New to the game - Basic Questions
Moderator: Shannon V. OKeets
- Joseignacio
- Posts: 3214
- Joined: Fri May 08, 2009 11:25 am
- Location: Madrid, Spain
Re: New to the game - Basic Questions
Hi, I have some doubts on MWIF's interpretation of a rule.
As we all know, Nat China and Com China factions do not cooperate. And Com China moves within the USSR limits, while Nat China has it's own.
However, they are not separate for all matters, in fact they are together for all except the one above and the building of units, mainly.
This would mean they have a common FTC. Cause they belong to the same Major Power, China, according to this:
However we got Stilwell, he is a Nat. chinese unit with chinese colours, bougth by the Nat chinese, however it has some specialities with USA units, it can give then FTC:
Check that it says that it can give FTC to USA units, no that it cannot give FTC to chinese units, being a Chinese HQ. I understand it as a Plus capacity, not a change in FTC abilities from Chinese to USA units.
In fact, the game follows this line of approach to the behaviour of this HQ, because in matters of supply the rules say that it can give supply to USA units, but the game (and the players of the board game) take it as it can supply any or both,
In our game, that HQ is not giving it's FTC abilities to chinese units in USSR, it seems the game doesn't consider that it can give it to Chinese units, maybe only USA units, haven't tried.
So, I believe it is a bug. Is it?
As we all know, Nat China and Com China factions do not cooperate. And Com China moves within the USSR limits, while Nat China has it's own.
However, they are not separate for all matters, in fact they are together for all except the one above and the building of units, mainly.
This would mean they have a common FTC. Cause they belong to the same Major Power, China, according to this:
However we got Stilwell, he is a Nat. chinese unit with chinese colours, bougth by the Nat chinese, however it has some specialities with USA units, it can give then FTC:
Check that it says that it can give FTC to USA units, no that it cannot give FTC to chinese units, being a Chinese HQ. I understand it as a Plus capacity, not a change in FTC abilities from Chinese to USA units.
In fact, the game follows this line of approach to the behaviour of this HQ, because in matters of supply the rules say that it can give supply to USA units, but the game (and the players of the board game) take it as it can supply any or both,
In our game, that HQ is not giving it's FTC abilities to chinese units in USSR, it seems the game doesn't consider that it can give it to Chinese units, maybe only USA units, haven't tried.
So, I believe it is a bug. Is it?
- paulderynck
- Posts: 8538
- Joined: Sat Mar 24, 2007 5:27 pm
- Location: Canada
Re: New to the game - Basic Questions
I would consider it to be a bug. It is a Nationalist Chinese HQ and should give FTC to Nationalist Chinese units.
Paul
- Joseignacio
- Posts: 3214
- Joined: Fri May 08, 2009 11:25 am
- Location: Madrid, Spain
Re: New to the game - Basic Questions
Thanks, Paul.
Nobody dissents? We'll apply edit today
Nobody dissents? We'll apply edit today
Re: New to the game - Basic Questions
I think I agree, but am not yet sure. Could this mean that he can give FTC to 4 units in USSR? Two US and two Chinese.paulderynck wrote: Fri Oct 30, 2026 10:59 pm I would consider it to be a bug. It is a Nationalist Chinese HQ and should give FTC to Nationalist Chinese units.
The rule shown here says that Stilwell counts as a US HQ for FTC. Therefore I think there is room to discuss it.
Although the paragraph above states that Stilwells US abilities are indeed extra which implies that the are added to the Chinese abilities.
Have a bit more patience with newbies. Of course some of them act dumb -- they're often students, for heaven's sake. - Terry Pratchett
A government is a body of people; usually, notably, ungoverned. - Quote from Firefly
A government is a body of people; usually, notably, ungoverned. - Quote from Firefly
Re: New to the game - Basic Questions
RAW:Orm wrote: Sun Nov 01, 2026 9:38 amI think I agree, but am not yet sure. Could this mean that he can give FTC to 4 units in USSR? Two US and two Chinese.paulderynck wrote: Fri Oct 30, 2026 10:59 pm I would consider it to be a bug. It is a Nationalist Chinese HQ and should give FTC to Nationalist Chinese units.
The rule shown here says that Stilwell counts as a US HQ for FTC. Therefore I think there is room to discuss it.
