ORIGINAL: JocMeister
ORIGINAL: GreyJoy
I don't want to sound polemic or anything like that, but i'm feeling obliged (sp?!) to comment.
Joc: probably the best way to judge if PDU=ON is really a game breaker as you say, for your next game you should simply try to shift sides and play on Japan with Scen 2 and PDU=ON.
I did it and it was an "eyes-opener". An Epiphany.
Once you discover how fragile is japanese power (even in 1942) you'll surely change your mind a bit.
I'm currently playing 2 games, one with Japan against QBall and one with the allies against Mr.Kane (both are DBB-C games) and i can tell you every time i open the allied game i'm amazed by the quantity and quality of my assets. In 1944 "my" Japan is a paper-pussycat
I wonder if you (and perhaps a lot of other people as well) has misunderstood me with my PDU ON/OFF speculations? I have never once said its a game breaker or that its ruining the game. What I have said is that I don´t like it and I think it messes with a lot of things. This in turn takes a lot of enjoyment out of the game (at least for me). The air war have been the least enjoyable part of the game for me. I don´t think Erik has enjoyed it very much either but you will have to ask him about that.
I think (speculation on my part) that playing with PDU OFF would make things make a lot more sense and you could do away with all the HRs about night bombing, altitudes, sweep/LRCAP, airfield stacking and the myriad of different variations on this we see today.
Either people are taking things out of context or I´m being unclear. I don´t think PDU ON destroys the game. I have never said that. Is it fun having empty pool in 45 as an allied player when you are forced to push, push and push? Not at all. But it can still be done so it hasn´t broken the game. I never said it did. I´m just saying its not much fun. And I do whine about it a lot. But I think in my own AAR I´m entitled to do that? [;)]
I just don´t buy the talk that the game is impossible to play as the Japanese with PDU OFF. Do anyone here envision PzB rolling belly up because he has to play with PDU OFF? Not likely I say.
Again to make it perfectly clear: I´m just speculating around the idea that PDU OFF will give a better overall experience. For both sides. But I guess it depends on what you are after. I´m still very intrigued by fcharton and he his game. It will be very interesting to hear his thoughts when he is further in.
Have you played with PDU Off all the way through before? I remember in my first AI game I learned what PDU On did (or even that it existed), and even as the Allies my immediate thought was "Why would you ever play with it off?" It can be so frustrating to have state-side units in P-40s and P-38s when your allegedly front line units are still flying P-36s. Or like when you eventually run out of British Buffalos, but the Hurricane replacements begin to arrive and you can switch some of those squadrons.
I also encourage you (everyone) to play Japan against the AI, with or without PDU, for at least a couple of in-game months. For many reasons. I'd list them, but other people have whenever this recommendation comes up and I've got work to do [8D].







