1943-1945 Campaign Expanded Air HQ

Post descriptions of your brilliant victories and unfortunate defeats here.

Moderator: MOD_WarintheWest

kentkroeckel
Posts: 706
Joined: Mon Jun 26, 2017 6:32 pm
Location: USA Colorado

1943-1945 Campaign Expanded Air HQ

Post by kentkroeckel »

Greetings to all WitW enthusiasts. I have contacted Mr. Liquid Sky and asked if he would be willing to play a 1943-1945 Grand Campaign. He graciously accepted; and also hopes that all will go well for Mr. Bimmler. I also want to state clearly that Mr. Bimmler is canceling our challenge due to a serious personal problem and not loss of interest in the game. I hope in the future other players will be able to play with him, as I also would like too.

I do not know if Mr. Liquid Sky has played a campaign game with the option of "Expanded Allied Air HQ?" Yet he was willing to do this with me so I think that is pretty cool. Most aspects of the air war are the same but following is the difference. In a standard campaign the US has 8 US Air Force along with the 15 US Air Force for strategic bombing missions. UK has RAF Bomber Command. No such limitation with this option. Any air HQ can create them.

There are no UK static divisions in England in this option and I think that is because there are so many new air HQ. This pretty much covers the unique aspects of this option.

One final aspect is the administrative points for the Allies. I wanted to double that so flak can be effectively utilized. Meaning, twenty points instead of ten.

Once again, thank you Mr. Liquid Sky for accepting this Challenge:

To the community; Mr. Liquid Sky is an exceedingly skilled player. You will see him utilize the Luftwaffe in a ways that degrades the Allies. Ground units of the Axis will not fail in holding a line. And finally, and I think most importantly, Germany will destroy Allied Naval capacity. I will of course try to counter but I have no illusions at what faces the Allies. This challenge is going to be hell.

Enjoy and comment often. Mr. Liquid Sky will be doing the same, as this is a combined AAR from both of us.
Last edited by kentkroeckel on Mon Nov 09, 2026 4:51 am, edited 2 times in total.
kentkroeckel
Posts: 706
Joined: Mon Jun 26, 2017 6:32 pm
Location: USA Colorado

Turn 1

Post by kentkroeckel »

It took a couple days to set up air but I am now done. At least done enough. I think I got 85% of what I wanted to do so next turn I can continue to setup. It is a tedious process to say the least. And I do hope the program runs without a hiccup. I will probably be a little less forthcoming on what I show until I know Mr. Liquid Sky cannot gain intelligence from his spies on this server. Ha. However, I am my own worst enemy on that.

First picture is of air superiority over Sardinia. I want to stop Italian naval air and fighters from interfering on next weeks invasion.
Screenshot 2026-11-08 200853.jpg
Screenshot 2026-11-08 200853.jpg (133.12 KiB) Viewed 1172 times

Second picture shows air superiority over Sicily. Notice how some of the protection box is north of Sicily. That is to prevent Mainland Italy from interfering with next weeks invasion.
Screenshot 2026-11-08 200914.jpg
Screenshot 2026-11-08 200914.jpg (190.55 KiB) Viewed 1172 times

The following picture shows ground attacks on the ports of Corsica and Sardinia. This is to reduce logistics for Italian air based on these two Islands. There is a lot to start with and I believe Mr. Liquid Sky will place much more on them. That is, unless he feels logistics are getting strangled too much for the Italian presence there.
Screenshot 2026-11-08 200952.jpg
Screenshot 2026-11-08 200952.jpg (97.52 KiB) Viewed 1172 times

Final picture is of potential landing areas on Mainland Italy. There are two sites near Rome and Naples. Both are risky but with the Luftwaffe pushed back from Corsica, Sardinia, and Sicily, it is possible. There is also a good landing spot where the mainland meets Sicily. Very doable for the Allies to control. Further east are the prize ports but they are far from Allied air support.
Screenshot 2026-11-08 201107.jpg
Screenshot 2026-11-08 201107.jpg (192.17 KiB) Viewed 1172 times
Last edited by kentkroeckel on Mon Nov 09, 2026 4:51 am, edited 1 time in total.
kentkroeckel
Posts: 706
Joined: Mon Jun 26, 2017 6:32 pm
Location: USA Colorado

