Westfront 1914

Post descriptions of your brilliant successes and unfortunate demises.

Moderator: Vic

Post Reply
User avatar
Metatron
Posts: 28
Joined: Thu Jun 19, 2014 9:50 am

Westfront 1914

Post by Metatron »

Greetings if anyone is left in these parts :D

Maybe someone remembers that I was working on a WW1 mod for this game 12 years ago before giving up while transferring the project to the DC Community engine. I found the mod a few weeks ago and decided to finish it to a playable state, and after 200 hours of work I'm quite close. I did not do any scripting so all reinforcements are on the map and unlock through game rules (they are attached down below). It is a big game as you can see below with HQ's at divisional level and up.

Image
hqs.png
hqs.png (1.59 MiB) Viewed 290 times
So I'm starting my first test match against myself to test the balance past August and I thought I'd give a preview of it here in a AAR format before putting the files up for anyone who wants to play it if the balance is ok.

The AAR will be from the French perspective starting 5th August 1914 all the way to (maybe) 30th November 1914. I hope you enjoy the carnage.

Game Rules Westfront 14.pdf
(139.32 KiB) Downloaded 7 times
Last edited by Metatron on Wed Jul 15, 2026 9:57 pm, edited 1 time in total.
-There is safety in numbers.
-Well there is also death in numbers. It's called a massacre.
User avatar
Metatron
Posts: 28
Joined: Thu Jun 19, 2014 9:50 am

Re: Westfront 1914

Post by Metatron »

5aout.png
5aout.png (2.98 MiB) Viewed 280 times
Source of the journals: https://gallica.bnf.fr/accueil/fr/html/accueil-fr

5 August 1914

War it is. The German troops enter Belgium all along the front and even French territory at Briey and Jerny. We await news from Belgium but généralissime Joffre doesn’t think the German push into Belgium to be of consequence. French mobilization according to Plan XVII is under way with the active divisions starting finishing their concentration and moving into position for the first French attacks. So far no direct combat occurred but planes of both side have been spotted reconnoitering the terrain in front of them.

Left Flank:
Image

5. Armée of Charles Lanzerac is moving north along the Semois and Meuse river to make a junction with Namur and the Belgian army. Behind it 4. Armée is moving up to slide in between 5. and 3. Armée.

Center left:
Image

3. Armée is anchoring it's position in front of the Fortified region of Verdun on the two small citadels of Montmédy and Longwy; waiting to see if the German army will try to challenge them. Planes reconnaissance has signaled cavalry formations moving west along the Luxembourg-Sedan railroad and infantry units outside of Metz and Thionville. A clash in the Woëvre plain is more than likely in the next few days.

Center right:
Image

1. and 2. Armée are moving up to launch one of the two main French offensive into Lorraine. Cavalry of both sides are jockeying for position to cover the advance of six Corps d'armée moving up to the front while XX. Corps d'armée covers the Seille river and XXI. Corps d'armée rushes forward to secure the mountain passes over the Vosges of Saales and Donon.

Right flank:
Image

So far the right flank of the French army has not encountered any resistance in the second main effort: an offensive into the Alsace region. French mountain troops are rushing to secure the mountain passes of the Vosges while VII. Corps d'armée pushes towards Mulhouse with 8. Division de cavalerie reaching the outskirts of Altkirch.

Conclusion:

So far everything is going to plan, the war should be over by Christmas.
Last edited by Metatron on Thu Jul 16, 2026 4:48 pm, edited 1 time in total.
-There is safety in numbers.
-Well there is also death in numbers. It's called a massacre.
User avatar
Metatron
Posts: 28
Joined: Thu Jun 19, 2014 9:50 am

Re: Westfront 1914

Post by Metatron »

6august.png
6august.png (3.35 MiB) Viewed 271 times
Source of the journals: https://gallica.bnf.fr/accueil/fr/html/accueil-fr

6 August 1914

First blood was drawn on this day. Who the first victim of this new war was is unclear, maybe future historians will be able to answer that question. The first French engagement happened near Réméréville, when 7. Kavallerie-Division attacked the 2. Division de cavalerie. Both sides suffered around 300 casualties but the French of the 2. Brigade de dragons retreated giving up a bridge over the river Seille without blowing it.

Dispatches from Belgium:
Little official news is reaching us, Belgian newspapers tout a great victory in front of Liège but it is impossible to know exactly. The only concrete news we have come from civilians that fled the German advance and reached our troops at Virton: they report bloody fighting between the Arlon Garde civique and German cavalry. The latest flyover by Escadrille C25 reported Arlon in German hands and the bridge over the Semois as intact, the fate of the Belgian militia is unclear.

