Thanks for the replies!

For the Soviet player: Should you ever refit NKVD units? (does refit even work on them?) How many units should be on refit at one time? For normal infantry, is there a point where you might as well disband as opposed to refit (like when units get to single digits TOE). Is there any reason not to ref...

<t> I am not sure what units are in your hexes- is there a HQ there, etc? Try selecting just combat unit and see if the results are the same. Can the cavalry unit even advance one hex east? It should have the needed MP to do that, even if there is an enemy ZOC there. I think it would take 12 MP to c...

<t> Thanks Ajax<br/> 16.3.5.1. Air Transport of Supply<br/> Supplies and fuel can be airdropped (F9) to units by transport and level bomber air group units and this mission can be<br/> escorted by fighter air group units (5.3.9). There’s a limit of two air transport missions per hex and they may onl...

Is that a thing really, just for transports? It is quite possible they are not. I will look in Chris's manual for that.

<t> Turn 1 as the German. I had a very successful air campaign- 6,475 Soviet aircraft destroyed, followed by dropping supplies to the leading edge armored units.<br/> Turn 2- I cannot get any transports to drop supplies. Period. Same for turn 3.<br/> Air Doctrine- set to 0% to fly<br/> Air bases are...

Fetnum- incredible spreadsheet. I have one question/comment.

On the dropdown "choose type of display", between Accumulative or This turn, I get the same numbers (it does not display the turn, only the accumulative. I have Office 2016.

How hard would it be to code that you think- as in give them port supply if they can trace a line to a city hex (or above)?
Perhaps a rhetorical question, really one for someone like Morvael.

<t> There has been a some talk about Soviets not fighting forward, and German supply being under-powered (or over-powered, depending on the poster), and fixes needed for the game, etc.<br/> <br/> One thing that would help the Soviets fight forward would be if cities could provide some supply to Sovi...

<t> Hey Chris<br/> First off, great work. Anyone just taking on this monster deserves kudos- and then doing a great job of it on top of that- extraordinary!<br/> <br/> Anyways<br/> Under 9.1.1, the 6th bullet point reads<br/> • Units that are below 40 automatically gain one morale point.<br/> <br/> ...

Sorry- ST summed it up well. Defense of the Ancients, a 5 vs 5 game based off a Warcraft mod.

I seriously can't wait to use this!
Good grief- playing WITE already puts me in the top 0.1% of nerdy, but being into spreadsheets about WITE is such a small percent it's almost immeasureable!

<t> It comes down to money. Chris I think you and I were born 25 years too soon to have the AI opponent we want.<br/> There are generic type AIs, like Alpha Zero, that basically learn by playing a game hundreds of thousands of times (in a short time span). I am sure it could be adapted for Wite, but...

Looking forward to seeing this from both sides. Good luck to both of you.

Nice that you were able to isolate the two panzer divisions by Riga. Every little bit helps for the Soviet on T1.

You left an airbase alone just NE of Tarnopol? I guess no planes are in it.

<r> I am genuinely excited to see you back, Dinglir. Your AARs are simply the best. I hope to learn a lot from your triumphs (and failures)- but wishing both of you the best.<br/> I like adding the modifiers. I am always amazed at how people complain about balance <I><s>[i]</s>but never use any modi...

Paint.net is a really nice free program for this type of thing.

Really good to see you again! It's really hard for me to give a good answer now, I am getting my teeth cleaned.

New Year's resolution for morvael- no more "itis"!

If you leave them on the trains at the end of your turn (do not debark them), they count against your rail cap the next turn.

Merry Christmas to all my fellow nerdy guys. This is a fantastic game, even with all it's warts.