Turn 1 Air Phase

Post by kentkroeckel »

First picture is of Northern Europe. very intense.
Screenshot 2026-11-08 203559.jpg
Screenshot 2026-11-08 203559.jpg (380.21 KiB) Viewed 1168 times

Next picture is over Ruhr Germany. Contacts are in about every hex.
Screenshot 2026-11-08 203529.jpg
Screenshot 2026-11-08 203529.jpg (489.17 KiB) Viewed 1168 times

There was much activity over Corsica and Sardinia as well.
Screenshot 2026-11-08 203627.jpg
Screenshot 2026-11-08 203627.jpg (187.13 KiB) Viewed 1168 times

Waters north of Sicily were active too.
Screenshot 2026-11-08 203644.jpg
Screenshot 2026-11-08 203644.jpg (184.43 KiB) Viewed 1168 times

Allies lost 693 while Germany lost 375. A Luftwaffe advantage of 318. I think this is just the beginning of such weeks.

The reason there are no pictures of invasions is because there are no invasions. I changed all six task force locations. Next week they will initiate amphibious operations. In essence, allies loose a week of game time but are able to select better landing sites. At least I think they are better. Mr. Liquid Sky may change my opinion on that. Ha.

I do believe this is nessecary, conducting a radical strategy to ensure control of a piece of Italy. Otherwise, a standard Sicily invasion can be mauled over by a determined Axis player. If they are really good, they can even push the Allies off Sicily. By the way, I have not ruled out invading Sicily, but if I did that, it would be strategically around the whole Penesula with all six task forces. That would force German units to flee or get trapped. the downside to this is that the Axis player gets a turn of preparation, unlike an invasion on turn one.
Last edited by kentkroeckel on Mon Nov 09, 2026 5:03 am, edited 1 time in total.
RedBunny
Posts: 109
Joined: Wed Dec 08, 2010 9:43 pm

Re: 1943-1945 Campaign Expanded Air HQ

Post by RedBunny »

Great to see you back at it Kemt. Good luck to you both.
kentkroeckel
Posts: 706
Joined: Mon Jun 26, 2017 6:32 pm
Location: USA Colorado

Information Post

Post by kentkroeckel »

Turn one was sent and now I wait to see how Germany (Mr. Liquid Sky) responds to this peculiar Allied setup. I am also glad to report that naval losses were small. And In fact, this is winning strategy. Just say no to invasions. Ha. But seriously, no amphibious transports were lost in the first turn.

I waited until turn two before moving any unit by sea. Most notably, no unit movement from UK to Mediterranean. The reason for this is that I wanted to wait until a reasonable amount of Allied air naval control existed over sea paths.

With expanded air missions, many more naval missions can be created; and that is exactly what I did. This gives me the option of not having to use automatic naval missions. The advantage is that I can control patrolled areas. For example, auto system sends out aircraft for thirty hexes, and no more or less, unless physically limited by range. It does a good job but cannot do more than block protection.

I am placing patrol blocks of three hexes along the Allied coastline, along with a few specialized sized ones. Reasoning for this is to make safe paths for units traversing ports. Additionally, logistic ships also use the same paths yet they do not follow along the shoreline so that is why I am using 3 hex block size patrols rather than a single hex line. Each patrol sea block gets one naval squadron and some will get more, when needs arise. I have never done this because when playing against Mr. Metalist, the goal was to maximize air ground attacks. This expanded use of naval missions I feel is a better use of this expand ability. I do hope this also presents a unique challenge for Mr. Liquid Sky. The Luftwaffe may need to engage some of the Allied logistics over the sea to reduce Allied logistics and naval capacity.

The pattern I am using for strategic bombing is four. Meaning, during a daylight attack, I have a wing attack on odd days. A second one attacks on even days. That gets you to two per week, keeping up bombing every day.