Left Flank:
Image

4. and 5. Armée are still moving. The Corps de cavalerie is getting close to the Givet while the German cavalry seems to be securing crossings across the numerous rivers of the Ardennes.

Center left:
Image

3. Armée is almost completely deployed and is blowing up bridges in the Woëvre plain to force the German advance into the the artillery positions of V. and VI. Corps d'armée (CA). An entire German army corps looks to be assembled in front of Briey so we expect an attack to happen tomorrow.

Center right:
Image

1. and 2. Armée are still moving into place, it will take several more days before the main attack can happen. IX. CA is sliding into the left of the line, allowing XX. CA to concentrate it's units again along the Seille. 2. Division de cavalerie lost it's first battle but XV. Corps d'armée is arriving behind it and should relieve the cavalry tomorrow. On the right the entirety of 1st Bavarian Corps appears to be crossing the Saar at Saarburg and this forced 6. Division de cavalerie (DC) to fall back towards the fort of Manonviller. The good news is general Pierre Lanquetot pushed his 43. Division d'infanterie to move quickly and the chasseurs à pied of 86. Brigade d'infanterie managed to capture the Saales mountain pass and to push into the Bruche valley, threatening Schirmeck alongside the bicycle company and artillery group of 6. DC which secured the Donon mountain pass.

Right flank:
Image

Great news everyone! Mulhouse is liberated by 27. Brigade d'infanterie but a German division is at the gates of the city. A clash is surely about to happen, with French artillery still lagging behind and 41. Division d'infanterie one day away after securing the lower Vosges mountain passes. In the central Vosges the race is on for the passes with German infantry at the gates of Münster and Markirch.

In other news:

- Joseph Joffre visited the 2. Division coloniale today. We expect great things from our colonial infantry.
- The first French plane was lost today. A Blériot XI of Escadrille BL9 was either shot down or crashed in the Bruche valley during a reconnaissance flight.

Conclusion

The stage is almost set, the actors are sharpening their blade and the curtain will soon be soaked in blood. Our first engagement may have been a defeat but our quick advance seems to bear fruit in Alsace and the Vosges.
Last edited by Metatron on Thu Jul 16, 2026 4:51 pm, edited 1 time in total.
-There is safety in numbers.
-Well there is also death in numbers. It's called a massacre.
User avatar
Metatron
Posts: 28
Joined: Thu Jun 19, 2014 9:50 am

Re: Westfront 1914

Post by Metatron »

7 aout presse.png
7 aout presse.png (3.15 MiB) Viewed 242 times
Source of the journals: https://gallica.bnf.fr/accueil/fr/html/accueil-fr

7 August 1914

The battle of Mulhouse is on and after one day of fighting the French troops still hold the city in southern Alsace. The rest of the line is still calm with some small exceptions but both sides are lining up in Lorraine and the Wöevre for a big fight. Joffre and his staff is happy with this sign that the German main effort will be indeed in the center and not in Belgium. Several heavy artillery batteries from the Grand Quartier Général (GQG) reserves are being rerouted to Verdun to support 3. Armée of general Emmanuel Ruffey.

Dispatches from Belgium:
The Belgian defense of Liège is still holding, the fighting is apparently concentrated on the forts of Barchon and Evegnée.

Left flank:
Image

Some reorganizing here, with II. Corps d'armée being assigned to 4. Armée that is still lagging behind 5. Armée. Meanwhile the cavalry corps advances in the Ardennes and might clash with German cavalry is the next few days.

Center left:
Image

German 15cm artillery fire landed on Piennes but no main attack happened. Aerial reconnaissance is noting an increasing number of enemy artillery units concentrating. Joffre is sending more of his own limited heavy artillery to counter the threat since it seems to be the main German attack; with at least 10 German divisions concentrating in the area. GQG is organizing the mouvement on some of the reserve divisions that will finish their mobilisation in the next few days to the area to have more reserves to stop any German attack towards the Meuse or to organize a counter attack.

Center right:
Image

Similarly on the Lorraine plateau both sides are lining up, but while the Bavarians are now fully on the front, there is still three French army corps moving up. Once in place the French will have numerical superiority and the offensive will be launched as planned. 1. Armée left flank is in the worst position so far here and is threatened by I. Bavarian Corps near Blamont and Manonviller since the 16. Division d'infanterie is late and 6. Division de cavalerie holding the line in the meantime. Consequently 13. Division had to abandon the Donon mountain pass.

