How is colonization not always doomed to this?

[mordachai]

Not sure what the thinking is behind the current design of colonization?

but - you've got it setup so that this is 100% inevitable, and... that just seems dumb.

Sorry to be blunt about it - but this algo just doesn't account for nearly enough - it just grabs a pile of people - of some race that is acceptable to one or more colonization targets - and then has to unload colonists (which takes forever) because by randomly grabbing a population w/o respect for how many ships are needed with that race - you're doomed to do exactly that: get the wrong race, and have to redo it.

And in an unlucky situation, you could then have a pathological case:
10 ships grab all one race
1 goes to target...
9 unload
9 grab all of 2nd race needed...
1 goes to target...
8 have to unload
8 grab all of 3rd race needed...
1 goes to target...
7 have to unload...
etc.

Until you rethink this algo so that you account for who is going where ahead of time, you're totally doomed to repeat this blundergarten.

Here's a current example. There are 2 worlds that call for Ackdarians. But 4 are being loaded (so far). 2 will inevitably have to unload them pointlessly again shortly... and there's just no reason for this other than "cause we say so..."

Colonization doomed to repeat.png (534.3 KiB) Viewed 547 times

[mordachai]

In case it isn't obvious - here's the same game shortly later - and as should be obvious - many colonizers are now unloading - more have the wrong races and will need to unload shortly - and some are still loading the wrong race - and will have to unload those in a while.

Very inefficient.

Colonization doomed to repeat 2.png (155.64 KiB) Viewed 543 times

[maggiecow]

Are you using the latest Beta? I don't think I've ever seen these problems, but I've only been playing the Betas since starting to play again, after ditching the game in March.

[mordachai]

Are you using the latest Beta? I don't think I've ever seen these problems, but I've only been playing the Betas since starting to play again, after ditching the game in March.

Yeah. 1.0.5.6. I always play the latest beta. I've found and reported a great many bugs.

This is less bug and more "the design is insufficient."