At night I do the same bombing pattern if the hex is within the British special ground radar reach, and of course the aircraft are equipped with the corresponding radar. This means that hexes in the Ruhr area get hit every day and every night by a total of four strategic missions.

I am doing the odd and even patterns with level bombers conducting tactical bombing. The goal is to hit a hex every day without making crew morale drop to a critical level.
Last edited by kentkroeckel on Mon Nov 09, 2026 11:59 pm, edited 1 time in total.
kentkroeckel
Posts: 706
Joined: Mon Jun 26, 2017 6:32 pm
Location: USA Colorado

Red Bunny

Post by kentkroeckel »

Thank you very much for your response Mr. Red Bunny. This is going to be an exciting match between Mr. Liquid Sky and myself.

I am concerned if I will be able to have the Allies stay on the initial landing site. For Mr. Liquid Sky is vastly more skilled than I am, or ever could hope to be. But the goal is to have fun and not winning. At least that is my philosophy. Otherwise, what is the point of playing. I guess it could be for an ego boost but this challenge is not about that.

We are both playing to win but that is not the only thing driving Mr. Liquid Sky and myself. The hope from us is that the WitW community is able to learn effective techniques in how to conduct the Axis side. I suppose there is a chance that a thing or two can be learned when watching the Allied side too. Or maybe at least not what to do. Ha.

Most of my games are played to conclusion so what happened with Mr. Bimmler is not typical for me. I do believe Mr. Liquid Sky has not had such luck so I think he will enjoy hurting the Allies till the end. In the process this will give me ulcers. Oh well, if I am having fun playing, then I am okay with ulcers and stress. Ha.

Best wishes to you Mr. Red Bunny.
And best of luck to you Mr. Liquid Sky.

PS: At the time of this writing Mr. Liquid Sky does not know where the Allies will land.

Sincerely, Kent Kroeckel
Last edited by kentkroeckel on Tue Nov 10, 2026 7:00 am, edited 1 time in total.
kentkroeckel
Posts: 706
Joined: Mon Jun 26, 2017 6:32 pm
Location: USA Colorado

Air setup

Post by kentkroeckel »

For the first turn Allies left transport aircraft, Patrol aircraft, and torpedo aircraft at rest (4). All others were active. At the end of turn one I put all to rest; except fighter bombers assigned to air superiority for both phases.
User avatar
LiquidSky
Posts: 2845
Joined: Tue Jun 24, 2008 4:28 am

Re: 1943-1945 Campaign Expanded Air HQ

Post by LiquidSky »

No invasion turn one.

While this may seem to open up a myriad of possible invasion sites, it really only comes down to two.

Possible invasion sites:

1) France/Belgium/Netherlands. He could have pulled the amphibs back to England to invade from their. Not likely for a few reasons...one, their probaby would have been some naval losses in the movement through the med. Also...why? It would be better to hit Sicily with the default invasions, and then pull out. It would buy a month or so before I start wondering about where the amphibs are.

2) Sicily. Yup....wait a turn, and invade Sicily anyways. Not likely as it would be better to invade Sicily and hold back 2 of the amphibs to invade both sides of the toe to cut it off. In fact, it is because of this I usually pull all the Germans out of Sicily so they won't get trapped. Sicily is a lost cause if it is invaded, and waiting a turn doesn't make it easier.

3) Italy mainland. Around Naples....Taranto....in front of Rome? Very very high risk. While the lack of German units in the theatre means you will successfully invade, the lack of aircover means you will be doomed to only receiving supply from far off African airbases....and even then, I would pretty much park the entire German luftwaffe in Italy while reinforcements show up turn after turn. Again...Sicily (and the toe) first and then anywhere from Naples to Brindisi, would be much safer. No....you need aircover which means if not Sicily then....

4) Sardinia/Corsica. These are the only two logical sites. When Italy surrenders, these two islands will flip to being allied, but many axis players will put a few units on them to prevent that. By invading it you ensure that the islands will be allied. As an allied player I would love the opportunity to invade Corsica along it's entire eastern coast to put down level 2 airfields which I would upgrade to level 3, and turn it into one big airfield. The Italian surrender rules require either Sicily or Sardinia so if not Sicily....then Sardinia.