Although the paragraph above states that Stilwells US abilities are indeed extra which implies that the are added to the Chinese abilities.
![]()
Stilwell counts as a US HQ for foreign troop commitment purposes
(see 18.2), so his presence in China allows the US player to send up to
2 US units to China.
So no: he doesn't count as a Chinese HQ for FTC. That's not stated in the rules. Because if he would also be able to give Chinese units FTC in the USSR, the rule had to be stated like this:
Stilwell counts also as a US HQ for foreign troop commitment purposes
(see 18.2)...
Peter
- Joseignacio
- Posts: 3214
- Joined: Fri May 08, 2009 11:25 am
- Location: Madrid, Spain
Re: New to the game - Basic Questions
I was meaning an additional ability in the sense of giving FTC to ones or others, not both, but that's intriguing as wellOrm wrote: Sun Nov 01, 2026 9:38 amI think I agree, but am not yet sure. Could this mean that he can give FTC to 4 units in USSR? Two US and two Chinese.paulderynck wrote: Fri Oct 30, 2026 10:59 pm I would consider it to be a bug. It is a Nationalist Chinese HQ and should give FTC to Nationalist Chinese units.
The rule shown here says that Stilwell counts as a US HQ for FTC. Therefore I think there is room to discuss it.
Although the paragraph above states that Stilwells US abilities are indeed extra which implies that the are added to the Chinese abilities.
![]()
- paulderynck
- Posts: 8538
- Joined: Sat Mar 24, 2007 5:27 pm
- Location: Canada
Re: New to the game - Basic Questions
I disagree. AAMOF your citation argues against an ability to give FTC to US units when Stilwell is in the USSR. (By "his presence in China" wording). This part I agree with. But arguing against a Nationalist Chinese HQ giving FTC to any Nationalist Chinese unit outside of China is the same as arguing against any major power HQ being able to give FTC to its own major power units ANYWHERE.Centuur wrote: Sun Nov 01, 2026 12:10 pmRAW:Orm wrote: Sun Nov 01, 2026 9:38 amI think I agree, but am not yet sure. Could this mean that he can give FTC to 4 units in USSR? Two US and two Chinese.paulderynck wrote: Fri Oct 30, 2026 10:59 pm I would consider it to be a bug. It is a Nationalist Chinese HQ and should give FTC to Nationalist Chinese units.
The rule shown here says that Stilwell counts as a US HQ for FTC. Therefore I think there is room to discuss it.
Although the paragraph above states that Stilwells US abilities are indeed extra which implies that the are added to the Chinese abilities.
![]()
Stilwell counts as a US HQ for foreign troop commitment purposes
(see 18.2), so his presence in China allows the US player to send up to
2 US units to China.
So no: he doesn't count as a Chinese HQ for FTC. That's not stated in the rules. Because if he would also be able to give Chinese units FTC in the USSR, the rule had to be stated like this:
Stilwell counts also as a US HQ for foreign troop commitment purposes
(see 18.2)...
You are being way too literal.
Paul
- Joseignacio
- Posts: 3214
- Joined: Fri May 08, 2009 11:25 am
- Location: Madrid, Spain
Re: New to the game - Basic Questions
I see what Centuur means, and he's got a point, but IMHO Harry was not so subtle when writing the rules. Hence the many pages document of "clarifications".
However, it seems to me that the text doesnt forbide giving FTC to a Chinese unit outside China, including the USSR, the text doesnt explicitely forbid it, and it is a Chinese HQ.
However, he's got a point that the text doesnt say "also", but neither do they say "only".
However, it seems to me that the text doesnt forbide giving FTC to a Chinese unit outside China, including the USSR, the text doesnt explicitely forbid it, and it is a Chinese HQ.
However, he's got a point that the text doesnt say "also", but neither do they say "only".
Re: New to the game - Basic Questions
For me the "definfite" part of the rule is, Stillwell counts as a US HQ for FTC purposes. For me that phrase with no other modification, which there isn't, only example, means that Stillwell's FTC ability applies only to US units.