Right flank:
Image

The battle of Mulhouse was started by German artillery followed by an infantry attack just north of town, inflicting heavy casualties among 28. Brigade d'infanterie and forcing it to retreat. But the arrival of French artillery changed the battle when 5. and 47. Régiment d'artillerie de campagne and their 84 canon de 75mm hammered the German assault brigade and a countercharge by French troops forced the Germans back across the Canal du Rhin-Rhône. The results: 1900 French casualties to 2850 Germans. Meanwhile in the Vosges the race for the mountain passes is still on.

In other news:
- An 12cm armored turret of fort Barchon was knocked out by a 15cm German shell.
- An artillery duel between the fort of Manonviller and German artillery on the northern side of the Canal de Lorraine goes bad for the French, loosing two 120mm Mlle 1877 guns and one of it's four 155mm armored turrets in the exchange.

Conclusion:

A victory in Alsace will be a great propaganda coup, yet it remains to be seen if the German will continue their attacks or if the French troops will be able to start pushing towards Colmar. GQG is happy and projects a victory in Alsace if sufficient reserves are sent to strengthen the push.
-There is safety in numbers.
-Well there is also death in numbers. It's called a massacre.
Emp_Palpatine
Posts: 102
Joined: Sun Jan 01, 2006 10:49 am

Re: Westfront 1914

Post by Emp_Palpatine »

Very interesting indeed!

I guess this won't be playable against the AI? :|
I am the Senate!
User avatar
Metatron
Posts: 28
Joined: Thu Jun 19, 2014 9:50 am

Re: Westfront 1914

Post by Metatron »

Emp_Palpatine wrote: Thu Jul 16, 2026 7:52 pm Very interesting indeed!

I guess this won't be playable against the AI? :|
Unfortunately not, it will be PvP only.
-There is safety in numbers.
-Well there is also death in numbers. It's called a massacre.
User avatar
Metatron
Posts: 28
Joined: Thu Jun 19, 2014 9:50 am

Re: Westfront 1914

Post by Metatron »

8august.png
8august.png (2.64 MiB) Viewed 220 times
Source of the journals: https://gallica.bnf.fr/accueil/fr/html/accueil-fr

8 August 1914

Mulhouse stand as a French city after two days of battle. The roar of artillery is now heard along large portions of the front but the main action of the day happened in Lorraine as the I. Bavarian Corps launched a dual pronged attack.

Dispatches from Belgium:
The defenders of Liège hold steadfast, Germans are being mowed down by artillery but now it's the four eastern forts of the city-fortress that are reported to be under attack, not just Barchon and Evegnée. Numerous massacres are also being reported as the German troops sweep across the Ardennes, with reports of civilians being killed coming out of Marche, St. Hubert and Neufchâteau.

Left flank:
Image

The French line is extending slowly north towards Namur but are yet to meet the Germans. The Belgian militias and franc-tireurs seem to have blown some bridges but the advance of the enemy has been constant the last few days.

Center left:
Image

German artillery continues to gain in intensity, hinting at an avalanche to come. Both sides are maneuvering into place strengthening their defensive line and positioning for an attack respectively. French heavy artillery batteries, including 24 Canon de 120L Mle 1878, 6 Obusier de 120C Mle 1890 and 6 Obusier de 155C Mle 1904, are now deployed around Piennes to provide counter battery fire once/if the German attacks comes.

Center right:
Image

As predicted I. Bayerisches Armeekorps launched an attack, but was supported on it's right by 42. Infanterie Division . The resulting two battles for Blamont on the right and Manonviller on the left, from French perspective, were a mixed bag: 10. Division de cavalerie being mauled on the left, loosing at least 24 canon de 75mm of it's own and from VIII. CA artillery. The Bavarian Cavalry Division in full force smashed into 30. Brigade d'infanterie forcing them to flee before 16. Division d'infanterie could re-establish the line. Near Blamont things went better with 6. Division de cavalerie and 13. Division d'infanterie holding the line despite fierce artillery fire.
The day of fighting left almost 9000 Germans, Bavarians and French dead, wounded or missing as artillery of both sides slaughtered infantry formations advancing in open fields.

Meanwhile 2. Division de cavalerie was taken out of the line to be sent west. 10. and 6. Division de cavalerie were also supposed to be extracted but the fierce fighting forced Augustin Dubail, commander of 1. Armée to leave them holding the line. Hopefully the fighting will die down and the cavalry will be able to be send west to form a new cavalry corps and support 5. Armée or the BEF once it arrives.

Edouard de Castelnau's 2. Armée at the same time is finishing it's preparation for the main French assault in Lorraine. 9 divisions should start attacking on August 9th or 10th.