So my guess is he is landing on Sardinia and Corsica. With only a single german unit and Italians that are fixed unless an allied unit gets close, the invasion of Sardinia will be easy. Corsica will be problematic as it is in easy range of many German/Italian airbases but will eventually fall as the Sardinian airfields come on line. If he wants to play it safe, then he will land all 6 on Sardinia.
“My logisticians are a humorless lot … they know if my campaign fails, they are the first ones I will slay.” – Alexander the Great
User avatar
LiquidSky
Posts: 2845
Joined: Tue Jun 24, 2008 4:28 am

Re: 1943-1945 Campaign Expanded Air HQ

Post by LiquidSky »

It occurs to me that their are two other possible invasion sites.

5) Southern France/Northern Italy or anywhere along the Adriatic....this would be suicide for the allies. No aircover, close to German reinforcements.....not doable. Won't spare any more thought here.

6) This one intrigues me. Land all 6 in Calabria on both sides of the boot. It places 6 airfields down which can be built up while you send a force down to take Reggio.....and a later invasion staged for Sicily. By the time Sicily is all done, you have air cover over Naples and can land all around it. It's a bit risky since it is out of range of Malta and African fighters, but you will also gain 3 level 1 airfields. The terrain is rough so you should be able to hold back the Germans while you push south down the boot. And you might trap a bunch of mech/armour down there.

My money is still on Sardinia/Corsica though.
“My logisticians are a humorless lot … they know if my campaign fails, they are the first ones I will slay.” – Alexander the Great
kentkroeckel
Posts: 706
Joined: Mon Jun 26, 2017 6:32 pm
Location: USA Colorado

A British Diary

Post by kentkroeckel »

This is my response to Mr. Liquid Sky. Enjoy.

Private Wingmire had been fighting in North Africa for a little over a year. He had heard others being disgruntled with British High Command but his experience was one of acceptance and trust. General Montgomery was the only commander he knew and rather liked him. The General had led them to a substantial victory over the German African Corp.

Yet the American General, Patton was bragging on how his personal army (U.S. Seventh Army) had saved the British from defeat. Of course anyone near the war knew the Desert Rats (Montgomery’s Eighth Army) had completely defeated the Desert Fox, (Rommel’s African Corp). German and Italian troops had been in retreat for six months, until their surrender in Tunis. But now another chapter in the war was about to start.


Below is the letter Private Wingmire wrote to his Mother and sister, Elan:

Hello mum [British spelling of mother] and sis [Abbreviation of sister] I hope you two are doing well. In the last letter you sent me, you asked what most I missed. Well, I have got an answer, but I think you two will find it odd. The tube. [British word for subway] Of course it really is not much of a bustling place anymore. I mean, people are not racing from place to place. They are just trying to keep safe from the V-1 attacks. I remember when I wanted to go into London to see the hustle and chaos. I know our city of Waterford is not far away but it was calm during the night. London never was, day or night. Just happy chaos all the time.

I know you two worry about my safety and so felt relieved when the news of the African Corp surrender happened. But that is just one piece to puzzle we are in. Much more war is ahead of us. We are going somewhere soon but no one knows where. At least the small chaps [British grouping of men] like me. It seemed we were ready to leave last week but then, nothing happened.

Yet I fear this week will be different. Instead of being strict with the morning breakfast rations, we were told to have as much as we like. I know you worry if I am fed enough mum, but I am. And on this morning, it was especially tasty. Crumpets [British pastry] and black tea. We had a few tea variety choices too. I can hear you now, wondering if I am drinking milk too. Yes, I am Mum. It is delicious with my crumpets.

Some were wondering if we were being sent back to the UK but I think not. Ships are small for that. No, this is going to be an invasion in the Mediterranean. We were issued small translation books with German and Italian words so I do not think France is it. We will just have to wait and see.
***********************************************************************

This post is dedicated to Mr. Liquid Sky. Have to stop the diary here and not reveal the invasion destination since I have not received turn two. No need to rush though, and this gives me a chance to do a post like this. I think it enriches the thread.

