BBC - Hiroshima

Gary Grigsby's strategic level wargame covering the entire War in the Pacific from 1941 to 1945 or beyond.

Moderators: Joel Billings, wdolson, Don Bowen, mogami

User avatar
DuckofTindalos
Posts: 39781
Joined: Fri Apr 22, 2005 11:53 pm
Location: Denmark

RE: BBC - Hiroshima

Post by DuckofTindalos »

Well, then it seems I may have misunderstood you. You've been talking about a Soviet invasion...
We are all dreams of the Giant Space Butterfly.
User avatar
Dereck
Posts: 3329
Joined: Mon Sep 06, 2004 10:43 pm
Location: Romulus, MI

RE: BBC - Hiroshima

Post by Dereck »

ORIGINAL: ilovestrategy

To give credit to Truman, you have to look at the fact that the US had been at war for a while now and I'm sure everyone was ready for it to be over. He had a choice of using the A bombs now or bomb Japan for several more months before an invasion fleet could be ready. And I'm sure the cost of taking Okinawa was on his mind too. It was a different time back then. For example, I have a cousin that is a female college student with no knowledge of military history whatsoever and she is totally convinced that we were evil for dropping the bombs.

I just thought of another informative tidbit you can mention to your cousin about dropping the bomb versus an invasion of Japan.

Before major operations the US military would order the production of medals such as Purple Hearts (given for battle wounds and deaths). The very same Purple Hearts produced for the invasion of Japan were so numerous that they are still be issued to this day.
PO2 US Navy (1980-1986);
USS Midway CV-41 (1981-1984)
Whidbey Island, WA (1984-1986)
Naval Reserve (1986-1992)
User avatar
invernomuto
Posts: 944
Joined: Fri Oct 08, 2004 4:29 pm
Location: Turin, Italy

RE: BBC - Hiroshima

Post by invernomuto »

Some days ago I read an interview to Gar Alperovitz, University of Meryland, on an important Italian newspaper.
He said that the decision to drop the A-bomb on Hiroshima and Nagasaki was only political, for two reasons:
1 - According to US intel, Japan "was ready to surrender". It was just a diplomatical matter, Japanese want to preserve their Emperor.
2 - Soviet DOW to Japan should have been the final blow to Japanese resistance.
Truman ordered to drop the A-bomb for political reasons. US used the A bomb as a threat against a soviet expansion in the area.

I cannot translate the entire interview (not so skilled in English, sorry), if someone is interested here is the link http://www.lastampa.it/Speciali/hiroshi ... morale.asp

Bye
User avatar
Dereck
Posts: 3329
Joined: Mon Sep 06, 2004 10:43 pm
Location: Romulus, MI

RE: BBC - Hiroshima

Post by Dereck »

There was more than just political reasons for dropping the bomb. There were legitimate military reasons as well.

Both military and political reasons ended up causing the bomb to be dropped.

Japan was defeated - at that time any "Western" country would have already had surrendered - but the Japanese military didn't consider surrender as an option even at this stage and in the end it basically took a direct order from Hirohito to force the military to surrender. After that decision was made it may be interesting to note that the Japanese prime minister was changed to a member of the royal family so the military wouldn't assassinate him and continue the war.
PO2 US Navy (1980-1986);
USS Midway CV-41 (1981-1984)
Whidbey Island, WA (1984-1986)
Naval Reserve (1986-1992)
User avatar
Tomo
Posts: 66
Joined: Sat Apr 10, 2004 6:36 am
Location: JAPAN

RE: BBC - Hiroshima

Post by Tomo »

ORIGINAL: Nikademus

The Germans officially accepted their responsibilty for what the Nazi government had done but by and large from what i've read, Japan has not. Even an attempt to understand the radical differences in Japanese culture from the West really dont excuse this IMO.

I don't wanna talk about political problem here. This is a game board.