Right flank:
Image

The German 29th Division is falling back leaving us in control of Mulhouse. After much debate Louis Bonneau of VII. CA ordered not to pursue the Germans towards the Rhine: the forested area east of Mulhouse would be difficult terrain for the French infantry and some concrete bunkers with machine guns, called the Eichwald Stellung, secure the bridge at Neuenburg am Rhein. Instead 14. Division d'infanterie will secure Mulhouse until a reserve division can come to relieve it while 41. Division d'infanterie and 8. Division de cavalerie pivot north and launch an offensive towards Colmar in coordination with XIV. Corps d'armée coming down the Fecht valley. Further offensives would be much more difficult with the Rhine and the forts of Neu-Brisach being major obstacles.

In other news:
In recognition of the capture of Mulhouse 14. Division d'infanterie was mentioned in the Citation à l'ordre de l'armée of 8. August 1914. Hopefully the first of many exceptional feats of arms.

Image

Conclusion:

Casualties start to rise but the current fighting may well be just a simple skirmish compared to the titanic battles to come. Success in Alsace has lifted the mood of the nation but the next few days of this battle of the Frontiers might prove decisive.
-There is safety in numbers.
-Well there is also death in numbers. It's called a massacre.
Emp_Palpatine
Posts: 102
Joined: Sun Jan 01, 2006 10:49 am

Re: Westfront 1914

Post by Emp_Palpatine »

I see the 42th DI has started to fight in the Ardennes.
That's my great-grand father unit. Hope they make it!
I am the Senate!
User avatar
Metatron
Posts: 28
Joined: Thu Jun 19, 2014 9:50 am

Re: Westfront 1914

Post by Metatron »

Emp_Palpatine wrote: Fri Jul 17, 2026 7:00 am I see the 42th DI has started to fight in the Ardennes.
That's my great-grand father unit. Hope they make it!
Nice, I'll try not to get them all killed. I have family on both sides, two of them buried just a few kilometers away from one another in the Vosges on opposite sides.

42. DI is holding Piennes, so I'm pretty sure they about get the main attack of 5. Armee in the face.
-There is safety in numbers.
-Well there is also death in numbers. It's called a massacre.
User avatar
Metatron
Posts: 28
Joined: Thu Jun 19, 2014 9:50 am

Re: Westfront 1914

Post by Metatron »

9 aout.png
9 aout.png (2.93 MiB) Viewed 195 times
Source of the journals: https://gallica.bnf.fr/accueil/fr/html/accueil-fr

9 August 1914

Liège stands tall and thus the French left flank since 5. Armée just linked up with the Belgians at Namur. Meanwhile the decisive battles of this war have begun according to Emile Belin and Henri Berthelot at the Grand Quartier général (GQG). In Lorraine 2. Armée attacks while 1. Armée absorbs the punches thrown by the Bavarians; around Longwy the army of the German crown prince has started it's attack.

Dispatches from Belgium:
Liège is bent but unbroken: a secret report from the headquarters of Gérard Léman's 3. Division in charge of the defense acknowledges that super heavy German artillery is now firing at the forts on the right bank on the Maas. The Belgian cavalry was routed and is falling back behind the Maas where the bridges are being blown one after another.

Left flank:
Image

I. Corps d'armée (I.CA) made the connection with the Belgians at Namur while the Corps de cavalerie is screening the Meuse crossing. The leading German column of infantry reached Carlsbourg where 3. Division de cavalerie blew the railway bridge under German artillery fire. In reaction of the battle at Longwy and to shorten it's frontline II. CA abandoned Chiny and is currently blowing up the two bridges there.

Center left:
Image

The expected German offensive in the center finally began, but the main attack occurred in the woods between Piennes and Longwy instead of hitting 42. Division d'infanterie. Thus it is Martial Verraux's 12. Division d'infanterie (12. DI) that took the brunt of the first day's offensive. Casualties where high with German heavy artillery, including 21cm Mörser shells, hammering the woods. The following infantry attack could not be stop and 24. Brigade d'infanterie (24. BI) suffered almost 40% casualties during the day. Victor Boëlle of IV. CA ordered a counter attack from Longwy to aid the endangered 12. DI but 16. Brigade d'infanterie of 8. DI suffered heavy casualties trying to repulse the spearhead of the German 10th Division. Maurice Sarrail, commanding VI. CA, sent several panicked messages to GQG asking for immediate aid from at the very least 72. Division de réserve still mobilizing as GQG reserve at Verdun.