Your posts on the invasion is intuitive and filled with logic. Skill level is showing Mr. Liquid Sky. Allied High Command is nervous now that you have been assigned Command over the German defense effort. I hope my choice of an invasion location does not embarrass me. I tried to figure out what would be a safe yet productive landing site.
kentkroeckel
Posts: 706
Joined: Mon Jun 26, 2017 6:32 pm
Location: USA Colorado

Fog of War

Post by kentkroeckel »

Hello to all. Wanted to let all know that fog of war (FOG) is on for this challenge. First turn, units are displayed; to the level that there is a unit but not nationality, type, or size. Turn two sets everything to total FOG. At that point reconnaissance becomes important for both sides. Well, maybe not so critical for Germany but Allies need it. Strategic bombing in particular. I do not recall the specific difference between full reconnaissance and generic strategic bombing but it is significant. I think Mr. Liquid Sky may know the exact figure. If there are any questions please ask, Mr. Liquid Sky or myself will try to answer them. More often though, Mr. Liquid Sky. Ha.

Best wishes, Kent Kroeckel
User avatar
JeffroK
Posts: 6437
Joined: Wed Jan 26, 2005 4:05 am

Re: 1943-1945 Campaign Expanded Air HQ

Post by JeffroK »

Kent, Drop the diary. If you do keep it at least get the facts right.
Interdum feror cupidine partium magnarum Europae vincendarum
kentkroeckel
Posts: 706
Joined: Mon Jun 26, 2017 6:32 pm
Location: USA Colorado

Response to Mr. Jeffrok

Post by kentkroeckel »

Greetings to Mr. Jeffrok and all others. First of all, thank you for your response. I will now respond to your fist comment.

Mr. Jeffrok's comment: Kent, Drop the diary.

You sound irritated that I added a story to Turn one. I felt Mr Liquid Sky deserved a narration to his in-depth response on where the Allies would land. I asked him to do this so if there is any fault, it is mine alone. I would also like to add that what Mr. Liquid Sky wrote, with his logical deduction, shows great skill at this game; and probability in life too. That being said, I seem to be the source of your irritant.

Yet I do not understand why you are angry at the diary style of turn one, or at me personally. It is a simple story, human made by the way, no AI, that helps explain what is happening on the initial invasion location. If you do not like the diary or do not understand how it is related to turn one, then that is okay too. Simply skip over it and follow along on the game specific posts.

But sir, I will not stop a story of a turn that can contribute to this thread. And I would add Mr. Jeffrok, that it is inappropriate for you to request me to stop. If you feel that the diary has violated WitW policy or that my refusal has offended you, please send a flag report to system monitors so they can address any potential violation.


However, I recommend a more positive approach and it covers your second comment.

Mr. Jeffrok's second comment: If you do keep it at least get the facts right.

I believe Mr. Jeffrok, that this second part of your comment is the main source of your sourness. My misuse of language and failure to present facts correctly. First discloser. I am an American who has never lived in the United Kingdom. It is in my profile. therefore, I looked up British words that would give, what I thought would be an authentic flair for the story that I made up. It is a complete fabrication (fiction) that I assumed all knew. But I did try to fill the story with factual pieces. Guess I failed. I do apologize if I used any words incorrectly or did not translate them accurately. I meant no harm or offense.

The final part is your comment on my misuse of facts or leaving some out or adding something. You did not clarify as to where my error was Mr. Jeffrok so I do not know what to change. I want to be clear to you, and to all, I do try to the best of my ability in being accurate. Yet as you claim, I have failed in this. For that I offer an apology from my heart Mr. Jeffrok. I am terribly sorry and did not mean any disrespect to you, or any who fought in WWII or lost loved ones.

I would only ask of you Mr. Jeffrok, to assist me in correcting my failing. Please write up the facts or interpretation that I failed to present accurately. I do not take the correction personally. Many a time I have misquoted a rule in WitW, only to have to change my response. Mr. Metalist was good at finding my blunders. Fortunately, he never felt I was doing anything intentionally; as I hope you do not now, after my explanation.

