ORIGINAL: BBfanboy
Taking Marcus and then the Bonins gives you a good penetration into the Emperors perimeter, but you could suffer a lot of grief from LBA [Netties] striking from both the HI and the Marianas [and maybe the Philippines]. You may eventually be able to load strong fighter cover on the Bonins but raids will always be an issue until you can close some of his airfields in range. Problem is, they are beyond your fighter range so your HB are on their own.
And then what? The airfields on the Bonins won't support much in the way of B-29s for strategic bombing. The Bonins give a nice naval location for your subs, but any AS in port could be hit in a raid. Same goes for any surface naval forces and supply convoys. I am not that confident that your fighters can always protect the bases and ships in the area.
Again, a matter of personal style but I think the NG - Palau - Philippines - Okinawa route offers more potential for short hops that do not rely on CV support for extended periods. The CVs can remain ghosts, appearing and striking suddenly and vanishing before he can react.
Good points! I´m actually not that worried about Nettie strikes. Erik has proven so far to be very risk averse and so far my CAP has performed very well even against his most concentrated attacks. That being said, good things never last for long!
The NG - Philippines route will remain to be my main thrust! I have 12 divisions working on that route. This is just for ...fun! [:)]
ORIGINAL: Bullwinkle58
Well, Nimitz was looking at the same map you are.
Nimitz probably wasn´t feeling the stress of having played a terrible 42 and 43 and trying to find shortcuts wherever he could. [:D]
My reasoning is simply just to gain some time. I´m thinking it takes just as long to prep for Eniwetok as its takes to prep for something in the Bonins. If I can skip the Marshalls completely I gain 100 days of prep.
So I´m thinking along the lines of doing Wake - Bonins - Marianas instead of Wake - Marshalls - Marianas - Bonins.
I´m just not sure its doable!? [:)]