Center right:
Image

De Castelnau's offensive is starting with 6 divisions in front followed by 2 more. 39. Division d'infanterie launched the first unsuccessful assault but the real fighting should start of the 10th. 10. Division de cavalerie was pulled out of the front as initially intended and will move west with 2. Division de cavalerie in the coming days.

The main fighting was further east as the second day of the Battle of the Vezouze raged on:

Battle of the Vezouze
Image

Following artillery barrages the Bavarian Cavalry division and 2nd Bavarian Infantry division renewed the attack for a second day between the fort of Manonviller and Blamont, attacking the newly arrived 16. Division d'infanterie. The Bavarian cavalry once again performed impressively and 16. DI lost 40% of it's strength during the day of attacks and counter attacks. With XIII. CA still a few kilometers away general Dubail had a choice of either abandoning Blâmont or engaging 6. Division de cavalerie (6. DC) to gain time. Refusing to give up his right flank Dubail ordered the cavalry charge and Levilain's 6. DC attacked: unfortunately he did not perform as well as the Bavarians and his attack was torn to shreds by machine guns of 4th Bavarian Infantry brigade. 5. Brigade of cuirassiers was down to 30% effective manpower by days end.

1. Armée and XXI. CA are debating wherever to abandon Blâmont or hope for XIII. CA to change the course of the battle. The effect of 2. Armée's offensive is also expected to relieve pressure from the front if the Bavarians have to reroute artillery to defend their center.

Right flank:
Image

81. Brigade d'infanterie was caught off guard by a German counter attack and suffered heavy losses, especially since German artillery is occupying the right bank of the river Ill. Thankfully 82. BI with artillery support stormed Ensisheim and pushed the Germans back. Louis Bonneau is worried he doesn't have the troops to dislodge the German artillery and asks for reserves to come quickly to be able to push on. The good news is that the chasseurs alpins of Grenoble and Draguignan managed to advance and put pressure on the German 28th Division.

In other news:
- The second stage of mobilization is coming to an end, we expect reserve units to start be ready tomorrow 10. August and our railroad transport capabilities to free up for redeployment of our units.
- General Paul Pau is rumored to have been recalled from retirement and to be traveling east from Paris to take over a new army in Alsace to coordinate the offensive towards Colmar. This would allow 1. Armée to concentrate on the Battle of the Vezouze.

Conclusion:

Heavy casualties due to artillery seems to be defining the initial battles, although the Bavarian cavalry is making the case that cavalry is in fact not obsolete. Rising casualty numbers worry the GQG though, for Joffre did not intend to commit reserve divisions to active frontlines immediately. Calls from his army commanders, like Sarrail, are mounting to mitigate losses and replace active divisions on quiet frontlines with the reserves: they may experience the steel thunderstorm of artillery rather sooner than later.
-There is safety in numbers.
-Well there is also death in numbers. It's called a massacre.
User avatar
Metatron
Posts: 28
Joined: Thu Jun 19, 2014 9:50 am

Re: Westfront 1914

Post by Metatron »

10august.png
10august.png (2.4 MiB) Viewed 100 times
Source of the journals: https://gallica.bnf.fr/accueil/fr/html/accueil-fr

10 August 1914

The battle of the frontiers is continuing with ferocity: the fire of artillery is raging on in Lorraine and the Ardennes. Meanwhile the French offensive in Alsace seems to loose momentum. There is now a continuous front from Switzerland to the Netherlands but for how long? The Belgians report an increasing number of German divisions in front of Liège and the French cavalry and pilots in the Ardennes report an equaly great number of Germans moving towards Namur. Is the battle of Longwy not the main German effort after all ? There is much debate at GQG, with the first reserve divisions being moved up to the front to counter what Joffre perceives to be the greatest threat: 5. German Army. 57. 71. 72. and 73. Divisions de réserve (DR) are detached from their initial duty of fortress mobile reserve for Epinal, Toul, Verdun and Belfort to shore up their respective local frontlines, while reserves units from all over France start planing or begin moving to northern France.

Dispatches from Belgium:
The city of Liège is still in Belgian hands but the first forts seem to have fallen: Evégnée and Barchon. The entire right bank on the Maas seems to be under extreme pressure by German heavy artillery. Will Liège be able to hold?

Left flank:
Image

5. Armée is arriving into position on the middle Meuse south of Namur. Two of the army corps are still catching up but soon there should be a solid line stopping any German breakthrough near Dinant. As long as Liège and Namur hold this line should be unbreakable. 4. Armée is also still not fully on the frontline, thus our front should be even stronger in a few days.