And to all reading any of my posts on rules, I do not claim to know all the rules. Not even close. I try my best but always encourage all to read the manual, along with the living manual. If anything, Mr. Liquid Sky can probobly answer just about any technical question in the manual.

Best wishes to you Mr. Jeffrok and to all.
Kent Kroeckel
kentkroeckel
Posts: 706
Joined: Mon Jun 26, 2017 6:32 pm
Location: USA Colorado

Allied Invasion of Sicily

Post by kentkroeckel »

I did not receive a turn today so wanted to talk about Allied invasion sites. Why not invade normal. Most of the time it would be acceptable. However, if a German player wants to make a fight of it, then Allies get challenged. In particular, heading towards Messina. I sometimes counter this with having some task forces invading in other strategic locations over Italy. Bottom line, it can still be challenging in trying to clear Messina.

A way to help push Germany out of Sicily is to invade the tip of the Italian Boot. The two towns of Palmi and Locri. This would leave two original invasion points along with two strategic locations. Yellow for original, red for strategic locations, and black for securing Sicily and getting ten hexes of the Mainland, which needs to be gotten by February of 1944 or receive a 400 point penalty. A good German player will make sure to have a lot of combat points so that a simple surrender does not occur from the second type check, normal combat value.


First check happens when an Allied unit lands on the Mainland of Italy and Allies control Sicily or Sardinia. One time only; and starting in August.

Second check happens each turn when units land on the Mainland and control Sicily or Sardinia. Starting in August, (Normal Combat Value) is computed. It is possible for a German player to have sufficient combat points to reduce a surrender by a significant amount during this check. In all checks Northern and southern Italy are used.

Third check happens each turn when units land on the Mainland and Allies control Sicily or Sardinia. Starting in September, German units within ten hexes of an Allied unit get their combat value halved. This is what usually triggers an Italian surrender. Not enough combat points. The German value is then checked against the generated random number, I think between 1 and 200. I do not know if a different random number is created for the second and third check.


An Allied player could land over northern and Southern Italy, with the express intent to halve all Axis units. It would probibly succeed but the landing sites would be destroyed. this would also remove the garrison requirement for Northern Italy. Finally, It would allow the German player to receive ten administrative points instead of five per turn.
kentkroeckel
Posts: 706
Joined: Mon Jun 26, 2017 6:32 pm
Location: USA Colorado

Heel of Italy

Post by kentkroeckel »

Continuation of landing sites. Mr. Seminole suggested an invasion of the Heel of the Boot of Italy. He felt the Allies could keep control of the air through the six level two airbases that would be created. I feel differently. I believe the distance is too great for successful Allied logistics if the Axis concentrate the Luftwaffe. And I do mean any available aircraft. I would drain Europe too, for a victory. The Italian air force has range limitations but it would not be a factor for this mission. Aircraft would be launching from the Boot and Sicily, completely harassing the Allied invasion site and along the supply line.
Screenshot 2026-11-12 165154.jpg
Screenshot 2026-11-12 165154.jpg (209.37 KiB) Viewed 747 times

The Seminole goal is to secure the ports of Taranto, Brindisi, and Bari. Important ports to be sure but the whole Luftwaffe, with Italy too, would spell disaster. At least that is my thought on it. One by one each landing site could get strangled for logistics and then collapse. If bunched together I still think the same outcome is looming.
Screenshot 2026-11-12 165338.jpg
Screenshot 2026-11-12 165338.jpg (135.07 KiB) Viewed 747 times
User avatar
LiquidSky
Posts: 2845
Joined: Tue Jun 24, 2008 4:28 am

Re: 1943-1945 Campaign Expanded Air HQ

Post by LiquidSky »

I have seen many invasions of the Brindisi peninsula. In fact, peninsula's are a popular invasion destination. Brittany, Brindisi, just north of Foggia, and of course..Normandy.