Just wanna let you know how many times Japanese govermment officially accepted responsibility of the pacific war.
From below site,The Japanese Government and many politicians expressed an apology officially at least more than 30 times. It is including emperor. I know The Chinese Communist Party and Korean government still need Japanese apologies. Almost of its aims are for a domestic nationalism reason.
If the Korean political party could get a Japanese new apology, she can win an election.
1 Japanese apology produce many votes[:D]
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_wa ... d_by_Japan

http://ja.wikipedia.org/wiki/%E6%97%A5% ... 0%E8%A6%A7

http://ja.wikipedia.org/wiki/%E6%97%A5% ... E.E6.95.B0


http://babelfish.altavista.com/

Hiroshima
http://www.pcf.city.hiroshima.jp/

Nagasaki
http://headlines.yahoo.co.jp/hl?a=20050 ... 01&kz=soci
http://base.mng.nias.ac.jp/
http://www1.city.nagasaki.nagasaki.jp/na-bomb/museum/
Japanese wargamer. Will post from "the other side" .
User avatar
Apollo11
Posts: 25478
Joined: Thu Jun 07, 2001 8:00 am
Location: Zagreb, Croatia
Contact:

RE: BBC - Hiroshima

Post by Apollo11 »

Hi all,
ORIGINAL: Apollo11

I have just watched BBC documentary made in 2005 (party re-enacted, partly documentary, partly computer graphics) on my country's national TV.

It was 50+minutes long and it ends with bomb explosion.

I just saw that today at 4 PM is 2nd part (form bob explosion afterwards I suppose)... it must be long documentary 2x 50 minutes...


Leo "Apollo11"
Image

Prior Preparation & Planning Prevents Pathetically Poor Performance!

A & B: WitW, WitE, WbtS, GGWaW, GGWaW2-AWD, HttR, CotA, BftB, CF
P: UV, WitP, WitP-AE
User avatar
Twotribes
Posts: 6466
Joined: Fri Feb 15, 2002 10:00 am
Location: Jacksonville NC
Contact:

RE: BBC - Hiroshima

Post by Twotribes »

What war crime did the US commit on Saipan?

If your going to claim the murder of the civilian population, I suggest you get a better history teacher and source, the Japanes population committed suicide at the insistance of their own government and local commanders. They had been taught we were barbarians and might do things like eat them if captured.

The projected losses in the invasion mainland japan were in the millions for both sides, it was feared that an invasion could lead to the destruction of the Japanese race, based on the events on Saipan and Okinawa.

You tell me.... was the loss of 250 thousand worse than the potential loss of MILLIONS? Based on what the Americans knew in August 1945, the Japanese would NOT surrender and the civilian population would aid in defense using bamboo sticks ( meaning slaughtered when they tried to attack american positions) those civilians not killed in defense of Japan would likely take their own life.

There was no way the Americans were gonna make a settlement with Japan. It wasnt going to happen, pretending if only we had, is a waste of time.
Using records from the time found AFTER the surrender to justify what the Government should have done BEFORE they knew the facts is stupid and foolish.

The reality is that EVEN after Hirohito called for surrender the Japanese military tried to prevent him from announcing it.

Were the bombs justified.... YES. Were they neccassary... Yes.

Both targets were ( in WW2) legitamate Military targets. At least Hiroshima was a marshalling center for an entire Army for the defense of Japan. They were selected BECAUSE they hadnt been bombed previously and would show the full weight of what the BOMB would do. In an effort to shock the Japanese into surrender. And it worked.
Favoritism is alive and well here.
madmickey
Posts: 1336
Joined: Wed Feb 11, 2004 6:54 pm
Location: Calgary, Alberta

RE: BBC - Hiroshima

Post by madmickey »

In regards to "supposed" diplomatic effort by the Japan to end the war later Ulta-Magic intercept
""The diplomatic intercepts included, for example, those of neutral diplomats or attachés stationed in Japan. Critics highlighted a few nuggets from this trove in the 1978 releases, but with the complete release, we learned that there were only 3 or 4 messages suggesting the possibility of a compromise peace, while no fewer than 13 affirmed that Japan fully intended to fight to the bitter end. Another page in the critics' canon emphasized a squad of Japanese diplomats in Europe, from Sweden to the Vatican, who attempted to become peace entrepreneurs in their contacts with American officials. As the editors of the "Magic" Diplomatic Summary correctly made clear to American policymakers during the war, however, not a single one of these men (save one we will address shortly) possessed actual authority to act for the Japanese government."