Center left:
Image

The German offensive gains some ground near Longwy thanks to overwhelming artillery superiority. 10. German division continues to push back 12. Division d'infanterie (12. DI) forcing IV. Corps d'armée (IV. CA) to commit more and more resources on it's right flank to support the retreating division. Fed up by the performance of Martial Verraux, Joffre dismisses him and sends him to the central officer reserve at Limoges; he is replaced by Oliver Mazel.

The retreat of 12. DI also forces 42. DI to fall back, abandoning Piennes. In answer to the panic of 3. Armée Joffre prioritized the transport of all the divisions (i.e. 54. 55. and 56. DR) of the 3. Groupe de divisions de réserve (3. GDR) to the Verdun area, leaving other army commanders, especially in Alsace, fuming.

Center right:
Image

Both the French and German offensives in Lorraine continue today. On the Vezouze the Bavarians act faster than French reserves can arrive and take Blâmont in a direct assault. Near Manonviller attacks and counterattack continue inflicting some pain on the 42nd German division and the Bavarian cavalry division but without Blâmont the fort of Manonviller is increasingly vulnerable to flanking attacks. During the day the first super heavy shells from 42cm and 30.5cm guns hit the fort, disabling one of the 15cm armored turret. How long can it hold and protect the road to Lunéville?

The battered 6. Division de cavalerie in finally taken out of the frontline, as XIII. CA takes up position; although the position is now behind the Vezouze. Very unhappy with how the battle is going Joffre has several of the commanders here replaced (see below in other news)

2. Armée's offensive is doing a bit better but at a terrible cost. 31. and 39. Division d'infanterie manage to advance and push back German infantry but the Bavarian and German line is well positioned in and around villages and forests of along the Nied and Seilles rivers. The French infantry advancing en masse is slaughtered by the accurate German shells. The exact number of casualties being so enormous no one really knows so far what the blood tally of the day was.

The worst news reaching de Castenau comes from his pilots reporting several German and Bavarian reserve divisions arriving behind the frontline. It seems the Germans are not afraid to use their reserves as frontline units at army corps level. Maybe if 2. Armée can break through the first line the price paid so far will be worth it and the French infantry will be able to overwhelm the Bavarian reserves on the plains.

Right flank:
Image

Similarly in Alsace the bad news is the arrival reported by pilots and cavalry reconnaissance of at least three reserve divisions and some Landwehr brigades stopping cold any hope of further advances towards Colmar. With only the 57. DR moving up from Belfort so far the newly created Armée d'Alsace is at best at parity numerically, at worst locally inferior to the Germans. Paul Pau, commanding the new army, is pushing GQG to commit 1. Groupe de divisions de réserve (1. GDR) as fast as possible so as to maybe still make it to Colmar. For the time being VII. and XIV. CA take up defensive positions.

In other news:
The following officiers were sent to Limoges:
- 13. DI: Frédéric Bourdériot is replaced by Henri de Cadoual
- 25. DI: Gaston Delétoille is replaced by Louis Baquet
- 26. DI: Gustave Silhol is replaced by Auguste Duchêne
- VIII. CA: César Alix is replaced by Jean de Mondésir
- XIII. CA: Joseph Castelli is replaced by Henri Requichot

Conclusion

It seems that Généralissime Joffre and his staff has made a fatal miscalculation: while his reserve and territorial units were mobilized in dispersed order and to mostly serve in the second line the German army appears to have mobilized it's reserves in army corps structures adding to their frontline power. Moreover the lack of French heavy artillery has been felt keenly both in offense as in defense; especially the reports of 3. Armée emphasize that the German 10.5 howitzer and 15cm canons at division and army corps level are inflicting heavy casualties, notably on the 75mm batteries trying to counter battery. Will the French army be able to adapt quickly to this new reality ?
-There is safety in numbers.
-Well there is also death in numbers. It's called a massacre.
User avatar
Metatron
Posts: 28
Joined: Thu Jun 19, 2014 9:50 am

Re: Westfront 1914

Post by Metatron »

11aoutjour.png
11aoutjour.png (1.62 MiB) Viewed 65 times
Source of the journals: https://gallica.bnf.fr/accueil/fr/html/accueil-fr

11 August 1914

The hopes of a swift victory and of glorious French offensives seems to have vanished in cordite smoke. The slaughter in Lorraine astonished 2. Armée headquarters that calls for a stop to the frontal assaults. In the Ardennes the fight for the border towns and fortresses also appears to favor the Germans. Joffre and his staff have plenty of gripes with the field commanders at this point and we can expect many more generals to follow Verraux's example of a forced retirement in Limoges, no matter how deserved this fate might be. At the same time the Généralissime is starting to deploy his reserves in a more defensive way.