The problem with invading in the Adriatic though is there are so many places supply can be interdicted with naval air. The actual invasion will succeed...in fact all non-port invasions will succeed because I won't defend a coast hex.

You see the rail line between Brindisi and Taranto? The two rough hexes north of Taranto? Those are where the defending units would sit. If a port has a unit defending it, then the inland hex behind it will also have a unit in it (to prevent being surrounded by paratroopers). So Bari would have a unit, and possibly the three hex line to Taranto.

And after the invasion? You are now hemmed in at a choke point. The airfields being bombed from Foggia to prevent fighter build up. Naval interdiction on my turn to prevent supply. And only 5-6 German divisions holding the choke point.

Think fighter cover. The range of your fighters dictate how far you can invade. Invading beyond that invites naval interdiction and axis bombing of your troops. But it also means that I will have more land units guarding the areas your fighters can reach, and rely more on the luftwaffe to buy time to reinforce the riskier landing sites.

The exception is Rome. Rome is worth about as much as the rest of Italy combined in Victory points. And will be defended accordingly.

Oh...I have finished the more boring parts of the first turn...the air phase is over and I am doing the ground movement. Should be done tonight.
“My logisticians are a humorless lot … they know if my campaign fails, they are the first ones I will slay.” – Alexander the Great
kentkroeckel
Posts: 706
Joined: Mon Jun 26, 2017 6:32 pm
Location: USA Colorado

Response to Liquid Sky

Post by kentkroeckel »

Greetings to all and Mr. Liquid Sky. With my gaming experience I would question the logistics, in going for the heel of Italy. Just do not think it would hold up. More importantly, amphibious transports could be required for eight turns or more. Allies could be loosing ten to twenty of them per turn. And once Allies fall to 150, D-Day will be limited. I am playing at a lower skill level so this is what I have experienced compared to you, Mr. Liquid Sky and Mr. Seminole. I feel both of you would reduce the allied amphibious pool to below 150 points with an aggressive Luftwaffe stance.

I agree with you on the Adriatic / east side of Italy. One simple line of Axis air naval cuts supply and creates isolated Allied units.

Now if all six task forces landed in and near the arch of the Boot; could be doable. Still though, supply is going to be problematic. And isolation from an Axis air naval line cutting to Yugoslavia or Greece is probable.

Sicily and landing up the Toe of the Boot seems the best of both goals. advantageous and logistically safe. Reasonable air cover can reach it. This is also why I put it in the possible category for what I have chosen. Heavy attack on Sicily is also there as well. I disagree on starting the invasion on turn one. I think waiting until turn two for all six task forces is fine. It adds uncertainty for the Axis player while turn two is maxed with challenges since six task forces are landing simultaneously.

I do not know if Rome is really doable since the Italian islands along with the Mainland would remove Allied naval strength.

I do agree with you on Corsica. It could be attempted but it would be costly, due to range. Doing Corsica and Sardinia is a good choice as long as the invasions are quick. I would be concerned with invasion beaches along Corsica eating up amphibious landing ships. Still doable but it will be costly. I suppose three task forces for each.

I think the final one you proposed, and if I remember correct, the most likely one you felt, was Sardinia. It is definitely the safest prospect. I think six task forces would quickly isolate the Island. But the advance would be limited. Wait eight turns to invade Corsica, Sicily, or the Mainland? You could invade two islands at once after that but then you are back to splitting up your forces.

I have obviously chosen something from above. And hint, as I said in the Diary, not Europe or France.

Best wishes to you Mr. Liquid Sky.
Last edited by kentkroeckel on Fri Nov 13, 2026 6:49 pm, edited 1 time in total.
kentkroeckel
Posts: 706
Joined: Mon Jun 26, 2017 6:32 pm
Location: USA Colorado

Turn Two German phase

Post by kentkroeckel »

July 10, 1944.