An inner cabinet in Tokyo authorized Japan's only officially sanctioned diplomatic initiative. The Japanese dubbed this inner cabinet the Big Six because it comprised just six men: Prime Minister Kantaro Suzuki, Foreign Minister Shigenori Togo, Army Minister Korechika Anami, Navy Minister Mitsumasa Yonai, and the chiefs of staff of the Imperial Army (General Yoshijiro Umezu) and Imperial Navy (Admiral Soemu Toyoda). In complete secrecy, the Big Six agreed on an approach to the Soviet Union in June 1945. This was not to ask the Soviets to deliver a "We surrender" note; rather, it aimed to enlist the Soviets as mediators to negotiate an end to the war satisfactory to the Big Six--in other words, a peace on terms satisfactory to the dominant militarists. Their minimal goal was not confined to guaranteed retention of the Imperial Institution; they also insisted on preservation of the old militaristic order in Japan, the one in which they ruled.

The conduit for this initiative was Japan's ambassador in Moscow, Naotake Sato. He communicated with Foreign Minister Togo--and, thanks to code breaking, with American policymakers. Ambassador Sato emerges in the intercepts as a devastating cross-examiner ruthlessly unmasking for history the feebleness of the whole enterprise. Sato immediately told Togo that the Soviets would never bestir themselves on behalf of Japan. The foreign minister could only insist that Sato follow his instructions. Sato demanded to know whether the government and the military supported the overture and what its legal basis was--after all, the official Japanese position, adopted in an Imperial Conference in June 1945 with the emperor's sanction, was a fight to the finish. The ambassador also demanded that Japan state concrete terms to end the war, otherwise the effort could not be taken seriously. Togo responded evasively that the "directing powers" and the government had authorized the effort--he did not and could not claim that the military in general supported it or that the fight-to-the-end policy had been replaced. Indeed, Togo added: "Please bear particularly in mind, however, that we are not seeking the Russians' mediation for anything like an unconditional surrender."

Starting with the publication of excerpts from the diaries of James Forrestal in 1951, the contents of a few of the diplomatic intercepts were revealed, and for decades the critics focused on these. But the release of the complete (unredacted) "Magic" Far East Summary, supplementing the Diplomatic Summary, in the 1990s revealed that the diplomatic messages amounted to a mere trickle by comparison with the torrent of military intercepts. The intercepts of Japanese Imperial Army and Navy messages disclosed without exception that Japan's armed forces were determined to fight a final Armageddon battle in the homeland against an Allied invasion. The Japanese called this strategy Ketsu Go (Operation Decisive). It was founded on the premise that American morale was brittle and could be shattered by heavy losses in the initial invasion. American politicians would then gladly negotiate an end to the war far more generous than unconditional surrender. Ultra was even more alarming in what it revealed about Japanese knowledge of American military plans. Intercepts demonstrated that the Japanese had correctly anticipated precisely where U.S. forces intended to land on Southern Kyushu in November 1945 (Operation Olympic). American planning for the Kyushu assault reflected adherence to the military rule of thumb that the attacker should outnumber the defender at least three to one to assure success at a reasonable cost. American estimates projected that on the date of the landings, the Japanese would have only three of their six field divisions on all of Kyushu in the southern target area where nine American divisions would push ashore. The estimates allowed that the Japanese would possess just 2,500 to 3,000 planes total throughout Japan to face Olympic. American aerial strength would be over four times greater."

From mid-July onwards, Ultra intercepts exposed a huge military buildup on Kyushu. Japanese ground forces exceeded prior estimates by a factor of four. Instead of 3 Japanese field divisions deployed in southern Kyushu to meet the 9 U.S. divisions, there were 10 Imperial Army divisions plus additional brigades. Japanese air forces exceeded prior estimates by a factor of two to four. Instead of 2,500 to 3,000 Japanese aircraft, estimates varied between about 6,000 and 10,000. One intelligence officer commented that the Japanese defenses threatened "to grow to [the] point where we attack on a ratio of one (1) to one (1) which is not the recipe for victory.""


http://www.weeklystandard.com/Utilities ... =C62A29C91
It also talks about the fact that between 250,000- 400,000 Asian were dying a month due to the war.