Dispatches from Belgium:
Liège still holds but the first shells hit the citadel itself. The right bank is near collapse and the first German troops on the left bank signal maybe the end of the Maas-line. Belgian divisions fall back slowly to avoid being encircled in Liège. The French left might soon not be so secure after all.

Right flank:
Image

5. and 4. Armée are finishing their set up on the Meuse. Reconnaissance indicates that 3. German army is converging towards Namur. The changing situation in Belgium also now makes the Sambre an important obstacle for 5. Armée to control. GQG sets up 6 reserve divisions ( 51. 52. 53. 60. 67. and 69. Division de réserve) in the rear of 5. Armée. They will serve as mobile reserve and link the forts of Maubeuge to 5. Armée along the Sambre river. The arrival of the BEF in the coming week should strengthen our left flank even further.

Center left:
Image

The heavy casualties forces Ruffey's 3. Armée to begin a fighting retreat around Longwy, leaving the citadel exposed. Nonetheless the defenders of the citadel manage to repulse the first German assault by 10. German infantry division.

XII. Corps d'armée (XII. CA) enters the frontline between II. CA and VI. CA, too late to stop a German frontal assault on Virton, which falls to the 21. German infantry division. Individual reserve regiments arrive to plug some gaps and this allows 4. Division de cavalerie to leave the front.

While Joffre accepts Ruffey's decision to begin a fighting retreat towards the Verdun area he still replaces some commanders in this area: namely of 40. DI Emile Hache replaced by the aptly named Louis Guerrrier and VI. CA's Maurice Sarrail replaced by Edouard Bolgert.

The 3. Groupe de divisions de réserve is moving up behind the line to take over part of the frontline tomorrow and give some rest to the embattled units of VI. CA.

Center right:
Image

The battle of Lorraine is the most ferocious of the war so far, with casualties in the tens of thousands but the German/Bavarian line won't budge. De Castelnau, commander of 2. Armée, is appalled by the carnage and has decided to abandon the offensive. He is now even worried that a Bavarian counter attack could breach his lines and threaten Nancy if the doesn't reform his army.

XVI. CA on his right was the only formation to score significant wins and inflicting heavy casualties on the XXI. German corps, relieving some of the pressure on the fort of Manonviller since the German guns can no longer fire against it from the northern bank of the canal of the Marne. In recognition of that feat Jean-Jacques Vidal's 31. Division d'infanterie is named in the Citation à l'ordre de l'armée of 11. August 1914.

The battle of the Vezouze is quieting down as a consequence of the flaring up of the battle in Lorraine and the fall of Blâmont. The bulk of the fighting is now around the fort of Manonviller that is still holding so far, with Bavarian pioneers deploying trench mortars to try to disable the armored turrets of the fort.

Right flank:
Image

The fighting in Alsace has mostly subsided, with both forces forming a line. It is clear that without substantial forces and artillery Paul Pau cannot advance on Colmar but with the situation in Belgium in flux it is unclear if those reinforcement will come. On the contrary Joffre has signaled that he might take 8. Division de cavalerie and even 14. DI away from this front if he needs to reinforce other points of the frontline. Similarly the 2. Brigade d'infanterie colonial of XIV. CA is leaving the frontline to serve as GQG reserve.

In the Vosges small skirmishes still take place, mostly to consolidate the frontline.

In other news:
67. Division de réserve has arrived in northern France, coming up from Montauban (Occitania).

Conclusion:

The spirit of the offensive did not carry the French infantry to victory in Lorraine. Horrific casualties forces the French armies to get back on the defensive. The arrival of even more German reserve army corps and the news from Belgium are compounding the result of the first six days of operations: the initiative is German. But GQG is still hopeful: 4. and 5. Armée have yet to meet the enemy in any serious way and a victory on the left flank would be surely decisive since the center of the French army is anchored on the forts of Verdun, Toul and Epinal.
-There is safety in numbers.
-Well there is also death in numbers. It's called a massacre.
User avatar
Metatron
Posts: 28
Joined: Thu Jun 19, 2014 9:50 am

Re: Westfront 1914

Post by Metatron »

12aoutjourn.png
12aoutjourn.png (4.59 MiB) Viewed 22 times
Source of the journals: https://gallica.bnf.fr/accueil/fr/html/accueil-fr

12 August 1914

The scale of the German right flank's attack is slowly becoming clearer, although Berthelot still maintains the center is the main German offensive, moving 71. Division de réserve (71. DR) south of Verdun to guard the Meuse crossings there. The Belgians on the other hand claim to be facing two full armies and are falling back towards their national redoubt: Antwerp. The day is less bloody than the previous ones as 2. and 3. Armée slowly fall back to reform their lines.