I wanted to comment on a couple things from the German phase. Mr. Liquid Sky is using Axis air naval in the best fashion. Germany should not try to match the Allies in dominating a whole naval region, unless it is an invasion site. What he has done, and I am assuming this; is the removal of a German mechanized division from Sardinia. He has created a specific retreat path that is secure in air cover. This is also how Germany should use its air naval to cut an Allied invasion when it is exposed on a faraway Italian coast; say the Boot area of Italy. Below is picture of this subject.
Screenshot 2026-11-13 091553.jpg
Screenshot 2026-11-13 091553.jpg (239.48 KiB) Viewed 598 times

I also want to point out the box size at end of the air naval mission. I think it is a three box of protection. That is what I am using along the coastline of Allied controlled coast.

In a traditional game Allies are not able to use this method due to limited air mission capacity. In the last games I played with Mr. Metalist with expanded Allied Air HQ, I concentrated on ground attacks, which was the test of it; to see if Germany could be overwhelmed by this. The result was no. Ha.

In this match, with Mr. Liquid Sky my goal is to do the best I can do. I also learned a bit with Mr. Metalist's challenges which I will apply in this Allied Expanded Air HQ option. There really are some unique aspects to this option that can be beneficial. One of them I believe is being able to ring the coast with small but sufficient air naval protection. The three box should be the most productive size in protection without waist. 26 cargo ships were lost on turn two logistics and that is a good number for Allies. This is before the main naval air protection has been activated.

I wanted to to show the Axis naval protection around Sicily. Just port sea presence. Mr. Liquid Sky has not felt the need to protect Sicily.
Screenshot 2026-11-13 091642.jpg
Screenshot 2026-11-13 091642.jpg (234.44 KiB) Viewed 598 times

The same is true for the Boot of Italy. Just sea protection from ports.
Screenshot 2026-11-13 091736.jpg
Screenshot 2026-11-13 091736.jpg (224.65 KiB) Viewed 598 times

Soon It will be revealed if Mr. Liquid Sky has made wise choices. But until then I want to bring up a disturbing anomaly. No construction engineering battalions were automatically assigned to repair / improve. If by next turn this does not change, then I will have to physically assign them. I will also change HQ to see if that will help trigger usage. They are now at UK Home Forces and AFHQ. Easy enough to set for Army group or Army. In traditional game not an issue.

Final point is victory points. No losses yet the score dropped. Wonder if the system just assumes a first turn invasion. Victory point losses are connected to other losses so maybe in aircraft but that is all that was lost on turn one. I will watch that to see what happens in the first five turns.
Screenshot 2026-11-13 001203.jpg
Screenshot 2026-11-13 001203.jpg (101.95 KiB) Viewed 598 times

Okay, that is it from what I can see for the end of turn one and the German phase for turn two. I do encourage all to comment.

Sincerely, Kent.
User avatar
LiquidSky
Posts: 2845
Joined: Tue Jun 24, 2008 4:28 am

Re: 1943-1945 Campaign Expanded Air HQ

Post by LiquidSky »

I have some dim memory that the score drop is from the game processing at start disabled manpower. Some are returned to the pool and others are treated as lost.

The air I used for naval interdiction was actually Italian. And only a portion of them at that. They have very good naval planes. I miss them when they surrender.


EDIT: Yup, I just booted up the scenario and at start manpower for the Brits is only 5k. After the German turn (when the allies get their logistics done) the Brits have over 100k manpower in transit. Open up your production window and change from Active to Transit and you will see them.
“My logisticians are a humorless lot … they know if my campaign fails, they are the first ones I will slay.” – Alexander the Great
User avatar
tm1
Posts: 2628
Joined: Tue May 14, 2013 10:21 pm
Location: Central Coast NSW Australia

Re: 1943-1945 Campaign Expanded Air HQ

Post by tm1 »

HI
Some heavy Axis Naval air power there looks like this could be a bloody fight on the Sicilian beaches if the Axis have hit the transports hard.
Just wondering what length of time and who has the longest recorded record for keeping Italy in the game and has there ever been anyone able in a PVP game that Italy actually stayed in game till the very end.
It is feasible to keep Italy from surrendering completely but the odds are incredible to keep the allied player from getting a surrender.
Post Reply

Return to “After Action Reports”