This from the author of "Downfall: The End of the Imperial Japanese Empire."



Mike Scholl
Posts: 6187
Joined: Wed Jan 01, 2003 1:17 am
Location: Kansas City, MO

RE: BBC - Hiroshima

Post by Mike Scholl »

My point was that INVADING Japan by the Fall of '45 wasn't going to be that difficult. The "defensive" capabilities of her Navy and Air Power were almost nil.
Her ability to fight started at the shoreline. Yes, there would be suicide boats and kamikazes thrown at the follow up waves (they had to be dragged out of their hiding places). Yes, there were lots of troops and spear carrying militia once you got ashore. But invading wasn't going to be a problem. Establishing a successful beachhead, and expanding it, was going to be the tough part. But Japan's resources (such as were left) we concentraited to meet the Americans
in the South and then on Honshu. The Russians would have landed on Hokaido in the north, where much less was available defensively. And given Stalin's willingness to pile up bodies, they had a good chance of succeeding. Thus opening the "can of worms" I mentioned. I still maintain that Harry was right to use the bomb. Japan "sewed the wind..., and reaped the whirlwind". It's as simple as that. And all they had to do to save themselves was say "I quit" any time before the 6th of August. Stupidity CAN be fatal...
User avatar
Apollo11
Posts: 25478
Joined: Thu Jun 07, 2001 8:00 am
Location: Zagreb, Croatia
Contact:

RE: BBC - Hiroshima

Post by Apollo11 »

Hi all,
ORIGINAL: Mike Scholl

My point was that INVADING Japan by the Fall of '45 wasn't going to be that difficult. The "defensive" capabilities of her Navy and Air Power were almost nil.
Her ability to fight started at the shoreline. Yes, there would be suicide boats and kamikazes thrown at the follow up waves (they had to be dragged out of their hiding places). Yes, there were lots of troops and spear carrying militia once you got ashore. But invading wasn't going to be a problem. Establishing a successful beachhead, and expanding it, was going to be the tough part. But Japan's resources (such as were left) we concentraited to meet the Americans
in the South and then on Honshu. The Russians would have landed on Hokaido in the north, where much less was available defensively. And given Stalin's willingness to pile up bodies, they had a good chance of succeeding. Thus opening the "can of worms" I mentioned. I still maintain that Harry was right to use the bomb. Japan "sewed the wind..., and reaped the whirlwind". It's as simple as that. And all they had to do to save themselves was say "I quit" any time before the 6th of August. Stupidity CAN be fatal...

Japanese had _NO_ serious wish to defend the beaches with all might they still possesed - they have learned the hard lesson(s) that they can't stop the invasion.

What would be bloody is to crush Japanese defensive lines inland... here is where casualties would lie... not at amphibious landing...


Leo "Apollo11"
Image

Prior Preparation & Planning Prevents Pathetically Poor Performance!

A & B: WitW, WitE, WbtS, GGWaW, GGWaW2-AWD, HttR, CotA, BftB, CF
P: UV, WitP, WitP-AE
User avatar
EUBanana
Posts: 4255
Joined: Tue Sep 30, 2003 3:48 pm
Location: Little England
Contact:

RE: BBC - Hiroshima

Post by EUBanana »

Well, I watched it.

God, that was disturbing. [:(]
Image
User avatar
wild_Willie2
Posts: 2934
Joined: Fri Oct 08, 2004 10:33 am
Location: Arnhem (holland) yes a bridge to far...

RE: BBC - Hiroshima

Post by wild_Willie2 »

God, that was disturbing

told you so [;)]
In vinum illic est sapientia , in matera illic est vires , in aqua illic es bacteria.

In wine there is wisdom, in beer there is strength, in water there are bacteria.
User avatar
51st Highland Div
Posts: 348
Joined: Sat Jul 23, 2005 1:30 pm
Location: Glasgow,Scotland

RE: BBC - Hiroshima

Post by 51st Highland Div »

Yep especially the bit with the Japanese mother unable to help her trapped daughter..very disturbing.
User avatar
EUBanana
Posts: 4255
Joined: Tue Sep 30, 2003 3:48 pm
Location: Little England
Contact:

RE: BBC - Hiroshima

Post by EUBanana »

ORIGINAL: 51st Highland Div

Yep especially the bit with the Japanese mother unable to help her trapped daughter..very disturbing.