Left flank:
Image

The Belgian situation according to the headquarter of the King of Belgium is deteriorating quickly. Liège still stands but the forts are falling one after another under the heavy artillery fire. Half of 3. Belgian division managed to fall back to avoid being encircled and is now retreating north with the main Belgian force towards Antwerp. Thankfully all the bridges over the Maas were blown and the Belgian army and Garde civique are blowing as many bridges as possible to slow down the German advance.

The Belgian military also informed us that they intend to announce Brussels to be a open city to spare it from the fighting. 5. Armée of Lanzerac now finds itself with an opening left flank but 4. Belgian division still holds firm in Namur; the forts of which have begun firing at the approaching German troops. The French reserves arriving by rail will need some days to reform and cross the frontier into Belgium and line up on the Sambre, in the meantime the Garde civique of Charleroi and Thuin are moving up to form a picket line on the Orneau river.

Center left:
Image

The French cavalry corps is reforming behind the Meuse and planing to move up north to counter any threats of German cavalry in the Belgian plain. They should be soon reinforced by a second cavalry corps currently forming out of the cavalry divisions taken out of the line in Lorraine and Alsace. The rumors say that Louis Conneau of 10. Division de cavalerie (10. DC) will be taking command of the new corps.

On the Meuse itself both sides are lining up. Unclear if a clash will happen or if both sides are waiting to see how the fight for Namur will develop.

Center:
Image

Around Virton attacks and counter attacks on a smaller scale still continue; causing around 3000 casualties on both sides but a German reserve corps appears to have arrived by rail to support the advance towards Montmédy. Pierre Roques' XII. Corps d'armée (XII. CA) was thus tasked with a fighting retreat towards the Chiers river.

Longwy still stands after two German assaults were bloodedly repulsed today but the end is near for the valiant garrison. VI. CA's three battered divisions are being pulled out of the line replaced by four reserve divisions. The calls for 3. Armée's commander general Ruffey to be replaced are growing at GQG and the hunt for a replacement is according to the rumor mill well under way.

Aerial recon also notes here a new German concentration including two cavalry divisions on the left flank of the German 5. army. A push towards the Meuse there may be coming.

Center right:
Image

After four days of carnage the fighting dies down in Lorraine, but not completely.

Around the fort of Manonviller both sides vie for position with VIII. CA and XVI. CAstill pressuring the German XXI. Army corps with success; stopping the German artillery from concentrating on reducing the fort further.

In Lorraine proper the French divisions fall back towards the Seilles river under Bavarian artillery fire. De Castelnau is regrouping his divisions and concentrating his artillery in case the Bavarians try to launch an offensive of their own.

On the left flank the 33. German reserve division tried to counter attack in coordination with 6. Bavarian Division but Marie-Joseph Chatelain's 73. DR performed a textbook counterstroke, inflicting heavy casualties on the 8. Bavarian infantry brigade. It was the first engagement for a French reserve unit of this war.


Right flank:
Image

Both sides seem to be content with the results in Alsace, the fall of Mulhouse was a nice moral boost for the French but German reserves stopped any push on Colmar. Now both sides seem to be pulling out divisions for use elsewhere, only the Vosges still sees some fighting for position on the mountain tops around the Saales, Bonhomme and St. Marie mountain passes. The solid position around Mulhouse still leaves the door open at a future offensive from Joffre's perspective though; time will tell.

In other news:
37. and 38. Division d'infanterie which landed at Marseille at few days ago were urgently transported by rail to the Belgian border at Maubeuge. The two divisions hail from the Armée d'Afrique and are composed of veteran colonial troops, both French zouaves and indigenous Algerian, Moroccan and Tunisian troops. They will provide a solid core of battle hardened troops for the defense of the river Sambre.
Image

Conclusion:

The fight for Alsace seems to be at an end, but the fight for Belgium might just be starting. The French railroad system is working at full capacity to transfer units around and redeploy divisions to the Sambre. These activities won't slow down any time soon and the arrival of the BEF, that will also need trains to move to the Belgian border, will put even more strain on French railroads. Hopefully Namur will hold longer than Liège and give the GQG enough time to gather sufficient forces to counter any attack through Belgium while holding on to the Meuse from Verdun to Namur.
-There is safety in numbers.
-Well there is also death in numbers. It's called a massacre.
Post Reply

Return to “After Action Reports”