.u.K Kriegsmarine (Austria-Hungary) AAR - 1890

Post by TheConeezeanEmperor »

Unfortunately the post before the latest one is still locked behind a moderation check. You can also find this AAR on the original RTW forums, here: https://nws-online.proboards.com/board/ ... discussion
User avatar
IslandInland
Posts: 1189
Joined: Mon Dec 08, 2014 3:54 pm
Location: YORKSHIRE
Contact:

Re: Indivisibiliter ac Inseparabiliter - K.u.K Kriegsmarine (Austria-Hungary) AAR - 1890 - HOSTED ON NWS FORUM

Post by IslandInland »

There is a dedicated section for AARs in this forum located here:

https://www.matrixgames.com/forums/view ... hp?f=11966

Although I can understand why you posted your AAR in the main forum as there isn't much happening there which also applies to the rest of this Matrix RTW3 forum.

Most people seem to prefer the NWS boards or the RTW3 Discord.
Beta Tester for:
War In The East 2 & Steel Inferno Expansion
War In The West Operation Torch
Strategic Command American Civil War
Strategic Command WWII: War in the Pacific
XXXCorps
1941 Hitler's Dream Scenario for WITE 2
User avatar
EwaldvonKleist
Posts: 2412
Joined: Thu Apr 14, 2016 3:58 pm
Location: Berlin, Germany

Re: Indivisibiliter ac Inseparabiliter - K.u.K Kriegsmarine (Austria-Hungary) AAR - 1890 - HOSTED ON NWS FORUM

Post by EwaldvonKleist »

You make awesome AARs. Great to see them for RtW3 as well, and you on matrixgames.
Post Reply

Return to “Rule the Waves 3”