Yeah, thats the bit I was thinking of. [:(]
Image
madmickey
Posts: 1336
Joined: Wed Feb 11, 2004 6:54 pm
Location: Calgary, Alberta

RE: BBC - Hiroshima

Post by madmickey »

We both agree on Truman wisdom I also brought in my post 68 to back it up.
If the USSR invaded Hokkaido they would have to transfer far east troops from Korea to Vladivostock (which is still nearer to Jap air bases at Hohshu than Hokkaido), I doubt they would take troop from Germany and Eastern Europe for that operation. Do you think the Japanese would have reacted to that and moved troops around? The passage between the Hohshu and Hokkaido is narrow and troops can be ferried and Northern Hokkaido is very mountainous and can be easily defended. Where would you place your air cover for your invasion fleet to prevent the thousands of kamikazes? If the US with all its naval air arms heaviled AA ships and experience in amphibious operation had so much problems with kamikazes at Okinawa what do you think the USSR would have face?
User avatar
Apollo11
Posts: 25478
Joined: Thu Jun 07, 2001 8:00 am
Location: Zagreb, Croatia
Contact:

RE: BBC - Hiroshima

Post by Apollo11 »

Hi all,
ORIGINAL: EUBanana

Well, I watched it.

God, that was disturbing. [:(]

I watched the 2nd part as well on my national TV yesterday afternoon... true... disturbing... but I think it was necessary...


Leo "Apollo11"
Image

Prior Preparation & Planning Prevents Pathetically Poor Performance!

A & B: WitW, WitE, WbtS, GGWaW, GGWaW2-AWD, HttR, CotA, BftB, CF
P: UV, WitP, WitP-AE
User avatar
EUBanana
Posts: 4255
Joined: Tue Sep 30, 2003 3:48 pm
Location: Little England
Contact:

RE: BBC - Hiroshima

Post by EUBanana »

ORIGINAL: Apollo11

Hi all,
ORIGINAL: EUBanana

Well, I watched it.

God, that was disturbing. [:(]

I watched the 2nd part as well on my national TV yesterday afternoon... true... disturbing... but I think it was necessary...


Leo "Apollo11"

I agree there.

You need to have a hard heart to be a general or president I think, though.
Image
User avatar
DuckofTindalos
Posts: 39781
Joined: Fri Apr 22, 2005 11:53 pm
Location: Denmark

RE: BBC - Hiroshima

Post by DuckofTindalos »

Yeah... knowingly sending young people to their deaths and all...
We are all dreams of the Giant Space Butterfly.
User avatar
Nikademus
Posts: 22517
Joined: Sat May 27, 2000 8:00 am
Location: Alien spacecraft

RE: BBC - Hiroshima

Post by Nikademus »

Thx for the information Tomo. I should have been more specific in mentioning that yes, officials in the Japanese gov have multiple times expressed regret and made acknowledgements on the part of their country for what was done in WWII. I was referring more to actions such as the recent Japanese 'version' of WWII (what little mention there was of it apparantly) authorized for the public schools combined with recent revisionist histories that among other things claimed that massacres such as Nanking did not happen.
Mike Scholl
Posts: 6187
Joined: Wed Jan 01, 2003 1:17 am
Location: Kansas City, MO

RE: BBC - Hiroshima

Post by Mike Scholl »

ORIGINAL: madmickey

. Where would you place your air cover for your invasion fleet to prevent the thousands of kamikazes? If the US with all its naval air arms heaviled AA ships and experience in amphibious operation had so much problems with kamikazes at Okinawa what do you think the USSR would have face?

Wouldn't need any. The Kamikazes would have all trashed themselves against the Americans. That's when the Russians would make their move. Joe Stalin was an inhuman monster..., but he wasn't stupid.
Let the Allies pull the teeth of the Japanese defense, then make your move is the way I see it.
Post Reply

Return to “War In The Pacific - Struggle Against Japan 1941 - 1945”