Ronnie
- Joseignacio
- Posts: 3214
- Joined: Fri May 08, 2009 11:25 am
- Location: Madrid, Spain
Re: New to the game - Basic Questions
Thanks all
- paulderynck
- Posts: 8538
- Joined: Sat Mar 24, 2007 5:27 pm
- Location: Canada
Re: New to the game - Basic Questions
For you, what can Stilwell do for Nationalist Chinese units, for example can he extend supply, re-org units, provide HQ Support? If the answer is yes, then what grounds are there to deny FTC for Nationalist Chinese units?rkr1958 wrote: Wed Nov 04, 2026 2:02 pm For me the "definfite" part of the rule is, Stillwell counts as a US HQ for FTC purposes. For me that phrase with no other modification, which there isn't, only example, means that Stillwell's FTC ability applies only to US units.
Paul
Re: New to the game - Basic Questions
Do we know how MWIF is programmed wrt/Stillwell's FTC?paulderynck wrote: Mon Nov 09, 2026 9:18 pmFor you, what can Stilwell do for Nationalist Chinese units, for example can he extend supply, re-org units, provide HQ Support? If the answer is yes, then what grounds are there to deny FTC for Nationalist Chinese units?rkr1958 wrote: Wed Nov 04, 2026 2:02 pm For me the "definfite" part of the rule is, Stillwell counts as a US HQ for FTC purposes. For me that phrase with no other modification, which there isn't, only example, means that Stillwell's FTC ability applies only to US units.
To answer your question I think according the rules he should be able to all that except FTC for Chinese units.
I, for now, concur with Centuur's interpretation. The rule states for FTC purposes Stillwell counts as a US HQ. Otherwise and except for FTC he acts as a Chinese Nationalist HQ, with another exception stated in rules. He can serve as a secondary supply source for US units, and for units that cooperate with the US.
Ronnie
- Joseignacio
- Posts: 3214
- Joined: Fri May 08, 2009 11:25 am
- Location: Madrid, Spain
Re: New to the game - Basic Questions
We think we got it right, that the GE units not in a 2 hex range of Istambul, are OOS, even though the game insists that they are not. Not using the optional Limited Overseas Supply.
It is obvious that the proferred route through the Black Sea is not valid because GE NAVs cant patrol but USSR ships can.
Is there another route possible that anybody can see? I am afraid not. Weather is Rain in the Med and Storm in the N Temperate. The TU HQ cannot reach the Balkans on his left, and I cannot find any route for it or Von Rundstedt (who sits on the railroad) to reach through USSR even though Irak is aligned but it cannot trace through the Arabian sea (and other seas).
It is obvious that the proferred route through the Black Sea is not valid because GE NAVs cant patrol but USSR ships can.
Is there another route possible that anybody can see? I am afraid not. Weather is Rain in the Med and Storm in the N Temperate. The TU HQ cannot reach the Balkans on his left, and I cannot find any route for it or Von Rundstedt (who sits on the railroad) to reach through USSR even though Irak is aligned but it cannot trace through the Arabian sea (and other seas).
- Joseignacio
- Posts: 3214
- Joined: Fri May 08, 2009 11:25 am
- Location: Madrid, Spain
Re: New to the game - Basic Questions
Another matter.
We dont think there is a reason why the JA partisans (after being completely conquered by Allies) are full german units, they should be JA controlled by GE.
But even if so, they should be able to move though USA hexes to do their duty with GE land moves. They cant. We think this is not correct. Is it?
We dont think there is a reason why the JA partisans (after being completely conquered by Allies) are full german units, they should be JA controlled by GE.
But even if so, they should be able to move though USA hexes to do their duty with GE land moves. They cant. We think this is not correct. Is it?
- paulderynck
- Posts: 8538
- Joined: Sat Mar 24, 2007 5:27 pm
- Location: Canada
Re: New to the game - Basic Questions
On the partisan - yeah that looks weird. Did you see if Japan can still call actions?
About Istanbul - the capital of Turkey is Ankara and so the game is right for the units within two. I don't see a way for the Turk HQ to trace supply in that weather. Maybe through the Med in better weather.
About Istanbul - the capital of Turkey is Ankara and so the game is right for the units within two. I don't see a way for the Turk HQ to trace supply in that weather. Maybe through the Med in better weather.
Paul
- Joseignacio
- Posts: 3214
- Joined: Fri May 08, 2009 11:25 am
- Location: Madrid, Spain
Re: New to the game - Basic Questions
Japan cannot. It has been completely conquered.
And thanks for chercking our opinion on Turkey.
And thanks for chercking our opinion on Turkey.




